C > yl[Ƃ̃Rg > G̎ iUef9YLMjtI
@
g iUef9YLMjtI g hk3SORw2nEVEw
@
G̎ iUef9YLMjtI SRg
[eXg31] eXg
Jslu@9̍IӋv(2016N123ũeLXgN)

Jsl u@9̍IӋv sA u 2016.1.23iPlaceUniversityj

m0:35n ͌@9ɂĘb܂ȂOɈĂƂ܂BN̋㌎A\ẺiZjwłuaɊւ鍑ۉcvōu܂B̂Ƃɂ͌@9ɂĘbłAb̂͂̉cŕƂłB̉cł́AbOɉw̍ېw̕iju܂āA̍ŌɂƂB{ł͍ŋߎႢlɃfĂĂ΂炵BɈ؍ł͎҂͐ȂBlƈWCƁBču߂킯łBN̋㌎΂ł܂{̃f̗]CcĂłB͔ނ̔𕷂ċ܂B܂Ŏ́A{ɂ͂ȂǊ؍ɂ̓fAƂɊw̃fƂƎvĂBɂĊ؍l{̃f̂ƂŁAɊ]Ə܎^ꂽBuOɂꂽȂvƂ܂ǁAƂɎĝȂłǁA_߂Ă̂ɂȂB

m2:30n ɂ킩ɐMȂ̂ŁǍアȐlɈӌ𕷂܂BƂƂ킩܂Bނ؍ɂ̓f܂B傢ɂB܂Ήr𓊂ĂƂĂ܂B܂񓹂ȂǁB͎ƂĘJ҂̃fłāAwfȂȂƂ͎̂̂悤łBR͏AEςłB̈ŁA͈l̊w[ȑk󂯂܂Bނ́ARɍsȂBÂ߂ɂ͖SقȂƌłB{łAĂ̂Ŋ؍ɋAȂƂ؍l̎҂ɉƂ܂Bނ͓{̎҂Ƃ͍{IɈɒuĂ܂B̂悤Șb𕷂ƁA{Ɍ@9ƂƂ܂BƂA{Ɏ҂̃fNĂ邱ƂɊ󂯂lOɂB͂낱΂v܂B

m4:10n 2002NCN푈̂납{ɂȂfȂ̂lĂ܂BfKvƁB2011Ň̂ƂƂɑ傫ȃfNƂA܂BfȂǂŎЉς邩ƂlBfŎЉ͊mɕςBȂȂf΁A{͐lfЉɕς邩炾ƁBmɊ؍͓̋{fЉɂȂƂƂF߂킯łB݂̂Ƃ낻܂œ{ł́Af͎iłƌȂĂ܂Bɂ͊v̂߂̎iłB̂߂ɉߌȃfǋĂB͑Î߂̎iƂlłBfɂĐlXɈӌiAIłƁB̓̍lA{Ńf߂ɂĂƎv܂BÔ͂͂̕肵Ă܂Bߌȃf߂ɕʂ̐l̓fɍsȂȂƂjIȎ邩łBA҂ɂĂ͍lĂȂƎvłBA͍NĂ̂͂ƌqłBN̉Ăɂf̑IɗLɐƂB͂悢łBAŖYĂ炢Ȃ肪܂B́Af͂đÎ߂̎ił͂ȂAI邢͐}ɏ]悤Ȃ̂ł͂ȂƂƂłB

m6:28n ͈ȑOfɂčlA̂悤ȂƂɋCÂ܂B{ł̓f͏WƋʂĂ܂BpłƁAf\͂낢날܂AɂassemblyłB͓{ŁuWvƖ󂳂Ă܂BfWassemblyȂłˁB{̌@21ɂ́uWAЁA\̎RvƂ̂܂ǂAuf̎RvȂB炩Ắuf̎Rvu\̎Rv獪Â悤Ș_܂ǁAPȌłBfassemblyłBuW̎Rvuf̎RvӖĂ킯łBȂ݂Ɍ@21ɂuЂ̎RvƂ\A͂킩Ȃ̂łB͉płassociation̎RȂłBuЁvƂƂقƂǂ̐l͔閧Ђ炢v΂ȂłBassociationƂ̂͂ǂɂł̂łBwZɍs΂܂BPTAABeƋtassociationȂłB܂ɂӂꂽtłB{łassemblyƂ̂͊񍇂łBǂ̑⒬ɂ񍇂܂BƎv܂AɂẮBꂪɂȂ킯łBmł͂񍇂cɂȂ킯łBcassemblyƂłB񍇂łB܂cƃf͐eʂ̂悤Ȃ̂łˁBƂ΁A\[wЉ__xŁu͖͂OassemblyvƏĂB̏ꍇAassemblyƂ̂͋cƂWEfƂӖƎv܂BjIɂ͐Ήɑ΂assemblyłˁBWEf񂾂Ƒ傫ȂċcƂďF悤ɂȂ킯łB̈Ӗŋc̋N̓fEWȂłˁB܂\[͂Ă܂Bl͏WɗƂɂ匠҂ƂčsƁBlƂ匠҂͌Xlł͂ȂłBXlWƂɓoꂷ̂łBɃ\[uʈӎvv݂Ă킯łBXlW߂ał͂܂B̏Wɂāuʈӎvv݂B烋\[͓̋cBCMXɂ񂵂ĂĂ܂BCMX̐l͎RƎvĂ邪A͑܂Bނ炪RȂ̂͋cI邠̂ƂŁAcI΂₢ȂACMXl͓zƂȂAɋAĂ܂ƁB܂\[͂Ă܂B\҂Ƃl͋ߐ̂̂łB͕ɗRĂƁB܂A\cɂ͎匠҂ƂĂ̐l͂܂B\҂͕ɂ̎̂悤Ȃ̂łB̂Ƃ݂͌̓{̑cm݂Ƃ悭킩܂B{񑊂߁Aނ͉̑ɂ킽鐢PłB쎞̕{q獡͂܂łBȋcɎ匠҂ƂĐl݂͂ȂBꂪ݂̂͂assemblyȂ킿fEWɂĂłB

m11:25n c܂l匠ɔ邩ƂƁAł͂܂BcfEWƂassembly𔽉f邩ÂŐl匠IłƂƂł܂BƂ΁AIɂČ܂ƂfŕςĂ܂͖̂ɔƂނ̔Ƃ܂B͖ł邩lƂȂ񂾂ƎvłBIŌ߂ƂfŏC邱Ƃ肤Ƃɐl匠ƂƂłłB̍OfEWA܂Ȍ̍OfEWł́A낢ۂ܂B͍̑O炢łǁAassemblyʂƂƂłBfƋcBf̑獑ɍsƂ͂ȂłȂfɈAɗĂBƂ܂BȂȂ΁Af{assemblyłBANp̂Ђ܂vł́Af̕ɍs܂BɂĂނf{assemblyłƂƂ킯łBނ͑Iŏ܂BA̓f̉Ǝv܂B܂łȂƍゾ߂ɂȂ܂BāA̓fEWȂiƌȂĂ͂ȂBɎ匠҂ƂĂ̐lƂ킯łB̖͐ł͂܂BfEW_łB̂Ƃ͍ĊmFĂƎv܂B

m13:47n ̍̍úu@9̍IӋvƂɂȂĂ܂A͎߂̂ł͂܂BCƂȂĂB񌛖@9ɕՓIȈӋ邱Ƃ͂܂܂BƂΌ@9́AJǵwiâ߂ɁxA邢́wEjIsIꂩ݂lނ̕Վj̍\zxƂ̂痈Ă܂BJg̗O͑ꎟA1920N̍ۘAƂČ܂B1928Nɂ͐푈@upsvꂽB@9͂󂯂̂łBpłł݂ƌ@9ɂ͂̒ꂽ\cĂ܂BÂ͍ƂɂČ邱Ƃ͂܂B݂Ȃ͌@9̕ՓIӋĊmFāAɂĉj~͂Ƃ悤ƍlĂ邩܂񂪁A͎͂̕Kv͂ȂƎvĂłBƂ̂́AȂ邱Ƃ͂ȂƎvĂ邩łB̘͂bBނ낻ɕՓIȈӋƎv܂B

m15:16n {̐㌛@́A9ɂĂ̓䂪܂BɁAEjIɈٗ̂̂悤ȏ{̌@ɂ̂͂ȂƂƂłBɁAꂪɂ炸sĂȂ̂͂ȂƂƂłBƂΎqAČRn݂Ă܂BOɁAsȂ̂ł΂ӂ͖@ς͂łA9͂܂cĂ̂͂ȂƂƂłB܂O̓䂩lĂ݂܂傤BΑA̓ƎvłBqČRnȂǂ́A@9̉߂ɂčm肳Ă܂B܂AWcIqA͌R̕ʖłB̂\Ƃ߉ȂĂ܂BA@9ςƂƂ͂ĂȂȂ̂łBȂȂ̂ł傤BނARƒNΑIŕĂ܂łBł́AȂĂ܂̂BlX@9x̂͐푈ւ̐[Ȃ邩炾Ƃ܂A͂^܂BƂsɂ̂悤ȋCƂĂAŌ@9̂悤Ȃ̂ł킯ȂBAꂪł̂͐̌RłB܂A@9lX̐푈̌ɂƂÂĂ̂ƂAȂl命ɂȂΏĂ܂ł傤BہAȂ̂ł͂Ȃƌ쌛_҂͌OĂ܂Bł͂Ȃ9cA܂lX͂낤Ƃ̂ł傤B쌛_҂́A͎炪푈̌oA܂@9̏dviĂ炾Ƃł傤BA͋^킵B

m17:35n Ŗ̔΂̑A܂茛@9pƍlĂ鑤݂Ă݂Ǝv܂Bނ60Nɂ킽Ăp悤ƂĂłȂBȂȂ̂ł傤Bނ́Ȃ͍mlɐ]Ă邩炾ƍl܂B͒[Iɂ܂łB͌@9Ɏ^ł͂ȂłBƂ1946N626V@Rc鍑cAQOY}ćA푈ɂ͐푈ƂłȂ푈BNꂽc邽߂̐푈͐̂ł͂ȂƏqׂ܂B͍ɂƂĂ͂ӂ̌łāA̐VɂĂłB̒ɂ͐ԌRhłAV̑͌Ɍ쌛hɓ]܂BAނ炪ӌςƂ鎑i͕ێhɂ͂܂BƂΎǂ̋gcΎ񑊂́AQO̎ɑ΂ĂłBߔN̐푈͍̑Ɩhq̖ɂčsȂꂽ邱Ƃ͌Ȃ鎖ł܂B̂ɐhqF߂邱Ƃ푈U䂦łƎv̂ł܂ƁBɒN푈ŃAJČR𔗂ꂽƂAނ͂₵ĂBČRȂǋ̍łAsl̖łƏĂ܂BȂƂێhccȂƎv܂Bނ͌@9̉߂ŏWcIqAR𐳓hqƂĂ܂Bvɕێhӌς킯łBƂ낪ނ͌@9p悤Ƃ͂ȂBȂBɂ邱ƂłȂłBꂪIő_ƂȂȂ΁Aŝ͊młBāAނ͂܂ȂĂقȂBژ_60N]肽Ƃ̂ɂ܂łȂłˁB͂ȂBނ玩gɂƂĂ̂͂łB̓𖾂悤ƂɁA}AiIlAml̂ɂB͎̖́AIグ邱ƂłB@9XɎcĂ̂́AlXӎIɎĂł͂܂Bł΂ƂɏĂł傤BlԂ̈ӎuȂǂ͋CŐƎȂ̂łB9͂䂦ɖӎ̖Ȃ̂łB

m21:06n ӎƂƈʂɁAӎĂȂƂẍӖŗĂ܂B邢݈͐ӎƓꎋĂ܂BƂΐȂǂŖӎA݈ӎɓTu~iʂ_Ƃ܂Bقǂꂽ悤ɉׂJԂĂƐl͂񂾂Ǝ󂯂Ƃ悤ɂȂ񂾂ƂӖłBAtCg͂̂悤Ȃ̂OӎƌĂŁAӎƂ͋ʂłBtCgӎɂ̎ނ܂B̓GXƂ̂ŁAuvƂƂŁAÂ悤̂Ȃ̂wĂ킯łB͒łB̍lł́A@9͒̂悤Ȃ̂łB̂悤Ȗӎ̒́AӎƂ͈قȂāAɂđ삷邱ƂłȂ̂łBɕێh60Nȏɂ킽w͓͂kJɏIĂ܂Bނ炪9͔񌻎IȗzłƑiƂŖʂłB9͖ӎ̎ɍ̂As\ȂłBӎIȎłΐ͂ł܂ǁBÂƂ𗝉ĂȂ̂͌쌛hlłB@9́A쌛h[ւ邱ƂɂđĂ̂ł͂܂B9͌쌛hɂĎĂ̂ł͂ȂB̋tɌ쌛h@9ɂĎĂB͂łĂ킯ł͂܂BɈSĂ悢ƂĂłBĂ̏ŉׂAȂ邩lĂق̂łB

m23:34n ͐{ɐ܂ꂽ@ɂ񂵂āAtCĝƂTO𓱓čl悤Ƃ܂B͂ɐSw̉pł͂܂BtCgɂčl悤ɂȂƂ́A[푈̖Ɗ֘AĂ̂łBɂďqׂĂƎv܂BtCg͑ꎟɁA邱ƂŖӎɂ񂷂l{IɕςłBɂđOtCgƌtCgɋʂłƎv܂BÕtCg̍lł́Aӎ~]𖞂ƂƁA𖞂Ƃ炷댯邽߂ɗ}悤Ƃ錻BƂ̂́AȂΎЉ̋K͂łBeʂĎqǂɍ荞܂BꂪӎɂĐlKA邢͌{킯łBtCǵwfx͂̂悤ȍlɂƂÂďĂ܂BA̍l͐V̂ł͂̂łAӖł͏펯IȂ̂łBƂ΁AlԂ͎v܂܂ɗ~]𖞂킯ɂ͂ȂB炻ɂė}ȂƂȂBĎЉIIȋK͂ɏ]ƂɂȂBꂪn邱ƂłBǁAɂƂɂ͂ꂩȂƂȂBƂ΍Ղ푈ɂȂƁAꂪƂ킯łBہAtCg͑ꎟ̒Ő푈ɂĂ͂ނmIłBĂ܂푈IΎRɌɖ߂ƍlĂ܂Bނ̍lς̂͐łBA͔ގg푈oƂɂ̂ł͂܂B

m26:09n ނ̍lς̂́Aɐ푈_oǂɋꂵފ҂ɏoƂłBނɂƂāA푈͂ɏǂł͂Ȃ킯łˁBӐ푈̖ĔыNĂ̂B̂悤Ȕ͉Ȃ̂Aɂ̂BtCg͂lBĔނ́AƌƂ悤ȓ񌳐̒Ɏ̗~A邢͂̔hłU~oBtCg͂l܂B҂̔́A푈ɊOɌĂU~ɓɌ邱ƂɂĐ̂ƁBtCgƂTON̂͂̌łBɎ͈̂ȑO炠܂B͌Sӎ̌{Ȃ̂łBA͎ЉIK͂eʂĎqǂɓʉĐ̂łB܂肻͊O痈̂łBɑ΂Ē͂Γ痈BȂȂΓl̗̎~AU~ɍĂ邩łBtCĝ̂悤ȍl̓WJ́A̐_͂ނނ̕_ɂĂ薾ɎĂƎv܂BtCg̍lT^IɎ̂́A1930Nɏw̒̋SnxƂ_łBŃtCǵA͌lł͂ȂWcɂƂ܂BƂނA͏Wc̕ɂ茰ɂƏĂ܂BĂ̒̏WcÏԂƂ킯łB̈ӖŁA͐̓{ɐ܂ꂽ@9𒴎ƂĂ݂̂ӂ킵Ǝv܂B΁Aӎł͂Ȃӎ̖ƂāBƂ΃tCǵA_oǂ̊҂͊O݂ƍߐӊɋꂵł悤ɂ݂邯ǂA̖{l͂ɂĉӎĂȂAƂƂwE܂BŃtCg͂uӎI߈vƌĂт܂B

m29:19n {l@9ɍŜ͂ƎĂ܂B͈̋_oǂłAuӎI߈v̂łBԂƁA{lɐ푈ɑ΂߈ƂĂA͈ӎIȂ̂ł͂ȂƂƂłB@9͐lX߈ꂽ̂ł͂ȂAߋ̍sւ̔Ȉӎ߂邱ƂɂĈێĂ̂ł܂BꂪӎIȔȂɂ̂łȂA9͂Ƃ̐̂ɔpĂł傤BȂȂӎς̂͂₷ƂłBȂŐ_ς邱Ƃ͂ł܂BȂ̂9ςȂ̂͂Ȃł傤Bŉh́AAsĂ邩炾ƎvA쌛h̋A炾ƍlBtɌ쌛h́Ah̐HɂĂBiƑĂ킯łB@9ɂ͐푈鋭ϗIȈӎu܂BA͈ӎI邢͎IɏoĂ̂ł͂܂B9͖炩ɐ̌R̋ɂ̂Ȃ̂łB^ɎIȌ@Vɍ낤Ƃlɂ͂ƂA܂BA@9ꂽ̂ƂƂƁA{lIɎ󂯓ꂽƂƂƂ͖Ȃ̂łB݂̂ƂAtCǧt͂̋^ɓĂƎv܂B

m31:20n ul͒ʏAϗIȗvŏɂA~̒fǑʂƂĐ܂ƍlłBł́Aϗ̗RsȂ܂܂łBۂɂ͂̔΂ɐis悤ɎvBŏ̗~̒fÓAO̗͂ɂċꂽ̂łA~̒fO߂ėϗ𐶂ݏoAꂪǐSƂŕ\A~̒fOɋ߂̂łBv

m31:58n tCĝ̍lׂ͂Ɍ@ɂď̂ł͂Ȃł @9ߒɂ܂ĂƎv܂BƂ̂́A@9͊Ó̗A܂̌R̎w߂ɂĐ܂ꂽ킯łBɂ炸A͓{l̖ӎɐ[蒅BȂB܂O̗͂ɂ푈iUj̒fOBꂪǐS𐶂ݏoāAꂪ푈̒fO߂邱ƂɂȂ킯łB猛@9͎IȈӎuɂĂł̂ł͂ȂBỎɂ̂łA炱͂̌ɐ[蒅̂łB͂lẌӎuɂ̂łΐȂAƂĂƂɔpĂƎv܂B

m32:56n ƂŁAl̖ӎ̏ꍇ͐_͈オΘbʂăANZXł邩܂񂪁AWc̏ꍇ͂͂܂BAIA[ɂȂƁA͂xoĂ܂B񂻂̂悤ȔF͂܂񂪁AoIɂꂪ킩ĂB˂炤}AƂ͂ƂȂƌ@9𑈓_Ђ߂܂BđǏł܂BԂĂ킯łB̂悤ȏWcIӎ͑I⍑[ʂȊOɎ@mȂ̂Ƃ΁Ał͂܂B͂m@Ǝv܂Bגoi_TvOjɂ鐢_łB̂́AAJ̐̐̈Ƃē̂ȂłBނ͓{̖剻ɂ͐_KvƍlBނ炪̂vw̗_ɂƂÂ_TvOɂ钲łB̓AJł܂sĂȂ̂ȂłBꂪ{ŎsꂽB1948NVsȂ_ŏ̂̂ƂĂ܂BӖł̂悤Ȑ_́A@9Ɨގ_܂B͂ǂ̌RAJłĂȂƂ{ł낤ƂBɂ̗ގ_́ǍR{̓̂߂Ɏ񂾂̂̂ǍRɂƂėڂɏoƂłBƂ΁AN푈n܂ƂɃ}bJ[T[͌@9ƂƎv܂Bނ͂ŋgc΂ɍČRAČ@̉v킯łBgc͂ȂfBɂċgc͉z^łĂ܂B܂A{͍ČR̂߂̎ȂBꂪ̗RłBɁAvz̎猾āAČR̔wiׂSIՂSĂBOɁARȂ푈ɋ藧ĂꂽɂƂāAs̏ՂcĂāȀ̖I炴̂ƁB݂̂܂ƋgcɁuSIՁvƂus̏ՁvƂ̂͂ȂB炭ނ͐_̌ʂmĂ̂ł͂ȂƎv܂Bނ͂lBōČR炽ւȔΉ^NAtǂ납vɂȂĂ܂B炭ނ͂}bJ[T[ɂɂȂBAgc΂̓}bJ[T[̗vɏ]Čx@\܂BČRNɌ̈Sۏ̂߂ƂڂłBƂ͂Agc͂܂Ō@͑ނBx@\ۈAqƔWĂiKłÁúvł͂ȂƂāA@9̉̕Kvے肵łB͂Ӗ9̉߉̂悤Ȃ̂łBȗA9̕ʂςȂ܂܂ɁAɑ悤ȌRg傪ȂꑱĂ킯łB

m37:17n Ő_ƑI̊֌WɂĈꌾqׂĂ܂B_炢ƁAI͏WcIӎƂĂ̐_\̂ɂ͂Ȃ肦܂BȂȂΑ_BȂA[TĒႭA[҂̒nNȂǂ̊ɂ΂肪邩łBIʂČ@9悤ƂꍇAŌɍ[sKv܂B[炩͉̑\A_\ɔf̂Ƃ͂܂񂪁A_͂肵Ă̂ŁA[AӎOʂɏoĂ܂B䂦ɍ[ł͕Ă܂܂BIŏĂ[Ŕsk΁A͒vIȃ_[W󂯂܂B߉ێłȂȂĂ܂\BނIł9B̑_ƂȂsƎv܂B琭{}͕i9̉Ăɂ炸AIƂȂƂČ@9𑈓_ɂ͂ȂłBłB

m38:47n ȂA_mƂƂł́A_TvOɂ鐢_̕ƓImƎv܂BȀꍇ͎̂ɒӂȂƂȂłBƂ΁u@9ǂvvƂ悤Ȏ͂߂ȂłARƂĂ邩Bu@9p邩ǂvƊm肵ĖȂƂȂBƂɂK؂ɂ邱Ƃ̐SłBȂɂ₤Ă鑊͌Xl̈ӎƂł͂ȂāAӎ܂ȂłBłɂƁA݂Ă悤ȓdbɂ̓_TvOɂȂȂƎv܂BdbĂȂl͏OĂ܂܂BƂɍŋ߂̎҂͌gтĂȂłȂłBł̓_Ȓoɂ͂Ȃ܂BʐڂȂƂȂłÂłȂBvɎ̂́A@9ӎ̒łƂƂ́ASIȉł͂ȂāAvwIɗÂ̂ƂƂłB

m40:20n ŌɈꌾBݐEŐ푈̊@Ă邱Ƃ͂܂܂Bǂ̍̊@̂ƂɂAꂼɑ΍uĂ܂BĂꂪɉeAݓIɓGΐSB̒œ{ŗDɂȂĂ̂́AčƂ̌RiWcIqjmƂĂłB͐푈ؔ̂Ƃł̓AXeBbNȑΉł悤ɂ݂܂BAtɊẽAXeBbNȑΉ̂ŁAvȂŐE푈Ɋ܂Ă܂WR
̂łBꎟ͂܂ɂ̂łB[bp̒nIȕAI[XgAƃZrA̕AR̍ۓIlbg[Nɂē{Q悤ȐE푈ɓWJĂ킯łB{̏ꍇ͓płB܂̑ꎟ̌ʂƂčۘA܂A푈@Ƃusv܂B{̌@9́usvɕƂ͐ɂ܂ǁAۘAEނAusv𓥂݂ɂ͎̂̓hCcƓ{Ȃ̂łBǂ̂悤ȃJgIO}΂āÄSAXeBbNɊmۂ悤Ƃ킯łB̌ʂ񎟑łBāAhq̂߂̏WcIR͉畽aۏႷ̂ł͂ȂB

m42:27n AꂪAXeBbNȂƍlĂ܂Bē{l邽߂ɂ͉ƂĂ񌻎IȌ@9pȂ΂ȂȂƂƂɂȂ܂BAނ͂]łł܂B60Nȏɂ킽Č@9p悤ƂĂ̂ɁAłȂ̂łBێh̒́AȂłȂ̂킩ȂȂAԂ߂Ă̂Ǝv܂B񂢂ɂ܂BAłƂ͍lĂȂB̂ɋcőhƂȂĈۖ@Ă̂悤Ȗ@邱ƂA܂Ɍ@ɋً}ԏȂǂŁA9𖳗͉@Ƃ낤Ɖ􂵂Ă܂B͍ł͒ʂĂ[ł͊mɋp܂AȂł傤BvɈ{́A9Ă푈ł悤ȑ̐낤ƂĂ킯łB

m43:40n 䂦Ɍ쌛h9ȂȂĂ܂̂ł͂ȂƂƂKv͂܂܂B͂ނ쌛ĥɉ邠܂9̏𕶂ێł΂悢ƍlӂ邱ƂłB̏ł̂9邾ȂA9Ăłł悤ȑ̐ɂȂĂ܂܂BꂪɋN肤邱ƂłB̈ӖŎ͌@9̉Ă͂ȂƂBނɂ͐XXƌ@9ςǂƂ΂łBЍ[܂傤Bׂ32̋cȂȂĂAꏏɂ܂傤ƂāAS^ɉĂłA[ɂ悤ƁB͏kB

m44:44n 璍ӂׂƂ́Aނ炪@9ς邱ƂȂ܂܂ȎŐ푈s̐Ă܂ƂłBɓ{푈Ɋ܂邱Ƃ͑傢ɂ肦܂B邢͂̂悤Ȋ@čoČ@͂ƂƂ肦ł傤BÂɂǂȂ邩Ƃ΁Aꍂ㏞𕥂Č@9Ăю߂ƂɂȂ邾łBȂƂ݂݂͌ĂłBāA푈̊@g߂ɔ鎞ɂĂƂAXeBbNȂ́Aʂɔ񌻎IƖڂĂ錛@9fA𕶎ʂs邱ƂłB9s邱Ƃ́A炭{lłB̕ՓI͂ȍsׂłBꂪ̉ɂ悤Ɂu@9̍IӋvłB

me҃Rgn

iɕt́A̍ĐԂłB^CvȂǂŊԈႢ炲e͂B
ȂAwE 2015N9xigXjɂ́uƂĂ̕avƂłقړ|͂̕fڂĂ܂B

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/428.html

[GkEStory41] Jslu@9̍IӋv(2016N123ũeLXgN)
Jslu@9̍IӋv(2016N123ũeLXgN)

Jsl u@9̍IӋv sA u 2016.1.23iPlaceUniversityj

m0:35n ͌@9ɂĘb܂ȂOɈĂƂ܂BN̋㌎A\ẺiZjwłuaɊւ鍑ۉcvōu܂B̂Ƃɂ͌@9ɂĘbłAb̂͂̉cŕƂłB̉cł́AbOɉw̍ېw̕iju܂āA̍ŌɂƂB{ł͍ŋߎႢlɃfĂĂ΂炵BɈ؍ł͎҂͐ȂBlƈWCƁBču߂킯łBN̋㌎΂ł܂{̃f̗]CcĂłB͔ނ̔𕷂ċ܂B܂Ŏ́A{ɂ͂ȂǊ؍ɂ̓fAƂɊw̃fƂƎvĂBɂĊ؍l{̃f̂ƂŁAɊ]Ə܎^ꂽBuOɂꂽȂvƂ܂ǁAƂɎĝȂłǁA_߂Ă̂ɂȂB

m2:30n ɂ킩ɐMȂ̂ŁǍアȐlɈӌ𕷂܂BƂƂ킩܂Bނ؍ɂ̓f܂B傢ɂB܂Ήr𓊂ĂƂĂ܂B܂񓹂ȂǁB͎ƂĘJ҂̃fłāAwfȂȂƂ͎̂̂悤łBR͏AEςłB̈ŁA͈l̊w[ȑk󂯂܂Bނ́ARɍsȂBÂ߂ɂ͖SقȂƌłB{łAĂ̂Ŋ؍ɋAȂƂ؍l̎҂ɉƂ܂Bނ͓{̎҂Ƃ͍{IɈɒuĂ܂B̂悤Șb𕷂ƁA{Ɍ@9ƂƂ܂BƂA{Ɏ҂̃fNĂ邱ƂɊ󂯂lOɂB͂낱΂v܂B

m4:10n 2002NCN푈̂납{ɂȂfȂ̂lĂ܂BfKvƁB2011Ň̂ƂƂɑ傫ȃfNƂA܂BfȂǂŎЉς邩ƂlBfŎЉ͊mɕςBȂȂf΁A{͐lfЉɕς邩炾ƁBmɊ؍͓̋{fЉɂȂƂƂF߂킯łB݂̂Ƃ낻܂œ{ł́Af͎iłƌȂĂ܂Bɂ͊v̂߂̎iłB̂߂ɉߌȃfǋĂB͑Î߂̎iƂlłBfɂĐlXɈӌiAIłƁB̓̍lA{Ńf߂ɂĂƎv܂BÔ͂͂̕肵Ă܂Bߌȃf߂ɕʂ̐l̓fɍsȂȂƂjIȎ邩łBA҂ɂĂ͍lĂȂƎvłBA͍NĂ̂͂ƌqłBN̉Ăɂf̑IɗLɐƂB͂悢łBAŖYĂ炢Ȃ肪܂B́Af͂đÎ߂̎ił͂ȂAI邢͐}ɏ]悤Ȃ̂ł͂ȂƂƂłB

m6:28n ͈ȑOfɂčlA̂悤ȂƂɋCÂ܂B{ł̓f͏WƋʂĂ܂BpłƁAf\͂낢날܂AɂassemblyłB͓{ŁuWvƖ󂳂Ă܂BfWassemblyȂłˁB{̌@21ɂ́uWAЁA\̎RvƂ̂܂ǂAuf̎RvȂB炩Ắuf̎Rvu\̎Rv獪Â悤Ș_܂ǁAPȌłBfassemblyłBuW̎Rvuf̎RvӖĂ킯łBȂ݂Ɍ@21ɂuЂ̎RvƂ\A͂킩Ȃ̂łB͉płassociation̎RȂłBuЁvƂƂقƂǂ̐l͔閧Ђ炢v΂ȂłBassociationƂ̂͂ǂɂł̂łBwZɍs΂܂BPTAABeƋtassociationȂłB܂ɂӂꂽtłB{łassemblyƂ̂͊񍇂łBǂ̑⒬ɂ񍇂܂BƎv܂AɂẮBꂪɂȂ킯łBmł͂񍇂cɂȂ킯łBcassemblyƂłB񍇂łB܂cƃf͐eʂ̂悤Ȃ̂łˁBƂ΁A\[wЉ__xŁu͖͂OassemblyvƏĂB̏ꍇAassemblyƂ̂͋cƂWEfƂӖƎv܂BjIɂ͐Ήɑ΂assemblyłˁBWEf񂾂Ƒ傫ȂċcƂďF悤ɂȂ킯łB̈Ӗŋc̋N̓fEWȂłˁB܂\[͂Ă܂Bl͏WɗƂɂ匠҂ƂčsƁBlƂ匠҂͌Xlł͂ȂłBXlWƂɓoꂷ̂łBɃ\[uʈӎvv݂Ă킯łBXlW߂ał͂܂B̏Wɂāuʈӎvv݂B烋\[͓̋cBCMXɂ񂵂ĂĂ܂BCMX̐l͎RƎvĂ邪A͑܂Bނ炪RȂ̂͋cI邠̂ƂŁAcI΂₢ȂACMXl͓zƂȂAɋAĂ܂ƁB܂\[͂Ă܂B\҂Ƃl͋ߐ̂̂łB͕ɗRĂƁB܂A\cɂ͎匠҂ƂĂ̐l͂܂B\҂͕ɂ̎̂悤Ȃ̂łB̂Ƃ݂͌̓{̑cm݂Ƃ悭킩܂B{񑊂߁Aނ͉̑ɂ킽鐢PłB쎞̕{q獡͂܂łBȋcɎ匠҂ƂĐl݂͂ȂBꂪ݂̂͂assemblyȂ킿fEWɂĂłB

m11:25n c܂l匠ɔ邩ƂƁAł͂܂BcfEWƂassembly𔽉f邩ÂŐl匠IłƂƂł܂BƂ΁AIɂČ܂ƂfŕςĂ܂͖̂ɔƂނ̔Ƃ܂B͖ł邩lƂȂ񂾂ƎvłBIŌ߂ƂfŏC邱Ƃ肤Ƃɐl匠ƂƂłłB̍OfEWA܂Ȍ̍OfEWł́A낢ۂ܂B͍̑O炢łǁAassemblyʂƂƂłBfƋcBf̑獑ɍsƂ͂ȂłȂfɈAɗĂBƂ܂BȂȂ΁Af{assemblyłBANp̂Ђ܂vł́Af̕ɍs܂BɂĂނf{assemblyłƂƂ킯łBނ͑Iŏ܂BA̓f̉Ǝv܂B܂łȂƍゾ߂ɂȂ܂BāA̓fEWȂiƌȂĂ͂ȂBɎ匠҂ƂĂ̐lƂ킯łB̖͐ł͂܂BfEW_łB̂Ƃ͍ĊmFĂƎv܂B

m13:47n ̍̍úu@9̍IӋvƂɂȂĂ܂A͎߂̂ł͂܂BCƂȂĂB񌛖@9ɕՓIȈӋ邱Ƃ͂܂܂BƂΌ@9́AJǵwiâ߂ɁxA邢́wEjIsIꂩ݂lނ̕Վj̍\zxƂ̂痈Ă܂BJg̗O͑ꎟA1920N̍ۘAƂČ܂B1928Nɂ͐푈@upsvꂽB@9͂󂯂̂łBpłł݂ƌ@9ɂ͂̒ꂽ\cĂ܂BÂ͍ƂɂČ邱Ƃ͂܂B݂Ȃ͌@9̕ՓIӋĊmFāAɂĉj~͂Ƃ悤ƍlĂ邩܂񂪁A͎͂̕Kv͂ȂƎvĂłBƂ̂́AȂ邱Ƃ͂ȂƎvĂ邩łB̘͂bBނ낻ɕՓIȈӋƎv܂B

m15:16n {̐㌛@́A9ɂĂ̓䂪܂BɁAEjIɈٗ̂̂悤ȏ{̌@ɂ̂͂ȂƂƂłBɁAꂪɂ炸sĂȂ̂͂ȂƂƂłBƂΎqAČRn݂Ă܂BOɁAsȂ̂ł΂ӂ͖@ς͂łA9͂܂cĂ̂͂ȂƂƂłB܂O̓䂩lĂ݂܂傤BΑA̓ƎvłBqČRnȂǂ́A@9̉߂ɂčm肳Ă܂B܂AWcIqA͌R̕ʖłB̂\Ƃ߉ȂĂ܂BA@9ςƂƂ͂ĂȂȂ̂łBȂȂ̂ł傤BނARƒNΑIŕĂ܂łBł́AȂĂ܂̂BlX@9x̂͐푈ւ̐[Ȃ邩炾Ƃ܂A͂^܂BƂsɂ̂悤ȋCƂĂAŌ@9̂悤Ȃ̂ł킯ȂBAꂪł̂͐̌RłB܂A@9lX̐푈̌ɂƂÂĂ̂ƂAȂl命ɂȂΏĂ܂ł傤BہAȂ̂ł͂Ȃƌ쌛_҂͌OĂ܂Bł͂Ȃ9cA܂lX͂낤Ƃ̂ł傤B쌛_҂́A͎炪푈̌oA܂@9̏dviĂ炾Ƃł傤BA͋^킵B

m17:35n Ŗ̔΂̑A܂茛@9pƍlĂ鑤݂Ă݂Ǝv܂Bނ60Nɂ킽Ăp悤ƂĂłȂBȂȂ̂ł傤Bނ́Ȃ͍mlɐ]Ă邩炾ƍl܂B͒[Iɂ܂łB͌@9Ɏ^ł͂ȂłBƂ1946N626V@Rc鍑cAQOY}ćA푈ɂ͐푈ƂłȂ푈BNꂽc邽߂̐푈͐̂ł͂ȂƏqׂ܂B͍ɂƂĂ͂ӂ̌łāA̐VɂĂłB̒ɂ͐ԌRhłAV̑͌Ɍ쌛hɓ]܂BAނ炪ӌςƂ鎑i͕ێhɂ͂܂BƂΎǂ̋gcΎ񑊂́AQO̎ɑ΂ĂłBߔN̐푈͍̑Ɩhq̖ɂčsȂꂽ邱Ƃ͌Ȃ鎖ł܂B̂ɐhqF߂邱Ƃ푈U䂦łƎv̂ł܂ƁBɒN푈ŃAJČR𔗂ꂽƂAނ͂₵ĂBČRȂǋ̍łAsl̖łƏĂ܂BȂƂێhccȂƎv܂Bނ͌@9̉߂ŏWcIqAR𐳓hqƂĂ܂Bvɕێhӌς킯łBƂ낪ނ͌@9p悤Ƃ͂ȂBȂBɂ邱ƂłȂłBꂪIő_ƂȂȂ΁Aŝ͊młBāAނ͂܂ȂĂقȂBژ_60N]肽Ƃ̂ɂ܂łȂłˁB͂ȂBނ玩gɂƂĂ̂͂łB̓𖾂悤ƂɁA}AiIlAml̂ɂB͎̖́AIグ邱ƂłB@9XɎcĂ̂́AlXӎIɎĂł͂܂Bł΂ƂɏĂł傤BlԂ̈ӎuȂǂ͋CŐƎȂ̂łB9͂䂦ɖӎ̖Ȃ̂łB

m21:06n ӎƂƈʂɁAӎĂȂƂẍӖŗĂ܂B邢݈͐ӎƓꎋĂ܂BƂΐȂǂŖӎA݈ӎɓTu~iʂ_Ƃ܂Bقǂꂽ悤ɉׂJԂĂƐl͂񂾂Ǝ󂯂Ƃ悤ɂȂ񂾂ƂӖłBAtCg͂̂悤Ȃ̂OӎƌĂŁAӎƂ͋ʂłBtCgӎɂ̎ނ܂B̓GXƂ̂ŁAuvƂƂŁAÂ悤̂Ȃ̂wĂ킯łB͒łB̍lł́A@9͒̂悤Ȃ̂łB̂悤Ȗӎ̒́AӎƂ͈قȂāAɂđ삷邱ƂłȂ̂łBɕێh60Nȏɂ킽w͓͂kJɏIĂ܂Bނ炪9͔񌻎IȗzłƑiƂŖʂłB9͖ӎ̎ɍ̂As\ȂłBӎIȎłΐ͂ł܂ǁBÂƂ𗝉ĂȂ̂͌쌛hlłB@9́A쌛h[ւ邱ƂɂđĂ̂ł͂܂B9͌쌛hɂĎĂ̂ł͂ȂB̋tɌ쌛h@9ɂĎĂB͂łĂ킯ł͂܂BɈSĂ悢ƂĂłBĂ̏ŉׂAȂ邩lĂق̂łB

m23:34n ͐{ɐ܂ꂽ@ɂ񂵂āAtCĝƂTO𓱓čl悤Ƃ܂B͂ɐSw̉pł͂܂BtCgɂčl悤ɂȂƂ́A[푈̖Ɗ֘AĂ̂łBɂďqׂĂƎv܂BtCg͑ꎟɁA邱ƂŖӎɂ񂷂l{IɕςłBɂđOtCgƌtCgɋʂłƎv܂BÕtCg̍lł́Aӎ~]𖞂ƂƁA𖞂Ƃ炷댯邽߂ɗ}悤Ƃ錻BƂ̂́AȂΎЉ̋K͂łBeʂĎqǂɍ荞܂BꂪӎɂĐlKA邢͌{킯łBtCǵwfx͂̂悤ȍlɂƂÂďĂ܂BA̍l͐V̂ł͂̂łAӖł͏펯IȂ̂łBƂ΁AlԂ͎v܂܂ɗ~]𖞂킯ɂ͂ȂB炻ɂė}ȂƂȂBĎЉIIȋK͂ɏ]ƂɂȂBꂪn邱ƂłBǁAɂƂɂ͂ꂩȂƂȂBƂ΍Ղ푈ɂȂƁAꂪƂ킯łBہAtCg͑ꎟ̒Ő푈ɂĂ͂ނmIłBĂ܂푈IΎRɌɖ߂ƍlĂ܂Bނ̍lς̂͐łBA͔ގg푈oƂɂ̂ł͂܂B

m26:09n ނ̍lς̂́Aɐ푈_oǂɋꂵފ҂ɏoƂłBނɂƂāA푈͂ɏǂł͂Ȃ킯łˁBӐ푈̖ĔыNĂ̂B̂悤Ȕ͉Ȃ̂Aɂ̂BtCg͂lBĔނ́AƌƂ悤ȓ񌳐̒Ɏ̗~A邢͂̔hłU~oBtCg͂l܂B҂̔́A푈ɊOɌĂU~ɓɌ邱ƂɂĐ̂ƁBtCgƂTON̂͂̌łBɎ͈̂ȑO炠܂B͌Sӎ̌{Ȃ̂łBA͎ЉIK͂eʂĎqǂɓʉĐ̂łB܂肻͊O痈̂łBɑ΂Ē͂Γ痈BȂȂΓl̗̎~AU~ɍĂ邩łBtCĝ̂悤ȍl̓WJ́A̐_͂ނނ̕_ɂĂ薾ɎĂƎv܂BtCg̍lT^IɎ̂́A1930Nɏw̒̋SnxƂ_łBŃtCǵA͌lł͂ȂWcɂƂ܂BƂނA͏Wc̕ɂ茰ɂƏĂ܂BĂ̒̏WcÏԂƂ킯łB̈ӖŁA͐̓{ɐ܂ꂽ@9𒴎ƂĂ݂̂ӂ킵Ǝv܂B΁Aӎł͂Ȃӎ̖ƂāBƂ΃tCǵA_oǂ̊҂͊O݂ƍߐӊɋꂵł悤ɂ݂邯ǂA̖{l͂ɂĉӎĂȂAƂƂwE܂BŃtCg͂uӎI߈vƌĂт܂B

m29:19n {l@9ɍŜ͂ƎĂ܂B͈̋_oǂłAuӎI߈v̂łBԂƁA{lɐ푈ɑ΂߈ƂĂA͈ӎIȂ̂ł͂ȂƂƂłB@9͐lX߈ꂽ̂ł͂ȂAߋ̍sւ̔Ȉӎ߂邱ƂɂĈێĂ̂ł܂BꂪӎIȔȂɂ̂łȂA9͂Ƃ̐̂ɔpĂł傤BȂȂӎς̂͂₷ƂłBȂŐ_ς邱Ƃ͂ł܂BȂ̂9ςȂ̂͂Ȃł傤Bŉh́AAsĂ邩炾ƎvA쌛h̋A炾ƍlBtɌ쌛h́Ah̐HɂĂBiƑĂ킯łB@9ɂ͐푈鋭ϗIȈӎu܂BA͈ӎI邢͎IɏoĂ̂ł͂܂B9͖炩ɐ̌R̋ɂ̂Ȃ̂łB^ɎIȌ@Vɍ낤Ƃlɂ͂ƂA܂BA@9ꂽ̂ƂƂƁA{lIɎ󂯓ꂽƂƂƂ͖Ȃ̂łB݂̂ƂAtCǧt͂̋^ɓĂƎv܂B

m31:20n ul͒ʏAϗIȗvŏɂA~̒fǑʂƂĐ܂ƍlłBł́Aϗ̗RsȂ܂܂łBۂɂ͂̔΂ɐis悤ɎvBŏ̗~̒fÓAO̗͂ɂċꂽ̂łA~̒fO߂ėϗ𐶂ݏoAꂪǐSƂŕ\A~̒fOɋ߂̂łBv

m31:58n tCĝ̍lׂ͂Ɍ@ɂď̂ł͂Ȃ̂ł @9ߒɂ܂ĂƎv܂BƂ̂́A@9͊Ó̗A܂̌R̎w߂ɂĐ܂ꂽ킯łBɂ炸A͓{l̖ӎɐ[蒅BȂB܂O̗͂ɂ푈iUj̒fOBꂪǐS𐶂ݏoāAꂪ푈̒fO߂邱ƂɂȂ킯łB猛@9͎IȈӎuɂĂł̂ł͂ȂBỎɂ̂łA炱͂̌ɐ[蒅̂łB͂lẌӎuɂ̂łΐȂAƂĂƂɔpĂƎv܂B

m32:56n ƂŁAl̖ӎ̏ꍇ͐_͈オΘbʂăANZXł邩܂񂪁AWc̏ꍇ͂͂܂BAIA[ɂȂƁA͂xoĂ܂B񂻂̂悤ȔF͂܂񂪁AoIɂꂪ킩ĂB˂炤}AƂ͂ƂȂƌ@9𑈓_Ђ߂܂BđǏł܂BԂĂ킯łB̂悤ȏWcIӎ͑I⍑[ʂȊOɎ@mȂ̂Ƃ΁Ał͂܂B͂m@Ǝv܂Bגoi_TvOjɂ鐢_łB̂́AAJ̐̐̈Ƃē̂ȂłBނ͓{̖剻ɂ͐_KvƍlBނ炪̂vw̗_ɂƂÂ_TvOɂ钲łB̓AJł܂sĂȂ̂ȂłBꂪ{ŎsꂽB1948NVsȂ_ŏ̂̂ƂĂ܂BӖł̂悤Ȑ_́A@9Ɨގ_܂B͂ǂ̌RAJłĂȂƂ{ł낤ƂBɂ̗ގ_́ǍR{̓̂߂Ɏ񂾂̂̂ǍRɂƂėڂɏoƂłBƂ΁AN푈n܂ƂɃ}bJ[T[͌@9ƂƎv܂Bނ͂ŋgc΂ɍČRAČ@̉v킯łBgc͂ȂfBɂċgc͉z^łĂ܂B܂A{͍ČR̂߂̎ȂBꂪ̗RłBɁAvz̎猾āAČR̔wiׂSIՂSĂBOɁARȂ푈ɋ藧ĂꂽɂƂāAs̏ՂcĂāȀ̖I炴̂ƁBgcɁuSIՁvƂus̏ՁvƂ̂͂ȂB炭ނ͐_̌ʂmĂ̂ł͂ȂƎv܂Bނ͂lBōČR炽ւȔΉ^NAtǂ납vɂȂĂ܂ƁB炭ނ͂}bJ[T[ɂɂȂBAgc΂̓}bJ[T[̗vɏ]Čx@\܂BČRNɌ̈Sۏ̂߂ƂڂłBƂ͂Agc͂܂Ō@͑ނBx@\ۈAqƔWĂiKłÁúvł͂ȂƂāA@9̉̕Kvے肵łB͂Ӗ9̉߉̂悤Ȃ̂łBȗA9̕ʂςȂ܂܂ɁAɑ悤ȌRg傪ȂꑱĂ킯łB

m37:17n Ő_ƑI̊֌WɂĈꌾqׂĂ܂B_炢ƁAI͏WcIӎƂĂ̐_\̂ɂ͂Ȃ肦܂BȂȂΑ_BȂA[TĒႭA[҂̒nNȂǂ̊ɂ΂肪邩łBIʂČ@9悤ƂꍇAŌɍ[sKv܂B[炩͉̑\A_\ɔf̂Ƃ͂܂񂪁A_͂肵Ă̂ŁA[AӎOʂɏoĂ܂B䂦ɍ[ł͕Ă܂܂BIŏĂ[Ŕsk΁A͒vIȃ_[W󂯂܂B߉ێłȂȂĂ܂\BނIł9B̑_ƂȂsƎv܂B琭{}͕i9̉Ăɂ炸AIƂȂƂČ@9𑈓_ɂ͂ȂłBłB

m38:47n ȂA_mƂƂł́A_TvOɂ鐢_̕ƓImƎv܂BȀꍇ͎̂ɒӂȂƂȂłBƂ΁u@9ǂvvƂ悤Ȏ͂߂ȂłARƂĂ邩Bu@9p邩ǂvƊm肵ĖȂƂȂBƂɂK؂ɂ邱Ƃ̐SłBȂɂ₤Ă鑊͌Xl̈ӎƂł͂ȂāAӎ܂ȂłBłɂƁA݂Ă悤ȓdbɂ̓_TvOɂȂȂƎv܂BdbĂȂl͏OĂ܂܂BƂɍŋ߂̎҂͌gтĂȂłȂłBł̓_Ȓoɂ͂Ȃ܂BʐڂȂƂȂłÂłȂBvɎ̂́A@9ӎ̒łƂƂ́ASIȉł͂ȂāAvwIɗÂ̂ƂƂłB

m40:20n ŌɈꌾBݐEŐ푈̊@Ă邱Ƃ͂܂܂Bǂ̍̊@̂ƂɂAꂼɑ΍uĂ܂BĂꂪɉeAݓIɓGΐSB̒œ{ŗDɂȂĂ̂́AčƂ̌RiWcIqjmƂĂłB͐푈ؔ̂Ƃł̓AXeBbNȑΉł悤ɂ݂܂BAtɊẽAXeBbNȑΉ̂ŁAvȂŐE푈Ɋ܂Ă܂WR
̂łBꎟ͂܂ɂ̂łB[bp̒nIȕAI[XgAƃZrA̕AR̍ۓIlbg[Nɂē{Q悤ȐE푈ɓWJĂ킯łB{̏ꍇ͓płB܂̑ꎟ̌ʂƂčۘA܂A푈@Ƃusv܂B{̌@9́usvɕƂ͐ɂ܂ǁAۘAEނAusv𓥂݂ɂ͎̂̓hCcƓ{Ȃ̂łBǂ̂悤ȃJgIO}΂āÄSAXeBbNɊmۂ悤Ƃ킯łB̌ʂ񎟑łBāAhq̂߂̏WcIR͉畽aۏႷ̂ł͂ȂB

m42:27n AꂪAXeBbNȂƍlĂ܂Bē{l邽߂ɂ͉ƂĂ񌻎IȌ@9pȂ΂ȂȂƂƂɂȂ܂BAނ͂]łł܂B60Nȏɂ킽Č@9p悤ƂĂ̂ɁAłȂ̂łBێh̒́AȂłȂ̂킩ȂȂAԂ߂Ă̂Ǝv܂B񂢂ɂ܂BAłƂ͍lĂȂB̂ɋcőhƂȂĈۖ@Ă̂悤Ȗ@邱ƂA܂Ɍ@ɋً}ԏȂǂŁA9𖳗͉@Ƃ낤Ɖ􂵂Ă܂B͍ł͒ʂĂ[ł͊mɋp܂AȂł傤BvɈ{́A9Ă푈ł悤ȑ̐낤ƂĂ킯łB

m43:40n 䂦Ɍ쌛h9ȂȂĂ܂̂ł͂ȂƂƂKv͂܂܂B͂ނ쌛ĥɉ邠܂9̏𕶂ێł΂悢ƍlӂ邱ƂłB̏ł̂9邾ȂA9Ăłł悤ȑ̐ɂȂĂ܂܂BꂪɋN肤邱ƂłB̈ӖŎ͌@9̉Ă͂ȂƂBނɂ͐XXƌ@9ςǂƂ΂łBЍ[܂傤Bׂ32̋cȂȂĂAꏏɂ܂傤ƂāAS^ɉĂłA[ɂ悤ƁB͏kB

m44:44n 璍ӂׂƂ́Aނ炪@9ς邱ƂȂ܂܂ȎŐ푈s̐Ă܂ƂłBɓ{푈Ɋ܂邱Ƃ͑傢ɂ肦܂B邢͂̂悤Ȋ@čoČ@͂ƂƂ肦ł傤BÂɂǂȂ邩Ƃ΁Aꍂ㏞𕥂Č@9Ăю߂ƂɂȂ邾łBȂƂ݂݂͌ĂłBāA푈̊@g߂ɔ鎞ɂĂƂAXeBbNȂ́Aʂɔ񌻎IƖڂĂ錛@9fA𕶎ʂs邱ƂłB9s邱Ƃ́A炭{lłB̕ՓI͂ȍsׂłBꂪ̉ɂ悤Ɂu@9̍IӋvłB

me҃Rgn

iɕt͓̍ĐԂłB^CvȂǂŊԈႢ炲e͂B
ȂAwE 2015N9xigXjɂ́AuƂĂ̕avƂłقړ|͂̕fڂĂ܂B

http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/300.html

[EIEmgj200] Jslu@9̍IӋv(2016N123ũeLXgN) FGkN
Jslu@9̍IӋv(2016N123ũeLXgN)
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/300.html

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo200/msg/635.html
[eXg31] eXg
ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂ
http://digital.asahi.com/articles/DA3S12228246.html
VfW^@2016N2260500

@uȂg߂oȂ悤ɋCȂƂˁv

@eřł́AȎsIȌloĂ܂B

@uȂ񂾂ォ疳̃vbV[Ăłˁv

@ǂ̐l܂B

@sc̔́AɌ͂𔭊Ă悤łBǂɓdg~𖽂邱ƂłB܂Œ{悤ȂƂ𕽑RƌĂ̂bBׂƂłBĂ̖ȂAЂԂĂ܂˂ȂłB

@sŏɏô͂QW̏Oc@\ZψB傫񂶂̂͒VłBXt̂PʍɂRiƁAڗłB̓̑̐V͎グȂAقǑ傫Ȉł͂ȂŁA̍Dfł傤B̌Aeɍsɒڂ悤ɂȂ܂B

@͂PʂŔ񂶂ŁASʂ́uœ_̘^vŁA̓Iȓق̓eLڂĂ܂Bǂł݂܂傤B

@qIȖԑg̕ҏWɂẮAsΕs}̗ꂩ̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂԑgŜƂăoX̂Ƃꂽ̂ł邱ƂƉ߂ĂB̓ḰA̔ԑgł͂ȂƎ҂̔ԑgŜ݂Ĕfr
meҒF uœ_̘^@O@E\Zψ@Wv VfW^@2016N29 http://digital.asahi.com/articles/DA3S12200600.html n

@@@@@

@u̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂvuoX̂Ƃꂽ́vƂƂ𔻒f̂́ANBf̂łB͐ƂłA̐IMOĂ܂B̐l猩āu΂ĂvƔfꂽ̂́A{ɕ΂̂Ȃ̂B^o܂B

@Ƃ낪A̒ȎRɂ́AuԑǵA@ɒ߂錠ɊÂꍇłȂ΁AlA͋K邱ƂȂvƋK肳Ă܂B܂@́A͂̊rAǂ̎RȊۏႵ̂łAŚA̍ۂ̓w͖ڕŴɉ߂ȂƂ̂wE̒łB

@ԑgҏW̊{j߂SA͂ǂɑ΂Ė߂鍪ƂĎgB܂ƂɌ͂Ƃ͖fȂ̂łB炱A@ꂽ̂ɁB

@@@@@

@{tƂẮȂĂƂƐĂ܂A̓_ɊւĒ͂POtŁAQOOVN̕ci}łjł̑c瑍̍قЉĂ܂B̒őc͓dg~߂ɂāAuKp\Ƃ͎vBAs͑Ϗd̂ŁAɕKvȏ̒񋟂sȂȂA\̎R𐧖񂵂肷鑤ʂ邱ƂAɂ߂đ傫ȎЉIe炷BāA_TdɔfĂׂƍlĂvƏqׂĂ܂B
meҒFus̒gɔg@^}ɂTdΉ߂鐺v VfW^@2016N2100504 http://digital.asahi.com/articles/ASJ295DB7J29UTFK00Q.html n

@͂̍sg͗}IłȂ΂ȂȂBs@̉ł̑ÓȔfł傤B

@AςƁAjȂȂĂ܂ƂƂA̍s͎Ă܂B

@Ԃ́Aǂ̊ē𑍖ȂĂ邩B̍ہAAJ̘AMʐMψiebbĵ悤ȓƗψȂ\ƂĊē悤Ȏdg݂Kvm܂B

@{Дs̍ŏIłɂĂ܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/444.html

[eXg31] eXg

ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂ
http://digital.asahi.com/articles/DA3S12228246.html
VfW^@2016N2260500

@uȂg߂oȂ悤ɋCȂƂˁv

@eřł́AȎsIȌloĂ܂B

@uȂ񂾂ォ疳̃vbV[Ăłˁv

@ǂ̐l܂B

@sc̔́AɌ͂𔭊Ă悤łBǂɓdg~𖽂邱ƂłB܂Œ{悤ȂƂ𕽑RƌĂ̂bBׂƂłBĂ̖ȂAЂԂĂ܂˂ȂłB

@sŏɏô͂QW̏Oc@\ZψB傫񂶂̂͒VłBXt̂PʍɂRiƁAڗłB̓̑̐V͎グȂAقǑ傫Ȉł͂ȂŁA̍Dfł傤B̌Aeɍsɒڂ悤ɂȂ܂B

@͂PʂŔ񂶂ŁASʂ́uœ_̘^vŁA̓Iȓق̓eLڂĂ܂Bǂł݂܂傤B

@qIȖԑg̕ҏWɂẮAsΕs}̗ꂩ̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂԑgŜƂăoX̂Ƃꂽ̂ł邱ƂƉ߂ĂB̓ḰA̔ԑgł͂ȂƎ҂̔ԑgŜ݂Ĕfr

muœ_̘^@O@E\Zψ@WviVfW^ 2016N29j\eҒn

@@@@@

@u̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂvuoX̂Ƃꂽ́vƂƂ𔻒f̂́ANBf̂łB͐ƂłA̐IMOĂ܂B̐l猩āu΂ĂvƔfꂽ̂́A{ɕ΂̂Ȃ̂B^o܂B

@Ƃ낪A̒ȎRɂ́AuԑǵA@ɒ߂錠ɊÂꍇłȂ΁AlA͋K邱ƂȂvƋK肳Ă܂B܂@́A͂̊rAǂ̎RȊۏႵ̂łAŚA̍ۂ̓w͖ڕŴɉ߂ȂƂ̂wE̒łB

@ԑgҏW̊{j߂SA͂ǂɑ΂Ė߂鍪ƂĎgB܂ƂɌ͂Ƃ͖fȂ̂łB炱A@ꂽ̂ɁB

@@@@@

@{tƂẮȂĂƂƐĂ܂A̓_ɊւĒ͂POtŁAQOOVN̕ci}łjł̑c瑍̍قЉĂ܂B̒őc͓dg~߂ɂāAuKp\Ƃ͎vBAs͑Ϗd̂ŁAɕKvȏ̒񋟂sȂȂA\̎R𐧖񂵂肷鑤ʂ邱ƂAɂ߂đ傫ȎЉIe炷BāA_TdɔfĂׂƍlĂvƏqׂĂ܂B

mus̒gɔg@^}ɂTdΉ߂鐺viVfW^ 2016N210j\eҒn

@͂̍sg͗}IłȂ΂ȂȂBs@̉ł̑ÓȔfł傤B

@AςƁAjȂȂĂ܂ƂƂA̍s͎Ă܂B

@Ԃ́Aǂ̊ē𑍖ȂĂ邩B̍ہAAJ̘AMʐMψiebbĵ悤ȓƗψȂ\ƂĊē悤Ȏdg݂Kvm܂B

@{Дs̍ŏIłɂĂ܂B

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/445.html

[EIEmgj201] ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂiVfW^j

ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂ
http://digital.asahi.com/articles/DA3S12228246.html
VfW^@2016N2260500

@uȂg߂oȂ悤ɋCȂƂˁv

@eřł́AȎsIȌloĂ܂B

@uȂ񂾂ォ疳̃vbV[Ăłˁv

@ǂ̐l܂B

@sc̔́AɌ͂𔭊Ă悤łBǂɓdg~𖽂邱ƂłB܂Œ{悤ȂƂ𕽑RƌĂ̂bBׂƂłBĂ̖ȂAЂԂĂ܂˂ȂłB

@sŏɏô͂QW̏Oc@\ZψB傫񂶂̂͒VłBXt̂PʍɂRiƁAڗłB̓̑̐V͎グȂAقǑ傫Ȉł͂ȂŁA̍Dfł傤B̌Aeɍsɒڂ悤ɂȂ܂B

@͂PʂŔ񂶂ŁASʂ́uœ_̘^vŁA̓Iȓق̓eLڂĂ܂Bǂł݂܂傤B

@qIȖԑg̕ҏWɂẮAsΕs}̗ꂩ̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂԑgŜƂăoX̂Ƃꂽ̂ł邱ƂƉ߂ĂB̓ḰA̔ԑgł͂ȂƎ҂̔ԑgŜ݂Ĕfr

muœ_̘^@O@E\Zψ@Wv VfW^ 2016N29@\eҒn

@@@@@

@u̐Iɕ΂邱ƂȂvuoX̂Ƃꂽ́vƂƂ𔻒f̂́ANBf̂łB͐ƂłA̐IMOĂ܂B̐l猩āu΂ĂvƔfꂽ̂́A{ɕ΂̂Ȃ̂B^o܂B

@Ƃ낪A̒ȎRɂ́AuԑǵA@ɒ߂錠ɊÂꍇłȂ΁AlA͋K邱ƂȂvƋK肳Ă܂B܂@́A͂̊rAǂ̎RȊۏႵ̂łAŚA̍ۂ̓w͖ڕŴɉ߂ȂƂ̂wE̒łB

@ԑgҏW̊{j߂SA͂ǂɑ΂Ė߂鍪ƂĎgB܂ƂɌ͂Ƃ͖fȂ̂łB炱A@ꂽ̂ɁB

@@@@@

@{tƂẮȂĂƂƐĂ܂A̓_ɊւĒ͂POtŁAQOOVN̕ci}łjł̑c瑍̍قЉĂ܂B̒őc͓dg~߂ɂāAuKp\Ƃ͎vBAs͑Ϗd̂ŁAɕKvȏ̒񋟂sȂȂA\̎R𐧖񂵂肷鑤ʂ邱ƂAɂ߂đ傫ȎЉIe炷BāA_TdɔfĂׂƍlĂvƏqׂĂ܂B

mus̒gɔg@^}ɂTdΉ߂鐺v VfW^ 2016N210@\eҒn

@͂̍sg͗}IłȂ΂ȂȂBs@̉ł̑ÓȔfł傤B

@AςƁAjȂȂĂ܂ƂƂA̍s͎Ă܂B

@Ԃ́Aǂ̊ē𑍖ȂĂ邩B̍ہAAJ̘AMʐMψiebbĵ悤ȓƗψȂ\ƂĊē悤Ȏdg݂Kvm܂B

@{Дs̍ŏIłɂĂ܂B

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo201/msg/877.html

[EIEmgj201] ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂiVfW^j G̎
2. [1] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N227 11:56:06 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[57]
͌TCg̖o^ŁBǗlLɍ폜܂

͐\󂠂܂łB

e
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo201/msg/877.html#c2

[m点EǗ21] 2016NQ@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
143. [2] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N227 12:16:54 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[58]
>>141
K𗝉܂B
͓eLɉ蕔̃RsyȂ悤ɋC܂B
݂܂łB

ȂÄp̋KɂĂ͂m点ł̊ǗlRgŖĂ̂Ɛ@܂ACf̓ēJuCf̓eK 2011.09.12Łvł͖Ă܂łBeK̃Abvf[gv]܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/433.html#c143

[m点EǗ21] 2016NQ@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
145. [3] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N227 16:01:25 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[59]
>>144
>G̎҂̓e\ɖ߂Ă܂B

>eKɖLĂȂƂmF܂B
>܂ɓÔƂȂ̂ŁÂƂ͂̂܂܂ɂĂ܂B

OCȂĂǂ߂VL̃RsyȂ悢Ao^ăOCȂΓǂ߂Ȃ̃Rsy͂ȂƂ̂́A͂āuÔƁvł傤BVL̒쌠ӂ肩ꂩ炷΁AǂȂ̂ł͂܂񂩁B

NÔƂłAluO̗LLiԖJĂjRsyĂ̂ŁAYeL̃RgŐ񂽂Ȃ߂Ƃ܂Bm点łRsyLƒ쌠̖ɂĂ̋c_ڂɂ܂BǁACfŃRsyeiт̍j́A܂薾mɎꂽƂȂ̂ł͂܂񂩁Bꂪł̂͂܂Ȃ̂ŁAeKûƂ͂̂܂܁vɂĂƂ̂Ȃf낤Ǝv܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/433.html#c145

[EIEmgj201] ir㏲̐VȂȂߓǂ݁js̓dg~@͖͂fȂiVfW^j G̎
3. [4] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N228 10:07:04 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[60]
eҕ⑫F

̒r㏲̋ĹAua@ΒBvuOőSpďЉĂBuav̌TCgœǂ񂾕p킩₷ACfłǂނƂłBuavɂuVfW^vɂALǂ߂ȂȂɈCfł̈pLǂ߂Ƃ̂ARsyeLȂȂ݈̑Ӌ1ł͂Ȃ낤B

{fBA͐{ƃxbhC@s̓dg~ƃLX^[Ǖ
http://blog.goo.ne.jp/aibatatuya/e/16005cd920a7acd64380fc627ca6440b
a@ΒB@2016N0228

{fBA͐{ƃxbhC@s̓dg~ƃLX^[Ǖia@ΒBj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo202/msg/103.html
e ΖV 2016N22807:04:32
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo201/msg/877.html#c3

[m点EǗ21] 2016NQ@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
149. [5] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N229 18:02:36 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[62]
>>147

lӂ܂B

ƂŁA>>146̓eLł́Ae҂pLɂĘ_Ă܂BRsy̓eƂЂƂȂ݂ɂeɂuv̈psKpׂȂ̂ǂ́A̗]n邾낤Ǝv܂BuvpłȂƂȂ΁Aǎ҂͌Lɑēe҂̘_邱ƂłȂȂ܂BłƂ>>148ŐGĂ悤ȁAe҂̘_ƈpL̕ʂ̃oX̖͂̂ł傤ˁB
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/433.html#c149

[oϖ106] XeBObcułׂłȂv@یoϕ͉i{oϐVj
XeBObcułׂłȂv@یoϕ͉
http://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXLASFK16H26_W6A310C1000000/
2016/3/16 9:51 (2016/3/16 11:58XV)@{oϐV@

@{16ߑOAEoςɂėL҂ƈӌuۋZoϕ͉v߂ĊJButƂďm[xoϊw܂̎܎҂łWZtEXeBObcăRrA勳́AEoς͓ǂɂu2016N͂キȂ邾낤vƂ̌Bũ݂^C~Oł͏łグ鎞ł͂ȂvƂqׁANS̏ŗ10ւ̈グ悤񌾂B

@̊[16ߑŐL҉ŁuXeBObcŐɂāAvN̂ł͂ȂƂ̊ϓ_Aňグ͂܂̃^C~Oł͂ȂƂ̎|̔vƐB

@͉̏IA{WO񑊂ƃXeBObĉقA񑊂̌oϐ̃u[𖱂߂lcGA{cxNt[Q^ӌBXeBObc͎񑊊@ŋLҒcɁu񑊂́iŐ摗j炭AmɌ邾낤vƏqׂB

@񑊂͕͉̖ŁuɐuT~bg̋c̐ӔCʂ߁AĚoρEZɂėȈӌBAxm~NXɊւĂAǂǂӌ𒸂vƂB

@XeBObc͕͉ŁuEoς͒ĂvƂ̔F\BűZ􂾂ł͌EBɍƂ邱ƂdvvƋA{ɍo𑣂B

@͉̍ɂ͐ΌLWoύEĐABъYoώYƑMꉭA̍cFقoȁB{cAlcȂB

@͉17ɕăn[o[hw̃f[EWQ\ƌ╛قœ{oόZ^[̊cꐭB22ɂ̓m[xoϊw܂܂|[EN[O}ĂԁB

@񑊂͂܂ł̍قőł̐ɂāuEoς̎kNĂ邩AIn番͂fĂ˂΂ȂȂvƔĂB񑊎ӂ́uL҂oώk̃XNwEȂ瑝Ō̔f͂肤vƌB

@T~bg܂ŌpIɊJ\ŁAT̑^AxɈ{񑊂BKۂɂOVŌňoϊw҂͉JŒĂB
http://www.asyura2.com/16/hasan106/msg/603.html

[EIEmgj202] oϕ͉Fuŉv^}@IɌxiVj
oϕ͉Fuŉv^}@IɌx
http://mainichi.jp/articles/20160317/k00/00m/010/133000c
2016N316@2158iŏIXV@316@2241j V

@{́uۋZoϕ͉v̂PUɁAut̃XeBObcăRrA勳ŉ񌾂ƂŁA^}͕B{WO񑊂NS̏ŗPOւ̈グɌX̂ł͂ȂƂ̊ϑL炾B}ɂ́AōĉŉUAOQI||Ƃ̌܂AIɓ铮on߂B

@u܂肾vB}̈ĺAԂ₢B񑊂͉AXeBObcŉ咣{cxNAlcGꗼt[Q^ƖSTԁAkĂBuŐ΁iŐ摗Łj񑊂̋Cł܂邾낤v

@ŉƏO@U𗍂߂錩́AQOPSNɗႪ邩炾BAXeBObc͊e̐ϋɓIȎvnoĂтAiC΍ŉɁuv^iDB^}ł́AĂ̎Q@IɌv]܂iC΍łoAŐ摗𖼖ڂɉUďOQIɎނƂ̃ViI₩n߂B

@I̎Q@ćuO@c̕nł̊ŁAʂvƊҁB̏O@ćuI|X^[͂߂vƖACɑI[hɂȂĂBAIɐTdȌ}̐Γcj͂PŰL҉Łui͉ƁjO@Uт͔̂􂵂ł͂ȂvƂ񐧂B

@A}̎}Kj͂PŰL҉ŁuiPSN̉ɂ́jw͐΂Ɂiŗjグxƌ͎̂񑊂BłȂȂoω^c厸sƔF߂邱ƂvƔᔻB

@A}uIVtgv߂ĂB́APỦ̑_̂悤ɁAQ@Ȉd_I悾łȂAO@Iɂn߂ĂBY}͓AQ@I|X^[𔭕\B]Q{߂TOƂBRFLǒ͉ŁuO@Ił̃|X^[őivƏqׁAI[hɓƂ킹BycAeRNz
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo202/msg/865.html

[EIEmgj202] XeBObcułׂłȂv@یoϕ͉i{oϐVjFoϔN
XeBObcułׂłȂv@یoϕ͉i{oϐVj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/hasan106/msg/603.html
e G̎ 2016 N 3 16 22:44:33
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo202/msg/866.html
[EIEmgj203] ᑬ񁕘NIQ@VI͐̓}X䂤Ɉ{I}͌艺 Ԃ
7. [6] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N318 12:38:43 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[83]
Yippeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!
̂𓮂ĉĂ炢܂B
}܂B
Y}ѕĎRꂳƂ̍ӂɂĂ悢񍐂҂Ă܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/119.html#c7
[EIEmgj203] u̗vɂȂ炸v@j@O@sooŃXeBObc@傪k i{_ƐVj
u̗vɂȂ炸v@j@O@sooŃXeBObc@傪k
http://www.agrinews.co.jp/modules/pico/index.php?content_id=36655
2016/3/18@{_ƐV e_lbg

@}͂PVAsŁAm[xoϊw܎܎҂ŕăRrAw̃WZtEXeBObcƂ̍kJB́Asooɂāu̗vɂ͂Ȃ炸AƂ𗘂邾vusg債A󂷁vȂǂƋOB

@kɂ́A}cL҂łusooj~cṽo[QB

@oȎ҂ɂƁAXeBObćAsoo͖IȉߒoĂȂƖ莋BɁAÕɊւu傫ȐЂdg݂ɂȂĂǍNȂvƂ̌B

@ɁAƂƍƂ̕葱߂ƁEƑiׁihrcjɋO\BOƂio̐{i邱ƂpA̍̊یKނ鋰ꂪƑiB

@{́AsooFĂƊ֘A@ĂɒoA}BoȂ}c̈ĺu炽߂Ăsoo̖肪ƂBƂĂH~߂Ȃ΂ȂvƑB

m{_ƐV e_lbg ֘ALn

soo͈@ċcŔyʁ@m[xoϊw܁EXeBObc (2016/3/17j
http://www.agrinews.co.jp/modules/pico/index.php?content_id=36639
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/138.html

[EIEmgj203] XeBObcuuSٗpACN[WAʂȂv i}j
XeBObcuuSٗpACN[WAʂȂv
2016N0317@}

@}Љn{͂PVAWZtEXeBObcăRrAwAsōuJBXeBObc͂QOPSNɖSȂoϊw҂̌̉FÕVJSwł̋qŁA̖K͉F򎁂̒ǓuŝړIBF򎁂AĖ}ݗVN^N̗𖱂߂o܂A̍uB

@uɐ旧Aȏ\s}Љn{̎g݂ЉAuw킪ӂ𓾂xƎv̂́AXeBObc̐̒ɁAwiƐ키xƂwlԂւ̓̊gxƂƂĂA܂ɎǂlĂbƍvĂB̂bAi̕ǂǂ菜Ax͂ǂ݁A{IȐɂ͂ǂ炢̂AvƂB

@XeBObc͕č̌ɂāAuقǕ􂵂ĂƂ͂ȂvƂĊi̊gwEBƂ΁Ač̎Ɨ͂TxƂĂ邪IȎƗ͂ƍA̐Lт؂ĂƂB̏œ{ƕč͓悤ȉۑĂ邱ƂƎwEAKvȂƂ́uL΂߂̍vłAuSٗpACN[WiہjAʂȂƁv邱ƂƎ咣B̋̍ƂẮAYfł⑊łȂǂ̐ŐAqĎxƒxAJԂZkĘJ𕪂ƁAjԂ̒i𐥐邱ƂȂǂz肳ƂB

@܂AsooɂẮA񍇈ӂéAč̈ꕔ̑Ƃ̗v̂߂̂̂ƂȂĂAngЉȂǂւ̊ϓ_ȂAuQPI̋ߑЉɂӂ킵ɂȂĂȂvȂǂƔᔻB

@ǔAc\u{̂fcôQ{Ƃߑȍ钆AoƍSǂoXׂvƎBXeBObćA𑝂₳ɌiCh@ƂĂ͐Ő̖傫Ƃ̔FAłɂẮu󋵂ɈvȂǂƂĔےIȌB

@i͓cKvۋǒ߂B

[eXg31] eXg
XeBObcoiǂɂ{j@
1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zt@Qi񑊊@j
https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/kokusaikinyu/dai1/gijisidai.html

uQv

ƋZ̈𒴂A
SŎIȐɌ

WZtEEEXeBObc

2016N3

mp.2n

IDX͍ǂɂ邩

EɖȐ\iGreat MalaisejAVȖ}fiNew Mediocrej
@ÊƂ܂@ł͂ȂB

@EAG7̑̍Xł́iBꂽP[X܂߁jPIɑ̎ƂĂB
@@NwЉ̎嗬cꂽwł͍Xɍ̎ƂB

@E̊ɖȐ̉ʎ͈ꕔ̃gbvwɕ΂ĕzĂ\i͊g債Ȁ㏸͒؁B
@@Euɂ́vƗႢƂĂ鍑łAٗp̎╢BꂽƂɂ͋^╄B

@EEoϊ@Oɂւ炸A2007N̐Eoς͎ۂɂ͎ォB
@@@EouɂĎxĂB
@@@Eoϊ@O2007N̐E߂ƂƂ́AĉXێĂ̂ƓA
@@@@アoςɖ߂Ă܂ƂӖB

E錩ʂ\Ȑɖ߂\͏AiCނ؂̉\͍B
@EYiou̎kւ́AƂȌOB
@EƂƂz̍钆AV͋z̎{oɒʁB

mp.3n

LєYޕčo

E1980N1998N܂ł̌oϐpĂƂA̕čGDṔAGDP15%
@قǍ̂ƂȂĂ͂łB

E̘JQ}ɐi1980N㏉ƔrĂA݂̐YNl̏AƗ͒ႢB

Eʂ́iƌvj́A1989NƔr1%̏㏸BĂȂB

Eŉw̎60NOႢB

ENw̃AtJnAJl̎Ɨ͖23.7%B

mp.4n

mOtnčfcõgh mȗn

mp.5n

B͂ƈ

EƗ͍XɍB

EɎNw̎Ƃ[B

EoϐXɒႢB

E[@͏IĂȂBꎞIȁuNԁiremissionjvɂ邾B
@Eʉ݂@\邽߂ɕKvȐxn݂ĂȂB
@@āA̐xn݂錩݂ʂȂB

EB̌ƁAɉBoϐĂƂĂ낤pƂ̊Ԃɂ̓Mbv݁B

mp.6n

@ȗAB̃ptH[}X͔ߎSȂ

mOtn[̂fcõgh mȗn

mp.7n

EEZ@ȗAEoς̌B
@Ei͒ړIAԐړIɉe󂯂B

E[ȌoόƂȂ錩݁B

EBƕčł́Aoς̌𖄂ߍ킹邱Ƃ͂łȂB

mp.8n

sithe Great RecessionjɊւff

̋Z@ł͂ȂB

Es̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

EKv炩sꂽihbhEtN@jB

EAoς͖ɌSȏԂɖ߂ĂȂB
@ENWbgEl̉Pɏ\ȒӂĂȂB
@ÊƂ́AZɘa҂ꂽقǂ̌ʂ𓾂ĂȂR̈B

mp.9n

sithe Great RecessionjɊւff

̃oXV[gsł͂ȂB

EƂ̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

EƂɐϋɓIɂȂȂ̂́AoXV[g⎑B̖ł͂ȂB
@EvȂƂȂ̂B

mp.10n

XȂ錜O

EiIȐE̕sύt
@E[ĂB

EΏ̂Ȓ
@E̒ቺɒʂ鍑ƁiƁAƌvj͏𓾂ȂB
@EƁiƁAƌvj͂̎̕xo𑝉ĂȂB
@Ei̕ϓւ̑Ήł͈ȉ̓_B
@@@Eỉ͎v𑝉Ɗ҂ĂAusҁvilosersjւ̈e
@@@@̕։vĂB

mp.11n

ESIۑ̐ff

EEIȑv̕sB

EƑ܂āAeɂāAfՃZN^[ւ̎x͕s\B

EEZւ̉ߓẍˑB

EɍL݂΁A30NOɎsoς̃[̓]iŐ̍Đ݌vAȎRj̃vZX
@̐iŎn܂B́A̖ژ_ɔāAXȂoϐ̒ቺAs艻A
@sB

mp.12n

iGreat malaisej́AقǂɐiWȂA[Ȗ𕢂BĂ

ECϓ

EiA̕nw
@Ex̕sAN̕siÂ𖯊Ԃ̒񋟂Ɉˑ鍑ɂẮjAٔւ̃ANZX̕sA
@@ƑɓnB
@Eił͒ԑwkBr㍑ɂĂԑwkB
@É̖AЉ̎嗬cꂽwi΂΁jNwł͓ɐ[B

EI邽߂ɂ́AOIȁu\ϊvvistructural transformationsj߂B

Esoςɍt肪AY̒؂炵ĂB
@EԕEI̗ɂZIuB
@Ebւ̓̕sBāA̍ł̓Ctւ̓̕sB
@Eߓx̋ZBߓx̋Z͈ȉ̉ߒ̈ꕔłÄꕔłB
@@@ExƎ{̊Ԃ̃Mbv̍LB
@@@E̍ŎYoɑ΂x̊܂AYoɑ΂鎑{̔䗦ቺB
@EVXe̓K̎sB

mp.13n

IID̏󋵂ւ̑Ή

R̎iɊւΗ錩FZ

EŹAT˂̖SB

E[Ȓ؎ɂāAZ􂪋ɂ߂ėLƂ͂܂łɂȂB
@B̌ʓIȎi͍B

E{̖́A[ł͂ȂB邱ƁiႦ}CiẌ̗ɓƂĂj
@͋@\ȂB
E}CiX݂̎́AiC傫͎hAp炷\B

EʓIɘa͕sg債BAiƂĂj̑啝ȑɂ͂Ȃ炸A
@Zs̕sS邢͕sɂAXÑ~XvCVO₻̑̋Zs̘c݂
@炵\B
@Eȕ։v̈́AIȒʉ݂̐؂艺łBÁA[ETEQ[B
@EK؂ȍȂł́AuB̑Iv͍XɈrB

mp.14n

R̎iɊւΗ錩F

E􂪍̃XN߂錜OB
@E20082009NɎ{iCh͌ʂȂƂ͑S̊ԈႢB
@E΍􂪂Ȃ΍XɈĂł낤Ɨ̒ቺ炷ƂłAXȂiCށAs
@@Ɋׂ̂hB
@E@ɂẮAxoœK鎞Ԃ͂ȂB\ƂAsSȍΏołĂAʂ
@@pɂ邱ƂsɔׂΖ]܂B
@Eւ̌ÓAoXV[gEAv[ւ̖̂ւBł́A{͐YIȓ
@@΂Ďxo邱ƂOƂĂB

EO[o[[Vɂ萭ʂ͑ȂĂB\։v͑ɗoAp͎ɔB
@EAuDʁvȉ񎦂ɂ́AE̋֌W͎シB

mp.15n

ɉh߂߂ɂ͋@\Ȃ́As\Ȃ

PDZ
@@E{IȖ́A[ł͂ȂB
@@E͎{W^eNmW[𐶂ݏoAuٗpȂvoω񕜂ɂȂ\B

QDfՋ
@@E֐ł͊ɂȂ̒ᐅB
@@EG7ɂA{WAoŘJWAƂuoX̎ꂽv
@@@fՎ̑́AٗpB

RDႢ̋TCh̎{
@@E@lېŁB

SDXȂُk

̑΍̂Ȃɂ́AtʂƂȂ̂݁B

mp.16n

Ώ@F ً}̖\Ȇv߂

PDip󂯁jYfɍiݒ肷邱Ƃ́ACϓɑΉ鐢Eoςւ̉vɌ
@@𑣂B

QDo퍕̈ꕔ̍ĊpiႦΊJs̎{č\AVȊJs̑n݁j́ACt
@@܂߂̕Kv𖞂́B
@@Eԕ́A@\ɂĔł邱Ƃ玦ĂB
@@EIȓƂƒIȓȂ̂AZS̋ZsłB

mp.17n

ʓIȎ{

RD{xȏBIɐłŘdꂽ̂łoςhB
@@Eύt\Z搔Ɋւ錴FK؂ɐ݌vꂽłƎxoɂāA搔͋ɂ߂č̂ƂȂB
@@ẼoXV[gɂẮA݂̂ł͂ȂAYEʂ邱ƂK؂ȉv
@@@t[[NB
@@@@EA҂̌Nւ̎xo͓łAoXV[g̎YTChPB
@@@@ECtƃeNmW[ւ̓lB
@@Ełynł́A\Ȑoύč\zɖ𗧂B
@@E\ϊv𐄐iA߂鐭{xolB

SD߂邻̑̎{͐Ȇv𑝉B
@@Eoσ[̑]Fsœ鏊ƕɁB
@@Eړ]ƐŐ̉PB
@@E㏸ƘJҕی߂{B
@@@@E̍ł́Ag芪@Igg݂PB

TDO[oȊʉݐx\z邱ƂŁAvkOݏ̐ςݗĂ̕Kv炷
@@ƂłB

mp.18n

EIȑv̐

EɐEIɃT[rXoςւ̈ڍsiޒAfՃZN^[͂܂܂dvɁB

Ev̒͋炷B

Ev͖ԏ傫B
@ElԁAimMbv𖄂߂jeNmW[ACtAZ݂悢Xɂ邽߂̓
@@܂܂B

E̍v̑唼͌It@CiXŒBׂ́B
@EN⋳͂̒łdvȃT[rXB

mp.19n

Dُk߂

EčłAɂ₩ȌŋُkɂȂĂB
@Eʏ̌iCgǖʂł200ľIZN^[̌ٗp܂邪A݂͋t50lĂB

EiCgIȍُkA臒l𒴂ƌoϐቺAƂl̐
@ے肳ĂB

E̍lƂĂAGDPƏGDPA悤ɐŎƓ
@킹đĂƂƂύt\Z搔̋B

mp.20n

oX̎ꂽAv[Kv\

EŎ̐ǍʂɂAeƂɍœKȍƐł̃oX͈قȂB
@EɃoXV[g_Ƃ߂B

EׂĂ̍ɂāAYfł܂߂Łia؉ۋ܂ށuۋvj̈グŁAȍΓ
@Aoς̃ptH[}XP邾낤B

EZłɂĂl B

EقƂǂׂĂ̍ɂāAyniue͓Iɋ𑝉邱ƂłȂvj̓VR
@΂łグ邱ƂŁAȍΓ𑝂₵A㏸邾낤i~̔񐶎YIȗpr
@ւ̗炷ƂłjB

(y[Wɑ)

mp.21n

oX̎ꂽAv[Kv\ Łij

E@lŌł͓gɂ͊^ȂBȂȂA͎̓ؓłAxq͏T
@ƂȂ邩炾ił̓lbg̎{RXg㏸Aӗ~ނIj
@EނAł̓ٗpnoɐϋɓIłȂƂɑ΂āA@lłグAg
@@B

EiYfŁEłȂǁj̐ŋ́AۂɌ_ł̎xo𑣂ʂB

Eύt\Z搔́Ałƕ킹xog傪oςh邱ƂĂB

K؂ɐ݌vꂽŐ́AiEsEƂvȖɎgގiƂȂB

mp.22n

ُk𒴂

\Z[Et[[N̍čl

E{\ZiCapital Budgetingj
@EBRXgႭA^[ɂ́AoXV[g̊ϓ_ɏdvłB

Eî߂̊Jsidevelopment banksj̊p
@EłƎxoK؂ɑI΁A搔̌ʂ͋ɂ߂čB

mp.23n

eNmW[Ctɑ΂铊́Aԓ⊮ʂL̂ł邪AœKȐ
ׂƒႭ܂ĂB
Ebɑ΂鐭{xzi΂fcoj́AIOႭȂĂB
EYɂȂVȃCmx[V𐄐iACfǍオĂB

KvȂƂ́ACtƃeNmW[ւ̂ϋɓIȓłB
ECtEeNmW[ւ͖̌ԓƕ⊮IłAԓh鎖ɂȂB
E̓Ctsiinfrastructure bankjt@CiX邱ƂłB

mp.24n

CDʓIɎxoFdvȒ̖ɏœ_𓖂Ă\\ϊviStructural Transformationj

EEIɁAƂ̌ٗpĂB

EO[o[[VƂƂɁAił͌ٗpɐ߂鐻Ƃ̃VFAቺĂB

ET[rXYƂɃVtgKvB
@E̍ł́AT[rXYƂ̐YサĂB

Ê悤ȑK͂ȍ\ϊvistructural transformationj߂Ă邪As͂ꎩ̂ł
@KvƂĂ\ϊvB邱Ƃ肭łȂB
@Ečsꂽ_Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsؖĂB

ET[rXYƂ̒ł́AENɉP̗]nB
@E̕ł́A{ɏdvȖŜłB
@EAُḱA{̖ʂƂ}Ă܂B

mp.25n

\ϊviStructural TransformationjɔĔۑ

E̐Voύ\́AĂقǎ{WIicapital-intensivejł͂ȂȂ邾낤B
@E]āAz肳GDPB邽߂ɕKvƂȂ铊́A菬Ȃ̂낤B

EɏnNJ҂́AVoύ\ɑ΂ďsł낤B
@Exr[u[̍ƍ킹āAJ҂̂Ȃ̕ĂB
@E̐̍Ċ𑣂ȂƂɂЉIȃRXg\܂A̐̐lI{̒P
@@󂯓邱Ɓ\͑債ĂB

E݂茈߂A҂Ǝ҂Ɋւ𐶂ݏoĂB
@EʂĎ茘^pĂ鍂҂킸ȏȂƂƂA[̊
@@͈ӖB
@E҂͉Ƃ𔃂]T͖AE𓾂܂Œԑ҂KvXAE𓾂ẴXLE˔\
@@𐶂Ađ̍ł͎҂͑ȍw܂ĂB

mp.26n

\ϊviStructural Transformationj iɌ

E_Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsɂāA̍Ő{SIȖʂB

EϋɓIȘJsꐭ܂߁A{͍ĂѐϋɓIȖSƂ߂ĂB

EȂA̐́AĐEƋ󂯂J҂̂߂̎d݂ꍇɌČʂ
@B
@ESٗp߂߂̕Iȃt[[N߂B

mp.27n

cDiƐ키

EPȂĕz̘bł͂ȂB

EOzFsœ邱Ƃ̂ł鏊̂ȕzmȂ̂Ƃ邽߂̌oσ[̑]B
@Es͐^̒ɑ݂̂ł͂ȂFs̍\z@ɂAs̋@\EʁEz܂B
@Eƒ̏㏸́Aɑ΂鐶YIȎ{̔䗦Ăɂւ炸Aɑ΂x̔䗦
@@㏸ĂƂُ킳𕨌ĂB

mp.28n

iƐ키

E̗_́AJYƎɂ钘sύtĂB
@E̕sύt́AXLΏd^̋Zpi⒙~̍قƂWIȗ_ł͐łȂB

EiḱAZIɂAIɂAoσptH[}XPB

WZtEEEXeBObci˒JmjwXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv
̋ȏxiԏXA2016NjiFStiglitz, J. E., N. Abernathy, A. Hersh, S. Holmberg, and
M. Konczal (2015). Rewriting the Rules of the American Economy, New York: W.W. Norton, 2015.j
QƁB

mp.29n

III. \viStructural Reformsj

{IȌ

EK؂ȎvȂɂ́ATvCTCh̉v́AƂ𑝉邾ŁAoϐɂ͊^ȂB
@EᐶY傩[YA܂AlXƂɒǂ̂łB
@ÉAꎩ̂̎voȂB
@EۂɁATvCTCh̉v͎v߁AGDPቺB
@EAK؂ɐ݌vꂽvh́A/Y𑝉A݂ѐݓIGDP
@@グ邱ƂłB

mp.30n

@\TvCTCh̎{

uvvƈ̂ƂȂĂA@\邱ƂB

EeNmW[ւ̓g
@EvVIoρiinnovation economyjƊwKЉilearning societyjoŁAƂ킯dvB

ElԂւ̓̊g\茒Nł萶Y̍J͂noB

Eoςč\zAÂYƂVYƂւ̈ڍsɖ𗧂YƐ
@Esꂾł́A̕ϊv͍oȂB

E\oϓIȌ͂]邱Ƃh
@EƐ͎YojQB

EZsv
@EZ@ւɊQyڂƂhł͕s\B
@EƂ킯Ƃ̂߂Ɋ҂ʂAZ𒇉AԎ񋟂悤
@@Z@ւɑƂ߂B
@E{̎𑣂Ƃ߂B

mp.31n

@\TvCTCh̎{

EJQ𑣐i{
@ELȌʃVXe
@E玙xɁALaCx
@EqĎx

E퍷ʑwEЉ̎嗬cꂽw̕
@E
@EhE}CmeB[
@Eږ

mp.32n

@\TvCTCh̎{

EʓIłȂi܂͋tʂȁjTvCTCh̎{􂪑݂B
@E@lŗ̈B
@@EOƂāAČٗpnoƂɂ͌łAٗpnoɏɓIȊƂɂ͑
@@@{B
@EZs̋KɘaB
@@ĚA@̊gAs̕s艻ɂȂB
@EfՐɂăTvCTCȟʂ͊҂ĂȂB
@@Eʂ͏ɉߑ]B
@@@@E.čɂƂTPP̌ʂ͂قڃ[ƐvB
@@ETPP͈fՋłƂRZTXLAčcŔyȂł낤
@@@@EɓD܂Ȃ\Vʂ炵A苭ی쓙̂߂
@@@@@oϋKi𐧌

mp.33n

̋tʂȃTvCTCh{

EȃTvCTChv@\ȂB
@EčɂZ̉ߏ苟ilo_̋󂫉Ɓj̍팸́Ačoς̉񕜂Ɋ^ĂȂB
@E؍̌oϊ@i1998Njɂ锼̃bv̉ߏ萶Y\͂̔j́Aoς̉񕜂x点B
@@EIvVƂ̉l͖B
@E炷Ƃ]ތ悭oc_B
@@Eȗ\IƁvignational championshj Ƃt́A ̂Ƃ͉ǐ莖Ǝ҂Ӗ
@@@́B

mp.34n

TvCTCh{̎s

E1980N㏉̕čiёjɂTvCTCh{̎sB
@EŎ̖񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͌B
@E߂񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͒ቺB
@@E~ቺB
@@@@Eŋ߂2000N㏉ɂ錸łłʂ݂ꂽB
@@EJQቺB
@ETvCTCh{̐ATvCTCh{ɂiւ̉ěO͍ōɒB
@@B

mp.35n

IVDZZN^[ƋZ

EZ̍́AZs̕s𔽉fB

EZ̍́AZs̋ߎIȐ𔽉f\Zs͏ɂƂĂC܂B

EZ̍́AEoς̐sɊւ[ȕsm𔽉fB

EZ̍́A̍ɂZ̎sɊ֘AĂAʂƂĈבփ[g
@smsȎ{t[̑傫ȓĂB
@E{sAZs̎R𑣐iB

EZ̍̑́AZZN^[ɂ鍪{IȖւ̎g̎s𔽉f́B

Ê悤ȋZ̍̌oςɔgy\ƂłB

mp.36n

ZZN^[v

EZZN^[̊QhAȉj~B
@EߓxȃXNeCN
@EsɂxzInʂ̗p

EZZN^[ႢRXgŎЉIS悤ɂB
@EƋZZZ̋
@EN̊Ǘ⌈σVXẻ^pႢRXgŎ{

܂ł̂ƂÃ^XNɎsB

L[vƁA^M񋟂Ii̊g傪KvB
Ew[
EZ[ɊւIIvV
ENɊւIIvV @

mp.37n

VDEK͂̉v

EVEʉݐx̕Kv
@Ẽ݂VXe͉ߋ̈╨B
@Eo퍕ǋoCAXɂȂĂB
@Eʉݍ̐Ǝ㐫B
@EPCYŋ߂̍Aψ񏥂Ă悤ɁAEʉݐx͂苭łȐË
@@Ȃ́B

mp.38n

EK͂̉v

EE̕sύtk鐢EIȋ߂ĂB
@Ěo퍕͌ߒɂB
@EA[̌o퍕͑ĂA
@@E[ɂđ傫ȉvKvƂȂB

EEIȃ}NoρiZэj􋦒߂ĂB
@EEZ@ɋN邱Ƃ҂ꂽB
@EAɎĂȂ\ނA̕sa͊g債ĂB

Eo퍕pǂi߂ĂB
@EVJs͐B
@EAKoiXvƊJsԂ̎{č\̕Kv݁B

mp.39n

JɌĎ񋟂

JɌ̒񋟂́Ao퍕̊pAEv̑AJ̑iƂbg𓯎Ɏ
̂ł邪AR̏QB

E̎sFč\Ɋւ鍑ۓIȃt[[NȂB
@EAɂdvȔcA命̍xB
@EAčƊ̃[bpu@̎xzvirule of lawjɔ΁B

ECOړF 肪荑̋K\͂𑹂ȂB

EЊƂւ̉ېŁFۓIȐő̌nŎ̊gɂĂB
@Euӂւ̋viRace to the bottomj
@EۓIȐő̌n̂蔲{Iȉv߂B

mp.40n

Cϓւ̃ANV

ECϓւ̑΍ƂčśAEoςɂƂĕKvȎhƂȂ邾낤B

Eƌoϐ͕⊮IȊ֌WɂB
@EƂ킯oϐ𐳊mɑꍇɁB

EYfɉiݒ肷邱ƂɂANB

EACϓpćA̋C^Ƃϓ_dvBoϊÉAǂ̂悤Ȍ
@ȂɂA₪Ă͒Yfɉiݒ肳邱Ƃ𗝉͂łB

mp.41n

VIDEIȈӎvvZX̉v

EEIȌoϓ́AEIȐiłB

Ezgyʂꍇɂ͂AOɂ͏WcIȑΏ߂B

EAEIȑΉsɓĂ̗Dꂽgg݂͌_ł݂͑ȂB

EEIȌoϐ́A܂ɕpɂɌ̗͂QɍEB
@EEK͂̋͂⒲a߂镪ɕKœ_ĂĂȂB
@@EmIL[̉ߏȒaB
@@EŐӔC\ɉʂȂ悤ȓ̗Q𔽉f[̒áAEIɖI
@@@vZX琶܂钲aƂ͈قȂ̂łB
@@Ee{IȂŕKvȋK{悤ƂۂɁAVȖfՎ茈߂̔\͂
@@@ȂƂɌOB
@Eœ_𓖂ẮׂAւ̒ałAłb܂Ȃɂ҂Ƃ̋ʂ̊Ղւ̒a
@@łB

mp.42n

EIȈӎvvZX̉v

Eǂ̂悤ɑ\߂邩B
@EAn̑\͒ႢB
@EEoςɐ߂EFCg͏ƂĂA̍X͏dvȑ݂łB

Eǂ̂悤ɐ𑝂B
@EÁAEIȐL鍑ۓIȋ@ւłB
@EIMF̌ɂāAlɁAXɑ傫ȐLB

EủvihclubhjŜ߂̈ӎvs댯B
@ȆgD̐M𑹂ȂB

E֍FEoϒψiGlobal Economic Coordinating Councilj̑n
@EAAIMF̉ŉ^c

mp.43n

EIȈӎvčl

EόiVariable Geometryj
@E̖ŁASvɋ߂ÂƂ͍łƔF邱ƁB

EuLuAvigCoalition of willinghj\Ⴆ΁ACϓ
@EzېłɂA̋͂𑣂B

EVEʉݐx́A炭SĂ̍̍ӂ𓾂邱Ƃ͓B
@ȄꍇLuALB\Qɂ闘v݂邽߁A̍₪ĎQB

EOłLȏʂ𒍈Ӑ[B
@EŃXNUsdg݂݂ȂA̒~s܂AEIȑv
@@kB
@E{WςɗLɓEIȃ[́Aig傳AEIȑv̊gɂ͋tʁB
@EEIȕs萫͊i𐶂ݏoA̒~ɂȂ́BāÁAEI
@@v̌R̗vƂȂB

mp.44n

VIIDߖ@ō̐E

E30NقǑOA̐ił́Aŗ̈KɘaƂn߂B

EωoϊɑΉAoς̘gg݂𒲐KvB
@EAȂĂB

EʂƂāAoϐ͓݉AigB

EƂȂđQǍʂSĖڂɌ̂ƂȂAߋ炸ƐisĂ
@Ȃ̂łB

E݂̕ێƁA󋵂͍XɈ邾낤B
@EĂȂIȋAB̂̊͕n߂ĂB

E̎́A傫Ȏsłƍ⌾ƂłB傫ȎsłƌׂłB

EVȕ߂B
@E݂̎茈߂̔ł͏肭Ȃ낤B

mp.45n

̎s̒f

EZւ̐VȃAv[
@EoϐAٗpAoψ艻ƂoX̂鎋_ACẗ艻ɏœ_B

Eւ̐VȃAv[
@EBł́AԎɑ΂ČdȐB

Ec̐Vȗ
@EЉۏᕪɂ܂Ŗc̗ꂪyԍ݁B

̐́A҂قǂ̐ʂグĂȂB

mp.46n

E̐x݌vɊւsĂ

E40NOA{ړ̎R݂ĂB
@EɂAoς艻オKƊ҂ĂB

E{sꃁJjY̕ʓIƂĂB

ĚʁAtɁAEIȕs艻̎ɓ˓B
@EɁAZIȎ{ړɊ֘Aĕs萫B

E݂ł́AIMFł{ړ̐i{̊ǗjKvƎ咣B

mp.47n

̓Ȃ

E{Ǝs̃oX߂B

E{EԂƂ͈قȂuÕZN^[vigthird sectorhjAVȐxgg݂̏dvF
@B

Eُk߂B

EEIȊ{Ij[YAEIȌAEIȊOɑ΂āAEIɑΏB
@ECϓ𒴂āAEIȉȊwՂ܂߂ׂłB
@Eӂւ̋ŝł͂ȂAEIɐYɖ߂ׂłB

EEESĂ̐lԂ̐グ{ɑSĂB

EiɊւwW̐EIȍĕ]sB
@E]sɂeB
@EuoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvijɂ郁CbZ[WB
@ĚOECDɂČpĂB

@ijXeBObcSƂȂāAtX̃TRW哝̂̃CjVAeBủŁA
@@@@Љ̍Kx𑪒肵悤ƂgB

mp.48n

EoρF̓i

EuVȖ}fviThe New MediocrejA uvithe Great MalaisejAu؁v
@iSecular Stagnationj͔Ȃ̂ł͂ȂB
@ÉA̎sɂAB

EiW钆AOi邽߂̍őP̕@́AoX߂Av𑝉邽߂
@ۓIȋsƂB
@EႦ΁AE̋\Ang΍\ɌۋB
@E̍ۋ͂Ƃ킯łB
@EG7ɂāA{[_[Vbv𔭊邱ƂAOɐiނ߂̈ƂȂ邾낤B

EAۋ͂s\ȏ󋵉ɂĂAv̋␶Y̌̂߂Ɋe
@PƂōsƂ̂ł邱Ƃ݂͑B
@ÉA傫ȍDe𑼂̍ɑ΂Ă^̂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂRg

XeBObcƂ΁A]܂O[o[[Vւ̓؂ĂƂƂōȌoϊw҂̈lB2016N316̍ۋZoϕ͉ɂẮAm[xoϊw܎܎҂ƂĂ̌ЂXeBObcŗグ̌񌾂ƂƂŁAۂ̌ɂĂ̊ϑ܂߂đ傫񂶂ꂽB܂{_ƐV́Azz̒ŃXeBObcTPP̌ʂy̌ʂɔےIȌƂグB̂悤Șb萫̂zzɖڂʂłɁAeLXgĂ݂B

A̎ǂޕɂ͂͂胊ÑIWiPDFœǂł悳Be҂uPbgŃy[Wԍtɂ͂ꂼ̃y[W̌oĂ̂AeLXg炻ꂪoƂƂ킩ɂȂAȂǂ݂ɂȂĂ܂B2̃OtȗĂBƂ̃CAEgŃ~XȂƂȂBƂPDF̗򉻃Rs[Ƃ悤̂Ȃ̂ŁAN̖ɂȂȂAIȈӖ߂ēeĂB
http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/464.html

[eXg31] eXg
XeBObcoiǂɂ{j@
1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zt@Qi񑊊@j
https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/kokusaikinyu/dai1/gijisidai.html

uQv

ƋZ̈𒴂ASŎIȐɌ
@
@
WZtEEEXeBObc

2016N3
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.2nIDX͍ǂɂ邩

EɖȐ\iGreat MalaisejAVȖ}fiNew Mediocrej
@ÊƂ܂@ł͂ȂB

@EAG7̑̍Xł́iBꂽP[X܂߁jPIɑ̎ƂĂB
@@NwЉ̎嗬cꂽwł͍Xɍ̎ƂB

@E̊ɖȐ̉ʎ͈ꕔ̃gbvwɕ΂ĕzĂ\i͊g債Ȁ㏸͒؁B
@@Euɂ́vƗႢƂĂ鍑łAٗp̎╢BꂽƂɂ͋^╄B

@EEoϊ@Oɂւ炸A2007N̐Eoς͎ۂɂ͎ォB
@@@EouɂĎxĂB
@@@Eoϊ@O2007N̐E߂ƂƂ́AĉXێĂ̂ƓA
@@@@アoςɖ߂Ă܂ƂӖB

E錩ʂ\Ȑɖ߂\͏AiCނ؂̉\͍B
@EYiou̎kւ́AƂȌOB
@EƂƂz̍钆AV͋z̎{oɒʁB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.3nLєYޕčo

E1980N1998N܂ł̌oϐpĂƂA̕čGDṔAGDP
@15%قǍ̂ƂȂĂ͂łB

E̘JQ}ɐi1980N㏉ƔrĂA݂̐YNl̏AƗ͒ႢB

Eʂ́iƌvj́A1989NƔr1%̏㏸BĂȂB

Eŉw̎60NOႢB

ENw̃AtJnAJl̎Ɨ͖23.7%B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.4nmOtnčfcõgh mȗn
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.5nB͂ƈ

EƗ͍XɍB

EɎNw̎Ƃ[B

EoϐXɒႢB

E[@͏IĂȂBꎞIȁuNԁiremissionjvɂ邾B
@Eʉ݂@\邽߂ɕKvȐxn݂ĂȂB
@@āA̐xn݂錩݂ʂȂB

EB̌ƁAɉBoϐĂƂĂ낤pƂ̊Ԃɂ̓Mbv݁B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.6n@ȗAB̃ptH[}X͔ߎSȂ

mOtn[̂fcõgh mȗn
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.7n

EEZ@ȗAEoς̌B
@Ei͒ړIAԐړIɉe󂯂B

E[ȌoόƂȂ錩݁B

EBƕčł́Aoς̌𖄂ߍ킹邱Ƃ͂łȂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.8nsithe Great RecessionjɊւff

̋Z@ł͂ȂB

Es̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

EKv炩sꂽihbhEtN@jB

EAoς͖ɌSȏԂɖ߂ĂȂB
@ENWbgEl̉Pɏ\ȒӂĂȂB
@ÊƂ́AZɘa҂ꂽقǂ̌ʂ𓾂ĂȂR̈B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.9nsithe Great RecessionjɊւff

̃oXV[gsł͂ȂB

EƂ̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

EƂɐϋɓIɂȂȂ̂́AoXV[g⎑B̖ł͂ȂB
@EvȂƂȂ̂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.10nXȂ錜O

EiIȐE̕sύt
@E[ĂB

EΏ̂Ȓ
@E̒ቺɒʂ鍑ƁiƁAƌvj͏𓾂ȂB
@EƁiƁAƌvj͂̎̕xo𑝉ĂȂB
@Ei̕ϓւ̑Ήł͈ȉ̓_B
@@@Eỉ͎v𑝉Ɗ҂ĂAusҁvilosersjւ̈e
@@@@̕։vĂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.11nSIۑ̐ff

EEIȑv̕sB

EƑ܂āAeɂāAfՃZN^[ւ̎x͕s\B

EEZւ̉ߓẍˑB

EɍL݂΁A30NOɎsoς̃[̓]iŐ̍Đ݌vAȎRj̃vZX
@̐iŎn܂B́A̖ژ_ɔāAXȂoϐ̒ቺAs艻A
@sB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.12niGreat malaisej́AقǂɐiWȂA[Ȗ𕢂BĂ

ECϓ

EiA̕nw
@Ex̕sAN̕siÂ𖯊Ԃ̒񋟂Ɉˑ鍑ɂẮjAٔւ̃ANZX̕sA
@@ƑɓnB
@Eił͒ԑwkBr㍑ɂĂԑwkB
@É̖AЉ̎嗬cꂽwi΂΁jNwł͓ɐ[B

EI邽߂ɂ́AOIȁu\ϊvvistructural transformationsj߂B

Esoςɍt肪AY̒؂炵ĂB
@EԕEI̗ɂZIuB
@Ebւ̓̕sBāA̍ł̓Ctւ̓̕sB
@Eߓx̋ZBߓx̋Z͈ȉ̉ߒ̈ꕔłÄꕔłB
@@@ExƎ{̊Ԃ̃Mbv̍LB
@@@E̍ŎYoɑ΂x̊܂AYoɑ΂鎑{̔䗦ቺB
@EVXe̓K̎sB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.13nIID̏󋵂ւ̑Ή

R̎iɊւΗ錩FZ

EŹAT˂̖SB

E[Ȓ؎ɂāAZ􂪋ɂ߂ėLƂ͂܂łɂȂB
@B̌ʓIȎi͍B

E{̖́A[ł͂ȂB邱ƁiႦ}CiẌ̗ɓƂĂj
@͋@\ȂB
E}CiX݂̎́AiC傫͎hAp炷\B

EʓIɘa͕sg債BAiƂĂj̑啝ȑɂ͂Ȃ炸A
@Zs̕sS邢͕sɂAXÑ~XvCVO₻̑̋Zs̘c݂
@炵\B
@Eȕ։v̈́AIȒʉ݂̐؂艺łBÁA[ETEQ[B
@EK؂ȍȂł́AuB̑Iv͍XɈrB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.14nR̎iɊւΗ錩F

E􂪍̃XN߂錜OB
@E20082009NɎ{iCh͌ʂȂƂ͑S̊ԈႢB
@E΍􂪂Ȃ΍XɈĂł낤Ɨ̒ቺ炷ƂłAXȂiCށAs
@@Ɋׂ̂hB
@E@ɂẮAxoœK鎞Ԃ͂ȂB\ƂAsSȍΏołĂAʂ
@@pɂ邱ƂsɔׂΖ]܂B
@Eւ̌ÓAoXV[gEAv[ւ̖̂ւBł́A{͐YIȓ
@@΂Ďxo邱ƂOƂĂB

EO[o[[Vɂ萭ʂ͑ȂĂB\։v͑ɗoAp͎ɔB
@EAuDʁvȉ񎦂ɂ́AE̋֌W͎シB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.15nɉh߂߂ɂ͋@\Ȃ́As\Ȃ

PDZ
@@E{IȖ́A[ł͂ȂB
@@E͎{W^eNmW[𐶂ݏoAuٗpȂvoω񕜂ɂȂ\B

QDfՋ
@@E֐ł͊ɂȂ̒ᐅB
@@EG7ɂA{WAoŘJWAƂuoX̎ꂽv
@@@fՎ̑́AٗpB

RDႢ̋TCh̎{
@@E@lېŁB

SDXȂُk

̑΍̂Ȃɂ́AtʂƂȂ̂݁B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.16nΏ@F ً}̖\Ȇv߂

PDip󂯁jYfɍiݒ肷邱Ƃ́ACϓɑΉ鐢Eoςւ̉vɌ
@@𑣂B

QDo퍕̈ꕔ̍ĊpiႦΊJs̎{č\AVȊJs̑n݁j́ACt
@@܂߂̕Kv𖞂́B
@@Eԕ́A@\ɂĔł邱Ƃ玦ĂB
@@EIȓƂƒIȓȂ̂AZS̋ZsłB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.17nʓIȎ{

RD{xȏBIɐłŘdꂽ̂łoςhB
@@Eύt\Z搔Ɋւ錴FK؂ɐ݌vꂽłƎxoɂāA搔͋ɂ߂č̂ƂȂB
@@ẼoXV[gɂẮA݂̂ł͂ȂAYEʂ邱ƂK؂ȉv
@@@t[[NB
@@@@EA҂̌Nւ̎xo͓łAoXV[g̎YTChPB
@@@@ECtƃeNmW[ւ̓lB
@@Ełynł́A\Ȑoύč\zɖ𗧂B
@@E\ϊv𐄐iA߂鐭{xolB

SD߂邻̑̎{͐Ȇv𑝉B
@@Eoσ[̑]Fsœ鏊ƕɁB
@@Eړ]ƐŐ̉PB
@@E㏸ƘJҕی߂{B
@@@@E̍ł́Ag芪@Igg݂PB

TDO[oȊʉݐx\z邱ƂŁAvkOݏ̐ςݗĂ̕Kv炷
@@ƂłB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.18nEIȑv̐

EɐEIɃT[rXoςւ̈ڍsiޒAfՃZN^[͂܂܂dvɁB

Ev̒͋炷B

Ev͖ԏ傫B
@ElԁAimMbv𖄂߂jeNmW[ACtAZ݂悢Xɂ邽߂̓
@@܂܂B

E̍v̑唼͌It@CiXŒBׂ́B
@EN⋳͂̒łdvȃT[rXB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.19nDُk߂

EčłAɂ₩ȌŋُkɂȂĂB
@Eʏ̌iCgǖʂł200ľIZN^[̌ٗp܂邪A݂͋t50lĂB

EiCgIȍُkA臒l𒴂ƌoϐቺAƂl̐
@ے肳ĂB

E̍lƂĂAGDPƏGDPA悤ɐŎƓ
@킹đĂƂƂύt\Z搔̋B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.20noX̎ꂽAv[Kv\

EŎ̐ǍʂɂAeƂɍœKȍƐł̃oX͈قȂB
@EɃoXV[g_Ƃ߂B

EׂĂ̍ɂāAYfł܂߂Łia؉ۋ܂ށuۋvj̈グŁAȍΓ
@Aoς̃ptH[}XP邾낤B

EZłɂĂl B

EقƂǂׂĂ̍ɂāAyniue͓Iɋ𑝉邱ƂłȂvj̓VR
@΂łグ邱ƂŁAȍΓ𑝂₵A㏸邾낤i~̔񐶎YIȗpr
@ւ̗炷ƂłjB

(y[Wɑ)
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.21noX̎ꂽAv[Kv\ Łij

E@lŌł͓gɂ͊^ȂBȂȂA͎̓ؓłAxq͏T
@ƂȂ邩炾ił̓lbg̎{RXg㏸Aӗ~ނIj
@EނAł̓ٗpnoɐϋɓIłȂƂɑ΂āA@lłグAg
@@B

EiYfŁEłȂǁj̐ŋ́AۂɌ_ł̎xo𑣂ʂB

Eύt\Z搔́Ałƕ킹xog傪oςh邱ƂĂB

K؂ɐ݌vꂽŐ́AiEsEƂvȖɎgގiƂȂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.22nُk𒴂

\Z[Et[[N̍čl

E{\ZiCapital Budgetingj
@EBRXgႭA^[ɂ́AoXV[g̊ϓ_ɏdvłB

Eî߂̊Jsidevelopment banksj̊p
@EłƎxoK؂ɑI΁A搔̌ʂ͋ɂ߂čB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

eNmW[Ctɑ΂铊́Aԓ⊮ʂL̂ł邪AœKȐ
ׂƒႭ܂ĂB
Ebɑ΂鐭{xzi΂fcoj́AIOႭȂĂB
EYɂȂVȃCmx[V𐄐iACfǍオĂB

KvȂƂ́ACtƃeNmW[ւ̂ϋɓIȓłB
ECtEeNmW[ւ͖̌ԓƕ⊮IłAԓh鎖ɂȂB
E̓Ctsiinfrastructure bankjt@CiX邱ƂłB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.24nCDʓIɎxoFdvȒ̖ɏœ_𓖂Ă\\ϊviStructural Transformationj

EEIɁAƂ̌ٗpĂB

EO[o[[VƂƂɁAił͌ٗpɐ߂鐻Ƃ̃VFAቺĂB

ET[rXYƂɃVtgKvB
@E̍ł́AT[rXYƂ̐YサĂB

Ê悤ȑK͂ȍ\ϊvistructural transformationj߂Ă邪As͂ꎩ̂ł
@KvƂĂ\ϊvB邱Ƃ肭łȂB
@Ečsꂽ_Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsؖĂB

ET[rXYƂ̒ł́AENɉP̗]nB
@E̕ł́A{ɏdvȖŜłB
@EAُḱA{̖ʂƂ}Ă܂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.25n\ϊviStructural TransformationjɔĔۑ

E̐Voύ\́AĂقǎ{WIicapital-intensivejł͂ȂȂ邾낤B
@E]āAz肳GDPB邽߂ɕKvƂȂ铊́A菬Ȃ̂낤B

EɏnNJ҂́AVoύ\ɑ΂ďsł낤B
@Exr[u[̍ƍ킹āAJ҂̂Ȃ̕ĂB
@E̐̍Ċ𑣂ȂƂɂЉIȃRXg\܂A̐̐lI{̒P
@@󂯓邱Ɓ\͑債ĂB

E݂茈߂A҂Ǝ҂Ɋւ𐶂ݏoĂB
@EʂĎ茘^pĂ鍂҂킸ȏȂƂƂA[̊
@@͈ӖB
@E҂͉Ƃ𔃂]T͖AE𓾂܂Œԑ҂KvXAE𓾂ẴXLE˔\
@@𐶂Ađ̍ł͎҂͑ȍw܂ĂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.26n\ϊviStructural Transformationj iɌ

E_Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsɂāA̍Ő{SIȖʂB

EϋɓIȘJsꐭ܂߁A{͍ĂѐϋɓIȖSƂ߂ĂB

EȂA̐́AĐEƋ󂯂J҂̂߂̎d݂ꍇɌČʂ
@B
@ESٗp߂߂̕Iȃt[[N߂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.27ncDiƐ키

EPȂĕz̘bł͂ȂB

EOzFsœ邱Ƃ̂ł鏊̂ȕzmȂ̂Ƃ邽߂̌oσ[̑]B
@Es͐^̒ɑ݂̂ł͂ȂFs̍\z@ɂAs̋@\EʁEz܂B
@Eƒ̏㏸́Aɑ΂鐶YIȎ{̔䗦Ăɂւ炸Aɑ΂x̔䗦
@@㏸ĂƂُ킳𕨌ĂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.28niƐ키

E̗_́AJYƎɂ钘sύtĂB
@E̕sύt́AXLΏd^̋Zpi⒙~̍قƂWIȗ_ł͐łȂB

EiḱAZIɂAIɂAoσptH[}XPB

WZtEEEXeBObci˒JmjwXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv
̋ȏxiԏXA2016NjiFStiglitz, J. E., N. Abernathy, A. Hersh, S. Holmberg, and
M. Konczal (2015). Rewriting the Rules of the American Economy, New York: W.W. Norton, 2015.j
QƁB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.29nIII. \viStructural Reformsj

{IȌ

EK؂ȎvȂɂ́ATvCTCh̉v́AƂ𑝉邾ŁAoϐɂ͊^ȂB
@EᐶY傩[YA܂AlXƂɒǂ̂łB
@ÉAꎩ̂̎voȂB
@EۂɁATvCTCh̉v͎v߁AGDPቺB
@EAK؂ɐ݌vꂽvh́A/Y𑝉A݂ѐݓIGDP
@@グ邱ƂłB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.30n@\TvCTCh̎{

uvvƈ̂ƂȂĂA@\邱ƂB

EeNmW[ւ̓g
@EvVIoρiinnovation economyjƊwKЉilearning societyjoŁAƂ킯dvB

ElԂւ̓̊g\茒Nł萶Y̍J͂noB

Eoςč\zAÂYƂVYƂւ̈ڍsɖ𗧂YƐ
@Esꂾł́A̕ϊv͍oȂB

E\oϓIȌ͂]邱Ƃh
@EƐ͎YojQB

EZsv
@EZ@ւɊQyڂƂhł͕s\B
@EƂ킯Ƃ̂߂Ɋ҂ʂAZ𒇉AԎ񋟂悤
@@Z@ւɑƂ߂B
@E{̎𑣂Ƃ߂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.31n@\TvCTCh̎{

EJQ𑣐i{
@ELȌʃVXe
@E玙xɁALaCx
@EqĎx

E퍷ʑwEЉ̎嗬cꂽw̕
@E
@EhE}CmeB[
@Eږ
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.32n@\TvCTCh̎{

EʓIłȂi܂͋tʂȁjTvCTCh̎{􂪑݂B
@E@lŗ̈B
@@EOƂāAČٗpnoƂɂ͌łAٗpnoɏɓIȊƂɂ͑
@@@{B
@EZs̋KɘaB
@@ĚA@̊gAs̕s艻ɂȂB
@EfՐɂăTvCTCȟʂ͊҂ĂȂB
@@Eʂ͏ɉߑ]B
@@@@E.čɂƂTPP̌ʂ͂قڃ[ƐvB
@@ETPP͈fՋłƂRZTXLAčcŔyȂł낤
@@@@EɓD܂Ȃ\Vʂ炵A苭ی쓙̂߂
@@@@@oϋKi𐧌
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.33n̋tʂȃTvCTCh{

EȃTvCTChv@\ȂB
@EčɂZ̉ߏ苟ilo_̋󂫉Ɓj̍팸́Ačoς̉񕜂Ɋ^ĂȂB
@E؍̌oϊ@i1998Njɂ锼̃bv̉ߏ萶Y\͂̔j́Aoς̉񕜂x点B
@@EIvVƂ̉l͖B
@E炷Ƃ]ތ悭oc_B
@@Eȗ\IƁvignational championshj Ƃt́A ̂Ƃ͉ǐ莖Ǝ҂Ӗ
@@@́B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.34nTvCTCh{̎s

E1980N㏉̕čiёjɂTvCTCh{̎sB
@EŎ̖񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͌B
@E߂񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͒ቺB
@@E~ቺB
@@@@Eŋ߂2000N㏉ɂ錸łłʂ݂ꂽB
@@EJQቺB
@ETvCTCh{̐ATvCTCh{ɂiւ̉ěO͍ōɒB
@@B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.35nIVDZZN^[ƋZ

EZ̍́AZs̕s𔽉fB

EZ̍́AZs̋ߎIȐ𔽉f\Zs͏ɂƂĂC܂B

EZ̍́AEoς̐sɊւ[ȕsm𔽉fB

EZ̍́A̍ɂZ̎sɊ֘AĂAʂƂĈבփ[g
@smsȎ{t[̑傫ȓĂB
@E{sAZs̎R𑣐iB

EZ̍̑́AZZN^[ɂ鍪{IȖւ̎g̎s𔽉f́B

Ê悤ȋZ̍̌oςɔgy\ƂłB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.36nZZN^[v

EZZN^[̊QhAȉj~B
@EߓxȃXNeCN
@EsɂxzInʂ̗p

EZZN^[ႢRXgŎЉIS悤ɂB
@EƋZZZ̋
@EN̊Ǘ⌈σVXẻ^pႢRXgŎ{

܂ł̂ƂÃ^XNɎsB

L[vƁA^M񋟂Ii̊g傪KvB
Ew[
EZ[ɊւIIvV
ENɊւIIvV @
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.37nVDEK͂̉v

EVEʉݐx̕Kv
@Ẽ݂VXe͉ߋ̈╨B
@Eo퍕ǋoCAXɂȂĂB
@Eʉݍ̐Ǝ㐫B
@EPCYŋ߂̍Aψ񏥂Ă悤ɁAEʉݐx͂苭łȐË
@@Ȃ́B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.38nEK͂̉v

EE̕sύtk鐢EIȋ߂ĂB
@Ěo퍕͌ߒɂB
@EA[̌o퍕͑ĂA
@@E[ɂđ傫ȉvKvƂȂB

EEIȃ}NoρiZэj􋦒߂ĂB
@EEZ@ɋN邱Ƃ҂ꂽB
@EAɎĂȂ\ނA̕sa͊g債ĂB

Eo퍕pǂi߂ĂB
@EVJs͐B
@EAKoiXvƊJsԂ̎{č\̕Kv݁B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.39nJɌĎ񋟂

JɌ̒񋟂́Ao퍕̊pAEv̑AJ̑iƂbg𓯎Ɏ
̂ł邪AR̏QB

E̎sFč\Ɋւ鍑ۓIȃt[[NȂB
@EAɂdvȔcA命̍xB
@EAčƊ̃[bpu@̎xzvirule of lawjɔ΁B

ECOړF 肪荑̋K\͂𑹂ȂB

EЊƂւ̉ېŁFۓIȐő̌nŎ̊gɂĂB
@Euӂւ̋viRace to the bottomj
@EۓIȐő̌n̂蔲{Iȉv߂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.40nCϓւ̃ANV

ECϓւ̑΍ƂčśAEoςɂƂĕKvȎhƂȂ邾낤B

Eƌoϐ͕⊮IȊ֌WɂB
@EƂ킯oϐ𐳊mɑꍇɁB

EYfɉiݒ肷邱ƂɂANB

EACϓpćA̋C^Ƃϓ_dvBoϊÉAǂ̂悤Ȍ
@ȂɂA₪Ă͒Yfɉiݒ肳邱Ƃ𗝉͂łB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.41nVIDEIȈӎvvZX̉v

EEIȌoϓ́AEIȐiłB

Ezgyʂꍇɂ͂AOɂ͏WcIȑΏ߂B

EAEIȑΉsɓĂ̗Dꂽgg݂͌_ł݂͑ȂB

EEIȌoϐ́A܂ɕpɂɌ̗͂QɍEB
@EEK͂̋͂⒲a߂镪ɕKœ_ĂĂȂB
@@EmIL[̉ߏȒaB
@@EŐӔC\ɉʂȂ悤ȓ̗Q𔽉f[̒áAEIɖI
@@@vZX琶܂钲aƂ͈قȂ̂łB
@@Ee{IȂŕKvȋK{悤ƂۂɁAVȖfՎ茈߂̔\͂
@@@ȂƂɌOB
@Eœ_𓖂ẮׂAւ̒ałAłb܂Ȃɂ҂Ƃ̋ʂ̊Ղւ̒a
@@łB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.42nEIȈӎvvZX̉v

Eǂ̂悤ɑ\߂邩B
@EAn̑\͒ႢB
@EEoςɐ߂EFCg͏ƂĂA̍X͏dvȑ݂łB

Eǂ̂悤ɐ𑝂B
@EÁAEIȐL鍑ۓIȋ@ւłB
@EIMF̌ɂāAlɁAXɑ傫ȐLB

EủvihclubhjŜ߂̈ӎvs댯B
@ȆgD̐M𑹂ȂB

E֍FEoϒψiGlobal Economic Coordinating Councilj̑n
@EAAIMF̉ŉ^c
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.43nEIȈӎvčl

EόiVariable Geometryj
@E̖ŁASvɋ߂ÂƂ͍łƔF邱ƁB

EuLuAvigCoalition of willinghj\Ⴆ΁ACϓ
@EzېłɂA̋͂𑣂B

EVEʉݐx́A炭SĂ̍̍ӂ𓾂邱Ƃ͓B
@ȄꍇLuALB\Qɂ闘v݂邽߁A̍₪ĎQB

EOłLȏʂ𒍈Ӑ[B
@EŃXNUsdg݂݂ȂA̒~s܂AEIȑv
@@kB
@E{WςɗLɓEIȃ[́Aig傳AEIȑv̊gɂ͋tʁB
@EEIȕs萫͊i𐶂ݏoA̒~ɂȂ́BāÁAEI
@@v̌R̗vƂȂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.44nVIIDߖ@ō̐E

E30NقǑOA̐ił́Aŗ̈KɘaƂn߂B

EωoϊɑΉAoς̘gg݂𒲐KvB
@EAȂĂB

EʂƂāAoϐ͓݉AigB

EƂȂđQǍʂSĖڂɌ̂ƂȂAߋ炸ƐisĂ
@Ȃ̂łB

E݂̕ێƁA󋵂͍XɈ邾낤B
@EĂȂIȋAB̂̊͕n߂ĂB

E̎́A傫Ȏsłƍ⌾ƂłB傫ȎsłƌׂłB

EVȕ߂B
@E݂̎茈߂̔ł͏肭Ȃ낤B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.45n̎s̒f

EZւ̐VȃAv[
@EoϐAٗpAoψ艻ƂoX̂鎋_ACẗ艻ɏœ_B

Eւ̐VȃAv[
@EBł́AԎɑ΂ČdȐB

Ec̐Vȗ
@EЉۏᕪɂ܂Ŗc̗ꂪyԍ݁B

̐́A҂قǂ̐ʂグĂȂB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.46nE̐x݌vɊւsĂ

E40NOA{ړ̎R݂ĂB
@EɂAoς艻オKƊ҂ĂB

E{sꃁJjY̕ʓIƂĂB

ĚʁAtɁAEIȕs艻̎ɓ˓B
@EɁAZIȎ{ړɊ֘Aĕs萫B

E݂ł́AIMFł{ړ̐i{̊ǗjKvƎ咣B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.47n̓Ȃ

E{Ǝs̃oX߂B

E{EԂƂ͈قȂuÕZN^[vigthird sectorhjAVȐxgg݂̏dvF
@B

Eُk߂B

EEIȊ{Ij[YAEIȌAEIȊOɑ΂āAEIɑΏB
@ECϓ𒴂āAEIȉȊwՂ܂߂ׂłB
@Eӂւ̋ŝł͂ȂAEIɐYɖ߂ׂłB

EEESĂ̐lԂ̐グ{ɑSĂB

EiɊւwW̐EIȍĕ]sB
@E]sɂeB
@EuoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvijɂ郁CbZ[WB
@ĚOECDɂČpĂB

@ijXeBObcSƂȂāAtX̃TRW哝̂̃CjVAeBủŁA
@@@@Љ̍Kx𑪒肵悤ƂgB
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.48nEoρF̓i

EuVȖ}fviThe New MediocrejA uvithe Great MalaisejAu؁v
@iSecular Stagnationj͔Ȃ̂ł͂ȂB
@ÉA̎sɂAB

EiW钆AOi邽߂̍őP̕@́AoX߂Av𑝉邽߂
@ۓIȋsƂB
@EႦ΁AE̋\Ang΍\ɌۋB
@E̍ۋ͂Ƃ킯łB
@EG7ɂāA{[_[Vbv𔭊邱ƂAOɐiނ߂̈ƂȂ邾낤B

EAۋ͂s\ȏ󋵉ɂĂAv̋␶Y̌̂߂Ɋe
@PƂōsƂ̂ł邱Ƃ݂͑B
@ÉA傫ȍDe𑼂̍ɑ΂Ă^̂B
@
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂRg

XeBObcƂ΁A]܂O[o[[Vւ̓؂ĂƂƂōȌoϊw҂̈lB2016N316̍ۋZoϕ͉ɂẮAm[xoϊw܎܎҂ƂĂ̌ЂXeBObcŗグ̌񌾂ƂƂŁAۂ̌ɂĂ̊ϑ܂߂đ傫񂶂ꂽB܂{_ƐV́Azz̒ŃXeBObcTPP̌ʂy̌ʂɔےIȌƂグB

̂悤Șb萫̂zzɎڂʂłɁAeLXgĂ݂By[WԍȂǂ̃ubPbg͓e҂tBA̎ǂޕɂ͂͂胊ÑIWiPDF̕ǂ݂₷B2̃Ot͏ȗĂBƂ̃CAEgŃ~XȂƂȂBƂPDF̗򉻃Rs[Ƃ悤̂Ȃ̂ŁAN̖ɂȂȂAIȈӖ߂ēeĂB
http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/465.html

[eXg31] eXg
XeBObcoipj@
1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉@2016N316
zt@Pi񑊊@j
https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/kokusaikinyu/dai1/gijisidai.html
@
@
Beyond the Great Malaise and Financial Stability towards Robust and Sustainable Growth
@
@
Joseph E. Stiglitz
Tokyo
March, 2016
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.2nI. Where we are
@
@
• Slow growth\Great Malaise, New Mediocre
@@ENot a crisis yet
@@EBut with persistent moderately high unemployment (in some cases disguised) in
@@@many of G-7, higher unemployment among youth and marginalized groups
@@EDisproportionate share of slow growth going to a few at the top\growing inequality, wage
@@@stagnation
@@@@EEven in countries with low "official" unemployment, raising questions of quality of job
@@@@@growth and disguised unemployment
@@EWorld economy was weak in 2007, before crisis
@@@@EOnly sustained by a bubble
@@@@ERestoring the world to 2007 simply restores us to the weak economy we had then

• Mixed prospects\small probably of returning to robust growth, large probability of recession
@or worse
@@EJustifiable concerns about asset price bubbles that might deflate
@@EEmerging markets facing massive capital outflows, with many countries and
@@@companies over-indebted

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.3nUnderperformance of US Economy
@
@
• GDP some 15% below what it would have been had the growth rates that prevailed between 1980 and
@1998 continued

• Percentage of the working]age population employed lower than it was in the early 1980s, when
@women were entering the workforce en masse

• Median real (household) income is less than 1% higher than it was in 1989

• Real wages at the bottom are lower than 60 years ago

• African-American youth unemployment rate is still 23.7%

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.4n

mgraphn United States GDP Trend Analysis mȗn

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.5nEurope is even worse
@
@
• With higher levels of unemployment

• Especially youth unemployment

• And lower levels of growth

• Euro crisis is not over \ only under short term "remission"
@@EHaven't created institutions that are necessary to make a single currency work, and not
@@@likely to do so at time soon

• Gap between where they are and where they would have been growing

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.6nDismal European performance since crisis

mgraphn Euro Area GDP Trend Analysis mȗn

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.7nChina
@
@
• Has been driver of global economic since GFC
@@EAdvanced countries affected directly and indirectly

• Likely to be significant slowdown

• Europe and US not likely to be able to make up for the slowdown of China's economy

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.8nMisdiagnosis of the Great Recession
@
@
More than a financial crisis

• Banks' balance sheets are largely restored

• Some regulatory reform (Dodd Frank)

• Yet economy is not back to health
@@EInsufficient attention paid to improving credit channel
@@EHelps explain why monetary easing didnft help as much as hoped

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.9nMisdiagnosis of the Great Recession
@
@
More than a balance sheet recession

• Balance sheet of large corporations largely restored

• It is not corporate balance sheets or their access to finance that are holding them back from
@investing
@@EIt is lack of demand.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.10nFurther concerns
@
@
• Persistent Global imbalances
@@EEurozone has exacerbated problem
@@ECountries (firms, households) facing a decline in income have to reduce consumption
@@EThose with increased income do not expand spending symmetrically
@@EResponse to changes in oil price illustrates
@@@@EMany had expected lower prices to increase demand, but adverse effects of "losers"
@@@@@more than offsetting these benefits

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.11nDiagnosis of the central problem
@
@
• Lack of global aggregate demand

• Combined with insufficient efforts in each country to support non-traded sectors

• Excessive reliance on debt, financialization

• More broadly, in large parts of advanced countries about a third of a century ago, there began
@a process of rewriting the rules of the market economy (redesigning tax structures, ill-thought
@out liberalization) that led to slower growth, more instability and more inequality\just the
@opposite of what was promised

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.12nGreat malaise hides deeper problems on which there is being made remarkable little
@@@@progress
@
@
• Climate change

• Inequality, large number of individuals in poverty
@@EWith many dimensions\inequality in wealth, health (in countries relying on private provision
@@@of health care), and access to justice
@@EHollowing out of the middle in advanced countries\and even in developing world
@@EProblems especially severe for marginalized groups and (often) youth

• Deep structural transformations needed to achieve sustainable growth

• Deeper problems in market economies leading to productivity slowdown
@@EShort termism in both private and public sector
@@EInsufficient investment in basic research, and in many countries, infrastructure
@@EExcessive financialization, part of process, part of cause
@@@@EOpening up major gaps between wealth and capital
@@@@ECapital output ratio in many countries going down even as wealth output ratio increases
@@EFailures to adapt education system

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.13nII. Responding to the situation
@
@
Conflicting views about obvious instruments: monetary policy

• Monetary policy has largely run its course

• Never very effective in deep downturns: the only effective instrument is fiscal policy

• Real problem not zero lower bound\slight lowering of interest rates (into negative territory)
@will not work
@@EExperiments with negative interest rates unlikely to stimulate much, may have adverse side
@@@effects
• QE increased inequality, did not lead to significant increase in investment (if any) and
@because of financial market imperfections/irrationalities may have led to mispricing of risk
@and other financial market distortions
@@EOne of main benefits was competitive devaluation\but that's a zero sum game
@@EIn absence of adequate fiscal policies, "only game in town"\matters would have been worse
@@@in its absence

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.14nConflicting views about obvious instruments: fiscal policy
@
@
• Worry that fiscal policy risks damaging build up of debts
@@EView that fiscal stimuli in 2008/2009 didnft work is absolutely wrong
@@EReduced unemployment from what it otherwise would have been, prevented deeper recession,
@@@depression
@@EIn crisis, didn't have time to optimize spending\but even imperfect expenditures were
@@@better than alternative of massive idle resources and depressions
@@EWorry about debts is fundamentally misplaced in balance sheet approach, where government
@@@spends money on productive investments

• Effectiveness of policies undermined by globalization\large spillovers to others, costs borne
@at home
@@EBut global coordination sufficiently weak to provide "superior" globally coordinated
@@@solutions

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.15nWhat will not work\or not be sufficient\to restore prosperity
@
@
1. Monetary Policy
@@EUnderlying problem is not Zero Lower Bound
@@ELow interest rates induce capital intensive technology, may lead to "jobless" recovery

@@ETariffs already very low
@@EWith G]7 exporting capital intensive goods, importing labor intensive goods, a "balanced"
@@@increase in trade leads to lower employment

3. Misguided supply side measures
@@ECorporate income taxes

4. Another dose of austerity

Some of these measures would be counterproductive

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.16nRemedies: Immediate issue\restoring global aggregate demand
@
@
1. Setting a high price on carbon (following up on Paris) will induce investments to retrofit
@ the global economy for climate change

2. Recycle some of the surpluses, e.g. through recapitalization of development banks, or creating
@ new development banks: would help meet deep investment needs, including infrastructure
@@EPrivate sector has proven itself relatively ineffective in intermediation
@@EShort term financial markets sit between long term investors and long term investments

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.17nMeasures that would work
@
@
3. Increasing government spending, financed partially by taxes, will stimulate economy
@@EPrinciple of balanced budget multiplier; with well designed taxes and expenditures,
@@@multiplier can be quite high
@@EAppropriate accounting framework looks at both sides of the national balance sheet, not
@@@just at liabilities
@@@@ESpending on education, health of young people are investments which improve asset side
@@@@@of balance sheet
@@@@ESo do investments in infrastructure and technology
@@EEnvironmental taxes and land taxes will help restructure the economy to create sustainable
@@@growth
@@ESo will government expenditures to promote structural transformation and promote equality

4. Other measures to increase equality will increase global aggregate demand
@@ERewriting the rules: improving equality of market income
@@EImproving on transfer and tax system
@@EMeasures that increases wages and worker security
@@@@EIn some countries, improving legal framework surrounding unions/bargaining

5. A global reserve system will reduce need for demand-reducing build up of reserves

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.18nBeyond global aggregate demand
@
@
• Especially as world moves to service sector economy, non-traded sector likely to be
@increasingly important

• Absence of domestic demand impairs supply

• Domestic demand is more than private consumption
@@EIncludes investment in environment, people, technology (closing the knowledge gap),
@@@infrastructure, making cities livable

• Much of this domestic demand will have to be publicly financed
@@EHealth and education are among key service sectors

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.19nA. Ending austerity
@
@
• Even the US has had a mild firm of austerity
@@E500,000 fewer public sector employees, normal expansion would have some 2 million more

• Notions of expansionary contractions and that there is a critical threshold, above which debt
@lowers growth have been discredited

• Even if that were the case, the balanced budget multiplier means that increasing taxes in
@tandem with investment spending increases GDP now and in the future

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.20nNeed balanced approach to finance\debt vs. tax
@
@
• Will vary from country to country, depending on levels of debt and taxes, growth paths
@@EAlways need to keep balance sheet perspective

• In all countries, raising environmental taxes ("charges", including congestion fees),
@including carbon tax, would generate substantial revenues and improve economic performance

• So too would a Financial Transaction Tax

• In virtually all countries, raising taxes on land and other natural resources ("inelastically
@supplied") would raise substantial revenues, increase growth (less diversion of savings to
@unproductive uses)

(Cont'd on next slide)
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.21nNeed balanced approach to finance\debt vs. tax (Cont'd)
@
@
• Lowering taxes on corporations would not increase investment, since most investment is debt
@financed, and interest is tax deductible (lowering taxes raises net cost of capital, and thus
@discourages investment!)
@@EIncreasing taxes on companies that do not invest in the country and create jobs may
@@@incentivize investment

• Some taxes actually stimulate spending today (carbon tax, inheritance tax)

• Balanced budget multiplier implies that raising taxes and spending in tandem stimulates economy

Well designed taxes would also address key issues of inequality, instability, and environmental

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.22nBeyond austerity
@
@
Rethinking budgetary rules and frameworks

• Capital Budgeting
@@EBalance sheet perspective is especially important when cost of funds is low and returns
@@@to investments are high

• Using development banks to promote investment
@@EWith well designed taxes and expenditures, multiplier can be quite high

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.23nB. Spending money well: focusing on key long run problems\lack of productivity
@
@
There has been under-investment in technology and infrastructure which is complementary to
private investment
@@Ewith government support of basic research (as a percentage of GDP) lower than it was a half
@@@century ago
@@Ewellspring of ideas driving new innovations to increase productivity may be drying up

What is need is more Investment infrastructure and technology
@@Esince much of this public investment is complementary with private investment, private
@@@investment will be stimulated
@@Einvestment could be financed through an infrastructure bank

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.24nC. Spending money well: focusing on key long run problems\Structural Transformation
@
@
• Global manufacturing employment is in the decline

• With globalization, the advanced countries will be seizing a declining share of that employment

• Needs to be shift to service sector
@@EAnd in some countries, improving productivity of service sector

• Markets on their own do a poor job at managing the kind of large structural transformation that
@is needed
@@EEvidenced in earlier transition from agricultural to manufacturing

• Among the service sectors that should be taking up the slack are education and health
@@EGovernment rightly plays an important role in these sectors
@@EAusterity has constrained the ability of the government to play that role

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.25nChallenges posed by this structural transformation
@
@
• New economy may be less capital-intensive
@@ESo that the investment needed to support a given growth in GDP may be smaller

• Older workers especially may be ill-prepared for the new economy
@@EWith the aging of the baby-boomers, a larger fraction of workers are older
@@EThe societal costs of not retooling\of simply accepting their obsolescence\are higher

• Existing arrangements creating large issues for old and young
@@EZero interest rate environment means that old who saved prudently through government bonds
@@@have low income
@@EYoung can't afford to buy houses, often have to wait long time to get a job, when they get
@@@a job, it doesn't use their skills and talents, and in many countries, they are saddled
@@@with large debts

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.26nPolicies for promoting Structural Transformation
@
@
• In many countries government action was central in transition from agriculture to manufacturing

• The government needs to again take an active role, including through more active labor market
@policies.

• Such policies only work, however, if there are jobs for the retrained workers.
@@EThere needs to be a comprehensive framework for restoring full employment

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.27nD. Fighting Inequality
@
@
• More than redistribution

• Pre-distribution: Rewriting the Rules to ensure more equitable distribution of market income
@@EMarkets don't exist in a vacuum: the way they are structured affects how they function,
@@@efficiency, and distribution
@@EIncreases in rents explains the anomaly of an increase wealth/income ratio accompanied by
@@@a decrease in the ratio of productive capital to income

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.28nFighting Inequality
@
@
• These theories explain the marked disparity between the growth in labor productivity and real
@wages
@@EWedge can't be explained by standard theories\skilled bias technical change or differential
@@@savings rates

• Reduced inequality would improve economic performance, in the short term, and in the long term

See Stiglitz, J. E., N. Abernathy, A. Hersh, S. Holmberg, and M. Konczal (2015).
Rewriting the Rules of the American Economy, New York: W.W. Norton, 2015.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.29nIII. Structural Reforms
@
@
Some basic principles

• In the absence of adequate demand, supply side reforms will increase unemployment, not promote
growth
@@EMoving people from low productivity sector to zero productivity unemployment
@@ESupply does not create its own demand
@@EIndeed, supply side reforms can weaken demand and lead to lower GDP
@@EBut well designed demand policies can increase supply/productivity, can increase GDP today
@@@and potential growth rates

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.30nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
Often working in conjunction with "demand"

• Increased investment in technology

• Especially important as one creating an innovation economy and a learning society

• Increased investment in people\creating a healthier and more productive labor force

• Industrial policies which help restructure the economy, moving from old sectors to new
@@EMarkets don't make these transformation well on their own

• Competition policies\preventing the agglomeration of economic power
@@EMonopolies restrict output

• Financial market reform
@@ENot just prevent financial sector from imposing harms
@@EEncouraging it to do what it is supposed to do, intermediate, private finance, especially
@@@for small and medium sized enterprises
@@EEncouraging equity rather than debt

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.31nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
• Measures to facilitate participation in labor force
@@EGood public transportation systems
@@EParental and sick leave
@@EChild care

• Inclusion of groups that have been discriminated against and marginalized
@@EWomen
@@EMinorities
@@Eimmigrants

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.32nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
• There are many ineffective (or counterproductive) supply side measures
@@ELowering corporate income tax
@@@@EBut lowering taxes on corporations that invest and create jobs and increasing it on
@@@@@corporations that don't would incentivize investment and job creation
@@EFinancial market deregulation
@@@@ELeads to less investment, more speculation, instability
@@ETrade measures have not had hoped for supply side benefits
@@@@EBenefits always overestimated
@@@@@@ECurrent estimates of TPP for US around zero
@@@@EGrowing consensus TPP is a bad trade agreement, will not be ratified by US Congress
@@@@@@EInvestment provisions especially objectionable\introduce new source of
@@@@@@@discrimination, limits ability to regulate economy in ways that would lead
@@@@@@@to stronger growth, protect environment, etc.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.33nOther counterproductive supply side measures
@
@
• Backward looking supply side reforms also will not work
@@EReducing excess housing capacity in the US (empty homes in Nevada desert) would not have
@@@helped US recovery
@@EDestroying excess chip capacity in Korean crisis (1998) would have impeded its recovery
@@@@EIgnored option value
@@EArguments often made by those wishing a reduction in competition
@@@@E"national champions" = oligopolies

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.34nFailure of Supply side measures
@
@
• Supply side measures in US (and other countries) in early 1980s failed
@@EDidn't live up to promise of increasing tax revenues\actually fell
@@EDidn't live up to promise of increasing growth\actually fell
@@@@ESavings rate fell
@@@@@@ESame effect seen in more recent tax cuts in beginning of 2000s
@@@@ELabor force participation fell
@@EWorries about impact on inequality more than justified\have reached new heights

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.35nIV. Financial sector and financial turmoil
@
@
• Some of turmoil is reflection of lack of transparency in financial markets

• Some of turmoil is reflection of short-sighted nature of financial markets\they have always
@been very fickle

• Some of turmoil is reflection of deep uncertainty about the direction of the global economy

• Some of turmoil related to failure of countries to coordinate monetary policy, resulting
@uncertainty in exchange rates, large movements in destabilizing capital flows
@@EFacilitated by capital and financial market liberalization

• Much of the turmoil reflects failure to address fundamental problems in the financial sector

• Problem is that the turmoil is likely to have consequences for the real sector

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.36nReforming the financial sector
@
@
• More than preventing the sector from imposing harm
@@EThrough excessive risk taking
@@EMarket manipulation, predatory lending, etc.
@@EAbuse of market power

• Ensuring that it plays societal role at low transactions costs
@@Eproviding SME and housing finance
@@Emanaging retirement accounts and running the payments system at low transactions cost

So far, we have failed in both tasks

There is the need for broader and deeper reforms and broadening public instruments for providing
• Student loans
• Public option in mortgages
• Public option in retirement accounts

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.37nV. Global Reforms
@
@
• Need new global reserve system
@@ECurrent system is a historical anachronism
@@ELeads to biases towards surpluses
@@EWeaknesses in reserve currency countries
@@EA global reserve system, as suggested by Keynes and recent UN Commission would lead to
@@@greater global stability

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.38nGlobal reforms
@
@
• Need global coordination to reduce global imbalances
@@EChina's surpluses are in process of being reduced
@@EBut those in the Eurozone are increasing
@@@@EWill need deep reforms in Eurozone

• Need global macro]economic (monetary and fiscal) coordination
@@EWas hope that this would happen after Global Financial Crisis
@@EHasn't materialized\even greater asynchronous movements

• Need better ways of recycling surpluses
@@ENew development banks move in the right direction
@@EBut there is a need for governance reforms and recapitalization of Multilateral development
@@@banks

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.39nFinance for development
@
@
Could simultaneously recycle surpluses, adding to global demand, and promote development, but
there are three impediments

• Debt markets: no international framework for debt restructuring
@@EImportant initiative at the UN, supported by vast majority of countries
@@EBut US and some European countries arguing against a "rule of law"

• FDI: investment agreements undermine the ability of countries to regulate

• Taxation of multinationals: international tax regime makes raising revenues difficult
@@ERace to the bottom
@@EBEPS agreement at G-20 left key issues unaddressed
@@EDeeper reform of global tax regime needed

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.40nAction on climate change
@
@
• Investments to retrofit the economy for climate change would provide needed stimulus to global
economy

• Environment and economic growth are complementary
@@EEspecially if we measure growth correctly

• Providing a price on carbon would provide incentives for investment

• Paris meeting was important in creating momentum, so business community realizes that in one
@form or another there will eventually be a price for carbon
@@EKey investments (infrastructure, housing, buildings, power plants) are long term

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.41nVI. Reforms in the global decision making process
@
@
• Global economic integration has outpaced than of global political integration

• Whenever there are spillovers, externalities need for collective action

• But we have no good framework for doing so at the global level

• Global economic policy too often reflects power and special interests
@@ENot necessarily focusing on areas where global cooperation and harmonization are necessary
@@@@EExcessive harmonization of IPR rules
@@@@EHarmonization on rules that reflect special interests, with insufficient democratic
@@@@@accountability\different from what might emerge from a more global democratic process
@@@@EEspecial concern that new trade agreements will impair ability of governments to
@@@@@perform essential regulatory functions in a democratic way
@@EFocus is on harmonizing down, to lowest common denominator

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.42nReforms in global decision making process
@
@
• How to increase representativeness
@@EUnder-representation of small and poor countries
@@EImportant, even if they have little weight in global economy

• How to increase legitimacy
@@EUN is the international body with global legitimacy
@@EIMF has similarly more legitimacy within its remit

• Danger of "club" getting together to make decisions for all
@@EUndermines credibility of other organizations

• Alternative: Global Economic Coordinating Council
@@EOperating under the UN, IMF

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.43nRethinking global decision making
@
@
• Variable geometry
@@ERecognizing that it will be difficult to get close to unanimity on many issues

• "Coalition of willing"\for instance on climate change
@@EWith cross-border taxes to induce others to cooperate

• May not be able to get all to agree to new global reserve system
@@EAgain coalition of willing\advantages will induce others eventually to join

• Thinking carefully about where externalities are most important
@@EAbsence of collective risk bearing induces high level of savings, reduces global aggregate
@@@demand
@@EGlobal rules favoring capital increase inequality, with adverse effects on global aggregate
@@@demand
@@EGlobal instability creates inequality, leads to high savings, both of which contribute to
@@@deficiency in global aggregate demand

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.44nVII. The World Today in Perspective
@
@
• Many of the advanced countries began an experiment a third of a century ago\lowering taxes,
@deregulation

• There was a need to adjust economic framework to changing economic circumstances

• Consequence has been slower growth and increasing inequality

• Full effects are just now being felt\but they have been on their way

• If current course continues things will get worse
@@EWith untold political consequences\some of which we are beginning to see

• This experiment can and should now be declared a major failure

• There is a need for a new course
@@EMinor changes, tweaking of current arrangements will not do

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.45nMany pieces to this failed experiment
@
@
• New approaches to monetary policy
@@EFocus on inflation, rather than balanced perspective\growth, employment and stability

• New approaches to fiscal policy
@@EIn Europe, stringent constraints on deficits

• New emphasis on privatization
@@EExtending even to social security in some countries

These too have not brought promised benefits

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.46nExperiment in new global architecture is also a failure
@
@
• Forty years ago would began experiment with unfettered capital flows
@@EWas supposed to bring a new era of stability

• Markets would do a better job than governments

• Instead it ushered in new era of global instability
@@EEspecially associated with short term capital flows

• Now even the IMF says that there should be capital controls (capital account management)

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.47nThere is a way forward
@
@
• Restoring the balance between the government and the market

• Recognizing the importance of the "third sector" and new institutional arrangements

• Ending austerity

• Global efforts to address global needs, global public goods, global externalities
@@EBeyond climate change to include a global science foundation
@@EGlobal efforts to increase productivity\instead of a race to bottom

• Commitment to measures to increase living standards for all

• Global reassessment of how we measure progress
@@EWhat we measure affects what we do
@@EMain message of the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social
@@@Progress
@@EWork continuing at the OECD

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.48nThe World Economy: The Way Forward
@
@
• The New Mediocre, the Great Malaise, Secular Stagnation are not inevitable
@@EThey are the result of failed policies

• In an increasingly integrated world, the best way forward would entail global cooperation in
restoring balance and increasing aggregate demand
@@ECombined with cooperation, for instance, in the provision of global public goods
@@@\research, global warming
@@EAchieving that cooperation has proven difficult
@@EJapanfs leadership in G-7 may be part of way forward

• But even lacking that cooperation, there is much that each country can do to strengthen demand
@and improve productivity within its own borders
@@EWith significant spill-overs to others

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/466.html

[GkEStory41] XeBObcoiǂɂ{j 1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zti񑊊@j
XeBObcoiǂɂ{j@
1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉@2016N316
zt@Qi񑊊@j
https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/kokusaikinyu/dai1/gijisidai.html

@

ƋZ̈𒴂ASŎIȐɌ
@
@
WZtEEEXeBObc

2016N3
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.2nIDX͍ǂɂ邩
@
@
• ɖȐ\iGreat MalaisejAVȖ}fiNew Mediocrej
@ÊƂ܂@ł͂ȂB

@EAG7̑̍Xł́iBꂽP[X܂߁jPIɑ̎ƂĂB
@@NwЉ̎嗬cꂽwł͍Xɍ̎ƂB

@E̊ɖȐ̉ʎ͈ꕔ̃gbvwɕ΂ĕzĂ\i͊g債Ȁ㏸͒؁B
@@@Euɂ́vƗႢƂĂ鍑łAٗp̎╢BꂽƂɂ͋^╄B

@EEoϊ@Oɂւ炸A2007N̐Eoς͎ۂɂ͎ォB
@@@EouɂĎxĂB
@@@Eoϊ@O2007N̐E߂ƂƂ́AĉXێĂ̂ƓA
@@@@アoςɖ߂Ă܂ƂӖB

• 錩ʂ\Ȑɖ߂\͏AiCނ؂̉\͍B
@EYiou̎kւ́AƂȌOB
@EƂƂz̍钆AV͋z̎{oɒʁB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.3nLєYޕčo
@
@
• 1980N1998N܂ł̌oϐpĂƂA̕čGDṔAGDP
@15%قǍ̂ƂȂĂ͂łB

• ̘JQ}ɐi1980N㏉ƔrĂA݂̐YNl̏AƗ͒ႢB

• ʂ́iƌvj́A1989NƔr1%̏㏸BĂȂB

• ŉw̎60NOႢB

• Nw̃AtJnAJl̎Ɨ͖23.7%B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.4n

mOtnčfcõgh mȗn
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.5nB͂ƈ
@
@
• Ɨ͍XɍB

• ɎNw̎Ƃ[B

• oϐXɒႢB

• [@͏IĂȂBꎞIȁuNԁiremissionjvɂ邾B
@Eʉ݂@\邽߂ɕKvȐxn݂ĂȂB
@@āA̐xn݂錩݂ʂȂB

• B̌ƁAɉBoϐĂƂĂ낤pƂ̊Ԃɂ̓Mbv݁B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.6n@ȗAB̃ptH[}X͔ߎSȂ

mOtn[̂fcõgh mȗn
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.7n
@
@
• EZ@ȗAEoς̌B
@Ei͒ړIAԐړIɉe󂯂B

• [ȌoόƂȂ錩݁B

• Bƕčł́Aoς̌𖄂ߍ킹邱Ƃ͂łȂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.8nsithe Great RecessionjɊւff
@
@
̋Z@ł͂ȂB

• s̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

• Kv炩sꂽihbhEtN@jB

• Aoς͖ɌSȏԂɖ߂ĂȂB
@ENWbgEl̉Pɏ\ȒӂĂȂB
@ÊƂ́AZɘa҂ꂽقǂ̌ʂ𓾂ĂȂR̈B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.9nsithe Great RecessionjɊւff
@
@
̃oXV[gsł͂ȂB

• Ƃ̃oXV[g͊Tˍč\zꂽB

• ƂɐϋɓIɂȂȂ̂́AoXV[g⎑B̖ł͂ȂB
@EvȂƂȂ̂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.10nXȂ錜O
@
@
• iIȐE̕sύt
@E[ĂB

• Ώ̂Ȓ
@E̒ቺɒʂ鍑ƁiƁAƌvj͏𓾂ȂB
@EƁiƁAƌvj͂̎̕xo𑝉ĂȂB
@Ei̕ϓւ̑Ήł͈ȉ̓_B
@@@Eỉ͎v𑝉Ɗ҂ĂAusҁvilosersjւ̈e
@@@@̕։vĂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.11nSIۑ̐ff
@
@
• EIȑv̕sB

• Ƒ܂āAeɂāAfՃZN^[ւ̎x͕s\B

• EZւ̉ߓẍˑB

• ɍL݂΁A30NOɎsoς̃[̓]iŐ̍Đ݌vAȎRj̃vZX
@̐iŎn܂B́A̖ژ_ɔāAXȂoϐ̒ቺAs艻A
@sB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.12niGreat malaisej́AقǂɐiWȂA[Ȗ𕢂BĂ
@
@
• Cϓ

• iA̕nw
@Ex̕sAN̕siÂ𖯊Ԃ̒񋟂Ɉˑ鍑ɂẮjAٔւ̃ANZX̕sA
@@ƑɓnB
@Eił͒ԑwkBr㍑ɂĂԑwkB
@É̖AЉ̎嗬cꂽwi΂΁jNwł͓ɐ[B

• I邽߂ɂ́AOIȁu\ϊvvistructural transformationsj߂B

• soςɍt肪AY̒؂炵ĂB
@EԕEI̗ɂZIuB
@Ebւ̓̕sBāA̍ł̓Ctւ̓̕sB
@Eߓx̋ZBߓx̋Z͈ȉ̉ߒ̈ꕔłÄꕔłB
@@@ExƎ{̊Ԃ̃Mbv̍LB
@@@E̍ŎYoɑ΂x̊܂AYoɑ΂鎑{̔䗦ቺB
@EVXe̓K̎sB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.13nIID̏󋵂ւ̑Ή
@
@
R̎iɊւΗ錩FZ

• ŹAT˂̖SB

• [Ȓ؎ɂāAZ􂪋ɂ߂ėLƂ͂܂łɂȂB
@B̌ʓIȎi͍B

• {̖́A[ł͂ȂB邱ƁiႦ}CiẌ̗ɓƂĂj
@͋@\ȂB
• }CiX݂̎́AiC傫͎hAp炷\B

• ʓIɘa͕sg債BAiƂĂj̑啝ȑɂ͂Ȃ炸A
@Zs̕sS邢͕sɂAXÑ~XvCVO₻̑̋Zs̘c݂
@炵\B
@Eȕ։v̈́AIȒʉ݂̐؂艺łBÁA[ETEQ[B
@EK؂ȍȂł́AuB̑Iv͍XɈrB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.14nR̎iɊւΗ錩F
@
@
• 􂪍̃XN߂錜OB
@E20082009NɎ{iCh͌ʂȂƂ͑S̊ԈႢB
@E΍􂪂Ȃ΍XɈĂł낤Ɨ̒ቺ炷ƂłAXȂiCށAs
@@Ɋׂ̂hB
@E@ɂẮAxoœK鎞Ԃ͂ȂB\ƂAsSȍΏołĂAʂ
@@pɂ邱ƂsɔׂΖ]܂B
@Eւ̌ÓAoXV[gEAv[ւ̖̂ւBł́A{͐YIȓ
@@΂Ďxo邱ƂOƂĂB

• O[o[[Vɂ萭ʂ͑ȂĂB\։v͑ɗoAp͎ɔB
@EAuDʁvȉ񎦂ɂ́AE̋֌W͎シB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.15nɉh߂߂ɂ͋@\Ȃ́As\Ȃ
@
@
PDZ
@@E{IȖ́A[ł͂ȂB
@@E͎{W^eNmW[𐶂ݏoAuٗpȂvoω񕜂ɂȂ\B

QDfՋ
@@E֐ł͊ɂȂ̒ᐅB
@@EG7ɂA{WAoŘJWAƂuoX̎ꂽv
@@@fՎ̑́AٗpB

RDႢ̋TCh̎{
@@E@lېŁB

SDXȂُk

̑΍̂Ȃɂ́AtʂƂȂ̂݁B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.16nΏ@F ً}̖\Ȇv߂
@
@
PDip󂯁jYfɍiݒ肷邱Ƃ́ACϓɑΉ鐢Eoςւ̉vɌ
@@𑣂B

QDo퍕̈ꕔ̍ĊpiႦΊJs̎{č\AVȊJs̑n݁j́ACt
@@܂߂̕Kv𖞂́B
@@Eԕ́A@\ɂĔł邱Ƃ玦ĂB
@@EIȓƂƒIȓȂ̂AZS̋ZsłB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.17nʓIȎ{
@
@
RD{xȏBIɐłŘdꂽ̂łoςhB
@@Eύt\Z搔Ɋւ錴FK؂ɐ݌vꂽłƎxoɂāA搔͋ɂ߂č̂ƂȂB
@@ẼoXV[gɂẮA݂̂ł͂ȂAYEʂ邱ƂK؂ȉv
@@@t[[NB
@@@@EA҂̌Nւ̎xo͓łAoXV[g̎YTChPB
@@@@ECtƃeNmW[ւ̓lB
@@Ełynł́A\Ȑoύč\zɖ𗧂B
@@E\ϊv𐄐iA߂鐭{xolB

SD߂邻̑̎{͐Ȇv𑝉B
@@Eoσ[̑]Fsœ鏊ƕɁB
@@Eړ]ƐŐ̉PB
@@E㏸ƘJҕی߂{B
@@@@E̍ł́Ag芪@Igg݂PB

TDO[oȊʉݐx\z邱ƂŁAvkOݏ̐ςݗĂ̕Kv炷
@@ƂłB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.18nEIȑv̐
@
@
• ɐEIɃT[rXoςւ̈ڍsiޒAfՃZN^[͂܂܂dvɁB

• v̒͋炷B

• v͖ԏ傫B
@ElԁAimMbv𖄂߂jeNmW[ACtAZ݂悢Xɂ邽߂̓
@@܂܂B

• ̍v̑唼͌It@CiXŒBׂ́B
@EN⋳͂̒łdvȃT[rXB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.19nDُk߂
@
@
• čłAɂ₩ȌŋُkɂȂĂB
@Eʏ̌iCgǖʂł200ľIZN^[̌ٗp܂邪A݂͋t50lĂB

• iCgIȍُkA臒l𒴂ƌoϐቺAƂl̐
@ے肳ĂB

• ̍lƂĂAGDPƏGDPA悤ɐŎƓ
@킹đĂƂƂύt\Z搔̋B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.20noX̎ꂽAv[Kv\
@
@
• Ŏ̐ǍʂɂAeƂɍœKȍƐł̃oX͈قȂB
@EɃoXV[g_Ƃ߂B

• ׂĂ̍ɂāAYfł܂߂Łia؉ۋ܂ށuۋvj̈グŁAȍΓ
@Aoς̃ptH[}XP邾낤B

• ZłɂĂl B

• قƂǂׂĂ̍ɂāAyniue͓Iɋ𑝉邱ƂłȂvj̓VR
@΂łグ邱ƂŁAȍΓ𑝂₵A㏸邾낤i~̔񐶎YIȗpr
@ւ̗炷ƂłjB

(y[Wɑ)
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.21noX̎ꂽAv[Kv\ Łij
@
@
• @lŌł͓gɂ͊^ȂBȂȂA͎̓ؓłAxq͏T
@ƂȂ邩炾ił̓lbg̎{RXg㏸Aӗ~ނIj
@EނAł̓ٗpnoɐϋɓIłȂƂɑ΂āA@lłグAg
@@B

• iYfŁEłȂǁj̐ŋ́AۂɌ_ł̎xo𑣂ʂB

• ύt\Z搔́Ałƕ킹xog傪oςh邱ƂĂB

K؂ɐ݌vꂽŐ́AiEsEƂvȖɎgގiƂȂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.22nُk𒴂
@
@
\Z[Et[[N̍čl

• {\ZiCapital Budgetingj
@EBRXgႭA^[ɂ́AoXV[g̊ϓ_ɏdvłB

• î߂̊Jsidevelopment banksj̊p
@EłƎxoK؂ɑI΁A搔̌ʂ͋ɂ߂čB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
@
@
eNmW[Ctɑ΂铊́Aԓ⊮ʂL̂ł邪AœKȐ
ׂƒႭ܂ĂB
• bɑ΂鐭{xzi΂fcoj́AIOႭȂĂB
• YɂȂVȃCmx[V𐄐iACfǍオĂB

KvȂƂ́ACtƃeNmW[ւ̂ϋɓIȓłB
• CtEeNmW[ւ͖̌ԓƕ⊮IłAԓh鎖ɂȂB
• ̓Ctsiinfrastructure bankjt@CiX邱ƂłB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.24nCDʓIɎxoFdvȒ̖ɏœ_𓖂Ă\\ϊviStructural Transformationj
@
@
• EIɁAƂ̌ٗpĂB

• O[o[[VƂƂɁAił͌ٗpɐ߂鐻Ƃ̃VFAቺĂB

• T[rXYƂɃVtgKvB
@E̍ł́AT[rXYƂ̐YサĂB

• ̂悤ȑK͂ȍ\ϊvistructural transformationj߂Ă邪As͂ꎩ̂ł
@KvƂĂ\ϊvB邱Ƃ肭łȂB
@Ečsꂽ_Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsؖĂB

• T[rXYƂ̒ł́AENɉP̗]nB
@E̕ł́A{ɏdvȖŜłB
@EAُḱA{̖ʂƂ}Ă܂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.25n\ϊviStructural TransformationjɔĔۑ
@
@
• ̐Voύ\́AĂقǎ{WIicapital-intensivejł͂ȂȂ邾낤B
@E]āAz肳GDPB邽߂ɕKvƂȂ铊́A菬Ȃ̂낤B

• ɏnNJ҂́AVoύ\ɑ΂ďsł낤B
@Exr[u[̍ƍ킹āAJ҂̂Ȃ̕ĂB
@E̐̍Ċ𑣂ȂƂɂЉIȃRXg\܂A̐̐lI{̒P
@@󂯓邱Ɓ\͑債ĂB

• ݂茈߂A҂Ǝ҂Ɋւ𐶂ݏoĂB
@EʂĎ茘^pĂ鍂҂킸ȏȂƂƂA[̊
@@͈ӖB
@E҂͉Ƃ𔃂]T͖AE𓾂܂Œԑ҂KvXAE𓾂ẴXLE˔\
@@𐶂Ađ̍ł͎҂͑ȍw܂ĂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.26n\ϊviStructural Transformationj iɌ
@
@
• _Ƃ琻Ƃւ̈ڍsɂāA̍Ő{SIȖʂB

• ϋɓIȘJsꐭ܂߁A{͍ĂѐϋɓIȖSƂ߂ĂB

• ȂA̐́AĐEƋ󂯂J҂̂߂̎d݂ꍇɌČʂ
@B
@ESٗp߂߂̕Iȃt[[N߂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.27ncDiƐ키
@
@
• PȂĕz̘bł͂ȂB

• OzFsœ邱Ƃ̂ł鏊̂ȕzmȂ̂Ƃ邽߂̌oσ[̑]B
@Es͐^̒ɑ݂̂ł͂ȂFs̍\z@ɂAs̋@\EʁEz܂B
@Eƒ̏㏸́Aɑ΂鐶YIȎ{̔䗦Ăɂւ炸Aɑ΂x̔䗦
@@㏸ĂƂُ킳𕨌ĂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.28niƐ키
@
@
• ̗_́AJYƎɂ钘sύtĂB
@E̕sύt́AXLΏd^̋Zpi⒙~̍قƂWIȗ_ł͐łȂB

• iḱAZIɂAIɂAoσptH[}XPB

WZtEEEXeBObci˒JmjwXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv
̋ȏxiԏXA2016NjiFStiglitz, J. E., N. Abernathy, A. Hersh, S. Holmberg, and
M. Konczal (2015). Rewriting the Rules of the American Economy, New York: W.W. Norton, 2015.j
QƁB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.29nIII. \viStructural Reformsj
@
@
{IȌ

• K؂ȎvȂɂ́ATvCTCh̉v́AƂ𑝉邾ŁAoϐɂ͊^ȂB
@EᐶY傩[YA܂AlXƂɒǂ̂łB
@ÉAꎩ̂̎voȂB
@EۂɁATvCTCh̉v͎v߁AGDPቺB
@EAK؂ɐ݌vꂽvh́A/Y𑝉A݂ѐݓIGDP
@@グ邱ƂłB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.30n@\TvCTCh̎{
@
@
uvvƈ̂ƂȂĂA@\邱ƂB

• eNmW[ւ̓g
@EvVIoρiinnovation economyjƊwKЉilearning societyjoŁAƂ킯dvB

• lԂւ̓̊g\茒Nł萶Y̍J͂noB

• oςč\zAÂYƂVYƂւ̈ڍsɖ𗧂YƐ
@Esꂾł́A̕ϊv͍oȂB

• \oϓIȌ͂]邱Ƃh
@EƐ͎YojQB

• Zsv
@EZ@ւɊQyڂƂhł͕s\B
@EƂ킯Ƃ̂߂Ɋ҂ʂAZ𒇉AԎ񋟂悤
@@Z@ւɑƂ߂B
@E{̎𑣂Ƃ߂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.31n@\TvCTCh̎{
@
@
• JQ𑣐i{
@ELȌʃVXe
@E玙xɁALaCx
@EqĎx

• 퍷ʑwEЉ̎嗬cꂽw̕
@E
@EhE}CmeB[
@Eږ
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.32n@\TvCTCh̎{
@
@
• ʓIłȂi܂͋tʂȁjTvCTCh̎{􂪑݂B
@E@lŗ̈B
@@@EOƂāAČٗpnoƂɂ͌łAٗpnoɏɓIȊƂɂ
@@@@ł{B
@EZs̋KɘaB
@@@ĚA@̊gAs̕s艻ɂȂB
@EfՐɂăTvCTCȟʂ͊҂ĂȂB
@@@Eʂ͏ɉߑ]B
@@@@@EčɂƂTPP̌ʂ͂قڃ[ƐvB
@@@ETPP͈fՋłƂRZTXLAčcŔyȂł낤
@@@@@EɓD܂Ȃ\Vʂ炵A苭ی쓙̂߂
@@@@@@oϋKi𐧌
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.33n̋tʂȃTvCTCh{
@
@
• ȃTvCTChv@\ȂB
@EčɂZ̉ߏ苟ilo_̋󂫉Ɓj̍팸́Ačoς̉񕜂Ɋ^ĂȂB
@E؍̌oϊ@i1998Njɂ锼̃bv̉ߏ萶Y\͂̔j́Aoς̉񕜂x点B
@@@EIvVƂ̉l͖B
@E炷Ƃ]ތ悭oc_B
@@@Eȗ\IƁvignational championshj Ƃt́A ̂Ƃ͉ǐ莖Ǝ҂Ӗ
@@@́B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.34nTvCTCh{̎s
@
@
• 1980N㏉̕čiёjɂTvCTCh{̎sB
@EŎ̖񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͌B
@E߂񑩂͉ʂȂ\ۂɂ͒ቺB
@@@E~ቺB
@@@@@Eŋ߂2000N㏉ɂ錸łłʂ݂ꂽB
@@@EJQቺB
@ETvCTCh{̐ATvCTCh{ɂiւ̉ěO͍ōɒB
@@B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.35nIVDZZN^[ƋZ
@
@
• Z̍́AZs̕s𔽉fB

• Z̍́AZs̋ߎIȐ𔽉f\Zs͏ɂƂĂC܂B

• Z̍́AEoς̐sɊւ[ȕsm𔽉fB

• Z̍́A̍ɂZ̎sɊ֘AĂAʂƂĈבփ[g
@smsȎ{t[̑傫ȓĂB
@E{sAZs̎R𑣐iB

• Z̍̑́AZZN^[ɂ鍪{IȖւ̎g̎s𔽉f́B

• ̂悤ȋZ̍̌oςɔgy\ƂłB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.36nZZN^[v
@
@
• ZZN^[̊QhAȉj~B
@EߓxȃXNeCN
@EsɂxzInʂ̗p

• ZZN^[ႢRXgŎЉIS悤ɂB
@EƋZZZ̋
@EN̊Ǘ⌈σVXẻ^pႢRXgŎ{

܂ł̂ƂÃ^XNɎsB

L[vƁA^M񋟂Ii̊g傪KvB
• w[
• Z[ɊւIIvV
• NɊւIIvV @
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.37nVDEK͂̉v
@
@
• VEʉݐx̕Kv
@Ẽ݂VXe͉ߋ̈╨B
@Eo퍕ǋoCAXɂȂĂB
@Eʉݍ̐Ǝ㐫B
@EPCYŋ߂̍Aψ񏥂Ă悤ɁAEʉݐx͂苭łȐË
@@Ȃ́B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.38nEK͂̉v
@
@
• E̕sύtk鐢EIȋ߂ĂB
@Ěo퍕͌ߒɂB
@EA[̌o퍕͑ĂA
@@@E[ɂđ傫ȉvKvƂȂB

• EIȃ}NoρiZэj􋦒߂ĂB
@EEZ@ɋN邱Ƃ҂ꂽB
@EAɎĂȂ\ނA̕sa͊g債ĂB

• o퍕pǂi߂ĂB
@EVJs͐B
@EAKoiXvƊJsԂ̎{č\̕Kv݁B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.39nJɌĎ񋟂
@
@
JɌ̒񋟂́Ao퍕̊pAEv̑AJ̑iƂbg𓯎Ɏ
̂ł邪AR̏QB

• ̎sFč\Ɋւ鍑ۓIȃt[[NȂB
@EAɂdvȔcA命̍xB
@EAčƊ̃[bpu@̎xzvirule of lawjɔ΁B

• COړF 肪荑̋K\͂𑹂ȂB

• ЊƂւ̉ېŁFۓIȐő̌nŎ̊gɂĂB
@Euӂւ̋viRace to the bottomj
@EۓIȐő̌n̂蔲{Iȉv߂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.40nCϓւ̃ANV
@
@
• Cϓւ̑΍ƂčśAEoςɂƂĕKvȎhƂȂ邾낤B

• ƌoϐ͕⊮IȊ֌WɂB
@EƂ킯oϐ𐳊mɑꍇɁB

• Yfɉiݒ肷邱ƂɂANB

• ACϓpćA̋C^Ƃϓ_dvBoϊÉAǂ̂悤Ȍ
@ȂɂA₪Ă͒Yfɉiݒ肳邱Ƃ𗝉͂łB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.41nVIDEIȈӎvvZX̉v
@
@
• EIȌoϓ́AEIȐiłB

• zgyʂꍇɂ͂AOɂ͏WcIȑΏ߂B

• AEIȑΉsɓĂ̗Dꂽgg݂͌_ł݂͑ȂB

• EIȌoϐ́A܂ɕpɂɌ̗͂QɍEB
@EEK͂̋͂⒲a߂镪ɕKœ_ĂĂȂB
@@@EmIL[̉ߏȒaB
@@@EŐӔC\ɉʂȂ悤ȓ̗Q𔽉f[̒áAEIɖI
@@@@vZX琶܂钲aƂ͈قȂ̂łB
@@@Ee{IȂŕKvȋK{悤ƂۂɁAVȖfՎ茈߂̔\͂
@@@@ȂƂɌOB
@Eœ_𓖂ẮׂAւ̒ałAłb܂Ȃɂ҂Ƃ̋ʂ̊Ղւ̒a
@@łB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.42nEIȈӎvvZX̉v
@
@
• ǂ̂悤ɑ\߂邩B
@EAn̑\͒ႢB
@EEoςɐ߂EFCg͏ƂĂA̍X͏dvȑ݂łB

• ǂ̂悤ɐ𑝂B
@EÁAEIȐL鍑ۓIȋ@ւłB
@EIMF̌ɂāAlɁAXɑ傫ȐLB

• ủvigclubhjŜ߂̈ӎvs댯B
@ȆgD̐M𑹂ȂB

• ֍FEoϒψiGlobal Economic Coordinating Councilj̑n
@EAAIMF̉ŉ^c
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.43nEIȈӎvčl
@
@
• όiVariable Geometryj
@E̖ŁASvɋ߂ÂƂ͍łƔF邱ƁB

• uLuAvigCoalition of willinghj\Ⴆ΁ACϓ
@EzېłɂA̋͂𑣂B

• VEʉݐx́A炭SĂ̍̍ӂ𓾂邱Ƃ͓B
@ȄꍇLuALB\Qɂ闘v݂邽߁A̍₪ĎQB

• OłLȏʂ𒍈Ӑ[B
@EŃXNUsdg݂݂ȂA̒~s܂AEIȑv
@@kB
@E{WςɗLɓEIȃ[́Aig傳AEIȑv̊gɂ͋tʁB
@EEIȕs萫͊i𐶂ݏoA̒~ɂȂ́BāÁAEI
@@v̌R̗vƂȂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.44nVIIDߖ@ō̐E
@
@
• 30NقǑOA̐ił́Aŗ̈KɘaƂn߂B

• ωoϊɑΉAoς̘gg݂𒲐KvB
@EAȂĂB

• ʂƂāAoϐ͓݉AigB

• ƂȂđQǍʂSĖڂɌ̂ƂȂAߋ炸ƐisĂ
@Ȃ̂łB

• ݂̕ێƁA󋵂͍XɈ邾낤B
@EĂȂIȋAB̂̊͕n߂ĂB

• ̎́A傫Ȏsłƍ⌾ƂłB傫ȎsłƌׂłB

• Vȕ߂B
@E݂̎茈߂̔ł͏肭Ȃ낤B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.45n̎s̒f
@
@
• Zւ̐VȃAv[
@EoϐAٗpAoψ艻ƂoX̂鎋_ACẗ艻ɏœ_B

• ւ̐VȃAv[
@EBł́AԎɑ΂ČdȐB

• c̐Vȗ
@EЉۏᕪɂ܂Ŗc̗ꂪyԍ݁B

̐́A҂قǂ̐ʂグĂȂB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.46nE̐x݌vɊւsĂ
@
@
• 40NOA{ړ̎R݂ĂB
@EɂAoς艻オKƊ҂ĂB

• {sꃁJjY̕ʓIƂĂB

• ̌ʁAtɁAEIȕs艻̎ɓ˓B
@EɁAZIȎ{ړɊ֘Aĕs萫B

• ݂ł́AIMFł{ړ̐i{̊ǗjKvƎ咣B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.47n̓Ȃ
@
@
• {Ǝs̃oX߂B

• {EԂƂ͈قȂuÕZN^[vigthird sectorhjAVȐxgg݂̏dvF
@B

• ُk߂B

• EIȊ{Ij[YAEIȌAEIȊOɑ΂āAEIɑΏB
@ECϓ𒴂āAEIȉȊwՂ܂߂ׂłB
@Eӂւ̋ŝł͂ȂAEIɐYɖ߂ׂłB

• EESĂ̐lԂ̐グ{ɑSĂB

• iɊւwW̐EIȍĕ]sB
@E]sɂeB
@EuoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvijɂ郁CbZ[WB
@ĚOECDɂČpĂB

@ijXeBObcSƂȂāAtX̃TRW哝̂̃CjVAeBủŁA
@@@@Љ̍Kx𑪒肵悤ƂgB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.48nEoρF̓i
@
@
• uVȖ}fviThe New MediocrejA uvithe Great MalaisejAu؁v
@iSecular Stagnationj͔Ȃ̂ł͂ȂB
@ÉA̎sɂAB

• iW钆AOi邽߂̍őP̕@́AoX߂Av𑝉邽߂
@ۓIȋsƂB
@EႦ΁AE̋\Ang΍\ɌۋB
@E̍ۋ͂Ƃ킯łB
@EG7ɂāA{[_[Vbv𔭊邱ƂAOɐiނ߂̈ƂȂ邾낤B

• Aۋ͂s\ȏ󋵉ɂĂAv̋␶Y̌̂߂Ɋe
@PƂōsƂ̂ł邱Ƃ݂͑B
@ÉA傫ȍDe𑼂̍ɑ΂Ă^̂B
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂRg

XeBObcƂ΁Au99%v̑̐lԂɂƂĂ]܂O[oւ̓؂ĂƂ悤ȂƂŕ]Ă鍂Ȍoϊw҂̈lB̍ۋZoϕ͉ɂẮAm[xoϊw܎܎҂ƂĂ̌ЂXeBObcŗグ̌񌾂ƂƂŁAۂ̌ɂĂ̊ϑ܂߂đ傫񂶂ꂽB܂{_ƐV́AXeBObczz̒TPP̌ʂy̌ʂɔےIȌƂグB

̂悤Șb萫̂zzɖڂʂłɁAeLXgĂ݂BA͂肱̎ǂޕɂ̓ÑIWiPDF̕ǂ݂₷B2̃Ot͏ȗiȗy[WԍuPbg͓e҂tjBƂ̃CAEgŃ~XȂƂȂBƂPDF̗򉻃Rs[Ƃ悤̂Ȃ̂ŁAN̖ɂȂȂAIȈӖ߂ēeĂB
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/317.html

[GkEStory41] XeBObcoipj 1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zti񑊊@j
XeBObcoipj@
1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉@2016N316
zt@Pi񑊊@j
https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/kokusaikinyu/dai1/gijisidai.html
@
@
Beyond the Great Malaise and Financial Stability towards Robust and Sustainable Growth
@
@
Joseph E. Stiglitz
Tokyo
March, 2016
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.2nI. Where we are
@
@
• Slow growth\Great Malaise, New Mediocre
@@ENot a crisis yet
@@EBut with persistent moderately high unemployment (in some cases disguised) in
@@@many of G-7, higher unemployment among youth and marginalized groups
@@EDisproportionate share of slow growth going to a few at the top\growing inequality, wage
@@@stagnation
@@@@EEven in countries with low "official" unemployment, raising questions of quality of job
@@@@@growth and disguised unemployment
@@EWorld economy was weak in 2007, before crisis
@@@@EOnly sustained by a bubble
@@@@ERestoring the world to 2007 simply restores us to the weak economy we had then

• Mixed prospects\small probably of returning to robust growth, large probability of recession
@or worse
@@EJustifiable concerns about asset price bubbles that might deflate
@@EEmerging markets facing massive capital outflows, with many countries and
@@@companies over-indebted

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.3nUnderperformance of US Economy
@
@
• GDP some 15% below what it would have been had the growth rates that prevailed between 1980
@and 1998 continued

• Percentage of the working]age population employed lower than it was in the early 1980s, when
@women were entering the workforce en masse

• Median real (household) income is less than 1% higher than it was in 1989

• Real wages at the bottom are lower than 60 years ago

• African-American youth unemployment rate is still 23.7%

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.4n

mgraphn United States GDP Trend Analysis mȗn

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.5nEurope is even worse
@
@
• With higher levels of unemployment

• Especially youth unemployment

• And lower levels of growth

• Euro crisis is not over \ only under short term "remission"
@@EHaven't created institutions that are necessary to make a single currency work, and not
@@@likely to do so at time soon

• Gap between where they are and where they would have been growing

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.6nDismal European performance since crisis

mgraphn Euro Area GDP Trend Analysis mȗn

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.7nChina
@
@
• Has been driver of global economic since GFC
@@EAdvanced countries affected directly and indirectly

• Likely to be significant slowdown

• Europe and US not likely to be able to make up for the slowdown of China's economy

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.8nMisdiagnosis of the Great Recession
@
@
More than a financial crisis

• Banks' balance sheets are largely restored

• Some regulatory reform (Dodd Frank)

• Yet economy is not back to health
@@EInsufficient attention paid to improving credit channel
@@EHelps explain why monetary easing didnft help as much as hoped

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.9nMisdiagnosis of the Great Recession
@
@
More than a balance sheet recession

• Balance sheet of large corporations largely restored

• It is not corporate balance sheets or their access to finance that are holding them back from
@investing
@@EIt is lack of demand.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.10nFurther concerns
@
@
• Persistent Global imbalances
@@EEurozone has exacerbated problem
@@ECountries (firms, households) facing a decline in income have to reduce consumption
@@EThose with increased income do not expand spending symmetrically
@@EResponse to changes in oil price illustrates
@@@@EMany had expected lower prices to increase demand, but adverse effects of "losers"
@@@@@more than offsetting these benefits

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.11nDiagnosis of the central problem
@
@
• Lack of global aggregate demand

• Combined with insufficient efforts in each country to support non-traded sectors

• Excessive reliance on debt, financialization

• More broadly, in large parts of advanced countries about a third of a century ago, there began
@a process of rewriting the rules of the market economy (redesigning tax structures, ill-thought
@out liberalization) that led to slower growth, more instability and more inequality\just the
@opposite of what was promised

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.12nGreat malaise hides deeper problems on which there is being made remarkable little
@@@@progress
@
@
• Climate change

• Inequality, large number of individuals in poverty
@@EWith many dimensions\inequality in wealth, health (in countries relying on private provision
@@@of health care), and access to justice
@@EHollowing out of the middle in advanced countries\and even in developing world
@@EProblems especially severe for marginalized groups and (often) youth

• Deep structural transformations needed to achieve sustainable growth

• Deeper problems in market economies leading to productivity slowdown
@@EShort termism in both private and public sector
@@EInsufficient investment in basic research, and in many countries, infrastructure
@@EExcessive financialization, part of process, part of cause
@@@@EOpening up major gaps between wealth and capital
@@@@ECapital output ratio in many countries going down even as wealth output ratio increases
@@EFailures to adapt education system

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.13nII. Responding to the situation
@
@
Conflicting views about obvious instruments: monetary policy

• Monetary policy has largely run its course

• Never very effective in deep downturns: the only effective instrument is fiscal policy

• Real problem not zero lower bound\slight lowering of interest rates (into negative territory)
@will not work
@@EExperiments with negative interest rates unlikely to stimulate much, may have adverse side
@@@effects
• QE increased inequality, did not lead to significant increase in investment (if any) and
@because of financial market imperfections/irrationalities may have led to mispricing of risk
@and other financial market distortions
@@EOne of main benefits was competitive devaluation\but that's a zero sum game
@@EIn absence of adequate fiscal policies, "only game in town"\matters would have been worse
@@@in its absence

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.14nConflicting views about obvious instruments: fiscal policy
@
@
• Worry that fiscal policy risks damaging build up of debts
@@EView that fiscal stimuli in 2008/2009 didn't work is absolutely wrong
@@EReduced unemployment from what it otherwise would have been, prevented deeper
@@@recession, depression
@@EIn crisis, didn't have time to optimize spending\but even imperfect expenditures were
@@@better than alternative of massive idle resources and depressions
@@EWorry about debts is fundamentally misplaced in balance sheet approach, where government
@@@spends money on productive investments

• Effectiveness of policies undermined by globalization\large spillovers to others, costs borne
@at home
@@EBut global coordination sufficiently weak to provide "superior" globally coordinated
@@@solutions

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.15nWhat will not work\or not be sufficient\to restore prosperity
@
@
1. Monetary Policy
@@EUnderlying problem is not Zero Lower Bound
@@ELow interest rates induce capital intensive technology, may lead to "jobless" recovery

@@ETariffs already very low
@@EWith G]7 exporting capital intensive goods, importing labor intensive goods, a "balanced"
@@@increase in trade leads to lower employment

3. Misguided supply side measures
@@ECorporate income taxes

4. Another dose of austerity

Some of these measures would be counterproductive

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.16nRemedies: Immediate issue\restoring global aggregate demand
@
@
1. Setting a high price on carbon (following up on Paris) will induce investments to retrofit
@ the global economy for climate change

2. Recycle some of the surpluses, e.g. through recapitalization of development banks, or creating
@ new development banks: would help meet deep investment needs, including infrastructure
@@EPrivate sector has proven itself relatively ineffective in intermediation
@@EShort term financial markets sit between long term investors and long term investments

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.17nMeasures that would work
@
@
3. Increasing government spending, financed partially by taxes, will stimulate economy
@@EPrinciple of balanced budget multiplier; with well designed taxes and expenditures,
@@@multiplier can be quite high
@@EAppropriate accounting framework looks at both sides of the national balance sheet, not
@@@just at liabilities
@@@@ESpending on education, health of young people are investments which improve asset side
@@@@@of balance sheet
@@@@ESo do investments in infrastructure and technology
@@EEnvironmental taxes and land taxes will help restructure the economy to create sustainable
@@@growth
@@ESo will government expenditures to promote structural transformation and promote equality

4. Other measures to increase equality will increase global aggregate demand
@@ERewriting the rules: improving equality of market income
@@EImproving on transfer and tax system
@@EMeasures that increases wages and worker security
@@@@EIn some countries, improving legal framework surrounding unions/bargaining

5. A global reserve system will reduce need for demand-reducing build up of reserves

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.18nBeyond global aggregate demand
@
@
• Especially as world moves to service sector economy, non-traded sector likely to be
@increasingly important

• Absence of domestic demand impairs supply

• Domestic demand is more than private consumption
@@EIncludes investment in environment, people, technology (closing the knowledge gap),
@@@infrastructure, making cities livable

• Much of this domestic demand will have to be publicly financed
@@EHealth and education are among key service sectors

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.19nA. Ending austerity
@
@
• Even the US has had a mild firm of austerity
@@E500,000 fewer public sector employees, normal expansion would have some 2 million more

• Notions of expansionary contractions and that there is a critical threshold, above which debt
@lowers growth have been discredited

• Even if that were the case, the balanced budget multiplier means that increasing taxes in
@tandem with investment spending increases GDP now and in the future

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.20nNeed balanced approach to finance\debt vs. tax
@
@
• Will vary from country to country, depending on levels of debt and taxes, growth paths
@@EAlways need to keep balance sheet perspective

• In all countries, raising environmental taxes ("charges", including congestion fees),
@including carbon tax, would generate substantial revenues and improve economic performance

• So too would a Financial Transaction Tax

• In virtually all countries, raising taxes on land and other natural resources ("inelastically
@supplied") would raise substantial revenues, increase growth (less diversion of savings to
@unproductive uses)

(Cont'd on next slide)
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.21nNeed balanced approach to finance\debt vs. tax (Cont'd)
@
@
• Lowering taxes on corporations would not increase investment, since most investment is debt
@financed, and interest is tax deductible (lowering taxes raises net cost of capital, and thus
@discourages investment!)
@@EIncreasing taxes on companies that do not invest in the country and create jobs may
@@@incentivize investment

• Some taxes actually stimulate spending today (carbon tax, inheritance tax)

• Balanced budget multiplier implies that raising taxes and spending in tandem stimulates economy

Well designed taxes would also address key issues of inequality, instability, and environmental

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.22nBeyond austerity
@
@
Rethinking budgetary rules and frameworks

• Capital Budgeting
@@EBalance sheet perspective is especially important when cost of funds is low and returns
@@@to investments are high

• Using development banks to promote investment
@@EWith well designed taxes and expenditures, multiplier can be quite high

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.23nB. Spending money well: focusing on key long run problems\lack of productivity
@
@
There has been under-investment in technology and infrastructure which is complementary to
private investment
@@Ewith government support of basic research (as a percentage of GDP) lower than it was a half
@@@century ago
@@Ewellspring of ideas driving new innovations to increase productivity may be drying up

What is need is more Investment infrastructure and technology
@@Esince much of this public investment is complementary with private investment, private
@@@investment will be stimulated
@@Einvestment could be financed through an infrastructure bank

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.24nC. Spending money well: focusing on key long run problems\Structural Transformation
@
@
• Global manufacturing employment is in the decline

• With globalization, the advanced countries will be seizing a declining share of that employment

• Needs to be shift to service sector
@@EAnd in some countries, improving productivity of service sector

• Markets on their own do a poor job at managing the kind of large structural transformation that
@is needed
@@EEvidenced in earlier transition from agricultural to manufacturing

• Among the service sectors that should be taking up the slack are education and health
@@EGovernment rightly plays an important role in these sectors
@@EAusterity has constrained the ability of the government to play that role

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.25nChallenges posed by this structural transformation
@
@
• New economy may be less capital-intensive
@@ESo that the investment needed to support a given growth in GDP may be smaller

• Older workers especially may be ill-prepared for the new economy
@@EWith the aging of the baby-boomers, a larger fraction of workers are older
@@EThe societal costs of not retooling\of simply accepting their obsolescence\are higher

• Existing arrangements creating large issues for old and young
@@EZero interest rate environment means that old who saved prudently through government
@@bonds have low income
@@EYoung can't afford to buy houses, often have to wait long time to get a job, when they get
@@@a job, it doesn't use their skills and talents, and in many countries, they are saddled
@@@with large debts

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.26nPolicies for promoting Structural Transformation
@
@
• In many countries government action was central in transition from agriculture to manufacturing

• The government needs to again take an active role, including through more active labor market
@policies.

• Such policies only work, however, if there are jobs for the retrained workers.
@@EThere needs to be a comprehensive framework for restoring full employment

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.27nD. Fighting Inequality
@
@
• More than redistribution

• Pre-distribution: Rewriting the Rules to ensure more equitable distribution of market income
@@EMarkets don't exist in a vacuum: the way they are structured affects how they function,
@@@efficiency, and distribution
@@EIncreases in rents explains the anomaly of an increase wealth/income ratio accompanied by
@@@a decrease in the ratio of productive capital to income

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.28nFighting Inequality
@
@
• These theories explain the marked disparity between the growth in labor productivity and real
@wages
@@EWedge can't be explained by standard theories\skilled bias technical change or differential
@@@savings rates

• Reduced inequality would improve economic performance, in the short term, and in the long term

See Stiglitz, J. E., N. Abernathy, A. Hersh, S. Holmberg, and M. Konczal (2015).
Rewriting the Rules of the American Economy, New York: W.W. Norton, 2015.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.29nIII. Structural Reforms
@
@
Some basic principles

• In the absence of adequate demand, supply side reforms will increase unemployment, not
@promote growth
@@EMoving people from low productivity sector to zero productivity unemployment
@@ESupply does not create its own demand
@@EIndeed, supply side reforms can weaken demand and lead to lower GDP
@@EBut well designed demand policies can increase supply/productivity, can increase GDP today
@@@and potential growth rates

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.30nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
Often working in conjunction with "demand"

• Increased investment in technology

• Especially important as one creating an innovation economy and a learning society

• Increased investment in people\creating a healthier and more productive labor force

• Industrial policies which help restructure the economy, moving from old sectors to new
@@EMarkets don't make these transformation well on their own

• Competition policies\preventing the agglomeration of economic power
@@EMonopolies restrict output

• Financial market reform
@@ENot just prevent financial sector from imposing harms
@@EEncouraging it to do what it is supposed to do, intermediate, private finance, especially
@@@for small and medium sized enterprises
@@EEncouraging equity rather than debt

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.31nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
• Measures to facilitate participation in labor force
@@EGood public transportation systems
@@EParental and sick leave
@@EChild care

• Inclusion of groups that have been discriminated against and marginalized
@@EWomen
@@EMinorities
@@Eimmigrants

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.32nSupply side measures that would work
@
@
• There are many ineffective (or counterproductive) supply side measures
@@ELowering corporate income tax
@@@@EBut lowering taxes on corporations that invest and create jobs and increasing it on
@@@@@corporations that don't would incentivize investment and job creation
@@EFinancial market deregulation
@@@@ELeads to less investment, more speculation, instability
@@ETrade measures have not had hoped for supply side benefits
@@@@EBenefits always overestimated
@@@@@@ECurrent estimates of TPP for US around zero
@@@@EGrowing consensus TPP is a bad trade agreement, will not be ratified by US Congress
@@@@@@EInvestment provisions especially objectionable\introduce new source of
@@@@@@@discrimination, limits ability to regulate economy in ways that would lead
@@@@@@@to stronger growth, protect environment, etc.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.33nOther counterproductive supply side measures
@
@
• Backward looking supply side reforms also will not work
@@EReducing excess housing capacity in the US (empty homes in Nevada desert) would not have
@@@helped US recovery
@@EDestroying excess chip capacity in Korean crisis (1998) would have impeded its recovery
@@@@EIgnored option value
@@EArguments often made by those wishing a reduction in competition
@@@@E"national champions" = oligopolies

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.34nFailure of Supply side measures
@
@
• Supply side measures in US (and other countries) in early 1980s failed
@@EDidn't live up to promise of increasing tax revenues\actually fell
@@EDidn't live up to promise of increasing growth\actually fell
@@@@ESavings rate fell
@@@@@@ESame effect seen in more recent tax cuts in beginning of 2000s
@@@@ELabor force participation fell
@@EWorries about impact on inequality more than justified\have reached new heights

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.35nIV. Financial sector and financial turmoil
@
@
• Some of turmoil is reflection of lack of transparency in financial markets

• Some of turmoil is reflection of short-sighted nature of financial markets\they have always
@been very fickle

• Some of turmoil is reflection of deep uncertainty about the direction of the global economy

• Some of turmoil related to failure of countries to coordinate monetary policy, resulting
@uncertainty in exchange rates, large movements in destabilizing capital flows
@@EFacilitated by capital and financial market liberalization

• Much of the turmoil reflects failure to address fundamental problems in the financial sector

• Problem is that the turmoil is likely to have consequences for the real sector

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.36nReforming the financial sector
@
@
• More than preventing the sector from imposing harm
@@EThrough excessive risk taking
@@EMarket manipulation, predatory lending, etc.
@@EAbuse of market power

• Ensuring that it plays societal role at low transactions costs
@@Eproviding SME and housing finance
@@Emanaging retirement accounts and running the payments system at low transactions cost

So far, we have failed in both tasks

There is the need for broader and deeper reforms and broadening public instruments for providing
• Student loans
• Public option in mortgages
• Public option in retirement accounts

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.37nV. Global Reforms
@
@
• Need new global reserve system
@@ECurrent system is a historical anachronism
@@ELeads to biases towards surpluses
@@EWeaknesses in reserve currency countries
@@EA global reserve system, as suggested by Keynes and recent UN Commission would lead to
@@@greater global stability

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.38nGlobal reforms
@
@
• Need global coordination to reduce global imbalances
@@EChina's surpluses are in process of being reduced
@@EBut those in the Eurozone are increasing
@@@@EWill need deep reforms in Eurozone

• Need global macro]economic (monetary and fiscal) coordination
@@EWas hope that this would happen after Global Financial Crisis
@@EHasn't materialized\even greater asynchronous movements

• Need better ways of recycling surpluses
@@ENew development banks move in the right direction
@@EBut there is a need for governance reforms and recapitalization of Multilateral development
@@@banks

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.39nFinance for development
@
@
Could simultaneously recycle surpluses, adding to global demand, and promote development, but
there are three impediments

• Debt markets: no international framework for debt restructuring
@@EImportant initiative at the UN, supported by vast majority of countries
@@EBut US and some European countries arguing against a "rule of law"

• FDI: investment agreements undermine the ability of countries to regulate

• Taxation of multinationals: international tax regime makes raising revenues difficult
@@ERace to the bottom
@@EBEPS agreement at G-20 left key issues unaddressed
@@EDeeper reform of global tax regime needed

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.40nAction on climate change
@
@
• Investments to retrofit the economy for climate change would provide needed stimulus to global
@economy

• Environment and economic growth are complementary
@@EEspecially if we measure growth correctly

• Providing a price on carbon would provide incentives for investment

• Paris meeting was important in creating momentum, so business community realizes that in one
@form or another there will eventually be a price for carbon
@@EKey investments (infrastructure, housing, buildings, power plants) are long term

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.41nVI. Reforms in the global decision making process
@
@
• Global economic integration has outpaced than of global political integration

• Whenever there are spillovers, externalities need for collective action

• But we have no good framework for doing so at the global level

• Global economic policy too often reflects power and special interests
@@ENot necessarily focusing on areas where global cooperation and harmonization are necessary
@@@@EExcessive harmonization of IPR rules
@@@@EHarmonization on rules that reflect special interests, with insufficient democratic
@@@@@accountability\different from what might emerge from a more global democratic process
@@@@EEspecial concern that new trade agreements will impair ability of governments to
@@@@@perform essential regulatory functions in a democratic way
@@EFocus is on harmonizing down, to lowest common denominator

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.42nReforms in global decision making process
@
@
• How to increase representativeness
@@EUnder-representation of small and poor countries
@@EImportant, even if they have little weight in global economy

• How to increase legitimacy
@@EUN is the international body with global legitimacy
@@EIMF has similarly more legitimacy within its remit

• Danger of "club" getting together to make decisions for all
@@EUndermines credibility of other organizations

• Alternative: Global Economic Coordinating Council
@@EOperating under the UN, IMF

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.43nRethinking global decision making
@
@
• Variable geometry
@@ERecognizing that it will be difficult to get close to unanimity on many issues

• "Coalition of willing"\for instance on climate change
@@EWith cross-border taxes to induce others to cooperate

• May not be able to get all to agree to new global reserve system
@@EAgain coalition of willing\advantages will induce others eventually to join

• Thinking carefully about where externalities are most important
@@EAbsence of collective risk bearing induces high level of savings, reduces global aggregate
@@@demand
@@EGlobal rules favoring capital increase inequality, with adverse effects on global aggregate
@@@demand
@@EGlobal instability creates inequality, leads to high savings, both of which contribute to
@@@deficiency in global aggregate demand

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.44nVII. The World Today in Perspective
@
@
• Many of the advanced countries began an experiment a third of a century ago\lowering taxes,
@deregulation

• There was a need to adjust economic framework to changing economic circumstances

• Consequence has been slower growth and increasing inequality

• Full effects are just now being felt\but they have been on their way

• If current course continues things will get worse
@@EWith untold political consequences\some of which we are beginning to see

• This experiment can and should now be declared a major failure

• There is a need for a new course
@@EMinor changes, tweaking of current arrangements will not do

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.45nMany pieces to this failed experiment
@
@
• New approaches to monetary policy
@@EFocus on inflation, rather than balanced perspective\growth, employment and stability

• New approaches to fiscal policy
@@EIn Europe, stringent constraints on deficits

• New emphasis on privatization
@@EExtending even to social security in some countries

These too have not brought promised benefits

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.46nExperiment in new global architecture is also a failure
@
@
• Forty years ago would began experiment with unfettered capital flows
@@EWas supposed to bring a new era of stability

• Markets would do a better job than governments

• Instead it ushered in new era of global instability
@@EEspecially associated with short term capital flows

• Now even the IMF says that there should be capital controls (capital account management)

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.47nThere is a way forward
@
@
• Restoring the balance between the government and the market

• Recognizing the importance of the "third sector" and new institutional arrangements

• Ending austerity

• Global efforts to address global needs, global public goods, global externalities
@@EBeyond climate change to include a global science foundation
@@EGlobal efforts to increase productivity\instead of a race to bottom

• Commitment to measures to increase living standards for all

• Global reassessment of how we measure progress
@@EWhat we measure affects what we do
@@EMain message of the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social
@@@Progress
@@EWork continuing at the OECD

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
mp.48nThe World Economy: The Way Forward
@
@
• The New Mediocre, the Great Malaise, Secular Stagnation are not inevitable
@@EThey are the result of failed policies

• In an increasingly integrated world, the best way forward would entail global cooperation in
restoring balance and increasing aggregate demand
@@ECombined with cooperation, for instance, in the provision of global public goods
@@@\research, global warming
@@EAchieving that cooperation has proven difficult
@@EJapanfs leadership in G-7 may be part of way forward

• But even lacking that cooperation, there is much that each country can do to strengthen demand
@and improve productivity within its own borders
@@EWith significant spill-overs to others

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/318.html

[EIEmgj203] XeBObcoiǂɂ{j 1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zti񑊊@jFGkN
XeBObcoiǂɂ{j 1񍑍ۋZoϕ͉zti񑊊@j
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/317.html
e G̎ 2016 N 3 21 05:00:06
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/230.html
[EIEmgj203] AJ̐׊w̔TPP - XeBObc̓{ւ̃AhoCXî͂Fblogj
AJ̐׊w̔TPP - XeBObc̓{ւ̃AhoCX
http://www.shinohara21.com/blog/archives/2016/03/tpp52tpp_2016320.html
̂͂Fblog@2016N0320
@
@
@m[xoϊw܂܁i2001NjXeBObcERrAwB
@傽ړÍAVJSwi1965Nj̉tẢFO勳̈̋LOuAł̑ԂF򂳂񂪋\𖱂߂ĂuTPPj~cvł̕׋̍utŁAɎ𖱂߂uTPPTdɍlv邱ƂɂȂĂBƂ낪A{r荞݁A16Ɏ񑊊@ŊJۋZoϕ͉ŁAŗ10̈グɔΈӌqׁA傫񓹂ꂽB
@
@
F򋳎R֐SFAAa
@
@̗A܂֏g̉c\ȉ}TPPgƂۃe[u3ɕA30l1ԍuĂBOXATPP͓{̂߂ɂAĴ߂ɂȂȂƌAVɂe肵Ă邱Ƃ͏mĂAb𒼐ڕ̂͏߂ĂłBȘbƂÅܒ~̂eƂAF򂳂̒qȂł͂ƍ_B
@XeBObćAF򋳎GDP𑝂₷ƂɊ֐Š݂oϊw҂Ƃ͈ႢAAAa3dĂƉ񂾁B͉F򋳎̖{͐ǂł邪AXeBObct̉lς̂܂܎󂯌pł邱Ƃ悭킩B
@ȉÅTvЉB
@
@
łYfł̓
@
@{͌oϐႢƂ̔ᔻ邪A̎؂łAقǂ̐Sz͖pBAJ͐̕[BႦ΁A{͕ώBɑ΂wł͂ȂAJ̔lj̎}ɉĂBȂȂ΁A40NOႭAꂵȂĂ邩炾B
@ig債ĂB̓_́A{ɂY݂Biɂ͏łȂǂɁAƎvN鐭ꂽ悢B
@ŐȂAYfł͐{̍ɂv邵AoςBł͎𑝂₵Aizjɖ𗧂B
@ɕہiinclusionj⍷ʂȂƂKvBႦ΁ACȍ҂ɓĂ炤̂悢B
@
@
TPP͑ЊƂ̃rCXg
@
@TPPɂĂ̎咣łBu̔߂TPPᔻɏ[ĂB
@Io}哝̂́A21I̐Ẽ[͒ɏAAJƌAЊƂ̃rCXgĂ邾̂ƂŁAƂɓs悭ĂB
@mIỸ[łBɖ̖肪傫AWFlbNɂłȂ悤ɂȂĂB傫ȐЂ̗v悤ɂȂĂAAJľNȂ邱ƂɂȂB̕łƂ͂قƂǂȂB
@
@
ISDS͊Q炯AAJc͔yȂ
@
@ɓ͍D܂ȂB
@1980N܂ł́ACO2̔roȂǖɂȂȂB͈ႤBnɑ͂ȂȂB󂵂炨܂łBAK͕KvAJi_{̋Kɂ葹QƃAJ̊ƂISDSőiāAJi_{sĂB^oR̋KiĂBISDS͐Vʂ炵AlԂ̌NQ錜OB
@AJɂƂTPP̌ʂ̓[łAAJ̋cŔyȂ낤B]āA{yׂł͂ȂAƂ܂Ō؂B
@TPP͂ɂQ炯łA^łȂB
@O{t̂ŁA܂ŉF򋳎̍u𕷂Ă悤ƌ񂾁BSłB
@
@
{ɂ̓sbƂ䏊w҂炸A}XR~TPPɂȂтĂ΂聄
@
@AJ̊w҂͓{̊w҂肸Ɨ̂悤BɛZт𔄂邱ƂȂǂA_Ȃ̂̓_ƌ؂ĂBAJ̊eւ̓eK̃C^r[LŔTPPł邱ƁAϋɌoϘ_҂Ǝ኱͒mĂAɘb𕷂Ƃ͂ۂłBĂӂƎv̂́Am[xoϊw܂Ƃ͌Ȃ܂łA{̎vRc̈ψ𖱂߂{݂̕oϊw҂̒ɁÂ悤Ȋw҂ȂƂɁAꖕ̎₵łB
@
@
ȂTPPɊ֐SȂ{̃}XR~
@
@́AłłƖ@lłƕԓ{̎OŎ̈ɂAŗ̏グɂȑ呛̂ł͂ȂƎvĂBƏՌ傫̂TPPłB肵@ɂTPPɐGꂽAcOȂ瓌VƓ{_ƐV񂶂ŁǍܑ历͑SĂȂB܂ł͑Se炩ɂȂĂȂdȂƎvĂAȂƂ𕶂͖炩ɂĂBAJł͑哝̑Ȋ_ƂȂĂ̂ɁA{TPP͔ŷR̂悤ȈŁAǂグ悤ƂȂB}L҉ł̂ƂɑSGĂȂB
@
@
}a}TPPɔ΂ĂAJ
@
@AJł́AȂ̂͊w҂łȂAłB
@a}̏dgvƊn߂āAwj~ɏoA͎̐~܂ȂBgv́AXeBObcƓAfՋ͌ٗpDAĂƔᔻAa}̎x҂̑TPPɔ΂n߂ĂBHJ҂̑~VKBgv叟BgvlC̈ɖfՂŒA{ɕĂATPPȂǌ΂AAJ̑ȍɂƎ咣Ă邱Ƃ悤B
@}łT_[XANgNAFTAɎ^ATPP΂SOAƔᔻ~VKBŏĂBĎRfՂxĂƎvꂽa}AX΂̖}ATPPɋNO˂n߁AIΗvƂȂB
@
@
}a}Ĕ΂TPP͔y݂̌Ȃ
@
@āA⋤a}x҂̕iԂ񔒐ljA}x҂莩RfՂɔےIɂȂĂBig債AAJlŜn悤ɂȂłBNtAIo}YiKV[jɂƂTPPɑ΂A}Ĕ΂Aa}̎^ɂATPP̏ɂ܂őBIo}哝̂́Amɏd_ڂoXȌŁATPP𒆍Ƌł̒ʏO̐헪̗vɂĂBƂ낪A◊݂̋a}ۂBXeBObc\ƂA2016Nɂ͂ƂĂyȂ낤B
@
@
{̈I݂łӂ
@
@A䂪{́A\ZĂ̎Qc@ʉ߂ڑOƂȂA{^}TPPʈψ̐ݒu}łB{TPP[hĂƂiDƂ̂Ԃ̗R̂悤AQc@IOɖȂƂς܂Ă܂Ƃ__ԌB
@́AȈyȂ悤Ɋ撣łB
@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
֘ANieҁj
[eXg31] eXg
}EXeBObcHu 2016N317
@@
@

FOƃO[oȐim08:48/42:53n
@
FO搶̂тȂ炱̂悤ȉɎQĂ炦ĂꂵB1965NVJSwŁASĂ̍ō̊wƂƂɉF搶̂ƂŐoϊww񂾁B͐搶̗͋lɂ܂SA搶ƈꐶJŌ΂ꂽB搶͂̐̍ō̐oϊw҂̈lB搶̐̉ɂ͐[lςBɎЉAɊAOɕaB

ɂď悤ɂȂƂAƂ΃CN푈ɔ΂wEsKɂAJ̐푈oρxm1nƂA悭搶̂ƂvBȂ킿AGDP̍ő剻͎Љ̖ړIł͂ȂBGDPɊ^邪ACN푈ɓꂽŎЉ͖LɂȂĂȂBCNŎEꂽlɂƂĂ͂Ȃ̂ƂB

c𖱂߂uoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvm2nł́AGDPł͑Ȃ̎ɂB̂Ƃ͓{œɏdvB{oϐĂȂƂAJ͐lቺĂƂAvɂƂÂᔻBAԂJ҂ł݂ƁA{̐Y͍ōȂ̂B

O[oȐiƂłׂߔN̓́AF搶Ɠ悤ɎЉAAaɌĂB̓čł͂܂łɂȂ܂ĂB哝̗\Ił́A}̌₪2lƂsւ̑΍ƂăO[oŐiIȐBŁAčЉ͂܂łɂȂfĂBAYANیȂǂɂĊi܂܂LĂB

a}Ɍ{́A镔ł𔽉fĂB{͕čϗ]BFیxmĂBƂANɂ錠ۏႳĂȂi͕č炢BߔNł͑woĂȂlj̕ϗ]傫ቺAwoĂȂj̎NXቺĂBjŜ̒ʎ40NOႭȂB݂̎Œ60NOႢB܂Ꮚ҂̒60Nԏ㏸ĂȂB̎Љł͍҂N܂܂LɂȂĂ̂ɁA|I̐lX͂łȂBꂪ̓{NĂBAcOȂ炻̓{͌ݓIȕɌĂȂB}̑ł́AsiIȕɌĂB

O[oȐi̐m17:05/42:53n

͂̐iIȐۑɂĂ񂽂ɏqׂB̗͓̐}ɂƂꂸA̐󂯓邷ׂĂ̌҂xB

̌́ASٗpłBSٗpƂ͉BƂFRB̕cuƗ4.9%ł芮SٗpƂ݂ȂvƂBv悭݂΁Aۂ̎Ɨ͂̔{łBƂΏT1ԂȂĂv͌ٗpƂ݂ȂĂB4NԋEĎdȂΎƂƂ݂͂ȂȂȂB̂悤Ɏۂ̎Ɨ4.9%͂邩ɍ̂ŁA㏸Ȃ̂B

{ɂĂƂB3.7%ƂƗ͕čႢA͂オĂȂBقƂ̊SٗpB܂ł͌iC̎h􂪕KvłBCťÔȂׂAݓ{SzȂ΂ȂȂ̂̓ft̕B2%̃Ct^[QbgBĂȂB

̂悤ɁAč{ϋɓIȕKvƂĂBZł͂ł邾̂ƂBĎ͍ɏd_uȂ΂ȂȂB

ύt\Z搔Ƃ΂{BłĂ̕{xo𑝂₹ΌiChƂ̂BېłƐ{xȏIK؂ł΁A{xo͌iC̊gɏ搔ʂ炷B

iChېł̗ƂāAYfłB͓_Yf̔roېőΏۂƂ邱ƂŎƎ҂ɐYH̉ǂ𑣂A҂ɂ͒fMzR̎Ԃ̍w𑣂Błɓ{͕̌čƍA܂܂̗]nB̂悤ɁAYfł͐ŎƌiC΍̗ɌʂB

ł́A̐Ă邠ɂg悤ɂނ̂ŁAŎグƂƂɎYikBł́Aoςsɂ邾Ŏۂ̐ɂ͊^ȂZIȓ@}AȉkƐŎ炷BŒ莑YŁAƂɕsY擾ł́AłĂynƂ킯ł͂Ȃ̂ŌłKvȂB͂ނȉkƌoϐȂBȏオASٗpɌ̐ۑłB

ɁAЉIۂƍʂ̉BЉI҂⏗ɂ鍷ʂǂ̎Љɂ݂B́AjƓiœdĂAϒႢBčł͓ۏ؂錛@̋c_Aa}ۂB玙ExƁAtbNX^CȂǁAقɂЉIۂ𑣐i鐭􂪂B

ȂłdvȂ͍̂΍􂾁B܂ł̌oσVXe̖͂𖳎ĂB65΂ɂȂl̓S~̎RɓŎłȂƂƂ΂肾BZɘaԂɈBVɔĔ́AȂǂ납}CiXɂȂ낤ƂĂBł͈SV͖]߂ȂBlXƒ悤ɂׂBl͍ɂȂĂȂYIłAČP̋@_ȘJЂƂKvłB

Ƃ΍ĕzAېŁAړ]ɖڂꂪłA͏dvłBA͍ŋ߂̖{wXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv̋ȏxm3nłׂ̂ƂグBȂ킿Aoύ\̎Ă鍑łsꏊm4n̊ȉԂ͂܂قȂƂƂłBčł1970Nȍ~J͂̐Y{ɂ炸A؂ĂBĂ͐YオΒ㏸A݂͂łȂB́A[Kȗsoς̃[ςꂽʂłBJ҂̌͂߁AٗpsȂ̂ɂAR[|[gEKoiX┽gXg@̎sȂǌoς̘ggݑŜɂ郋[ςĂB

fՋ̖m26:18/42:53n

߂ɁAFO搶Ǝ[ĂfՋɂĐGꂽB̖fՋ߂āAčł͑̋c_ĂB́AĂ̍ő哝̂Ătm5nAčƂ̎RfՋɏׂǂӌ𕷂ꂽƂB́A͎RfՂł͂ȂAƎwEBRfՂȂ3y[Włނ̂ɁATPP6000y[WB͊ǗfՂłāAč͂߂ƂƂ̗v炻ƂĂBIo}哝̂́A̋́A21I̖fՃ[̂uvƂƂ肾ƂBAłuvƂ́ÂƂł͂ȂB̂͊Ƃ̃r[XgB̋߂ĂfՋƂ́AꂪAIȎ葱ɂĐA\ĂdvȖ肪TPPQ̋cŋc_悤Ȃ̂B

قǂ̈tɘbɖ߂ƁA͔ނɂ˂BuȂq|NeX̐ɏ̂łˁBvׂ͂Ă̈tȂ΂ȂȂŁAuQ^Ȃvł͂܂m6nBނułvƓ̂Ŏ͂BuȂ̖͂fՋɃTCł܂BȂȂq|NeX̐ɔwƂɂȂ邾낤łBȂ̐EƓIȐӔCłlX̌Nɂ܂ŊQԂ̂łBv

̖fՋ3琬B1̖fՂɂ񂵂Ă͂ƂĂZB́A֐ŏǂłɂȂ菜Ă邩炾BêYƂ͔rIɂ͏ȂB

2͈iANZXɂāB͒mƏ̂Ă邪îƂBł̓WFlbNiւ̃ANZXƂȂB܂łǂ̍łAȐĉƃWFlbNiƂ̃oXc_ĂBčł25NOɋc_AnbEbNX}@łB͂܂ɂЊŁAWFlbNiւ̃ANZXs\Ał̔i87%WFlbNŐ߂悤ɂȂB̏Ȃ΁AłEꍂzȕč̈iƍȂB

Ђ́AJꂽc_̏ł͂̃oXςȂƂ킩Ă̂ŁAe閧ɂĂfՋŃWFlbNi肵Â炭悤ƂBĂ̖͂]ނ͉̂łɓ̂ŁAvɍیȂBׂ͂Ă̕یȒƉāu{CŌȂƂȂvƓĂAĂ͎ۂ̂Ałč̐ĉ͗v̂قƂǂʂB̖fՋ͂܂܂Ȃi̒liグăWFlbNiւ̃ANZX炷ƂɂȂBIo}哝̂̎vȌт̓Io}PAłAč̈ÃANZXg債BƂ낪A̖fՋł͂̌тŌ@ƂĂBȂȂƂ̂Aɂ͂ς藝łȂB

ҋƂ΂́BK̓PpA~Bꂪč̌oϒc̃rWlXEEhe[ű߂ĂBoϊE㉟Ă̂͂̂߂B̏Ӑ}ʂƂĂ炷̂́A󋵂̕ωɑΉVȋK܂܂ɂȂƂƂBƂ΂͒ngɂ40NOɂ͉m炸A1980NɂȂĂ͂߂ĕꂽBɎgƂ΁A_Yfroʂ炷߂̋K݂Ȃ΂ȂȂBƂ낪TPP̂Ƃł́A鍑Ő݂ḰAɂĕsvނƂi\BJi_{9̏dvȑiׂɕȂ͊KɊ֌WĂB̊ԂAZXgsK؂ƑiƂɕĂ܂m7nB̊Ƃ̓Ji_̍ٔɑi邱Ƃł̂AԂِ̒lɂ钇وψI񂾁Bِl3lŁA1l͊ƂwA1l͐{A1l͗҂̍ӂɂĎwBƂ낪قɂ邱̖@Ƃ͂߂ĊƂ̑ɂĂm8nBŃJi_͂قǑ̑iׂɕĂ̂B

l̏Ɋ֘ÂŁA݌WłƂLȑiׂƂẮA^oR̃pbP[WɌNQ̋LڂÂKɂătBbvEXЂEOAC{iٔB̋K͂̍mɂȂĂlX^oR𔃂ȂȂƂʂ̂ŁAtBbvEXЂ̗vቺBŃtBbvEXЂ͑̕⏞߂B܂ł͐lXEĂ{ÎmMĂ݂B̌グ̂Ȃ甅ĂȂ΂ȂȂƂĂB

̏dvȏNjm9nA͏̓یmiׁnɂ̂ڂ邪A͂BúmVȁnKƂΗHւ̕ː̍h悤Ȃ̂ƂĂA͂i邱Ƃł悤ɏBvꂪɂ񂷂鋦̓eB

́AmTPPn21I̋łAmNAFTÁnׂ̂ĂɑΏƎ咣ĂBȂ̖@Ƃ̈ӌɂ΁A܂ĂȂBlX̓{肪傫^oR͎菜ꂽA_Yf̔roAuH̕ːvAȊÔׂĂ͂̂܂܎cĂBƂ΃AXxXg̊댯炩ɂȂƂɃAXxXgKƂBs@ł̓AXxXgɂ錒NQɂĂꂪAXxXg̐Ǝ҂i邱ƂłBƂ낪VTPP̋K̂Ƃł́AƎ҂͂EɂƂRłꂩx󂯂̂B͂ƂĂeFłȂB̂悤ȃ[AFO搶̎x{Ƃ͑eȂŔ閧ɏAςĂBig債AЉIƊی̊Ղ@ƂĂB̏ƂĂTPPɎ^łȂB

EÚAԂِ̒lψɂْ萧x̂鋦ɂ͏ȂƂ𖾊mɂBׂ̂咣ĂB{my悤ƂĂn̂20I̋肾BEU낤ƂĂ̂21I̋肾BߑЉ̕Kv𖞂ȂƂ炩ɂȂĂ鋦AȂ͂ǂė~̂B

ȏAO[oȐǐĂƎvȎg݂ɂĎQlɂĂB

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

m1nThe Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social ProgressiWikipediaj
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commission_on_the_Measurement_of_Economic_Performance_and_Social_Progress

m2nThe Three Trillion Dollar WariWikipediaj
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Trillion_Dollar_War

m3nRewriting the Rules of the American EconomyiRoosevelt Institutej
http://rooseveltinstitute.org/rewriting-rules-report/

m4nmarket income: ⋋^Ȃǂ̌ٗpҕVƎcƎҏAYъƔNdȂǂ܂łAłЉۏTȌӖB
uJILJ􃌃|[gVol.3@{̏iǂ݂邩viJ􌤋EC@\j
http://www.jil.go.jp/institute/rodo/documents/report3.pdf

m5nEOAC哝̃^oEoXPXiTabare VazquezjB
"La guerra del opio del siglo XXI"m21ĨAw푈niRed De Militantes De Izquierdaj
http://reddemilitantesdeizquierda.org/2015/12/27/la-guerra-global-del-opio-del-siglo-xxi-tpp-ttip-tisa-alianza-del-pacifico-tlc-mercosur-union-europea/

m6nFirst, Do No Harm: ɂĂ̓XeBObcɌF悤B
uuFirst, Do No Harmvq|NeX̐ƂĎgׂł͂ȂviEARL̈wm[gj
http://drmagician.exblog.jp/22144349/

m7n"Clayton/Bilcon v. Government of Canada"iGlobal Affairs Canadaj
"NAFTA ruling in Nova Scotia quarry case sparks fears for future settlements"iThe Globe and Mailj

m8nISDSِ̒x̖_iR̂߂̓j
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/575.html

m9nBarry Appleton, Canadian lawyer for Ethyl Corp. NAFTȀ̋Nɂǂ͕sB
hElizabeth May's submission on the Environmental Assessment for the Canada-China Foreign Investment Protection and Promotion Agreement hiElizabeth Mayj

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҃fBNe[V

m08:48/42:53n

It's a real pleasure to be here and participate in this session, in part commemorating the life of
Hirofumi Uzawa, who is my teacher. I studied under him in 1965 at the University of Chicago, where
he had brought the best students from all over the United States to discuss economic theory,
mathematic economics. He had a very powerful personality and in just a very short time we all became his disciples. We all maintained a lifelong connection with Professor Uzawa. There were three
themes that distinguished Professor Uzawa. He was a mathematical economist. He was one of the best
mathematical economist of his generation. But underlying the mathematics were very deeply held
values. Those values are values I think that he maintained he lived his life by. One of them was
Social Justice. A concern about inequality, concern about poor, concern about the way our society
functions discriminates. The second was the Environment. He was vey committed to the environment.
Economists often talk about this in terms of inter-generational equity, fairness across generations. He was deeply concerned not only about fairness within a generation which was the distribution of
income and wealth within a generation , but fairness across generations, social justice at one
moment of time and over time. Finally, he was vey concerned about Peace. Having grown up in part
during World War II, he was very committed to making sure that that kind of occurrence never
happened again.

Often when I write my work about Inequality, about the Environment, or my book "The Three Trillion
Dollar War" which was written to try to persuade America that it should not be engaged in the war
in Iraq and it was a war that was not going to be successful, which's going to cost us a great deal,I thought of Hirofumi Uzawa. One of the points that was just raised echoes one of those that I made
in ... work, which is maximizing GDP is not what the society is about. The spending on war adds to
GDP. But nobody thinks our society is better off as result of the money that was wasted in Iraq,
especially the people who got killed didn't think it was a good way of spending money.

I chaired an international commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress. Main theme of that commission was that GDP doesn't measure what is important and we have to focus
our attention not on GDP but on the quality of life. That's particularly important here in Japan
because the statistics often mislead people to criticizing Japan for saying it's not growing very
well but Japan has a declining labor force. In terms of output per hour, output per worker, is
actually among the best performance of the best advanced countries. That doesn't mean you can't do
better, but the single-minded focus on growth, I believe, is very much misplaced.
@@@@
In recent years there has developed what might be called a Global Progressive Movement, which is
focused on precisely these issues that were the mainstay of Professor Uzawa, on Social Justice and
Environment and Peace. Right now is a very interesting moment in terms of the Global Progressive
Movement. Because in the United States, for instance, on one side, I don't think the Global
Progressive Movement has ever been stronger. Both of the Democratic candidates have espoused
policies that are broadly consistent with ... many of the pillars of the Progressive Movement. They
talked about Inequality is being America's most important problem and what we can do about it. They
talked about the Environment and how we can protect it. On the other hand, never has ... been more
divided society. Income, wealth, health, every metric shows a society that is moving further and further apart. Part of the reason that you see on the Republican side, such anger on certain part, is
because for a large fraction of Americans life has not been very good.

Japan has a higher life expectancy than the United States. Japan has recognized the right of access
to health for everybody. The United States is one of the, I think the only advanced country that
does not recognize that as a basic right. The result of that is that in the United States there are
large disparities in access to health. Recent data show that among white males who are not college
graduates, life expectancy is declining very strongly. American males, for instance, who have not
graduated from college have seen their income decline year after year. The median income for men as
a whole, half above and half below, is now lower than it was 40 years ago. Real wages today in the
United States at the bottom are lower than it were in January 1955, 60 years ago. Those at the
bottom have not seen a pay raise in 60 years. This is not a society which is getting better every
year. This is a society in which the top are doing better every year, but the vast majority are not. That of course has spurred the kind of anger that you see. But unfortunately it's not being
channeled in a constructive way. On the other side, in the Democratic side, the discontent is being
channeled in a progressive way, in a way that's trying to see what we can do about those problems.

m17:05/42:53n

What I want to do this morning is very briefly talk about that Progressive agenda. Let me say that
we were.., The Progressive Movement has been very careful to say, "It's not partisan." It supports
anybody, any candidate that is going to support these ideas and talk to anybody who supports these
ideas.

Among the first principles is Full Employment. But what is Full Employment mean? There are some
people in the United States i.e. vice chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve who says, "Well, we are
4.9% unemployment and that means we are full employment." But of course those statistics don't
reflect the lives of those who don't have a job. If you are one of those 4.9% you don't feel fully
employed. If you look underneath the statistics you realize the true unemployment rate in the
United States is twice that number. The true unemployment rate reflects the fact that many Americans are called employed if they work just one hour a week. Of course that's not a meaningful employment. You can't get an income to survive. If you've looked for job for four years and you still can't get a job, you are not called unemployed. But you are not employed. When we look at the statistics what we realize is that the true unemployment is much larger. That is why even with 4.9% unemployment
wages are stagnating. If there were really no unemployment, wages would be bid up.

The same thing is true in Japan, except you are in a better shape. You have unemployment of ...
3.7%? But wages are not doing very well. Until you get truly full employment where wage pressures
are going up, you should try to continue to stimulate the economy. The only reason to stop
stimulating the economy is a worry about inflation. The worry now in Japan is about deflation. It's
difficult you getting up to a 2% target.

So, both in the United States and in Japan, there is a need for more aggressive measures. Monetary
policy has done as much as it can. Therefore the burden has to shift fiscal policy.

Here, there is a fundamental principle in economics which is called the Balance Budget Multiplier.
If you increase taxes and increase spending in tandem, it stimulates the economy. If you choose
your taxes right and your spending right, it increases the economy by a multiple of what the
spending.

For instance, taxes that stimulates the economy, a carbon tax. A carbon tax induces firms to invest
to retrofit their production processes for the higher charges of emissions, induces homes to invest
to insulate, it induces people to relocate to buy new cars that are more fuel efficient. Japan is
already much more efficient than in the United States, but there's still a long way to go. So a
carbon tax is a tax that both raises revenue and stimulates the economy.

There are other taxes like an inheritance tax. Inheritance taxes can often induce people to spend
money before they die, increase revenue and improve equality. Financial transaction tax discourages
the kind of short-term speculation that destabilizes the economy and produces no real growth,
reduces inequality and raises revenue. Taxes on property, particularly capital gains taxes on
property. Lower taxes on land do not result in more land, so have no negative incentive effects but
raise revenue, increase equality and promote growth. That's the first agenda which is promoting
full employment.

The second is inclusion and discrimination. All societies engage in discrimination to some extent.
There's discrimination against minorities, discrimination against women. Women receive on average a
fraction of the wages the men doing comparable work, comparable qualifications. United States,
we've been discussing constitutional amendment for guaranteeing equal wages, but Republicans have
refused to support this idea. There are other policies that promote inclusion. Child care, family
leave policy, flexible working hours, these are all aspects of inclusion.

There are other aspects of inclusion that are important, one of which was mentioned. Japan has an
aging population. All societies are now having aging population. We have an economic system that
has ignored that challenge. Traditionally, when people get the age of 65 you throw them in the
garbage heap and say, "try to survive." With QE, things have become even worse because many of
those elderly who acted safe and bought government bonds, those bonds yield zero interest rates.
They are about to yield negative interest rates. That's not a way to have a comfortable retirement.
You can't live on zero interest rates. One has to think about how we can include these people
longer in the labor force. The reason, they are living longer? But they don't want to retire. We
force them to retire. They are still productive. They would be productive particularly if we
retrain them and we made work more flexible. So greater flexibility in the work place recognizing
imperative inclusion is another part of the inclusion agenda.

When we talk about Equality, often people focus on redistribution, on taxes and transfers, and
those are important. But in my most recent book called "Rewriting the Rules," what we focused on
is something different. What we realize is that countries with similar economic structures wind up
with very different market income inequality. So ...... the demand and supply operate the same on
both sides of Atlantic, both sides of Pacific, in countries that is similar stages of development,
but market income is markedly different. For instance, one of the astounding things in the United
States is that since 1970s productivity of American labor force is roughly doubled. Wages,
compensation has stagnated. It used to be the productivity and wages move together. Now they don't.
This result of what happened beginning in the Reagan era where there was a rewriting of the rules
of the market economy, rewriting the rules in ways that weaken the bargaining power of workers,
increase their insecurity and changed the economic framework in a whole ...... ways, like changes
in corporate governance, changes in enforcement of antitrust laws and so forth.
@@@@
m26:18/42:53n

I want to conclude my brief remarks this morning by talking about one area that I understand that
Hirofumi Uzawa was very involved in and I've been involved in a great deal. That's a trade
agreements. These trade agreements have motivated a lot of the discussion in the United States.
I was once asked by a doctor who was the President of a Latin American country whether he should
sign a free trade agreement with the United States. I first pointed out it was not a free trade
agreement. If it was a free trade agreement, it would be about three pages, "We eliminate our tariffs, you eliminate your tariffs, we eliminate our non-tariffs, you eliminate yours, we eliminate our
subsidies, you eliminate yours," about three pages. Do you know how long? The TPP agreement is
6,000 pages. I have not met a single person who has ever read the entire agreement. That's not a
free trade agreement, it's a managed trade agreement. It's a managed trade agreement that ......
manage for the interest of corporate interest, corporate interest mostly in the United States, but
corporate interest in other countries as well. When the United States President Obama said that
this agreement is about who writes the rules of trade in the 21st century, China and the United
States, or he said, "Do we or China write it." The question is which "we". We didn't write it, the
corporate lobbyists wrote it. What we are asking is for a trade agreement that we write, that is
arrived at through a more democratic process, that the key issues are laid out in the open and
discussed in the parliaments of all of the TPP countries.

Well, could go back to this doctor, I asked him, "Did you sign the Hippocratic Oath?" which all
the doctors have to sign. The Hippocratic Oath begins, "Do no harm." He said, "Yes," he signed it.
So I told him, "You can't sign the trade agreement 'cause that would be a violation of the oath
that you have signed. It would actually even harm health and that is your responsibility."

There are three parts of the trade agreement. The first part is about trade. It's very small part
because tariff barrier's already relatively low. There are specially interested industries get
hurt, get helped, but that is a relatively small part.

The second part is about access to medicine. They call it intellectual property, but it's only
the balance between Big Pharma and generics. United States we had that debate 25 years ago. Result
was the Hatch-Waxman Act, which created a balance I thought was not good. Quite the right balance?
It was too weighted for Big Pharma and not enough for access to generic medicines, but even with
that unbalanced agreement, about 87% of all drugs are sold generically. If it were not for the
provision, the price of drugs in the United States, already the highest in the world, would be much
much higher.

The drug companies knew that they could not get that changed in an open debate, so they went in the
secret trade agreement and got that balance unbalanced to make it more difficult to get generic
medicines. That was the key part of this provision. They didn't get everything they wanted so they
are complaining, because they used to win everything. I met with all the health ministers and I
used to say, "You really have to bargain hard," and they did, but still the U.S. Big Pharma got
most of what they wanted. And effect of this agreement almost surely will be to raise the price of
drugs and reduce access to generic medicines. For me, this is a big puzzle because Obama's
Signature Achievement is Obamacare, making access to health care more affordable, greater in the
United States. Yet with this trade agreement, he is undermining his Signature Achievement.

But the worst provision in the TPP is the investment provision. It's not about protecting
investment, let's make that clear, because we are insisting, United States is insisting on the
same agreement with Europe, where they have good laws, even better protection of intellectual
property rights. So it's not about ... systems, it's not about protecting property right, it's not
about discrimination, it's nothing to do with discrimination.

We just called National Treatment. It is about deregulation, stopping regulations, and that
provision is what the Business Roundtable wanted. It is the main reason that some of the business
community is behind it. The intent and the consequence of this part of the agreement is to make it
increasingly difficult to pass new regulations as the circumstances change. We didn't know about
global warming 40 years ago. We just learned about it in the 1980s. As we're going about we have
to pass regulations that will reduce carbon emissions. But under the TPP, if a country passes a
regulation, they may be sued if the profit of the company goes down. Canada has lost nine important
suits, many of them in the area of the environment. They even just lost a suit where the company
claimed that environmental assessment was done improperly. They could have gone to the Canadian
courts, but they chose to go to a biased private arbitration panel. Three people, one appointed by
the business, one by the government, one by two together. But the ... of these lawyers who do these
arbitration cases is such that they are very biased toward the business side. That's why Canada's
lost so many cases.

Most famous case going on right now, in a similar kind of legal provision, is the suit by Phillip
Morris against Uruguay for the regulations simply saying that you have to disclose that cigarettes
are bad for your health. Just a disclosure, but that disclosure work because people stopped buying
as many cigarettes Phillip Morris' profits went down. Philip Morris is suing for the loss of
profits. They believe they have a fundamental right to kill people. You take away that right,
you have to compensate them. The guy who drafted the key provision, this is back in the earlier
investment protection, said, "We've designed it so if you pass a regulation preventing plutonium
in baby cereal, we will sue." That is what is in the investment agreement.
@@@@
Now, they claimed this is a 21st century agreement, they've taken care of all these problems. Our
lawyers have looked at that. Answer is "No." They have not solved. The way you can see that is
they explicitly carved out tobacco, because people are so angry about tobacco. But they left
carbon emissions, they left plutonium in baby cereal in, they left every other topic in. Only
thing they carved out was cigarettes. If we discovered that asbestos was dangerous for your health
and we regulated asbestos, under the current law, we can sue the asbestos manufacturers for what
they've done for our health. Under the new regulations of TPP, the asbestos manufacturers would be
paid by us for not killing us. That should be totally unacceptable. It is an example of how in
secret the rules are being written, rewritten, in ways that contradicts basic principles for which
Hirofumi Uzawa stood. It will increase Inequality and undermines basic principles of Social Justice
and the protection of the Environment. So, for me, this provision by itself is ground for rejecting
TPP.

Let me make one more point clear before ending. Europe has made it very clear that they will not
sign an agreement with the process of adjudication with these private arbitration panels, that they
have insisted on another way of doing it. So if Japan signs this agreement, it will be signing a
20th century agreement, while Europe will be getting a 21st century agreement. Why would you want
an agreement that has been shown to be inadequate to the needs of a modern society?

I hope that these words have given you some thinking about to where the Global Progressive Movement
is going and how it believes the key problems of our society can be addressed today. Thank you.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҃Rg

}ii}jJĂꂽ\̓𕷂Ė󂵂Bɂ͓{̂񂽂ȎĂ邪AƂǂ܂Ė󂳂ĂBi}ɂ͂ȂׂƖ|󂵂u^ČJĂ邱Ƃv]B
@
@
̃XeBObcuȊO̓e

u̎|юQ҂ɂẮAœcKv}ۋǒAЉĂB
uɐ旧āAȏ}\s}Љn{̎g݂ЉB
https://youtu.be/RX334pHGOJM?t=140
ǔ̎^ł́Ac疯}\uSƐEIȎvsɑ΂铊moñoXvɂĎ₵BŃXeBObćAc\yȂłɂāAiC΍Ƃϓ_炷Ƃ܂ېőIłƒfB
https://youtu.be/RX334pHGOJM?t=2245@
̍Ōł́ATPPj~čiO{t=O{c\ψj̃Xs[B
https://youtu.be/RX334pHGOJM?t=2422
@
@
}Hu֘ÄCfeN

XeBObcuuSٗpACN[WAʂȂv i}j
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/139.html
AJ̐׊w̔TPP - XeBObc̓{ւ̃AhoCXî͂Fblogj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/403.html
u̗vɂȂ炸v@j@O@sooŃXeBObc@傪k i{_ƐVj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/138.html
ꂩn܂uVEoρv̋ȏ@WZtEdEXeBObc ԑw𐬒鐭咣
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/151.html
}͂Ȃ݂݂Đ̃X𓦂̂? }ςAoϐςΉ\͂̂ɁcirWlXj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/560.html

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/469.html

[eXg31] eXg
}EXeBObcHu 2016N317
@

@
@
e҂ɂ鏴

FOƃO[oȐim08:48/42:53n
@
FO搶̂тȂ炱̂悤ȉɎQĂ炦ĂꂵB1965NVJSwŁASĂ̍ō̊wƂƂɉF搶̂ƂŐoϊww񂾁B͐搶̗͋lɂ܂SA搶ƈꐶJŌ΂ꂽB搶͂̐̍ō̐oϊw҂̈lB搶̐̉ɂ͐[lςBɎЉAɊAOɕaB

ɂď悤ɂȂƂAƂ΃CN푈ɔ΂wEsKɂAJ̐푈oρxm1nƂA悭搶̂ƂvBȂ킿AGDP̍ő剻͎Љ̖ړIł͂ȂBGDPɊ^邪ACN푈ɓꂽŎЉ͖LɂȂĂȂBCNŎEꂽlɂƂĂ͂Ȃ̂ƂB

c𖱂߂uoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvm2nł́AGDPł͑Ȃ̎ɂB̂Ƃ͓{œɏdvB{oϐĂȂƂAJ͐lቺĂƂAvɂƂÂᔻBAԂJ҂ł݂ƁA{̐Y͍ōȂ̂B

O[oȐiƂłׂߔN̓́AF搶Ɠ悤ɎЉAAaɌĂB̓čł͂܂łɂȂ܂ĂB哝̗\Ił́A}̌₪2lƂsւ̑΍ƂăO[oŐiIȐBŁAčЉ͂܂łɂȂfĂBAYANیȂǂɂĊi܂܂LĂB

a}Ɍ{́A镔ł𔽉fĂB{͕čϗ]BFیxmĂBƂANɂ錠ۏႳĂȂi͕č炢BߔNł͑woĂȂlj̕ϗ]傫ቺAwoĂȂj̎NXቺĂBjŜ̒ʎ40NOႭȂB݂̎Œ60NOႢB܂Ꮚ҂̒60Nԏ㏸ĂȂB̎Љł͍҂N܂܂LɂȂĂ̂ɁA|I̐lX͂łȂBꂪ̓{NĂBAcOȂ炻̓{͌ݓIȕɌĂȂB}̑ł́AsiIȕɌĂB

O[oȐi̐m17:05/42:53n

͂̐iIȐۑɂĂ񂽂ɏqׂB̗͓̐}ɂƂꂸA̐󂯓邷ׂĂ̌҂xB

̌́ASٗpłBSٗpƂ͉BƂFRB̕cuƗ4.9%ł芮SٗpƂ݂ȂvƂBv悭݂΁Aۂ̎Ɨ͂̔{łBƂΏT1ԂȂĂv͌ٗpƂ݂ȂĂB4NԋEĎdȂΎƂƂ݂͂ȂȂȂB̂悤Ɏۂ̎Ɨ4.9%͂邩ɍ̂ŁA㏸Ȃ̂B

{ɂĂƂB3.7%ƂƗ͕čႢA͂オĂȂBقƂ̊SٗpB܂ł͌iC̎h􂪕KvłBCťÔȂׂAݓ{SzȂ΂ȂȂ̂̓ft̕B2%̃Ct^[QbgBĂȂB

̂悤ɁAč{ϋɓIȕKvƂĂBZł͂ł邾̂ƂBĎ͍ɏd_uȂ΂ȂȂB

ύt\Z搔Ƃ΂{BłĂ̕{xo𑝂₹ΌiChƂ̂BېłƐ{xȏIK؂ł΁A{xo͌iC̊gɏ搔ʂ炷B

iChېł̗ƂāAYfłB͓_Yf̔roېőΏۂƂ邱ƂŎƎ҂ɐYH̉ǂ𑣂A҂ɂ͒fMzR̎Ԃ̍w𑣂Błɓ{͕̌čƍA܂܂̗]nB̂悤ɁAYfł͐ŎƌiC΍̗ɌʂB

ł́A̐Ă邠ɂg悤ɂނ̂ŁAŎグƂƂɎYikBł́Aoςsɂ邾Ŏۂ̐ɂ͊^ȂZIȓ@}AȉkƐŎ炷BŒ莑YŁAƂɕsY擾ł́AłĂynƂ킯ł͂Ȃ̂ŌłKvȂB͂ނȉkƌoϐȂBȏオASٗpɌ̐ۑłB

ɁAЉIۂƍʂ̉BЉI҂⏗ɂ鍷ʂǂ̎Љɂ݂B́AjƓiœdĂAϒႢBčł͓ۏ؂錛@̋c_Aa}ۂB玙ExƁAtbNX^CȂǁAقɂЉIۂ𑣐i鐭􂪂B

ȂłdvȂ͍̂΍􂾁B܂ł̌oσVXe̖͂𖳎ĂB65΂ɂȂl̓S~̎RɓŎłȂƂƂ΂肾BZɘaԂɈBVɔĔ́AȂǂ납}CiXɂȂ낤ƂĂBł͈SV͖]߂ȂBlXƒ悤ɂׂBl͍ɂȂĂȂYIłAČP̋@_ȘJЂƂKvłB

Ƃ΍ĕzAېŁAړ]ɖڂꂪłA͏dvłBA͍ŋ߂̖{wXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv̋ȏxm3nłׂ̂ƂグBȂ킿Aoύ\̎Ă鍑łsꏊm4n̊ȉԂ͂܂قȂƂƂłBčł1970Nȍ~J͂̐Y{ɂ炸A؂ĂBĂ͐YオΒ㏸A݂͂łȂB́A[Kȗsoς̃[ςꂽʂłBJ҂̌͂߁AٗpsȂ̂ɂAR[|[gEKoiX┽gXg@̎sȂǌoς̘ggݑŜɂ郋[ςĂB

fՋ̖m26:18/42:53n

߂ɁAFO搶Ǝ[ĂfՋɂĐGꂽB̖fՋ߂āAčł͑̋c_ĂB́AĂ̍ő哝̂Ătm5nAčƂ̎RfՋɏׂǂӌ𕷂ꂽƂB́A͎RfՂł͂ȂAƎwEBRfՂȂ3y[Włނ̂ɁATPP6000y[WB͊ǗfՂłāAč͂߂ƂƂ̗v炻ƂĂBIo}哝̂́A̋́A21I̖fՃ[̂uvƂƂ肾ƂBAłuvƂ́ÂƂł͂ȂB̂͊Ƃ̃r[XgB̋߂ĂfՋƂ́AꂪAIȎ葱ɂĐA\ĂdvȖ肪TPPQ̋cŋc_悤Ȃ̂B

قǂ̈tɘbɖ߂ƁA͔ނɂ˂BuȂq|NeX̐ɏ̂łˁBvׂ͂Ă̈tȂ΂ȂȂŁAuQ^Ȃvł͂܂m6nBނułvƓ̂Ŏ͂BuȂ̖͂fՋɃTCł܂BȂȂq|NeX̐ɔwƂɂȂ邾낤łBȂ̐EƓIȐӔCłlX̌Nɂ܂ŊQԂ̂łBv

̖fՋ3琬B1̖fՂɂ񂵂Ă͂ƂĂZB́A֐ŏǂłɂȂ菜Ă邩炾BêYƂ͔rIɂ͏ȂB

2͈iANZXɂāB͒mƏ̂Ă邪îƂBł̓WFlbNiւ̃ANZXƂȂB܂łǂ̍łAȐĉƃWFlbNiƂ̃oXc_ĂBčł25NOɋc_AnbEbNX}@łB͂܂ɂЊŁAWFlbNiւ̃ANZXs\Ał̔i87%WFlbNŐ߂悤ɂȂB̏Ȃ΁AłEꍂzȕč̈iƍȂB

Ђ́AJꂽc_̏ł͂̃oXςȂƂ킩Ă̂ŁAe閧ɂĂfՋŃWFlbNi肵Â炭悤ƂBĂ̖͂]ނ͉̂łɓ̂ŁAvɍیȂBׂ͂Ă̕یȒƉāu{CŌȂƂȂvƓĂAĂ͎ۂ̂Ałč̐ĉ͗v̂قƂǂʂB̖fՋ͂܂܂Ȃi̒liグăWFlbNiւ̃ANZX炷ƂɂȂBIo}哝̂̎vȌт̓Io}PAłAč̈ÃANZXg債BƂ낪A̖fՋł͂̌тŌ@ƂĂBȂȂƂ̂Aɂ͂ς藝łȂB

ҋƂ΂́BK̓PpA~Bꂪč̌oϒc̃rWlXEEhe[ű߂ĂBoϊE㉟Ă̂͂̂߂B̏Ӑ}ʂƂĂ炷̂́A󋵂̕ωɑΉVȋK܂܂ɂȂƂƂBƂ΂͒ngɂ40NOɂ͉m炸A1980NɂȂĂ͂߂ĕꂽBɎgƂ΁A_Yfroʂ炷߂̋K݂Ȃ΂ȂȂBƂ낪TPP̂Ƃł́A鍑Ő݂ḰAɂĕsvނƂi\BJi_{9̏dvȑiׂɕȂ͊KɊ֌WĂB̊ԂAZXgsK؂ƑiƂɕĂ܂m7nB̊Ƃ̓Ji_̍ٔɑi邱Ƃł̂AԂِ̒lɂ钇وψI񂾁Bِl3lŁA1l͊ƂwA1l͐{A1l͗҂̍ӂɂĎwBƂ낪قɂ邱̖@Ƃ͂߂ĊƂ̑ɂĂm8nBŃJi_͂قǑ̑iׂɕĂ̂B

l̏Ɋ֘ÂŁA݌WłƂLȑiׂƂẮA^oR̃pbP[WɌNQ̋LڂÂKɂătBbvEXЂEOAC{iٔB̋K͂̍mɂȂĂlX^oR𔃂ȂȂƂʂ̂ŁAtBbvEXЂ̗vቺBŃtBbvEXЂ͑̕⏞߂B܂ł͐lXEĂ{ÎmMĂ݂B̌グ̂Ȃ甅ĂȂ΂ȂȂƂĂB

̏dvȏNjm9nA͏̓یmiׁnɂ̂ڂ邪A͂BúmVȁnKƂΗHւ̕ː̍h悤Ȃ̂ƂĂA͂i邱Ƃł悤ɏBvꂪɂ񂷂鋦̓eB

́AmTPPn21I̋łAmNAFTÁnׂ̂ĂɑΏƎ咣ĂBȂ̖@Ƃ̈ӌɂ΁A܂ĂȂBlX̓{肪傫^oR͎菜ꂽA_Yf̔roAuH̕ːvAȊÔׂĂ͂̂܂܎cĂBƂ΃AXxXg̊댯炩ɂȂƂɃAXxXgKƂBs@ł̓AXxXgɂ錒NQɂĂꂪAXxXg̐Ǝ҂i邱ƂłBƂ낪VTPP̋K̂Ƃł́AƎ҂͂EɂƂRłꂩx󂯂̂B͂ƂĂeFłȂB̂悤ȃ[AFO搶̎x{Ƃ͑eȂŔ閧ɏAςĂBig債AЉIƊی̊Ղ@ƂĂB̏ƂĂTPPɎ^łȂB

EÚAԂِ̒lψɂْ萧x̂鋦ɂ͏ȂƂ𖾊mɂBׂ̂咣ĂB{my悤ƂĂn̂20I̋肾BEU낤ƂĂ̂21I̋肾BߑЉ̕Kv𖞂ȂƂ炩ɂȂĂ鋦AȂ͂ǂė~̂B

ȏAO[oȐǐĂƎvȎg݂ɂĎQlɂĂB

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂ钍

m1nThe Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social ProgressiWikipediaj
m2nThe Three Trillion Dollar WariWikipediaj
m3nRewriting the Rules of the American EconomyiRoosevelt Institutej
m4nmarket income: ⋋^Ȃǂ̌ٗpҕVƎcƎҏAYъƔNdȂǂ܂łAłЉۏTȌӖBmЉۏዋt͊܂܂Ȃn
uJILJ􃌃|[gVol.3@{̏iǂ݂邩viJ􌤋EC@\j
m5nEOAC哝̃^oEoXPXiTabare VazquezjB
"La guerra del opio del siglo XXI"m21ĨAw푈niRed De Militantes De Izquierdaj
m6nFirst, Do No Harm: ɂĂ̓XeBObcɌF悤B
uuFirst, Do No Harmvq|NeX̐ƂĎgׂł͂ȂviEARL̈wm[gj
m7n"Clayton/Bilcon v. Government of Canada"iGlobal Affairs Canadaj
"NAFTA ruling in Nova Scotia quarry case sparks fears for future settlements"iThe Globe and Mailj
m8nISDSِ̒x̖_iR̂߂̓j
m9nBarry Appleton, Canadian lawyer for Ethyl Corp. NAFTȀ̋Nɂǂ͕sB
"Elizabeth May's submission on the Environmental Assessment for the Canada-China Foreign Investment Protection and Promotion Agreement"iElizabeth Mayj

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂfBNe[V

m08:48/42:53n

It's a real pleasure to be here and participate in this session, in part commemorating the life of
Hirofumi Uzawa, who is my teacher. I studied under him in 1965 at the University of Chicago, where
he had brought the best students from all over the United States to discuss economic theory,
mathematic economics. He had a very powerful personality and in just a very short time we all
became his disciples. We all maintained a lifelong connection with Professor Uzawa. There were
three themes that distinguished Professor Uzawa. He was a mathematical economist. He was one
of the best mathematical economist of his generation. But underlying the mathematics were very
deeply held values. Those values are values I think that he maintained he lived his life by. One
of them was Social Justice. A concern about inequality, concern about poor, concern about the way
our society functions discriminates. The second was the Environment. He was vey committed to the
environment. Economists often talk about this in terms of inter-generational equity, fairness
across generations. He was deeply concerned not only about fairness within a generation which was
the distribution of income and wealth within a generation , but fairness across generations, social
justice at one moment of time and over time. Finally, he was vey concerned about Peace. Having
grown up in part during World War II, he was very committed to making sure that that kind of
occurrence never happened again.

Often when I write my work about Inequality, about the Environment, or my book "The Three
Trillion Dollar War" which was written to try to persuade America that it should not be engaged in
the war in Iraq and it was a war that was not going to be successful, which's going to cost us a
great deal,I thought of Hirofumi Uzawa. One of the points that was just raised echoes one of those
that I made in ... work, which is maximizing GDP is not what the society is about. The spending on
war adds to GDP. But nobody thinks our society is better off as result of the money that was
wasted in Iraq, especially the people who got killed didn't think it was a good way of spending
money.

I chaired an international commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social
Progress. Main theme of that commission was that GDP doesn't measure what is important and
we have to focus our attention not on GDP but on the quality of life. That's particularly important
here in Japan because the statistics often mislead people to criticizing Japan for saying it's not
growing very well but Japan has a declining labor force. In terms of output per hour, output per
worker, is actually among the best performance of the best advanced countries. That doesn't
mean you can't do better, but the single-minded focus on growth, I believe, is very much
misplaced.
@@@@
In recent years there has developed what might be called a Global Progressive Movement, which is
focused on precisely these issues that were the mainstay of Professor Uzawa, on Social Justice and
Environment and Peace. Right now is a very interesting moment in terms of the Global Progressive
Movement. Because in the United States, for instance, on one side, I don't think the Global
Progressive Movement has ever been stronger. Both of the Democratic candidates have espoused
policies that are broadly consistent with ... many of the pillars of the Progressive Movement. They
talked about Inequality is being America's most important problem and what we can do about it.
They talked about the Environment and how we can protect it. On the other hand, never has ......
been more divided society. Income, wealth, health, every metric shows a society that is moving
further and further apart. Part of the reason that you see on the Republican side, such anger on
certain part, is because for a large fraction of Americans life has not been very good.

Japan has a higher life expectancy than the United States. Japan has recognized the right of access
to health for everybody. The United States is one of the, I think the only advanced country that
does not recognize that as a basic right. The result of that is that in the United States there are
large disparities in access to health. Recent data show that among white males who are not college
graduates, life expectancy is declining very strongly. American males, for instance, who have not
graduated from college have seen their income decline year after year. The median income for men
as a whole, half above and half below, is now lower than it was 40 years ago. Real wages today in
the United States at the bottom are lower than it were in January 1955, 60 years ago. Those at the
bottom have not seen a pay raise in 60 years. This is not a society which is getting better every
year. This is a society in which the top are doing better every year, but the vast majority are not.
That of course has spurred the kind of anger that you see. But unfortunately it's not being
channeled in a constructive way. On the other side, in the Democratic side, the discontent is being
channeled in a progressive way, in a way that's trying to see what we can do about those problems.

m17:05/42:53n

What I want to do this morning is very briefly talk about that Progressive agenda. Let me say that
we were.., The Progressive Movement has been very careful to say, "It's not partisan." It supports
anybody, any candidate that is going to support these ideas and talk to anybody who supports these
ideas.

Among the first principles is Full Employment. But what is Full Employment mean? There are some
people in the United States i.e. vice chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve who says, "Well, we are
4.9% unemployment and that means we are full employment." But of course those statistics don't
reflect the lives of those who don't have a job. If you are one of those 4.9% you don't feel fully
employed. If you look underneath the statistics you realize the true unemployment rate in the
United States is twice that number. The true unemployment rate reflects the fact that many
Americans are called employed if they work just one hour a week. Of course that's not a
meaningful employment. You can't get an income to survive. If you've looked for job for four
years and you still can't get a job, you are not called unemployed. But you are not employed.
When we look at the statistics what we realize is that the true unemployment is much larger.
That is why even with 4.9% unemployment wages are stagnating. If there were really no
unemployment, wages would be bid up.

The same thing is true in Japan, except you are in a better shape. You have unemployment of ......
3.7%? But wages are not doing very well. Until you get truly full employment where wage pressures
are going up, you should try to continue to stimulate the economy. The only reason to stop
stimulating the economy is a worry about inflation. The worry now in Japan is about deflation. It's
difficult you getting up to a 2% target.

So, both in the United States and in Japan, there is a need for more aggressive measures. Monetary
policy has done as much as it can. Therefore the burden has to shift fiscal policy.

Here, there is a fundamental principle in economics which is called the Balance Budget Multiplier.
If you increase taxes and increase spending in tandem, it stimulates the economy. If you choose
your taxes right and your spending right, it increases the economy by a multiple of what the
spending.

For instance, taxes that stimulates the economy, a carbon tax. A carbon tax induces firms to invest
to retrofit their production processes for the higher charges of emissions, induces homes to invest
to insulate, it induces people to relocate to buy new cars that are more fuel efficient. Japan is
already much more efficient than in the United States, but there's still a long way to go. So a
carbon tax is a tax that both raises revenue and stimulates the economy.

There are other taxes like an inheritance tax. Inheritance taxes can often induce people to spend
money before they die, increase revenue and improve equality. Financial transaction tax discourages
the kind of short-term speculation that destabilizes the economy and produces no real growth,
reduces inequality and raises revenue. Taxes on property, particularly capital gains taxes on
property. Lower taxes on land do not result in more land, so have no negative incentive effects but
raise revenue, increase equality and promote growth. That's the first agenda which is promoting
full employment.

The second is inclusion and discrimination. All societies engage in discrimination to some extent.
There's discrimination against minorities, discrimination against women. Women receive on average
a fraction of the wages the men doing comparable work, comparable qualifications. United States,
we've been discussing constitutional amendment for guaranteeing equal wages, but Republicans
have refused to support this idea. There are other policies that promote inclusion. Child care,
family leave policy, flexible working hours, these are all aspects of inclusion.

There are other aspects of inclusion that are important, one of which was mentioned. Japan has an
aging population. All societies are now having aging population. We have an economic system that
has ignored that challenge. Traditionally, when people get the age of 65 you throw them in the
garbage heap and say, "try to survive." With QE, things have become even worse because many of
those elderly who acted safe and bought government bonds, those bonds yield zero interest rates.
They are about to yield negative interest rates. That's not a way to have a comfortable retirement.
You can't live on zero interest rates. One has to think about how we can include these people
longer in the labor force. The reason, they are living longer? But they don't want to retire. We
force them to retire. They are still productive. They would be productive particularly if we
retrain them and we made work more flexible. So greater flexibility in the work place recognizing
imperative inclusion is another part of the inclusion agenda.

When we talk about Equality, often people focus on redistribution, on taxes and transfers, and
those are important. But in my most recent book called "Rewriting the Rules," what we focused on
is something different. What we realize is that countries with similar economic structures wind up
with very different market income inequality. So ...... the demand and supply operate the same on
both sides of Atlantic, both sides of Pacific, in countries that is similar stages of development,
but market income is markedly different. For instance, one of the astounding things in the United
States is that since 1970s productivity of American labor force is roughly doubled. Wages,
compensation has stagnated. It used to be the productivity and wages move together. Now they
don't. This result of what happened beginning in the Reagan era where there was a rewriting of
the rules of the market economy, rewriting the rules in ways that weaken the bargaining power of
workers, increase their insecurity and changed the economic framework in a whole ...... ways, like
changes in corporate governance, changes in enforcement of antitrust laws and so forth.
@@@@
m26:18/42:53n

I want to conclude my brief remarks this morning by talking about one area that I understand that
Hirofumi Uzawa was very involved in and I've been involved in a great deal. That's a trade
agreements. These trade agreements have motivated a lot of the discussion in the United States.
I was once asked by a doctor who was the President of a Latin American country whether he should
sign a free trade agreement with the United States. I first pointed out it was not a free trade
agreement. If it was a free trade agreement, it would be about three pages, "We eliminate our
tariffs, you eliminate your tariffs, we eliminate our non-tariffs, you eliminate yours, we
eliminate our subsidies, you eliminate yours," about three pages. Do you know how long? The TPP
agreement is 6,000 pages. I have not met a single person who has ever read the entire agreement.
That's not a free trade agreement, it's a managed trade agreement. It's a managed trade agreement
that ...... manage for the interest of corporate interest, corporate interest mostly in the
United States, but corporate interest in other countries as well. When the United States President
Obama said that this agreement is about who writes the rules of trade in the 21st century, China
and the United States, or he said, "Do we or China write it." The question is which "we". We did
not write it, the corporate lobbyists wrote it. What we are asking is for a trade agreement that
we write, that is arrived at through a more democratic process, that the key issues are laid out
in the open and discussed in the parliaments of all of the TPP countries.

Well, could go back to this doctor, I asked him, "Did you sign the Hippocratic Oath?" which all
the doctors have to sign. The Hippocratic Oath begins, "Do no harm." He said, "Yes," he signed it.
So I told him, "You can't sign the trade agreement 'cause that would be a violation of the oath
that you have signed. It would actually even harm health and that is your responsibility."

There are three parts of the trade agreement. The first part is about trade. It's very small part
because tariff barrier's already relatively low. There are specially interested industries get
hurt, get helped, but that is a relatively small part.

The second part is about access to medicine. They call it intellectual property, but it's only
the balance between Big Pharma and generics. United States we had that debate 25 years ago.
Result was the Hatch-Waxman Act, which created a balance I thought was not good. Quite the right
balance? It was too weighted for Big Pharma and not enough for access to generic medicines,
but even with that unbalanced agreement, about 87% of all drugs are sold generically. If it were
not for the provision, the price of drugs in the United States, already the highest in the world,
would be much much higher.

The drug companies knew that they could not get that changed in an open debate, so they went in
the secret trade agreement and got that balance unbalanced to make it more difficult to get
generic medicines. That was the key part of this provision. They didn't get everything they wanted
so they are complaining, because they used to win everything. I met with all the health ministers
and I used to say, "You really have to bargain hard," and they did, but still the U.S. Big Pharma
got most of what they wanted. And effect of this agreement almost surely will be to raise the price
of drugs and reduce access to generic medicines. For me, this is a big puzzle because Obama's
Signature Achievement is Obamacare, making access to health care more affordable, greater in
the United States. Yet with this trade agreement, he is undermining his Signature Achievement.

But the worst provision in the TPP is the investment provision. It's not about protecting
investment, let's make that clear, because we are insisting, United States is insisting on the
same agreement with Europe, where they have good laws, even better protection of intellectual
property rights. So it's not about ... systems, it's not about protecting property right, it's not
about discrimination, it's nothing to do with discrimination.

We just called National Treatment. It is about deregulation, stopping regulations, and that
provision is what the Business Roundtable wanted. It is the main reason that some of the business
community is behind it. The intent and the consequence of this part of the agreement is to make it
increasingly difficult to pass new regulations as the circumstances change. We didn't know about
global warming 40 years ago. We just learned about it in the 1980s. As we're going about we have
to pass regulations that will reduce carbon emissions. But under the TPP, if a country passes a
regulation, they may be sued if the profit of the company goes down. Canada has lost nine
important suits, many of them in the area of the environment. They even just lost a suit where
the company claimed that environmental assessment was done improperly. They could have gone
to the Canadian courts, but they chose to go to a biased private arbitration panel. Three people,
one appointed by the business, one by the government, one by two together. But the ... of these
lawyers who do these arbitration cases is such that they are very biased toward the business side.
That's why Canada's lost so many cases.

Most famous case going on right now, in a similar kind of legal provision, is the suit by Phillip
Morris against Uruguay for the regulations simply saying that you have to disclose that cigarettes
are bad for your health. Just a disclosure, but that disclosure work because people stopped buying
as many cigarettes Phillip Morris' profits went down. Philip Morris is suing for the loss of
profits. They believe they have a fundamental right to kill people. You take away that right,
you have to compensate them. The guy who drafted the key provision, this is back in the earlier
investment protection, said, "We've designed it so if you pass a regulation preventing plutonium
in baby cereal, we will sue." That is what is in the investment agreement.
@@@@
Now, they claimed this is a 21st century agreement, they've taken care of all these problems. Our
lawyers have looked at that. Answer is "No." They have not solved. The way you can see that is
they explicitly carved out tobacco, because people are so angry about tobacco. But they left
carbon emissions, they left plutonium in baby cereal in, they left every other topic in. Only
thing they carved out was cigarettes. If we discovered that asbestos was dangerous for your health
and we regulated asbestos, under the current law, we can sue the asbestos manufacturers for what
they've done for our health. Under the new regulations of TPP, the asbestos manufacturers would be
paid by us for not killing us. That should be totally unacceptable. It is an example of how in
secret the rules are being written, rewritten, in ways that contradicts basic principles for which
Hirofumi Uzawa stood. It will increase Inequality and undermines basic principles of Social Justice
and the protection of the Environment. So, for me, this provision by itself is ground for rejecting
TPP.

Let me make one more point clear before ending. Europe has made it very clear that they will not
sign an agreement with the process of adjudication with these private arbitration panels, that they
have insisted on another way of doing it. So if Japan signs this agreement, it will be signing a
20th century agreement, while Europe will be getting a 21st century agreement. Why would you
want an agreement that has been shown to be inadequate to the needs of a modern society?

I hope that these words have given you some thinking about to where the Global Progressive
Movement is going and how it believes the key problems of our society can be addressed today.
Thank you.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂̃Rg

oƃuPbg͓e҂ɂ⑫B
@
@
XeBObcuȊO̓̓e

u̎|юQ҂ɂẮAœcKv}ۋǒAЉĂBuɐ旧āAȏ}\s}Љn{̎g݂񍐂Ăm2:20/42:53nBǔ̎^ł́Ac疯}\uSƐEIȎvsɑ΂铊moñoXvɂĎ₵BŃXeBObc͉c\yȂłɂāAiC΍Ƃϓ_炷Ƃ܂ېł̑Iłƒfm37:26/42:53nB@̍Ōɂ́ATPPj~čiO{tj̃Xs[m40:22/42:53nB
@
@
}ÃXeBObcu֘ÄCfeN

[eXg31] eXg
}EXeBObcHu 2016N317mn

}EXeBObcHu 2016N317

@
@
e҂ɂ鏴

FOƃO[oȐim08:48/42:53n
@
FO搶̂тȂ炱̂悤ȉɎQĂ炦ĂꂵB1965NVJSwŁASĂ̍ō̊wƂƂɉF搶̂ƂŐoϊww񂾁B͐搶̗͋lɂ܂SA搶ƈꐶJŌ΂ꂽB搶͂̐̍ō̐oϊw҂̈lB搶̐̉ɂ͐[lςBɎЉAɊAOɕaB

ɂď悤ɂȂƂAƂ΃CN푈ɔ΂wEsKɂAJ̐푈oρxm1nƂA悭搶̂ƂvBȂ킿AGDP̍ő剻͎Љ̖ړIł͂ȂBGDPɊ^邪ACN푈ɓꂽŎЉ͖LɂȂĂȂBCNŎEꂽlɂƂĂ͂Ȃ̂ƂB

c𖱂߂uoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvm2nł́AGDPł͑Ȃ̎ɂB̂Ƃ͓{œɏdvB{oϐĂȂƂAJ͐lቺĂƂAvɂƂÂᔻBAԂJ҂ł݂ƁA{̐Y͍ōȂ̂B

O[oȐiƂłׂߔN̓́AF搶Ɠ悤ɎЉAAaɌĂB̓čł͂܂łɂȂ܂ĂB哝̗\Ił́A}̌₪2lƂsւ̑΍ƂăO[oŐiIȐBŁAčЉ͂܂łɂȂfĂBAYANیȂǂɂĊi܂܂LĂB

a}Ɍ{́A镔ł𔽉fĂB{͕čϗ]BFیxmĂBƂANɂ錠ۏႳĂȂi͕č炢BߔNł͑woĂȂlj̕ϗ]傫ቺAwoĂȂj̎NXቺĂBjŜ̒ʎ40NOႭȂB݂̎Œ60NOႢB܂Ꮚ҂̒60Nԏ㏸ĂȂB̎Љł͍҂N܂܂LɂȂĂ̂ɁA|I̐lX͂łȂBꂪ̓{NĂBAcOȂ炻̓{͌ݓIȕɌĂȂB}̑ł́AsiIȕɌĂB

O[oȐi̐m17:05/42:53n

͂̐iIȐۑɂĂ񂽂ɏqׂB̗͓̐}ɂƂꂸA̐󂯓邷ׂĂ̌҂xB

̌́ASٗpłBSٗpƂ͉BƂFRB̕cuƗ4.9%ł芮SٗpƂ݂ȂvƂBv悭݂΁Aۂ̎Ɨ͂̔{łBƂΏT1ԂȂĂv͌ٗpƂ݂ȂĂB4NԋEĎdȂΎƂƂ݂͂ȂȂȂB̂悤Ɏۂ̎Ɨ4.9%͂邩ɍ̂ŁA㏸Ȃ̂B

{ɂĂƂB3.7%ƂƗ͕čႢA͂オĂȂBقƂ̊SٗpB܂ł͌iC̎h􂪕KvłBCťÔȂׂAݓ{SzȂ΂ȂȂ̂̓ft̕B2%̃Ct^[QbgBĂȂB

̂悤ɁAč{ϋɓIȕKvƂĂBZł͂ł邾̂ƂBĎ͍ɏd_uȂ΂ȂȂB

ύt\Z搔Ƃ΂{BłĂ̕{xo𑝂₹ΌiChƂ̂BېłƐ{xȏIK؂ł΁A{xo͌iC̊gɏ搔ʂ炷B

iChېł̗ƂāAYfłB͓_Yf̔roېőΏۂƂ邱ƂŎƎ҂ɐYH̉ǂ𑣂A҂ɂ͒fMzR̎Ԃ̍w𑣂Błɓ{͕̌čƍA܂܂̗]nB̂悤ɁAYfł͐ŎƌiC΍̗ɌʂB

ł́A̐Ă邠ɂg悤ɂނ̂ŁAŎグƂƂɎYikBł́Aoςsɂ邾Ŏۂ̐ɂ͊^ȂZIȓ@}AȉkƐŎ炷BŒ莑YŁAƂɕsY擾ł́AłĂynƂ킯ł͂Ȃ̂ŌłKvȂB͂ނȉkƌoϐȂBȏオASٗpɌ̐ۑłB

ɁAЉIۂƍʂ̉BЉI҂⏗ɂ鍷ʂǂ̎Љɂ݂B́AjƓiœdĂAϒႢBčł͓ۏ؂錛@̋c_Aa}ۂB玙ExƁAtbNX^CȂǁAقɂЉIۂ𑣐i鐭􂪂B

ȂłdvȂ͍̂΍􂾁B܂ł̌oσVXe̖͂𖳎ĂB65΂ɂȂl̓S~̎RɓŎłȂƂƂ΂肾BZɘaԂɈBVɔĔ́AȂǂ납}CiXɂȂ낤ƂĂBł͈SV͖]߂ȂBlXƒ悤ɂׂBl͍ɂȂĂȂYIłAČP̋@_ȘJЂƂKvłB

Ƃ΍ĕzAېŁAړ]ɖڂꂪłA͏dvłBA͍ŋ߂̖{wXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv̋ȏxm3nłׂ̂ƂグBȂ킿Aoύ\̎Ă鍑łsꏊm4n̊ȉԂ͂܂قȂƂƂłBčł1970Nȍ~J͂̐Y{ɂ炸A؂ĂBĂ͐YオΒ㏸A݂͂łȂB́A[Kȗsoς̃[ςꂽʂłBJ҂̌͂߁AٗpsȂ̂ɂAR[|[gEKoiX┽gXg@̎sȂǌoς̘ggݑŜɂ郋[ςĂB

fՋ̖m26:18/42:53n

߂ɁAFO搶Ǝ[ĂfՋɂĐGꂽB̖fՋ߂āAčł͑̋c_ĂB́AĂ̍ő哝̂Ătm5nAčƂ̎RfՋɏׂǂӌ𕷂ꂽƂB́A͎RfՂł͂ȂAƎwEBRfՂȂ3y[Włނ̂ɁATPP6000y[WB͊ǗfՂłāAč͂߂ƂƂ̗v炻ƂĂBIo}哝̂́A̋́A21I̖fՃ[̂uvƂƂ肾ƂBAłuvƂ́ÂƂł͂ȂB̂͊Ƃ̃r[XgB̋߂ĂfՋƂ́AꂪAIȎ葱ɂĐA\ĂdvȖ肪TPPQ̋cŋc_悤Ȃ̂B

قǂ̈tɘbɖ߂ƁA͔ނɂ˂BuȂq|NeX̐ɏ̂łˁBvׂ͂Ă̈tȂ΂ȂȂŁAuQ^Ȃvł͂܂m6nBނułvƓ̂Ŏ͂BuȂ̖͂fՋɃTCł܂BȂȂq|NeX̐ɔwƂɂȂ邾낤łBȂ̐EƓIȐӔCłlX̌Nɂ܂ŊQԂ̂łBv

̖fՋ3琬B1̖fՂɂ񂵂Ă͂ƂĂZB́A֐ŏǂłɂȂ菜Ă邩炾BêYƂ͔rIɂ͏ȂB

2͈iANZXɂāB͒mƏ̂Ă邪îƂBł̓WFlbNiւ̃ANZXƂȂB܂łǂ̍łAȐĉƃWFlbNiƂ̃oXc_ĂBčł25NOɋc_AnbEbNX}@łB͂܂ɂЊŁAWFlbNiւ̃ANZXs\Ał̔i87%WFlbNŐ߂悤ɂȂB̏Ȃ΁AłEꍂzȕč̈iƍȂB

Ђ́AJꂽc_̏ł͂̃oXςȂƂ킩Ă̂ŁAe閧ɂĂfՋŃWFlbNi肵Â炭悤ƂBĂ̖͂]ނ͉̂łɓ̂ŁAvɍیȂBׂ͂Ă̕یȒƉāu{CŌȂƂȂvƓĂAĂ͎ۂ̂Ałč̐ĉ͗v̂قƂǂʂB̖fՋ͂܂܂Ȃi̒liグăWFlbNiւ̃ANZX炷ƂɂȂBIo}哝̂̎vȌт̓Io}PAłAč̈ÃANZXg債BƂ낪A̖fՋł͂̌тŌ@ƂĂBȂȂƂ̂Aɂ͂ς藝łȂB

ҋƂ΂́BK̓PpA~Bꂪč̌oϒc̃rWlXEEhe[ű߂ĂBoϊE㉟Ă̂͂̂߂B̏Ӑ}ʂƂĂ炷̂́A󋵂̕ωɑΉVȋK܂܂ɂȂƂƂBƂ΂͒ngɂ40NOɂ͉m炸A1980NɂȂĂ͂߂ĕꂽBɎgƂ΁A_Yfroʂ炷߂̋K݂Ȃ΂ȂȂBƂ낪TPP̂Ƃł́A鍑Ő݂ḰAɂĕsvނƂi\BJi_{9̏dvȑiׂɕȂ͊KɊ֌WĂB̊ԂAZXgsK؂ƑiƂɕĂ܂m7nB̊Ƃ̓Ji_̍ٔɑi邱Ƃł̂AԂِ̒lɂ钇وψI񂾁Bِl3lŁA1l͊ƂwA1l͐{A1l͗҂̍ӂɂĎwBƂ낪قɂ邱̖@Ƃ͂߂ĊƂ̑ɂĂm8nBŃJi_͂قǑ̑iׂɕĂ̂B

l̏Ɋ֘ÂŁA݌WłƂLȑiׂƂẮA^oR̃pbP[WɌNQ̋LڂÂKɂătBbvEXЂEOAC{iٔB̋K͂̍mɂȂĂlX^oR𔃂ȂȂƂʂ̂ŁAtBbvEXЂ̗vቺBŃtBbvEXЂ͑̕⏞߂B܂ł͐lXEĂ{ÎmMĂ݂B̌グ̂Ȃ甅ĂȂ΂ȂȂƂĂB

̏dvȏNjm9nA͏̓یmiׁnɂ̂ڂ邪A͂BúmVȁnKƂΗHւ̕ː̍h悤Ȃ̂ƂĂA͂i邱Ƃł悤ɏBvꂪɂ񂷂鋦̓eB

́AmTPPn21I̋łAmNAFTÁnׂ̂ĂɑΏƎ咣ĂBȂ̖@Ƃ̈ӌɂ΁A܂ĂȂBlX̓{肪傫^oR͎菜ꂽA_Yf̔roAuH̕ːvAȊÔׂĂ͂̂܂܎cĂBƂ΃AXxXg̊댯炩ɂȂƂɃAXxXgKƂBs@ł̓AXxXgɂ錒NQɂĂꂪAXxXg̐Ǝ҂i邱ƂłBƂ낪VTPP̋K̂Ƃł́AƎ҂͂EɂƂRłꂩx󂯂̂B͂ƂĂeFłȂB̂悤ȃ[AFO搶̎x{Ƃ͑eȂŔ閧ɏAςĂBig債AЉIƊی̊Ղ@ƂĂB̏ƂĂTPPɎ^łȂB

EÚAԂِ̒lψɂْ萧x̂鋦ɂ͏ȂƂ𖾊mɂBׂ̂咣ĂB{my悤ƂĂn̂20I̋肾BEU낤ƂĂ̂21I̋肾BߑЉ̕Kv𖞂ȂƂ炩ɂȂĂ鋦AȂ͂ǂė~̂B

ȏAO[oȐǐĂƎvȎg݂ɂĎQlɂĂB

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂ钍

m1nThe Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress
iWikipediaj

m2nThe Three Trillion Dollar WariWikipediaj
m3nRewriting the Rules of the American EconomyiRoosevelt Institutej
m4nmarket income: ⋋^Ȃǂ̌ٗpҕVƎcƎҏAYъƔNdȂǂ܂łAłЉۏTȌӖBmЉۏዋt͊܂܂Ȃn
uJILJ􃌃|[gVol.3@{̏iǂ݂邩viJ􌤋EC@\j
m5nEOAC哝̃^oEoXPXiTabare VazquezjB
La guerra del opio del siglo XXIm21ĨAw푈niRed De Militantes De Izquierdaj
m6nFirst, Do No Harm: ɂĂ̓XeBObcɌF悤B
uFirst, Do No Harmvq|NeX̐ƂĎgׂł͂ȂiEARL̈wm[gj
m7n"Clayton/Bilcon v. Government of Canada"iGlobal Affairs Canadaj
"NAFTA ruling in Nova Scotia quarry case sparks fears for future settlements"iThe Globe and Mailj
m8nISDSِ̒x̖_iR̂߂̓j
m9nBarry Appleton, Canadian lawyer for Ethyl Corp. NAFTȀ̋Nɂǂ͕sB
Elizabeth May's submission on the Environmental Assessment for the Canada-China Foreign Investment Protection and Promotion AgreementiElizabeth Mayj

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂfBNe[V

m08:48/42:53n

It's a real pleasure to be here and participate in this session, in part commemorating the life of
Hirofumi Uzawa, who is my teacher. I studied under him in 1965 at the University of Chicago,
where he had brought the best students from all over the United States to discuss economic theory,
mathematic economics. He had a very powerful personality and in just a very short time we all
became his disciples. We all maintained a lifelong connection with Professor Uzawa. There were
three themes that distinguished Professor Uzawa. He was a mathematical economist. He was one
of the best mathematical economist of his generation. But underlying the mathematics were very
deeply held values. Those values are values I think that he maintained he lived his life by. One
of them was Social Justice. A concern about inequality, concern about poor, concern about the way
our society functions discriminates. The second was the Environment. He was vey committed to the
environment. Economists often talk about this in terms of inter-generational equity, fairness
across generations. He was deeply concerned not only about fairness within a generation which was
the distribution of income and wealth within a generation , but fairness across generations, social
justice at one moment of time and over time. Finally, he was vey concerned about Peace. Having
grown up in part during World War II, he was very committed to making sure that that kind of
occurrence never happened again.

Often when I write my work about Inequality, about the Environment, or my book "The Three
Trillion Dollar War" which was written to try to persuade America that it should not be engaged in
the war in Iraq and it was a war that was not going to be successful, which's going to cost us a
great deal,I thought of Hirofumi Uzawa. One of the points that was just raised echoes one of those
that I made in ... work, which is maximizing GDP is not what the society is about. The spending on
war adds to GDP. But nobody thinks our society is better off as result of the money that was
wasted in Iraq, especially the people who got killed didn't think it was a good way of spending
money.

I chaired an international commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social
Progress. Main theme of that commission was that GDP doesn't measure what is important and
we have to focus our attention not on GDP but on the quality of life. That's particularly important
here in Japan because the statistics often mislead people to criticizing Japan for saying it's not
growing very well but Japan has a declining labor force. In terms of output per hour, output per
worker, is actually among the best performance of the best advanced countries. That doesn't
mean you can't do better, but the single-minded focus on growth, I believe, is very much
misplaced.
@@@@
In recent years there has developed what might be called a Global Progressive Movement, which is
focused on precisely these issues that were the mainstay of Professor Uzawa, on Social Justice and
Environment and Peace. Right now is a very interesting moment in terms of the Global Progressive
Movement. Because in the United States, for instance, on one side, I don't think the Global
Progressive Movement has ever been stronger. Both of the Democratic candidates have espoused
policies that are broadly consistent with ... many of the pillars of the Progressive Movement. They
talked about Inequality is being America's most important problem and what we can do about it.
They talked about the Environment and how we can protect it. On the other hand, never has ......
been more divided society. Income, wealth, health, every metric shows a society that is moving
further and further apart. Part of the reason that you see on the Republican side, such anger on
certain part, is because for a large fraction of Americans life has not been very good.

Japan has a higher life expectancy than the United States. Japan has recognized the right of access
to health for everybody. The United States is one of the, I think the only advanced country that
does not recognize that as a basic right. The result of that is that in the United States there are
large disparities in access to health. Recent data show that among white males who are not college
graduates, life expectancy is declining very strongly. American males, for instance, who have not
graduated from college have seen their income decline year after year. The median income for men
as a whole, half above and half below, is now lower than it was 40 years ago. Real wages today in
the United States at the bottom are lower than it were in January 1955, 60 years ago. Those at the
bottom have not seen a pay raise in 60 years. This is not a society which is getting better every
year. This is a society in which the top are doing better every year, but the vast majority are not.
That of course has spurred the kind of anger that you see. But unfortunately it's not being
channeled in a constructive way. On the other side, in the Democratic side, the discontent is being
channeled in a progressive way, in a way that's trying to see what we can do about those problems.

m17:05/42:53n

What I want to do this morning is very briefly talk about that Progressive agenda. Let me say that
we were.., The Progressive Movement has been very careful to say, "It's not partisan." It supports
anybody, any candidate that is going to support these ideas and talk to anybody who supports these
ideas.

Among the first principles is Full Employment. But what is Full Employment mean? There are some
people in the United States i.e. vice chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve who says, "Well, we are
4.9% unemployment and that means we are full employment." But of course those statistics don't
reflect the lives of those who don't have a job. If you are one of those 4.9% you don't feel fully
employed. If you look underneath the statistics you realize the true unemployment rate in the
United States is twice that number. The true unemployment rate reflects the fact that many
Americans are called employed if they work just one hour a week. Of course that's not a
meaningful employment. You can't get an income to survive. If you've looked for job for four
years and you still can't get a job, you are not called unemployed. But you are not employed.
When we look at the statistics what we realize is that the true unemployment is much larger.
That is why even with 4.9% unemployment wages are stagnating. If there were really no
unemployment, wages would be bid up.

The same thing is true in Japan, except you are in a better shape. You have unemployment of ......
3.7%? But wages are not doing very well. Until you get truly full employment where wage pressures
are going up, you should try to continue to stimulate the economy. The only reason to stop
stimulating the economy is a worry about inflation. The worry now in Japan is about deflation. It's
difficult you getting up to a 2% target.

So, both in the United States and in Japan, there is a need for more aggressive measures. Monetary
policy has done as much as it can. Therefore the burden has to shift fiscal policy.

Here, there is a fundamental principle in economics which is called the Balance Budget Multiplier.
If you increase taxes and increase spending in tandem, it stimulates the economy. If you choose
your taxes right and your spending right, it increases the economy by a multiple of what the
spending.

For instance, taxes that stimulates the economy, a carbon tax. A carbon tax induces firms to invest
to retrofit their production processes for the higher charges of emissions, induces homes to invest
to insulate, it induces people to relocate to buy new cars that are more fuel efficient. Japan is
already much more efficient than in the United States, but there's still a long way to go. So a
carbon tax is a tax that both raises revenue and stimulates the economy.

There are other taxes like an inheritance tax. Inheritance taxes can often induce people to spend
money before they die, increase revenue and improve equality. Financial transaction tax discourages
the kind of short-term speculation that destabilizes the economy and produces no real growth,
reduces inequality and raises revenue. Taxes on property, particularly capital gains taxes on
property. Lower taxes on land do not result in more land, so have no negative incentive effects but
raise revenue, increase equality and promote growth. That's the first agenda which is promoting
full employment.

The second is inclusion and discrimination. All societies engage in discrimination to some extent.
There's discrimination against minorities, discrimination against women. Women receive on average
a fraction of the wages the men doing comparable work, comparable qualifications. United States,
we've been discussing constitutional amendment for guaranteeing equal wages, but Republicans
have refused to support this idea. There are other policies that promote inclusion. Child care,
family leave policy, flexible working hours, these are all aspects of inclusion.

There are other aspects of inclusion that are important, one of which was mentioned. Japan has an
aging population. All societies are now having aging population. We have an economic system that
has ignored that challenge. Traditionally, when people get the age of 65 you throw them in the
garbage heap and say, "try to survive." With QE, things have become even worse because many of
those elderly who acted safe and bought government bonds, those bonds yield zero interest rates.
They are about to yield negative interest rates. That's not a way to have a comfortable retirement.
You can't live on zero interest rates. One has to think about how we can include these people
longer in the labor force. The reason, they are living longer? But they don't want to retire. We
force them to retire. They are still productive. They would be productive particularly if we
retrain them and we made work more flexible. So greater flexibility in the work place recognizing
imperative inclusion is another part of the inclusion agenda.

When we talk about Equality, often people focus on redistribution, on taxes and transfers, and
those are important. But in my most recent book called "Rewriting the Rules," what we focused on
is something different. What we realize is that countries with similar economic structures wind up
with very different market income inequality. So ...... the demand and supply operate the same on
both sides of Atlantic, both sides of Pacific, in countries that is similar stages of development,
but market income is markedly different. For instance, one of the astounding things in the United
States is that since 1970s productivity of American labor force is roughly doubled. Wages,
compensation has stagnated. It used to be the productivity and wages move together. Now they
don't. This result of what happened beginning in the Reagan era where there was a rewriting of
the rules of the market economy, rewriting the rules in ways that weaken the bargaining power of
workers, increase their insecurity and changed the economic framework in a whole ...... ways, like
changes in corporate governance, changes in enforcement of antitrust laws and so forth.
@@@@
m26:18/42:53n

I want to conclude my brief remarks this morning by talking about one area that I understand that
Hirofumi Uzawa was very involved in and I've been involved in a great deal. That's a trade
agreements. These trade agreements have motivated a lot of the discussion in the United States.
I was once asked by a doctor who was the President of a Latin American country whether he should
sign a free trade agreement with the United States. I first pointed out it was not a free trade
agreement. If it was a free trade agreement, it would be about three pages, "We eliminate our
tariffs, you eliminate your tariffs, we eliminate our non-tariffs, you eliminate yours, we
eliminate our subsidies, you eliminate yours," about three pages. Do you know how long? The TPP
agreement is 6,000 pages. I have not met a single person who has ever read the entire agreement.
That's not a free trade agreement, it's a managed trade agreement. It's a managed trade
agreement that ...... manage for the interest of corporate interest, corporate interest mostly
in the United States, but corporate interest in other countries as well. When the United States
President Obama said that this agreement is about who writes the rules of trade in the 21st
century, China and the United States, or he said, "Do we or China write it." The question is
which "we". We did not write it, the corporate lobbyists wrote it. What we are asking is for a
trade agreement that we write, that is arrived at through a more democratic process, that the key
issues are laid out in the open and discussed in the parliaments of all of the TPP countries.

Well, could go back to this doctor, I asked him, "Did you sign the Hippocratic Oath?" which all
the doctors have to sign. The Hippocratic Oath begins, "Do no harm." He said, "Yes," he signed it.
So I told him, "You can't sign the trade agreement 'cause that would be a violation of the oath
that you have signed. It would actually even harm health and that is your responsibility."

There are three parts of the trade agreement. The first part is about trade. It's very small part
because tariff barrier's already relatively low. There are specially interested industries get
hurt, get helped, but that is a relatively small part.

The second part is about access to medicine. They call it intellectual property, but it's only
the balance between Big Pharma and generics. United States we had that debate 25 years ago.
Result was the Hatch-Waxman Act, which created a balance I thought was not good. Quite the right
balance? It was too weighted for Big Pharma and not enough for access to generic medicines,
but even with that unbalanced agreement, about 87% of all drugs are sold generically. If it were
not for the provision, the price of drugs in the United States, already the highest in the world,
would be much much higher.

The drug companies knew that they could not get that changed in an open debate, so they went in
the secret trade agreement and got that balance unbalanced to make it more difficult to get
generic medicines. That was the key part of this provision. They didn't get everything they wanted
so they are complaining, because they used to win everything. I met with all the health ministers
and I used to say, "You really have to bargain hard," and they did, but still the U.S. Big Pharma
got most of what they wanted. And effect of this agreement almost surely will be to raise the price
of drugs and reduce access to generic medicines. For me, this is a big puzzle because Obama's
Signature Achievement is Obamacare, making access to health care more affordable, greater in
the United States. Yet with this trade agreement, he is undermining his Signature Achievement.

But the worst provision in the TPP is the investment provision. It's not about protecting
investment, let's make that clear, because we are insisting, United States is insisting on the
same agreement with Europe, where they have good laws, even better protection of intellectual
property rights. So it's not about ... systems, it's not about protecting property right, it's not
about discrimination, it's nothing to do with discrimination.

We just called National Treatment. It is about deregulation, stopping regulations, and that
provision is what the Business Roundtable wanted. It is the main reason that some of the business
community is behind it. The intent and the consequence of this part of the agreement is to make it
increasingly difficult to pass new regulations as the circumstances change. We didn't know about
global warming 40 years ago. We just learned about it in the 1980s. As we're going about we have
to pass regulations that will reduce carbon emissions. But under the TPP, if a country passes a
regulation, they may be sued if the profit of the company goes down. Canada has lost nine
important suits, many of them in the area of the environment. They even just lost a suit where
the company claimed that environmental assessment was done improperly. They could have gone
to the Canadian courts, but they chose to go to a biased private arbitration panel. Three people,
one appointed by the business, one by the government, one by two together. But the ... of these
lawyers who do these arbitration cases is such that they are very biased toward the business side.
That's why Canada's lost so many cases.

Most famous case going on right now, in a similar kind of legal provision, is the suit by Phillip
Morris against Uruguay for the regulations simply saying that you have to disclose that cigarettes
are bad for your health. Just a disclosure, but that disclosure work because people stopped buying
as many cigarettes Phillip Morris' profits went down. Philip Morris is suing for the loss of
profits. They believe they have a fundamental right to kill people. You take away that right,
you have to compensate them. The guy who drafted the key provision, this is back in the earlier
investment protection, said, "We've designed it so if you pass a regulation preventing plutonium
in baby cereal, we will sue." That is what is in the investment agreement.
@@@@
Now, they claimed this is a 21st century agreement, they've taken care of all these problems. Our
lawyers have looked at that. Answer is "No." They have not solved. The way you can see that is
they explicitly carved out tobacco, because people are so angry about tobacco. But they left
carbon emissions, they left plutonium in baby cereal in, they left every other topic in. Only
thing they carved out was cigarettes. If we discovered that asbestos was dangerous for your health
and we regulated asbestos, under the current law, we can sue the asbestos manufacturers for what
they've done for our health. Under the new regulations of TPP, the asbestos manufacturers would be
paid by us for not killing us. That should be totally unacceptable. It is an example of how in
secret the rules are being written, rewritten, in ways that contradicts basic principles for which
Hirofumi Uzawa stood. It will increase Inequality and undermines basic principles of Social Justice
and the protection of the Environment. So, for me, this provision by itself is ground for rejecting
TPP.

Let me make one more point clear before ending. Europe has made it very clear that they will not
sign an agreement with the process of adjudication with these private arbitration panels, that they
have insisted on another way of doing it. So if Japan signs this agreement, it will be signing a
20th century agreement, while Europe will be getting a 21st century agreement. Why would you
want an agreement that has been shown to be inadequate to the needs of a modern society?

I hope that these words have given you some thinking about to where the Global Progressive
Movement is going and how it believes the key problems of our society can be addressed today.
Thank you.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂̃Rg

oƃuPbg͓e҂ɂ⑫B
@
@
XeBObcuȊO̓̓e

u̎|юQ҂ɂẮAœcKv}ۋǒAЉĂBuɐ旧āAȏ}\s}Љn{̎g݂񍐂Ăm2:20/42:53nBǔ̎^ł́Ac疯}\uSƐEIȎvsɑ΂铊moñoXvɂĎ₵BŃXeBObc͉c\yȂłɂāAiC΍Ƃϓ_炷Ƃ܂ېł̑Iłƒfm37:26/42:53nB@̍Ōɂ́ATPPj~čiO{tj̃Xs[m40:22/42:53nB
@
@
}ÃXeBObcu֘ÄCfeN

[GkEStory41] }EXeBObcHu 2016N317mn
}EXeBObcHu 2016N317

@
@
e҂ɂ鏴

FOƃO[oȐim08:48/42:53n
@
FO搶̂тȂ炱̂悤ȉɎQĂ炦ĂꂵB1965NVJSwŁASĂ̍ō̊wƂƂɉF搶̂ƂŐoϊww񂾁B͐搶̗͋lɂ܂SA搶ƈꐶJŌ΂ꂽB搶͂̐̍ō̐oϊw҂̈lB搶̐̉ɂ͐[lςBɎЉAɊAOɕaB

ɂď悤ɂȂƂAƂ΃CN푈ɔ΂wEsKɂAJ̐푈oρxm1nƂA悭搶̂ƂvBȂ킿AGDP̍ő剻͎Љ̖ړIł͂ȂBGDPɊ^邪ACN푈ɓꂽŎЉ͖LɂȂĂȂBCNŎEꂽlɂƂĂ͂Ȃ̂ƂB

c𖱂߂uoσptH[}XƎЉ̐ȋɊւψvm2nł́AGDPł͑Ȃ̎ɂB̂Ƃ͓{œɏdvB{oϐĂȂƂAJ͐lቺĂƂAvɂƂÂᔻBAԂJ҂ł݂ƁA{̐Y͍ōȂ̂B

O[oȐiƂłׂߔN̓́AF搶Ɠ悤ɎЉAAaɌĂB̓čł͂܂łɂȂ܂ĂB哝̗\Ił́A}̌₪2lƂsւ̑΍ƂăO[oŐiIȐBŁAčЉ͂܂łɂȂfĂBAYANیȂǂɂĊi܂܂LĂB

a}Ɍ{́A镔ł𔽉fĂB{͕čϗ]BFیxmĂBƂANɂ錠ۏႳĂȂi͕č炢BߔNł͑woĂȂlj̕ϗ]傫ቺAwoĂȂj̎NXቺĂBjŜ̒ʎ40NOႭȂB݂̎Œ60NOႢB܂Ꮚ҂̒60Nԏ㏸ĂȂB̎Љł͍҂N܂܂LɂȂĂ̂ɁA|I̐lX͂łȂBꂪ̓{NĂBAcOȂ炻̓{͌ݓIȕɌĂȂB}̑ł́AsiIȕɌĂB

O[oȐi̐m17:05/42:53n

͂̐iIȐۑɂĂ񂽂ɏqׂB̗͓̐}ɂƂꂸA̐󂯓邷ׂĂ̌҂xB

̌́ASٗpłBSٗpƂ͉BƂFRB̕cuƗ4.9%ł芮SٗpƂ݂ȂvƂBv悭݂΁Aۂ̎Ɨ͂̔{łBƂΏT1ԂȂĂv͌ٗpƂ݂ȂĂB4NԋEĎdȂΎƂƂ݂͂ȂȂȂB̂悤Ɏۂ̎Ɨ4.9%͂邩ɍ̂ŁA㏸Ȃ̂B

{ɂĂƂB3.7%ƂƗ͕čႢA͂オĂȂBقƂ̊SٗpB܂ł͌iC̎h􂪕KvłBCťÔȂׂAݓ{SzȂ΂ȂȂ̂̓ft̕B2%̃Ct^[QbgBĂȂB

̂悤ɁAč{ϋɓIȕKvƂĂBZł͂ł邾̂ƂBĎ͍ɏd_uȂ΂ȂȂB

ύt\Z搔Ƃ΂{BłĂ̕{xo𑝂₹ΌiChƂ̂BېłƐ{xȏIK؂ł΁A{xo͌iC̊gɏ搔ʂ炷B

iChېł̗ƂāAYfłB͓_Yf̔roېőΏۂƂ邱ƂŎƎ҂ɐYH̉ǂ𑣂A҂ɂ͒fMzR̎Ԃ̍w𑣂Błɓ{͕̌čƍA܂܂̗]nB̂悤ɁAYfł͐ŎƌiC΍̗ɌʂB

ł́A̐Ă邠ɂg悤ɂނ̂ŁAŎグƂƂɎYikBł́Aoςsɂ邾Ŏۂ̐ɂ͊^ȂZIȓ@}AȉkƐŎ炷BŒ莑YŁAƂɕsY擾ł́AłĂynƂ킯ł͂Ȃ̂ŌłKvȂB͂ނȉkƌoϐȂBȏオASٗpɌ̐ۑłB

ɁAЉIۂƍʂ̉BЉI҂⏗ɂ鍷ʂǂ̎Љɂ݂B́AjƓiœdĂAϒႢBčł͓ۏ؂錛@̋c_Aa}ۂB玙ExƁAtbNX^CȂǁAقɂЉIۂ𑣐i鐭􂪂B

ȂłdvȂ͍̂΍􂾁B܂ł̌oσVXe̖͂𖳎ĂB65΂ɂȂl̓S~̎RɓŎłȂƂƂ΂肾BZɘaԂɈBVɔĔ́AȂǂ납}CiXɂȂ낤ƂĂBł͈SV͖]߂ȂBlXƒ悤ɂׂBl͍ɂȂĂȂYIłAČP̋@_ȘJЂƂKvłB

Ƃ΍ĕzAېŁAړ]ɖڂꂪłA͏dvłBA͍ŋ߂̖{wXeBObĉꂩn܂uVEoρv̋ȏxm3nłׂ̂ƂグBȂ킿Aoύ\̎Ă鍑łsꏊm4n̊ȉԂ͂܂قȂƂƂłBčł1970Nȍ~J͂̐Y{ɂ炸A؂ĂBĂ͐YオΒ㏸A݂͂łȂB́A[Kȗsoς̃[ςꂽʂłBJ҂̌͂߁AٗpsȂ̂ɂAR[|[gEKoiX┽gXg@̎sȂǌoς̘ggݑŜɂ郋[ςĂB

fՋ̖m26:18/42:53n

߂ɁAFO搶Ǝ[ĂfՋɂĐGꂽB̖fՋ߂āAčł͑̋c_ĂB́AĂ̍ő哝̂Ătm5nAčƂ̎RfՋɏׂǂӌ𕷂ꂽƂB́A͎RfՂł͂ȂAƎwEBRfՂȂ3y[Włނ̂ɁATPP6000y[WB͊ǗfՂłāAč͂߂ƂƂ̗v炻ƂĂBIo}哝̂́A̋́A21I̖fՃ[̂uvƂƂ肾ƂBAłuvƂ́ÂƂł͂ȂB̂͊Ƃ̃r[XgB̋߂ĂfՋƂ́AꂪAIȎ葱ɂĐA\ĂdvȖ肪TPPQ̋cŋc_悤Ȃ̂B

قǂ̈tɘbɖ߂ƁA͔ނɂ˂BuȂq|NeX̐ɏ̂łˁBvׂ͂Ă̈tȂ΂ȂȂŁAuQ^Ȃvł͂܂m6nBނułvƓ̂Ŏ͂BuȂ̖͂fՋɃTCł܂BȂȂq|NeX̐ɔwƂɂȂ邾낤łBȂ̐EƓIȐӔCłlX̌Nɂ܂ŊQԂ̂łBv

̖fՋ3琬B1̖fՂɂ񂵂Ă͂ƂĂZB́A֐ŏǂłɂȂ菜Ă邩炾BêYƂ͔rIɂ͏ȂB

2͈iANZXɂāB͒mƏ̂Ă邪îƂBł̓WFlbNiւ̃ANZXƂȂB܂łǂ̍łAȐĉƃWFlbNiƂ̃oXc_ĂBčł25NOɋc_AnbEbNX}@łB͂܂ɂЊŁAWFlbNiւ̃ANZXs\Ał̔i87%WFlbNŐ߂悤ɂȂB̏Ȃ΁AłEꍂzȕč̈iƍȂB

Ђ́AJꂽc_̏ł͂̃oXςȂƂ킩Ă̂ŁAe閧ɂĂfՋŃWFlbNi肵Â炭悤ƂBĂ̖͂]ނ͉̂łɓ̂ŁAvɍیȂBׂ͂Ă̕یȒƉāu{CŌȂƂȂvƓĂAĂ͎ۂ̂Ałč̐ĉ͗v̂قƂǂʂB̖fՋ͂܂܂Ȃi̒liグăWFlbNiւ̃ANZX炷ƂɂȂBIo}哝̂̎vȌт̓Io}PAłAč̈ÃANZXg債BƂ낪A̖fՋł͂̌тŌ@ƂĂBȂȂƂ̂Aɂ͂ς藝łȂB

ҋƂ΂́BK̓PpA~Bꂪč̌oϒc̃rWlXEEhe[ű߂ĂBoϊE㉟Ă̂͂̂߂B̏Ӑ}ʂƂĂ炷̂́A󋵂̕ωɑΉVȋK܂܂ɂȂƂƂBƂ΂͒ngɂ40NOɂ͉m炸A1980NɂȂĂ͂߂ĕꂽBɎgƂ΁A_Yfroʂ炷߂̋K݂Ȃ΂ȂȂBƂ낪TPP̂Ƃł́A鍑Ő݂ḰAɂĕsvނƂi\BJi_{9̏dvȑiׂɕȂ͊KɊ֌WĂB̊ԂAZXgsK؂ƑiƂɕĂ܂m7nB̊Ƃ̓Ji_̍ٔɑi邱Ƃł̂AԂِ̒lɂ钇وψI񂾁Bِl3lŁA1l͊ƂwA1l͐{A1l͗҂̍ӂɂĎwBƂ낪قɂ邱̖@Ƃ͂߂ĊƂ̑ɂĂm8nBŃJi_͂قǑ̑iׂɕĂ̂B

l̏Ɋ֘ÂŁA݌WłƂLȑiׂƂẮA^oR̃pbP[WɌNQ̋LڂÂKɂătBbvEXЂEOAC{iٔB̋K͂̍mɂȂĂlX^oR𔃂ȂȂƂʂ̂ŁAtBbvEXЂ̗vቺBŃtBbvEXЂ͑̕⏞߂B܂ł͐lXEĂ{ÎmMĂ݂B̌グ̂Ȃ甅ĂȂ΂ȂȂƂĂB

̏dvȏNjm9nA͏̓یmiׁnɂ̂ڂ邪A͂BúmVȁnKƂΗHւ̕ː̍h悤Ȃ̂ƂĂA͂i邱Ƃł悤ɏBvꂪɂ񂷂鋦̓eB

́AmTPPn21I̋łAmNAFTÁnׂ̂ĂɑΏƎ咣ĂBȂ̖@Ƃ̈ӌɂ΁A܂ĂȂBlX̓{肪傫^oR͎菜ꂽA_Yf̔roAuH̕ːvAȊÔׂĂ͂̂܂܎cĂBƂ΃AXxXg̊댯炩ɂȂƂɃAXxXgKƂBs@ł̓AXxXgɂ錒NQɂĂꂪAXxXg̐Ǝ҂i邱ƂłBƂ낪VTPP̋K̂Ƃł́AƎ҂͂EɂƂRłꂩx󂯂̂B͂ƂĂeFłȂB̂悤ȃ[AFO搶̎x{Ƃ͑eȂŔ閧ɏAςĂBig債AЉIƊی̊Ղ@ƂĂB̏ƂĂTPPɎ^łȂB

EÚAԂِ̒lψɂْ萧x̂鋦ɂ͏ȂƂ𖾊mɂBׂ̂咣ĂB{my悤ƂĂn̂20I̋肾BEU낤ƂĂ̂21I̋肾BߑЉ̕Kv𖞂ȂƂ炩ɂȂĂ鋦AȂ͂ǂė~̂B

ȏAO[oȐǐĂƎvȎg݂ɂĎQlɂĂB

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂ钍

m1nThe Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress
iWikipediaj

m2nThe Three Trillion Dollar WariWikipediaj
m3nRewriting the Rules of the American EconomyiRoosevelt Institutej
m4nmarket income: ⋋^Ȃǂ̌ٗpҕVƎcƎҏAYъƔNdȂǂ܂łAłЉۏTȌӖBmЉۏዋt͊܂܂Ȃn
uJILJ􃌃|[gVol.3@{̏iǂ݂邩viJ􌤋EC@\j
m5nEOAC哝̃^oEoXPXiTabare VazquezjB
La guerra del opio del siglo XXIm21ĨAw푈niRed De Militantes De Izquierdaj
m6nFirst, Do No Harm: ɂĂ̓XeBObcɌF悤B
uFirst, Do No Harmvq|NeX̐ƂĎgׂł͂ȂiEARL̈wm[gj
m7n"Clayton/Bilcon v. Government of Canada"iGlobal Affairs Canadaj
"NAFTA ruling in Nova Scotia quarry case sparks fears for future settlements"iThe Globe and Mailj
m8nISDSِ̒x̖_iR̂߂̓j
m9nBarry Appleton, Canadian lawyer for Ethyl Corp. NAFTȀ̋Nɂǂ͕sB
Elizabeth May's submission on the Environmental Assessment for the Canada-China Foreign Investment Protection and Promotion AgreementiElizabeth Mayj

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂ɂfBNe[V

m08:48/42:53n

It's a real pleasure to be here and participate in this session, in part commemorating the life of
Hirofumi Uzawa, who is my teacher. I studied under him in 1965 at the University of Chicago,
where he had brought the best students from all over the United States to discuss economic theory,
mathematic economics. He had a very powerful personality and in just a very short time we all
became his disciples. We all maintained a lifelong connection with Professor Uzawa. There were
three themes that distinguished Professor Uzawa. He was a mathematical economist. He was one
of the best mathematical economist of his generation. But underlying the mathematics were very
deeply held values. Those values are values I think that he maintained he lived his life by. One
of them was Social Justice. A concern about inequality, concern about poor, concern about the way
our society functions discriminates. The second was the Environment. He was vey committed to the
environment. Economists often talk about this in terms of inter-generational equity, fairness
across generations. He was deeply concerned not only about fairness within a generation which was
the distribution of income and wealth within a generation , but fairness across generations, social
justice at one moment of time and over time. Finally, he was vey concerned about Peace. Having
grown up in part during World War II, he was very committed to making sure that that kind of
occurrence never happened again.

Often when I write my work about Inequality, about the Environment, or my book "The Three
Trillion Dollar War" which was written to try to persuade America that it should not be engaged in
the war in Iraq and it was a war that was not going to be successful, which's going to cost us a
great deal,I thought of Hirofumi Uzawa. One of the points that was just raised echoes one of those
that I made in ... work, which is maximizing GDP is not what the society is about. The spending on
war adds to GDP. But nobody thinks our society is better off as result of the money that was
wasted in Iraq, especially the people who got killed didn't think it was a good way of spending
money.

I chaired an international commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social
Progress. Main theme of that commission was that GDP doesn't measure what is important and
we have to focus our attention not on GDP but on the quality of life. That's particularly important
here in Japan because the statistics often mislead people to criticizing Japan for saying it's not
growing very well but Japan has a declining labor force. In terms of output per hour, output per
worker, is actually among the best performance of the best advanced countries. That doesn't
mean you can't do better, but the single-minded focus on growth, I believe, is very much
misplaced.
@@@@
In recent years there has developed what might be called a Global Progressive Movement, which is
focused on precisely these issues that were the mainstay of Professor Uzawa, on Social Justice and
Environment and Peace. Right now is a very interesting moment in terms of the Global Progressive
Movement. Because in the United States, for instance, on one side, I don't think the Global
Progressive Movement has ever been stronger. Both of the Democratic candidates have espoused
policies that are broadly consistent with ... many of the pillars of the Progressive Movement. They
talked about Inequality is being America's most important problem and what we can do about it.
They talked about the Environment and how we can protect it. On the other hand, never has ......
been more divided society. Income, wealth, health, every metric shows a society that is moving
further and further apart. Part of the reason that you see on the Republican side, such anger on
certain part, is because for a large fraction of Americans life has not been very good.

Japan has a higher life expectancy than the United States. Japan has recognized the right of access
to health for everybody. The United States is one of the, I think the only advanced country that
does not recognize that as a basic right. The result of that is that in the United States there are
large disparities in access to health. Recent data show that among white males who are not college
graduates, life expectancy is declining very strongly. American males, for instance, who have not
graduated from college have seen their income decline year after year. The median income for men
as a whole, half above and half below, is now lower than it was 40 years ago. Real wages today in
the United States at the bottom are lower than it were in January 1955, 60 years ago. Those at the
bottom have not seen a pay raise in 60 years. This is not a society which is getting better every
year. This is a society in which the top are doing better every year, but the vast majority are not.
That of course has spurred the kind of anger that you see. But unfortunately it's not being
channeled in a constructive way. On the other side, in the Democratic side, the discontent is being
channeled in a progressive way, in a way that's trying to see what we can do about those problems.

m17:05/42:53n

What I want to do this morning is very briefly talk about that Progressive agenda. Let me say that
we were.., The Progressive Movement has been very careful to say, "It's not partisan." It supports
anybody, any candidate that is going to support these ideas and talk to anybody who supports these
ideas.

Among the first principles is Full Employment. But what is Full Employment mean? There are some
people in the United States i.e. vice chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve who says, "Well, we are
4.9% unemployment and that means we are full employment." But of course those statistics don't
reflect the lives of those who don't have a job. If you are one of those 4.9% you don't feel fully
employed. If you look underneath the statistics you realize the true unemployment rate in the
United States is twice that number. The true unemployment rate reflects the fact that many
Americans are called employed if they work just one hour a week. Of course that's not a
meaningful employment. You can't get an income to survive. If you've looked for job for four
years and you still can't get a job, you are not called unemployed. But you are not employed.
When we look at the statistics what we realize is that the true unemployment is much larger.
That is why even with 4.9% unemployment wages are stagnating. If there were really no
unemployment, wages would be bid up.

The same thing is true in Japan, except you are in a better shape. You have unemployment of ......
3.7%? But wages are not doing very well. Until you get truly full employment where wage pressures
are going up, you should try to continue to stimulate the economy. The only reason to stop
stimulating the economy is a worry about inflation. The worry now in Japan is about deflation. It's
difficult you getting up to a 2% target.

So, both in the United States and in Japan, there is a need for more aggressive measures. Monetary
policy has done as much as it can. Therefore the burden has to shift fiscal policy.

Here, there is a fundamental principle in economics which is called the Balance Budget Multiplier.
If you increase taxes and increase spending in tandem, it stimulates the economy. If you choose
your taxes right and your spending right, it increases the economy by a multiple of what the
spending.

For instance, taxes that stimulates the economy, a carbon tax. A carbon tax induces firms to invest
to retrofit their production processes for the higher charges of emissions, induces homes to invest
to insulate, it induces people to relocate to buy new cars that are more fuel efficient. Japan is
already much more efficient than in the United States, but there's still a long way to go. So a
carbon tax is a tax that both raises revenue and stimulates the economy.

There are other taxes like an inheritance tax. Inheritance taxes can often induce people to spend
money before they die, increase revenue and improve equality. Financial transaction tax discourages
the kind of short-term speculation that destabilizes the economy and produces no real growth,
reduces inequality and raises revenue. Taxes on property, particularly capital gains taxes on
property. Lower taxes on land do not result in more land, so have no negative incentive effects but
raise revenue, increase equality and promote growth. That's the first agenda which is promoting
full employment.

The second is inclusion and discrimination. All societies engage in discrimination to some extent.
There's discrimination against minorities, discrimination against women. Women receive on average
a fraction of the wages the men doing comparable work, comparable qualifications. United States,
we've been discussing constitutional amendment for guaranteeing equal wages, but Republicans
have refused to support this idea. There are other policies that promote inclusion. Child care,
family leave policy, flexible working hours, these are all aspects of inclusion.

There are other aspects of inclusion that are important, one of which was mentioned. Japan has an
aging population. All societies are now having aging population. We have an economic system that
has ignored that challenge. Traditionally, when people get the age of 65 you throw them in the
garbage heap and say, "try to survive." With QE, things have become even worse because many of
those elderly who acted safe and bought government bonds, those bonds yield zero interest rates.
They are about to yield negative interest rates. That's not a way to have a comfortable retirement.
You can't live on zero interest rates. One has to think about how we can include these people
longer in the labor force. The reason, they are living longer? But they don't want to retire. We
force them to retire. They are still productive. They would be productive particularly if we
retrain them and we made work more flexible. So greater flexibility in the work place recognizing
imperative inclusion is another part of the inclusion agenda.

When we talk about Equality, often people focus on redistribution, on taxes and transfers, and
those are important. But in my most recent book called "Rewriting the Rules," what we focused on
is something different. What we realize is that countries with similar economic structures wind up
with very different market income inequality. So ...... the demand and supply operate the same on
both sides of Atlantic, both sides of Pacific, in countries that is similar stages of development,
but market income is markedly different. For instance, one of the astounding things in the United
States is that since 1970s productivity of American labor force is roughly doubled. Wages,
compensation has stagnated. It used to be the productivity and wages move together. Now they
don't. This result of what happened beginning in the Reagan era where there was a rewriting of
the rules of the market economy, rewriting the rules in ways that weaken the bargaining power of
workers, increase their insecurity and changed the economic framework in a whole ...... ways, like
changes in corporate governance, changes in enforcement of antitrust laws and so forth.
@@@@
m26:18/42:53n

I want to conclude my brief remarks this morning by talking about one area that I understand that
Hirofumi Uzawa was very involved in and I've been involved in a great deal. That's a trade
agreements. These trade agreements have motivated a lot of the discussion in the United States.
I was once asked by a doctor who was the President of a Latin American country whether he should
sign a free trade agreement with the United States. I first pointed out it was not a free trade
agreement. If it was a free trade agreement, it would be about three pages, "We eliminate our
tariffs, you eliminate your tariffs, we eliminate our non-tariffs, you eliminate yours, we
eliminate our subsidies, you eliminate yours," about three pages. Do you know how long? The TPP
agreement is 6,000 pages. I have not met a single person who has ever read the entire agreement.
That's not a free trade agreement, it's a managed trade agreement. It's a managed trade
agreement that ...... manage for the interest of corporate interest, corporate interest mostly
in the United States, but corporate interest in other countries as well. When the United States
President Obama said that this agreement is about who writes the rules of trade in the 21st
century, China and the United States, or he said, "Do we or China write it." The question is
which "we". We did not write it, the corporate lobbyists wrote it. What we are asking is for a
trade agreement that we write, that is arrived at through a more democratic process, that the key
issues are laid out in the open and discussed in the parliaments of all of the TPP countries.

Well, could go back to this doctor, I asked him, "Did you sign the Hippocratic Oath?" which all
the doctors have to sign. The Hippocratic Oath begins, "Do no harm." He said, "Yes," he signed it.
So I told him, "You can't sign the trade agreement 'cause that would be a violation of the oath
that you have signed. It would actually even harm health and that is your responsibility."

There are three parts of the trade agreement. The first part is about trade. It's very small part
because tariff barrier's already relatively low. There are specially interested industries get
hurt, get helped, but that is a relatively small part.

The second part is about access to medicine. They call it intellectual property, but it's only
the balance between Big Pharma and generics. United States we had that debate 25 years ago.
Result was the Hatch-Waxman Act, which created a balance I thought was not good. Quite the right
balance? It was too weighted for Big Pharma and not enough for access to generic medicines,
but even with that unbalanced agreement, about 87% of all drugs are sold generically. If it were
not for the provision, the price of drugs in the United States, already the highest in the world,
would be much much higher.

The drug companies knew that they could not get that changed in an open debate, so they went in
the secret trade agreement and got that balance unbalanced to make it more difficult to get
generic medicines. That was the key part of this provision. They didn't get everything they wanted
so they are complaining, because they used to win everything. I met with all the health ministers
and I used to say, "You really have to bargain hard," and they did, but still the U.S. Big Pharma
got most of what they wanted. And effect of this agreement almost surely will be to raise the price
of drugs and reduce access to generic medicines. For me, this is a big puzzle because Obama's
Signature Achievement is Obamacare, making access to health care more affordable, greater in
the United States. Yet with this trade agreement, he is undermining his Signature Achievement.

But the worst provision in the TPP is the investment provision. It's not about protecting
investment, let's make that clear, because we are insisting, United States is insisting on the
same agreement with Europe, where they have good laws, even better protection of intellectual
property rights. So it's not about ... systems, it's not about protecting property right, it's not
about discrimination, it's nothing to do with discrimination.

We just called National Treatment. It is about deregulation, stopping regulations, and that
provision is what the Business Roundtable wanted. It is the main reason that some of the business
community is behind it. The intent and the consequence of this part of the agreement is to make it
increasingly difficult to pass new regulations as the circumstances change. We didn't know about
global warming 40 years ago. We just learned about it in the 1980s. As we're going about we have
to pass regulations that will reduce carbon emissions. But under the TPP, if a country passes a
regulation, they may be sued if the profit of the company goes down. Canada has lost nine
important suits, many of them in the area of the environment. They even just lost a suit where
the company claimed that environmental assessment was done improperly. They could have gone
to the Canadian courts, but they chose to go to a biased private arbitration panel. Three people,
one appointed by the business, one by the government, one by two together. But the ... of these
lawyers who do these arbitration cases is such that they are very biased toward the business side.
That's why Canada's lost so many cases.

Most famous case going on right now, in a similar kind of legal provision, is the suit by Phillip
Morris against Uruguay for the regulations simply saying that you have to disclose that cigarettes
are bad for your health. Just a disclosure, but that disclosure work because people stopped buying
as many cigarettes Phillip Morris' profits went down. Philip Morris is suing for the loss of
profits. They believe they have a fundamental right to kill people. You take away that right,
you have to compensate them. The guy who drafted the key provision, this is back in the earlier
investment protection, said, "We've designed it so if you pass a regulation preventing plutonium
in baby cereal, we will sue." That is what is in the investment agreement.
@@@@
Now, they claimed this is a 21st century agreement, they've taken care of all these problems. Our
lawyers have looked at that. Answer is "No." They have not solved. The way you can see that is
they explicitly carved out tobacco, because people are so angry about tobacco. But they left
carbon emissions, they left plutonium in baby cereal in, they left every other topic in. Only
thing they carved out was cigarettes. If we discovered that asbestos was dangerous for your health
and we regulated asbestos, under the current law, we can sue the asbestos manufacturers for what
they've done for our health. Under the new regulations of TPP, the asbestos manufacturers would be
paid by us for not killing us. That should be totally unacceptable. It is an example of how in
secret the rules are being written, rewritten, in ways that contradicts basic principles for which
Hirofumi Uzawa stood. It will increase Inequality and undermines basic principles of Social Justice
and the protection of the Environment. So, for me, this provision by itself is ground for rejecting
TPP.

Let me make one more point clear before ending. Europe has made it very clear that they will not
sign an agreement with the process of adjudication with these private arbitration panels, that they
have insisted on another way of doing it. So if Japan signs this agreement, it will be signing a
20th century agreement, while Europe will be getting a 21st century agreement. Why would you
want an agreement that has been shown to be inadequate to the needs of a modern society?

I hope that these words have given you some thinking about to where the Global Progressive
Movement is going and how it believes the key problems of our society can be addressed today.
Thank you.

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
e҂̃Rg

oƃuPbg͓e҂ɂ⑫B
@
@
XeBObcuȊO̓̓e

u̎|юQ҂ɂẮAœcKv}ۋǒAЉĂBuɐ旧āAȏ}\s}Љn{̎g݂񍐂Ăm2:20/42:53nBǔ̎^ł́Ac疯}\uSƐEIȎvsɑ΂铊moñoXvɂĎ₵BŃXeBObc͉c\yȂłɂāAiC΍Ƃϓ_炷Ƃ܂ېł̑Iłƒfm37:26/42:53nB@̍Ōɂ́ATPPj~čiO{tj̃Xs[m40:22/42:53nB
@
@
}ÃXeBObcu֘ÄCfeN

[EIEmgj203] }EXeBObcHu 2016N317mnFGkN
}EXeBObcHu 2016N317mn
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/323.html
e G̎ 2016 N 3 29 22:55:00
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/627.html
[EIEmgj203] F@TPPyȂ3.30sNWAiƃeLXgj
F@TPPyȂ3.30sNWA
u20160330 UPLANyLOقɂČNzsooyȂ3.30s ̓ӂȂsoo ~߂Ȃ獡ȂIviYouTube/O֗S 2016/03/30j

@
m28:08/1:47:41n

\\ʈψA{iIɘ_cn܂܂B͍ĉ݂ȂłBQ̋ĉOЉA\̕炲A܂B

\\27Ɍ}܂i}AXؗOc@cAFOc@cAL(̂Ԃ䂫)Oc@cA{xuOc@cłBi}\āAFOc@c育A܂B
@
@
݂Ȃ񂱂ɂ́Bi}̎FłB͓}Ƃē}܂܂BƉXƂAc̏oԂ܂܂B

͂킢ƂARłǂATPP΍ʈψ̈ψɂȂ܂BT45ɁÂƂł͖{c܂B̃[A낢ȃwNȂ̂̂łAȂȖ@͖{cłƎ|A^𑍗łāAꂩψɕt܂BRc46n܂邩A7n܂邩킩܂񂪁ÂƂ1ڂ2ڂ͑őSerp邱ƂɂȂĂ܂BAꂩ1TԈƂȂ΁AerŎ₷邱ƂɂȂĂ܂BƂ낢눫ĂŁA邩Ȃ̂łA͂Ȃ悤ɋC܂B

ŁATPPςłBۖ@œ{̍Ȃ񂶂ȂƂ݂ȂSzĂ܂BSzłBۖ@łăAJ{U߂Ă邱Ƃ͂ȂłB܂ƂłǂˁBvgjEŁAqevgjE{30kgȏ㎝ĂłB4000A5000ȂłBŁA{͋ƁBqe肻ɂȂƂāAʔj󕺊n߂ƂĔĂ邩܂Bǂ̍łĂ܂ǁB܂ǂ͂肦ȂƎv܂B

ATPP댯ȂłBȂłł傤BTPPiƂĉX̕x݂ȒDĂƂĂłBŁAxD̂łǁA܂͓{̈肵nЉԂă_ȍɂ悤ƂÂłB{̒n̓K^K^ɂȂ܂B݂Ȃ񂨂킩̒ʂAEWƂ̂܂Ă܂BȂłł傤Bԍŏɑ傫ȕiڂŊ֐Ń[ɂȂ̂ۑȂłB1951N̉Bꂩ1964NIsbN̔NɁA[ɂȂ܂BԂ1978NłB؂܂ȂȂŁAŌEW{̂ɂłłB쌧̒RԒn͌EWǂ낶Ȃƕ傢܂BWƁB܂oĂ܂B

lĂ݂ĂBAۈ珊ŖȂRuA킢qłB܂łǂˁAƖȂ̂łB쌧̉ߑanɕۈ牀ABn͎łB킩ɂȂ܂B20NOA30NOnɂqǂ͂ȂȂĂłBuĂłB_Y̊֐ł[ɂ͂ĂȂƂĂ܂ǂA_RƂƑŌ󂯂āA{Sen̎sEsɂȂĂ܂܂BꂪTPP낵ƂĂԂ̗RłB

߁B܂łB̂ƂbƎv܂BB̒Ńn[{j[gĂ邩܂BC^̉Ɍ18~̖łBی܁AA̘b̒ɂ܂B炷A炵ƂĂ܂ǂA󂵂Ă܂BǂĂł傤BAJ̐Ђ͓{ɖ𔄂āAg킹łBrAی󂷂񂶂ȂāA{ɂ鐧xpāApĖׂ悤Ƃn߂łB

XcB񂴂񕶋傢Ă܂BXc낵ƁB{obNɕیxȂĂႢȂƁBŁAc܂B獡ǂȂł傤BmĂ܂H AtbN̕یX֋ǂĂłBj]łB{̐xƈpĖׂĂA󂵂Ă낤ƁBƂیÐxł낤ƂĂłBǂƂƂƁA18~̖12TԈݑłBC^̉EBXSɂȂȂłB680~N̂B{{͂₳łBیΏۈɂłB킩܂H Ⴀ31͎ȕSȂccƂ₳łB2~ōςނłBǂƂł傤B{̈Õیx650~AAJ̃MAhЂɍsłB킩܂H X֋ǂp̂Ɠ悤ɁA{̕یxpāAAJ̐Ђׂ悤ƂĂłB킩ɂȂ܂ł傤B

I[XgAj[W[hKɂȂăoCIĩf[^یԂ5NɂA5NɂƂĂłB×b͂ǂĂł傤BsiɓOƁBoJȂƂ񂶂ȂBsiȂĂ͍̂AWTOǒ΂łāAS҂Ȃ̂ɂ܂ĂȂłB͂łđbɂׂƎvĂ܂BTPP΍ʈψɈςoāBǓxڂ̎낤ƎvĂ܂B΁ATPPy܂BccɓcĂ܂Bꏏɂ΂ł܂Bꏏɂ΂܂傤B
@
@
me҃Rgn

@
@
̓e

m0:01:30/1:47:41n
m0:07:05/1:47:41n
m0:13:04/1:47:41nAG
m0:21:13/1:47:41ncq
m0:28:08/1:47:41nF
m0:35:30/1:47:41nTÍ
m0:43:25/1:47:41nRa
m0:47:35/1:47:41ngcq
m0:54:27/1:47:41n_
m0:59:28/1:47:41nbZ[WЉ
m1:03:25/1:47:41nψ
m1:08:04/1:47:41nJp̂肢
m1:09:06/1:47:41neEen悩̌ӕ\
m1:46:21/1:47:41nAs[̑
@
@
Cf֘Ae

TPPy΁@exr[J[ficW[ij
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/667.html
e Ԃ 2016N330

TPPΑj~ׂRǂɂ邩[iAGj
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/739.html
e Ԃ 2016N401

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/750.html

[eXg31] eXg
̂ITPP@
N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
ANV
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/p/home.html

## ̂藘vD悷TPPɁuNOvI

@N10Ɂu؍ӁvA2412ł̏sꂽTPPB{{͎b艼JĂ܂A蕶͖{ƕtł5000y[W𒴂cȗʂłAt񍑊ԌȂǊ֘AׂĂJE|󂳂Ă킯ł܂BTPP̑S̑\ɔcA̕炵{ЉɂƂĂ̖⌜O𐸍邱Ƃ͂܂܂ԂƂ܂Bč͂ߊełA蕶̌Jȍ~Acsĉ͂ƖN𑱂Ă܂
B
@TPP͔_Yi̊֐ł̖łȂAZAḦSHi\AT[rXfՑSʂ܂łAɂ͍LƂdqȂǂ܂ł̖fՋɂȂJ@[ɑɂ킽ełB

@{{͊֘A@Ă܂Ƃ߁A3ɂʈψݒu4ŷ߂̐Rc{iƂĂ܂B\ȏJƋc_AƁEêɂڍׂȉe]ȂȂ܂܁uy肫vŐRciނƂ͐΂ɔȂ΂Ȃ܂B

@TPPɋOsćE_ƒćEJgȂǂ11ɁuTPPeLXg̓[v𗧂グA_܂Ƃ߂Ă܂B̂ёQ񍐂ƂāAL̂ƂJ̕񍐏WsȂ܂B̕XƖLALc_NƈꓯĂ܂B
@
@

### ̂܂ܔy킯ɂ͂ȂI ȂɂłANV

1DƑEFlƘbI
܂͐g߂Ȑlɓ܂傤BЁÃ[tbgpB
2D͂ɍL߂悤I
׋ATPPJtFȂǂJ܂񂩁BeLXg̓[ɍs܂B
3Dcɓ悤I
TPP͓ĂyȂΔ܂Bn̍cɁAyj~𓭂܂傤B
@
@
sooeLXg̓[
RcFi_ѐYbATPP~Eጛỉׂj
cqiAWAmZ^[ǒj
ߓNjiTPPɔ΂lX̉^j
acmiTPP~Eጛỉׂ\Aٌmj
RYNiTPPɔ΂lX̉^Awj
R@ikCwyj
Oji_Aەj
iSHAǒj
ViSیc̘Aj
z{biSJAۋǁj
O_iTPP~EጛỉׂAٌmj

₢킹
c@l@AWAmZ^[iPARC)
mAȗn
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/p/tpp-text.html

### ̂ITPP

ł͋蕶͂̕킩Ƃ킩₷܂B
yTPPeLXg͇@z_Yi̊֐
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/blog-post_28.html
yTPPeLXg͇AzÁEیҁF򉿂AƂ̎v܂܂ɁH
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/tpp_31.html
yTPPeLXg͇BzmIYFč̒쌠VXe
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/04/tpp.html
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
2016N331ؗj
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/tpp.html

### ̂ITPP\[tbgI݂ȂōL܂傤

TPPeLXg̓[͍N11ȍ~ATPP蕶͂̕ƌʂ̔MsȂĂ܂B
񍐏4łƂȂÅF܂ɂpĂ܂Au񍐏̒gĂ悭킩ȂvulTPP̖ǁA킩₷łȂvȂǂ̐Ă܂B

ŁA[ł͂̂сAûITPPvƑ肵[tbg𐧍삵܂B

m̂ITPP@N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
@ 2016N330@TPPeLXg̓[iS9y[Wjn

LPDFɂĂ܂BEzzERłB

܂قIƂ́Aߓɐ\݃VXe𐮂܂̂ŁA҂B

[tbgPDF͂炩_E[hł܂B
http://www.parc-jp.org/teigen/img/tpp_leaflet.pdf
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
2016N329Ηj
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/ver4.html

### sooeLXg̓|[gver.4[X܂I

330AsooeLXg̓[͕̓|[g ver.4[X܂B

mTPP̑S̑Ɩ_\sĉɂ镪͕񍐁\ Ver.4
@ 2016N43 TPPeLXg̓[iS140y[Wjn

ЂpBŃ_E[h\łB

_E[h͂炩
http://www.parc-jp.org/teigen/2016/TPPtextanalysis_ver.4.pdf
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
me҃Rgn

TPP̑S̑Ɩ_ɂāA_ł̍ŐVŏڍׂȕ͂񋟂ĂĂƎvTCg̏ЉB̓̕|[g(ver.4)̂140y[WĂɓ\Ȃ̂ŁA_E[h̃N݂̂tB̏ꍇɂ͂̃TCgق̋Lł͓̕eڂmFƂɎQƂƂgɂȂ邾낤B

TPP̖߂ẮAÂ񂪃Abvf[gȂ܂܁A͂܂񂪏CȂ܂܊gUĂꍇ̂ŁACȂƂȂB̂Łu܂͐g߂Ȑlɓ܂傤vB

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/475.html

[GkEStory41] ̂ITPP@ N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
̂ITPP@
N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
ANV
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/p/home.html

### ̂藘vD悷TPPɁuNOvI

@N10Ɂu؍ӁvA2412ł̏sꂽTPPB{{͎b艼JĂ܂A蕶͖{ƕtł5000y[W𒴂cȗʂłAt񍑊ԌȂǊ֘AׂĂJE|󂳂Ă킯ł܂BTPP̑S̑\ɔcA̕炵{ЉɂƂĂ̖⌜O𐸍邱Ƃ͂܂܂ԂƂ܂Bč͂ߊełA蕶̌Jȍ~Acsĉ͂ƖN𑱂Ă܂B
@TPP͔_Yi̊֐ł̖łȂAZAḦSHi\AT[rXfՑSʂ܂łAɂ͍LƂdqȂǂ܂ł̖fՋɂȂJ@[ɑɂ킽ełB
@{{͊֘A@Ă܂Ƃ߁A3ɂʈψݒu4ŷ߂̐Rc{iƂĂ܂B\ȏJƋc_AƁEêɂڍׂȉe]ȂȂ܂܁uy肫vŐRciނƂ͐΂ɔȂ΂Ȃ܂B
@TPPɋOsćE_ƒćEJgȂǂ11ɁuTPPeLXg̓[v𗧂グA_܂Ƃ߂Ă܂B̂ёQ񍐂ƂāAL̂ƂJ̕񍐏WsȂ܂B̕XƖLALc_NƈꓯĂ܂B
@

### ̂܂ܔy킯ɂ͂ȂI ȂɂłANV

1DƑEFlƘbI
܂͐g߂Ȑlɓ܂傤BЁÃ[tbgpB
2D͂ɍL߂悤I
׋ATPPJtFȂǂJ܂񂩁BeLXg̓[ɍs܂B
3Dcɓ悤I
TPP͓ĂyȂΔ܂Bn̍cɁAyj~𓭂܂傤B
@
@
sooeLXg̓[
RcFi_ѐYbATPP~Eጛỉׂj
cqiAWAmZ^[ǒj
ߓNjiTPPɔ΂lX̉^j
acmiTPP~Eጛỉׂ\Aٌmj
RYNiTPPɔ΂lX̉^Awj
R@ikCwyj
Oji_Aەj
iSHAǒj
ViSیc̘Aj
z{biSJAۋǁj
O_iTPP~EጛỉׂAٌmj

₢킹
c@l@AWAmZ^[iPARC)
mAȗn
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/p/tpp-text.html

### ̂ITPP

ł͋蕶͂̕킩Ƃ킩₷܂B
yTPPeLXg͇@z_Yi̊֐
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/blog-post_28.html
yTPPeLXg͇AzÁEیҁF򉿂AƂ̎v܂܂ɁH
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/tpp_31.html
yTPPeLXg͇BzmIYFč̒쌠VXe
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/04/tpp.html
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
2016N331ؗj
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/tpp.html

### ̂ITPP\[tbgI݂ȂōL܂傤

TPPeLXg̓[͍N11ȍ~ATPP蕶͂̕ƌʂ̔MsȂĂ܂B
񍐏4łƂȂÅF܂ɂpĂ܂Au񍐏̒gĂ悭킩ȂvulTPP̖ǁA킩₷łȂvȂǂ̐Ă܂B
ŁA[ł͂̂сAûITPPvƑ肵[tbg𐧍삵܂B
m̂ITPP@N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
@ 2016N330@TPPeLXg̓[iS9y[Wjn
LPDFɂĂ܂BEzzERłB
܂قIƂ́Aߓɐ\݃VXe𐮂܂̂ŁA҂B
[tbgPDF͂炩_E[hł܂B
http://www.parc-jp.org/teigen/img/tpp_leaflet.pdf
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
2016N329Ηj
http://notppaction.blogspot.jp/2016/03/ver4.html

### sooeLXg̓|[gver.4[X܂I

330AsooeLXg̓[͕̓|[g ver.4[X܂B
mTPP̑S̑Ɩ_\sĉɂ镪͕񍐁\ Ver.4
@ 2016N43 TPPeLXg̓[iS140y[Wjn
ЂpBŃ_E[h\łB
_E[h͂炩
http://www.parc-jp.org/teigen/2016/TPPtextanalysis_ver.4.pdf
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
me҃Rgn
TPP̑S̑Ɩ_ɂāAŐVŏڍׂȕ͂񋟂ĂĂƎvTCg̏ЉB̓̕|[g(ver.4)̂140y[WĂɓ\Ȃ̂ŁA_E[h̃N݂̂tBe҂̏ꍇɂ́ÃTCgق̋LŏЉĂe킵mFƂɎQƂƂgɂȂ邾낤BTPP̖߂ẮAÂ񂪃Abvf[gȂ܂܁A͂܂񂪏CȂ܂܊gUĂ(gUĂ܂)Ƃ̂ŁACȂƂȂB̂Łu܂͐g߂Ȑlɓ܂傤vB

http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/329.html
[EIEmgj203] ̂ITPP@ N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩FGkN
̂ITPP@ N̂߁H ̂߁H TPP蕶킩
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/329.html
e G̎ 2016N404 01:36:06
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo203/msg/848.html
[EIEmgj204] VT͕ς@VT摍xACiĎR10N̂߂Ɂj
VT͕ς@VT摍xAC
http://www.election.ne.jp/10840/98878.html
ĎR10N̂߂Ɂ@2016/4/06 20:23:09
@
@
@i}CŁA̐VT摍xACF߂ARQVɂ̂ڂĖi}VTxƂȂƂ̒ʒm𒸂܂Bς肪vĂ܂B

@āA܂łȂ̂܂񂪁AVT́A̐܂̋{nɂāAPONÔQOOTNɑIɏoāARIłi΁jB}Eł钷cɂ͓ςbɂȂ܂AnEEEł߂đIɔɋł邱Ƃ܂A܂ł܂B

@́AT̊FɁAĖ₢Ǝv܂B

ûPONԂŁAT͕ς܂H{͕ς܂HȂ̐͗ǂȂ܂HvƁB

@QOOTN򐭌́AϊvfėXUɑłďo܂B̏򐭌ɂ́A{ςCT݂ȂĂ܂B
@̏򐭌pt̐ANvAHARN[glւ̌ƉvfĒD悵}ɂ܂Av̋@^Ă܂B
@̓F̋ɂ́AuŁAFNƂ炦悤ɂȂBŕ[āASĕ点悤ɂȂAHgāA{WBvƂ]Ǝv܂B

@Á̖A}ƂƂɁAׂ܂B
̌{́AuAxm~NXvfĈA|IȎxwiɁA͍\ł߂܂ẢߒŁA͂̊Ԃɂ苌^}ɗ߂A]^̔ƂŎqĂ͕̕uAN̂ƌN̎󋋊zi𐥐悤Ƃc_ȂȂAH̗͋ɕA̐lɂ̒ቺɋꂵ݁AiC͒܂܉񕜂An͐lɂł̊@ɕmĂ܂Bċ̃RVqJ͂߂ƂT̔_Ƃ́AsooΔ΂f͂̎}ɂ֐œPpŁAł̊@ɕmĂ܂B

͂AςƎvĂ܂BPONԎuŁA{̖̐{̖_|xɌŒ艻ꂽ^}ASɐxJNĂ邱Ɓ|𐳖ʂvAɑEЉ肽ƎvĂ܂B
@n̓yؔ݃Ctɕ΂Ƃ́Aőn̕SƂȂAAقǂn𔭓WȂƂ͊ɏ\킩Ǝv܂BȂAۈ{݁A{݁Aa@̒g␧xAuCtvuƁvɁAgׂłBĖ{ɂ̐VTňSĕ点悤ɂȂĂAVT͔W܂B
N̕s͉ς炸A^ʖڂɓāAꐶN𕥂ĂlAVŒ̐łȂ̂́A܂ɗssłBNłNłAƔN𕥂ėA̔NŁAVASz邱ƂȂ󂯂鐧xAׂłBĖ{ɂ̐VTňSĘV𑗂悤ɂȂĂAg債AVT͔W܂B
lЉ̒ŁAVH́Agl܂B̓HSɁAIɎg悤ɂ邱Ƃoς̔WɂȂ܂BĤ݂P^QP^RAIɂ͖ɂāi̐ɂ͍ăWׂłjAAɐE̐VTւ̃ANZX߂ׂłBĐVŤoϓI֐߂ĂAVT͔W܂B
EɌւVT̔_Ƃ́AusooΔ΁Iv̉ߋ𕢂BA}I_Ɠy؂ł͎܂B}A}yؗ\Ẑ߂ɔ̏p~肵Ă˕ʏ⏞x𕜊AĈ_ƂSĔ_ƂɎg߂鐧x\zׂłBāAsooɂĂA{ɊzɊ_Ƃx鐧xĂAVT̔_Ƃ͔W܂B

@Ă̐́AVT݂̂Ȃ炸AS̒nA܂߂{ŜɁAKpł̂Ǝ͎v܂B

̐s邽߂ɁAVTƓ{ς邽߂ɁAVTƑS̒nƓ{ŜɏZނׂĂ̐l{ɐǂȂƎł鐭邽߂ɁAS͂Ŋ撣낤Ǝv܂B
@
VT̊FAǂ낵肢܂B

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@i}VTI摍x
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@x@@@ĎR@

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
me҂̃Rgn

ĎRꎁB͂ߎQ@IVIɈېV̓}痧\ĂAꎞ͖}ij}ƂėiƂ񂶂ꂽBAi}VT摍xɏACB̃uO񍐂ЉB

@
@@@i5jGlM[
@q͔d̈S̊mۂ́A΂ɒB
@ׂۑłBĂƓɁAȊwIm
@璷IɈIȃGlM[mۂ
@ĂA{ɈSESɃGlM[
@gƂ\ɂȂ܂B
@http://www.yoneyamaryuichi.com/idea.html

eFƎ󂯎邱̂悤Ȑ̂΁A邢͂܂߂ĂƂׂȂ̂AĎR͂܂Ȃ̍ێ琭Ƃłi܂cɂ͂ȂĂȂjBw{wɂ͍OY[~ŕ׋Ƃ̂ÂƂobN{[̈ɂȂĂ̂낤B̂悤Ȑl}̐ƂɂȂȂ(VŤF͂ꂽ)ƂƂɂȂɂ뎞オĂB

[GkEStory41] GUxXEEH[ujꂽ񑩁vi2015N518jmn
GUxXEEH[ujꂽ񑩁vi2015N518jmn
Broken Promises: Decades of Failure to Enforce Labor Standards in Free Trade Agreements
Prepared by the Staff of Sen. Elizabeth WarreniMAY 18, 2015j
http://www.warren.senate.gov/files/documents/BrokenPromises.pdf

jꂽ񑩁F
RfՋɂJ{s̎s20N
쐬F GUxXEEH[@cX^bt

@
mp.1n

Tv

@@cł͂܂ȂA2015N}hcf՗D挠ӔC@āiTPA@āj\\t@XgEgbNifՑij\\̌悤ƂĂBIo}哝̂́Amp[gi[VbviTPPj̑Ì~邽߁AfՑicɋ߂BTPṔAEoς40%߂߂12ɂK͂ȖfՋłBIo}哝̂͌JԂqׂĂBTPP͘JAAlɂĂ̍ujłi񂾖fՖ@āvłƁB哝̂́ATPPu荂JA荂vсuXɐӔCViv邱ƂɂȂƎ咣B

Aߋ20NԂ̂قƂǂׂĂ̎RfՋiFTAj̐i҂́A܂Ƃ咣ĂB

E@1993NANg哝̂͂咣BukĎRfՋiNAFTAj́A̖ɐʂgށA荑Ɏ̘J҂јJɂĂȂׂƂɎg܂鏉߂Ă̋łB̂悤Ȃ̂͂܂łɂȂvƁB

E@2005NAĒʏ\mUSTRñuE|[g}͂咣BuiĎRfՋmCAFTAńj܂łɕčǂȖfՋ͂ȘJEvƁB

E@2007NAUSTR̃X[UEVu͂咣By[ARrAApi}Ƃ̖fՋɂ́uĂȂقǂ̘Jъ̕یv荞܂ĂƁB

E@2010NAIo}哝̂͂B؍Ƃ̋ɂ́uIȘJ҂̌یv܂܂ꂽƁB

E@2011NAzCgnEX͂咣BRrAƂ̖fՋɂ́AufՋɍJgݍނ߂2007N510AMc}hŏFsɂƂÂAJ҂̌̋͂ȕی삪܂܂ꂽvƁBIo}哝̂́A2012NɂBuJ҂ъ̋͂ȕیK̋́A̘J҂ƊɂƂĂ̏łA͂̐ӔC܂Ƃ̂vƁB

E@̐Api}Ƃ̎RfՋɂāAzCgnEX͂قƂǓƂ咣B

mp.2n

A̋̌o߂͌I悵ĂFߋ̕čRfՋ̘J̎{śA񑩂ꂽƂɂ͂邩ɗxĂB̃EH[@c̃X^btɂ镪͂炩ɂ̂́AčA20Nɂ킽lȖ񑩂ɂ炸ARfՋ̋̎{ɂE̓KpɂsĂƂƂłB

xxARfՋ̐i҂́Ax͐VfՋ肪͂ŗLӋȕیƂ咣Âтɂ̕یł͍ň̐NQH~߂ȂƂ炩ɂȂB}Aa}ɂ炸܂ł̑哝̂s悤ƂAɂׂ̂ŁA@KキĘJAی삳ĂȂXł͋̏[Ač̘J҂Ɗ֌Wĉ͋ɗȂԂɂꂽB͂̕ł́ÂƂ炩ɂȂF

E@č́AfՋ̘JیsĂȂB}h̐{č@iGAOjɂA̕񍐂JȁiDOLjэȂɂ񍐂́A̎RfՋ葊荑ɂdŏKIȘJNQ؋ĂĂBGAÓA荑ɂ̗sƊē@ւɂēɌF߂A_ÂBUSTRDOĹAuFTA̘J̏gDIɊĎA{sĂȂvƁB܂Ač̋@ւ͊Tāu̖̔FAɂΉƎsvȂĂȂƁB

E@č́As𐋍sƂقƂǂȂBDOL͎RfՋł̘JNQ̐Ȑ\Ă2008N܂ł1󗝂ĂȂB̌AIo}Ő\ĂɂĂ̓OꂵȂAԕ񍐂ƒ񌾂\BłDOĹAJ_ᔽ̂Xɂ5̍󗝂A2014N6NO̐\ĂɂĂ̋s\\͕č̎RfՋł͏߂Ă̂̂ƂȂ\\̍ĊJɍӂB̂Ƃ́A\Ď葱̍ƁA̋sŜ̖߂ĂB

E@ň̌NQɂ~߂ȂBčRfՋł邢̍XɂĂ̎ጤ́Ap̂낵Js҂𖾂炩ɂĂBOAe}́AčƂ̖fՋɉĂ5NɁAuJgɂƂĐE댯ȍvɋꂽBRrAł́ANɂ킽FTA邽߂ɓʂɍ肳ꂽJ[uviLabor Action Planj݂̑ɂ炸Ǎv悪4NOɐĈȗA105l̘JgƂEQA1337lEQ̋󂯂B

mp.3n

1.@_FIo}{TPPjłiIȖfՋɂȂƎ咣

@@cł͂܂ȂA2015N}hcf՗D挠ӔC@āiTPA@āj\\\t@XgEgbNifՑij\\̌悤ƂĂBIo}哝̂́Amp[gi[VbviTPPj̑Ì~邽߁AfՑicɋ߂BTPṔAEoς40%߂߂12ɂK͂ȖfՋłBIo}哝̂͂ʂŁAŏIIȋ肪JAAl̖ʂŁujłiIȖfՋvɂȂ邾낤Ǝ咣ĂB1 ƂΑ哝̂͐挎̂悤ɐ錾F2

u͂mMĂB͗jłiIȖfՖ@ĂɂȂBɂ͂܂܂ł̋ɂ͂Ȃ悤ȘJAAlی삪荞܂Bv

zCgnEX̊T񍐏͑哝̖̂񑩂ɓĂF3

uTPPʂāANAFTAČA苭͂ŊSȋ͂̂JA݂悤ƂĂB̍́Al͂̂J̂Ƃɂ݂тAEL̋}nтŊ@ɕm쐶ی삷邾ł͂Ȃ\\fՑ荑̃[ɏ]킹邱ƂŁA킪̘J҂ƊƂ̏ɂBv

@zCgnEXTPPɂāAuCmی삵An̍LłȂĂ쐶̖▧A@̂Ɛ키AjłɗDfՋvłƏ̂ĂB4 ܂ATPṔuŒAJԁAJSqɂĂ̋IvvɂuJグvƎ咣ĂB5

@USTRɂ΁A哝̂́uSȋ͂̂JfՋ肾xvƂƁAŏIӂuIȎJ⋭JƐ킢ٗpʂj~Vi񋟂ALVRуJi_Ƃ̖fՋɊ܂܂{IȘJgݍ񂾂̂ɂȂvƂAu˂ɖmɂĂvB6

@vȐ{ǎ҂́A悤Ȏ咣JԂĂBzCgnEXɂ΁A̋́uv́Aul͂̂J̂Ƃɂ݂тAEL̋}nтŊ@ɕm쐶ی삷邾ł͂Ȃ\\fՑ荑̃[ɏ]킹邱ƂŁA킪̘J҂ƊƂ̏ɂBv7

2.@܂ł̖fՋɂĂ̖

@Io}TPPɂĂ̖񑩂͐V̂ł͂ȂB20Nȏɂ킽āB勤a}̑哝̂́A{ɂfՋ̌ɂĂ͕č̘J҂̗vŗDɂ邱Ƃ񑩂ĂBNAFTACAFTA͂܂ċߔÑy[ARrAApi}A؍Ƃ̋ɂ܂ŁA̖fՋ̐i҂́AxxxA蓯Ƃ񑩂ĂB

A.@Ng哝̂̂ƂłNAFTA

mȗn

mp.4n

B.@W[WEWEubV哝̂̂ƂłCAFTA-DR

mȗn

C.@ubV哝̂̂Ƃł̃y[ƂFTA

mȗn

mp.5-6n

D.@Io}哝̂̂Ƃł̊؍ARrAApi}Ƃ̋

mȗn

mp.7n

3.@jꂽ񑩁F

@{čƂɂA̕񍐂́ARfՋ葊荑ł̘JAAl̖ɂĂ̎ᕪ͂Ƃ킹āA勤a}̑哝̖̂񑩂ɂ炸A΂ΎRfՋ肪荑ł̊ᔽ邢͖h~邱ƂłȂƂ𖾂炩ɂĂB

A.@GAOɂF

@2014NAGAOi{č@j́As̎RfՋ̎vȘJ̎{󋵂ɂĂ̓Oꂵ]͂ȂBGAÓA󋵂ɂĂ͋ɉP݂ƎwEȂAL͂ɌŒ݂Ƃ߂B񍐂ɂΎ̒ʂłF25

ułȘJNQ𐭕{@ւ񍐂AGAOF肵BƂ΁A\Ɏ{Ă炸Aڌٗp邽߂ɉgĂARrAƃOAe}ł͘Jg̎w҂ɂĖ\sBv

͐V̂ł͂Ȃ\̑2009N̓lGAO񍐂łmFĂA̐{Ώ邱Ƃ𐾂B27 GAO͊֌W@ւ̑Ή4NԂ킵ǐՂẢPƂؖB2014N̕񍐂́A֌WʂA@ւi菔ł̐iF߂̂A̎g݂ɂdȖ肪邱ƂȂmFBGAO͂̂悤Ɍ_ÂBUSTRDOĹuFTAJ̏gDIɊĎA{sĂȂvƁB28 ܂Ač̋@ւ͊Tāu̖̔FA܂ɂΉƎs[uvȂĂȂƁB29

mp.8n

B.@JAlgAlɂ񂷂JȂэȂ̕

@lɁAȂ͐Ee̐lɂĔN񍐏\ĂB31 ɂ͘J҂̐lɂĂ̏񂪊܂܂ĂBčƂ̎RfՋ肪Ă17ŁA񍐏͒ژJJɊ֌WlNQmFB10iRrAAh~jJaAGTohAOAe}AzWXA_ALVRAbRAjJOAApi}jŁA񍐏͘Jɂ񂷂ƁAlNQ̐ӔC҂߂ɖĂȂƂmFB

@Ƃ΁ALVRɂ́uJ̍vB32 zWXł́uJ@LɎsȂƁvAuJvAuƐӂ͂т点i@x̎コvȂǂ̐[Ȗ肪B33 _ł́u{J𐧌ĂAOlƎJ҂ւ̋s҂O̐lĉ񍐂ĂvBuƐӂ͖܂܂łA{͐lNQ{ANiA\ȑ[uuĂȂBv34

C.@sRfՋ获s̏ڍח

I.@y[Ƃ̎RfՋł̔jꂽ

@y[Ƃ̎RfՋ2009NɔB̕čEy[fՑiiPTPAj́AUSTR̂Ƃ́uEJیɂ񂷂Iȏv܂łB35 APTPA̔ȍ~Ay[͑lȎYƕŎJƋJ𗘗pĂ邱Ƃ񍐂ĂB邢̓A}]̈@؍ނAoÂĂB2014Nɂ́AO̓U邽߂ɁA܂ł̊یƈSqK̑傪ȈȂB

@DOLiJȁjɂ΁Ay[AARJAԉ΁AHȋ͎JŐYĂBuWibcƖ؍ސi͐lg܂ދJŐYĂBi͎JƋJ̗ŐYĂB36

mp.9n

@lɁAPTPA̔ȍ~̈@ȐXє̌ƐΖ̌@̋}gɂđ̒ǐՒȂꂽBmNGÓn@ցiEnvironmental InvestigationAgencyj2012N̕񍐂ɂ΁APTPA̔y2N̊ԂɁAy[čɈ@؍ނ100oׂꂽB37 2014N̂钲񍐂ɂ΁A@̂ւPTPȀɂ炸Ay[ŔF߂Ă锰̌70%߂ɂɂdȈᔽ^B38 ̕񍐂͎̂悤Ɍ_ÂĂF

u2009NɔčEy[fՑiiTPAjɂ́Ay[̐Xѕ̓ƐXю̎\ȊǗ邽߂̏dvȕt܂܂ĂBčEy[TPAĂAccw͂ɂ炸A\ȐXъǗ܂ɒBꂸAy[̃A}]ɂ͂т@̂Ă邱ƂƂAɖ炩ɂȂĂBv39

@2014N7Ay[́AJSqAȂ̎sȂAi̖ڂŊO̗vɘaƂꊇ@Ă𐬗B40 ̖@͈SqAɈᔽƂɂ锱𐧌B41 JA̑̎sĉ͂̊̈ᔻāAꂪ炩PTPAᔽłƎ咣B42 ̒ĉUSTRiĒʏ\jɂĂÄ𒆎~邽߂PTPA̎sKp悤ɋ߂BہA̈ȑOɁAłɃy[2009N̊ɏ]ĂȂƐ鍐ĂB43 ɂ炸AUSTR̂ƂΉ͏󋵂uvƂ̂łȂB44

II.@RrAƂ̎RfՋł̔jꂽ

@RrAƂFTAAMcŏFꂽƂAIo}哝̂́A肪uJAAmIYی삷vƏqׂB45 {́AƂ͕ʂ́uJ[uvv[LAP]iLabor Action PlanjɂĂ̗gBɂ́AuRrA̘Jgɂ\́A̎ElƂw͂̕sARrAł̘J҂̌ی̕svɂĂ̐{̌OɑΏ邽߂ɃRrA{ӂǍv悪ڏqĂB46

@AFTALAPJیɂ͂΂P炳ȂBNAmNGÓnt[_EnEXiFreedom Houseĵ͎悤ɎwEBLAṔuNQ̑{ƋsғIȘJs̎܂̋߂Ă邪A킸ȉPĂȂvƁB47 LAPŐMł񌹂ƂĔF߂ĂRrÁmNGOnSJgwZmENSniNational Union Schooljɂ΁A4NOLAP̐ȗA105l̑gƂEQA1337l̑gEQ̋󂯂B48 ܂AȂ́A2013N̎_ŁuigEQ́j{Ə͂͂ǂĂ炸AˑRƂč̖ƐӂvƔF肵B49

@USTRiĒʏ\jDOLiJȁj́ARrA̘J@s̎g݂ɂȂu傫ȉۑv邱ƂF߂ĂB2011NȗRrA{ɂĕ񍐂ꂽ110̘J֘A̎El̂ALߔ4ɂȂBgw҂Ƒgɂ鋺͂4NԂőĂɂ炸Aǂ̋܂ƂɉĂȂB50 Ȃ͂܂AuRrA{̉ۂɂ́ANQ҂}ʂقƂǂȂB͂΂ΒꂸɂÅƂ͔𕥂Ti邱ƂIvƎwEB51

mp.10n

@AFL-CIOičJEYƕʑgcj́Â悤Ɍ_ÂBúAٗp҂ɕsȂ߂[uƂAJȂ̍L񊈓ɂȂĂȂBv܂AJč̌ٗpsuč̍ٗʂƋZ\傫ȂĂBv52

@RrA̎J܂ݐis̖ɂ݂B2013NAȂ́ASyAΒYAGhAARJA|m̐Yɂ鎙J́u邵v񍐂BɁAzƂƌ݋Ƃł̎J̋֎~uقƂǖĂvƎwEB53

III.@OAe}iCAFTAjł̔jꂽ

@OAe}ł́ACAFTA-DRiĎRfՋj2006NɔB7NAۘJgAiITUCj́AOAe}uJgɂƂĐE댯ȍvƂċB54 ITUCɂ΁A2007NȗuȂƂ53l̑gw҂Ƒ\҂EQA؂Ȃقǂ̎ElAAUAAEQ̋BɂAJgȂǍsgłȂ|Ɩ\͂̕yꂽBv55

@̖̉̂߂ɕčvćAčوψv܂ŁA1NԒBوψ͗Vv邽߂ɉĂAv2013NɍӂɒBBAUSTRiĒʏ\j̊T񍐂͂̌v̂悤ɕ]BuOAe}{J@̎{s̉P̂߂ɖmȎԘĝȂŎsdvŋ̓Iȑ΍􂪊܂܂Aӗ~IAIȎ{vvłƁB58

@2013N̍Ȑl񍐏ɂ΁AumOe}n{́AЂ̎RAč̂߂ɁA邢͘JgʂɂāAʓIȖ@sȂȂBs\ȗ\ZzƔȖ@Es葱̂ŁA{̊֌W@ւ́AЂ̎RAčۏႷ@Ɉᔽٗp҂ʓIɑ{ANiAAgɎQ߂Ɉ@ɉقꂽJ҂𕜐E肷邱ƂłȂBv59

mp.11n

@2014N9AOAe}CAFTA-DR̋炷v̍ӂ炳1NAAFL-CIOƃOAe}̘JgDɂŏ̐\Ă6NɁAIo}{͂ɃOAe}ɂJs̖@I[uĊJƔ\B60 ŏ̌2015N6ɗ\肳ĂA̔\9ɂȂB61

IV.@GTohiCAFTAjł̔jꂽ

@CAFTA-DRiĎRfՋj̕ʂ̉AGToh́Aقǖ\͓Ił͂ȂA͂CAFTA̘J炷邤ł̏QɒʂĂB2013N̍Ȑl񍐏ɂ΁AGToh{́uȂꍇɂЂ̎RƒčۏႷ@ʓIɎsA~ϑ[uYʂ̂Ȃ܂܂Bi׎葱͒xƍTiŒBv62 ɁAuJgɂ鋺AJg悤Ƃ]ƈ̉فAvӐlXgւ̋LڂȂǂ̘Jgʂ񍐂ĂBv63 GAOi{č@j́AmGTohn{JȂ̗\Z𑝂₵@𑝈ɂ炸AčEɂ΁u@ǂ̎͂サĂȂvƂA܂Aٔ߂͂΂ΎsĂȂƂB64

@O[oJ҂̌Z^[iThe Center for Global Workers' RightsjƘJҌgiWorker Rights Consortiumjɂ񍐏́Â悤ɔF肵B65

@Ȑl񍐏͂܂AGToh̎Ju[ōLĂvłAuň̎J̓R[q[ƃTgELr͔̍|AƁAL̊kނAԉ΂̐łĂvƔF肵B񍐏͂܂AJȂɂ֘A@̎sɂ́uIȌʁvȂƎwEĂB66

mp.12n

4.@_

@TPP͂܂łōŋ̎RfՋ肾Ə̗gĂBÂ悤Ȏ咣𕷂̂͏߂Ă̂Ƃł͂ȂB1993NNAFTA肩ߔÑRrAApi}Ƃ̋ɂ܂ŁAߋ20NԂɔyꂽׂĂ̎RfՋɂāAi҂͓悤ȂƂ咣B

@łɂ́A勤a}̂ƂŁARfՋɂ20ŇoςłB̋̎x҂͂A肪J҂ی삷鋭łȊ܂łƐĂB

@A{͂͂ɂȂƂ𖾂炩ɂBRfՋ̘J̎s̖WƂȂL͂Ȗ⌇ׂ݂ĂBGAOi{č@j́AUSTRiĒʏ\jDOLiJȁjuFTAJ̏ɂđgDIȊĎA{sv67 Ă炸A܂Ač̋@ւTāu̖̔FƂɂΉƎs[uv68 ȂĂȂƌ_ÂBȂƘJȂɂ񍐏́AčƎRfՋXɁAJJNQɂẲȖ肪邱Ƃ𖾂炩ɂĂB

@̒ł̎ጤ́Ap̂낵Js҂𖾂݂ɂF@OAe}́AčƂ̖fՋɉĂ5NɁAuJgɂƂĐE댯ȍvɋꂽBRrAł́ANɂ킽FTA邽߂ɓʂɍ肳ꂽuJ[uvv݂̑ɂ炸ARfՋ̐ȗA105l̘JgƂEQA1337lEQ̋󂯂B
@
@
mp.13n
@

@

mp.14n

mp.15n

TPPɔ΂č̖}@cGUxXEEH[̕񍐏 "Broken Promises"i2015Nj̏BoȂɂ́mȗnƋLB

ŃEH[cɂďЉ񍐏̔wił΂̂AȂɂ듊e҂̓EH[Ƃc̑ݎ̂ŋߒm΂肾B̕񍐏̂Ƃ́AEH[TPPɂďꂽLɌyĂB񍐏̓{{ł̂킵ЉL݂Ȃ̂ŁAǂނłɖ󂵂ƂBe҂͉pflȂ̂ŁA킩ɂӏ͌QƂ킩邩ȂB󂪂RgŎwEACĂƂ肪BƂɌŗLp̖󂵕ɂ͎MȂBsK؂Ȗꂪ肻B

Ə΂炢̂Ȃ񂾂A̕񍐏ɂ͂قǏdvTPP֘A񂪏oĂ킯ł͂ȂBډ{TPPyɔ΂ĂʐlԂĂ݂݂܂ŒJɂ̕񍐏ǂޕKv͂ȂƎvB񍐏̘_|͂ƂĂVvȂ̂ŁA񍐏̊Tv2015NꂽuȌЉLǂނŏ\BނMׂȂ̂́Â悤Ȏ咣A{ōLʂĂTPPΘ_̂Ȃɂ߂ɂ݂ȂƂƂBč̖}ЂĂ͕čƂ𗝉邤ŁA̕񍐏͂ȂȂɕxłBtɂ΁A̕񍐏̓eɂ̂ȂɁAƎ̍̂̂܂܂̎pf̂ł͂ȂB̕񍐏ǂނƂŁAƂΓ{@̑OOVNɊ悤ɂȂ邩ȂB

͂̕񍐏̓ǂ݂ɂRɂ1Bp咣̌񂵂̏dڗAŜƂĂ̎dグǂ݂ĂeȂ̂Bׂp~X2BЂƂЂƂ̈poTƏƂ炵킹Ă͂Ȃ̂ŁAƂ܂邩ȂBC2̓Rs[y[XgĂ邩肠肦Ȃނ̃~XȂ̂ŁA̕񍐏̉ǂ̂悤ɏAǂ̂悤ɕҏWꂽ̂[Ƃ낾B̕񍐏̍쐬҂̓EH[ł͂ȂAEH[̃X^btƂȂĂBX^bt͓{ł΋c鏑ɂB@c̃X^bt͍ő50lɂԂ炵AX^btSĂ̂񂹏W߂Ŕ\Ă܂Ƃۂ󂯂Br̗͋ƂłȂ͂ȂB

Ȃ݂ɁAe҂EH[̂Ƃm̂́A挎{̖}ijōuXeBObcÂƃJi_̃I^włTPPɂē悤ȍuĂA̘b̂ȂɏoĂ炾B
Sense of the TPP i2016N41@SDM MDS/YOuTubej
XeBObcM񂹂EH[Ƃ̂͂ǂȐƂ낤Ǝvēǂ񂾂̋LɐkꂽB
"The Other Woman: Elizabeth Warren and the 2016 Election" by Robert Kuttneri2016N41@The American Prospectj
EH[̕񍐏̏Љ܂߁ATPP߂č̓|CgēĂ̂́Ae҂JĂ݂͈͂ł́A͂肱̃uOB
}XR~ɍڂȂCOL
̃uOEH[̕񍐏̔\ĹACfɂƓ]ڂĂB
EH[@cAIo}TPPɂԂāejꂽ񑩁f񍐏𔭕\i}XR~ɍڂȂCOLjie Ԃԁ@ 2015N522j

http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/335.html

[13] GUxXEEH[ujꂽ񑩁vi2015N518jmnFGkN
Ė}EH[@c2015NTPP̃t@XggbNɔ΂Ƃ̕񍐏
"Broken Promises: Decades of Failure to Enforce Labor Standards in Free Trade Agreements"

ŋߓǂƂ󂪂݂Ȃ̂ŏ󂵂B
j[X͂Ȃ̂ŁA܂Ȃ悤B

GUxXEEH[ujꂽ񑩁vi2015N518jmn
http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/335.html
e G̎ 2016 N 4 10 19:22:16:
http://www.asyura2.com/16/kokusai13/msg/318.html

[GkEStory41] lԂƎЉwCgXs[iMb~c_uEv2014N11 gXj
lԂƎЉwCgXs[iMb~c_uEv2014N11 gXj

## Mb~c_

EVl@t[C^[B1971NA㐶܂BݓRA2.5BNm2014Nn8AwCgXs[JԂuݓȂs̉viݓjƓ̍䐽Albg̃uO^c҂ɑQ߂iׂNB
₷E@W[iXgB1964NAÉ܂Bwlbgƈ\\ݓ́uŁvǂāxiukЁjJCJ܂ё34ukЃmtBNV܎܁B̒ɁAwOlCElxiXفjȂǁB

@wCgXs[̖{Ƃ͉

\\܁Aʂ\͂wCgXs[wCgfɂȂĂ܂B{̂ƂŒ؍Ƃ̊֌W钆AN͂قڈɈ̃wCgfsȂꂽƂ܂BŁAɔ΂s̃JE^[sĂ܂BwCgXs[ۂɂǂ̂悤ȔQ^Ă̂Aɂǂ΍RĂ΂̂A8ɒiƂIꂽMbƁAݓiݓȂs̉j𒷂ނĂcɌ荇Ă܂B

c@wCgXs[X̂Ƃ͒ɊĂ܂A҂󂯂Ăɂ݁AQ𔧂Ŋ悤ɂȂ̂́Ǎt𕷂ĂȂłB2013N224AōݓRA̐l炷ߋōݓ̃wCgfAƗ񂪎ނȂfɂĂ̂łB̂Ƃ́AݓɖOƊ炪mĂ闛񂪖wŔ排ȂA΂SzĂ܂B̓̃f򂵂܂Ȃ̂łAւ̌lU͂Ȃ܂܏IA͂łقƂłBŎ́u悩ˁvƁAɂĂ܂B͕\c߂āAāAuˁASLuĎ͂ƌĂ񂩁A͎ɌꂽtȂ́HvƁBď߂ċCB܂Ŏ́AwCgXs[ut̖\́vƍlĂ܂AȐՂ̂ł͂ȂB\͂̂̂Ə߂Ď̂łBɋCÂĂꂽɐS犴ӂĂ܂B

@2011NHɒNwŊJÂꂽ55NLOtFX^ނɍsƂA܂ł͖OmĂȂłAޒ̗lqBeāA̓lbgŗꂽƂŊ炪m킽悤ɂȂ܂Bŏ͋CÂȂӂāAقĂ܂B|łAԂ悤ȂƂ΁Au\͓IȒNlvƃlbgɏ܂邾ƎvĂłBۂɂ͖ق荞ނ悤ɎdĂ񂾂ƁAォCt܂ǂˁB̎AݓɒڐԂ΂悩łAڂ̑OɂcɎvԂĂ܂܂B

c@͂܂łwCgXs[󂯂Qґ̐SɂāAł͏qׂĂ܂A̒ߋł̈ꌏĂAwCgXs[͖\͂̂̂łAQ҂𐶂ݏoÂĂƂƂɊ܂BuˁvuEvƂt́A܂ɓ҂ɌĂBꂾłȂAɂlɂĂBRA̒ɍݓRA܂BQ҂ʎYĂ̂wCgXs[łA͂܂ɔƍ߂̂̂łBӖœ̓Iȏ[S悤ȍsׂłB
@wCgXs[̖{𖾊mɈӎ悤ɂȂẮACŃfɑΛ悤ɂȂ܂B܂ł́AȂwCgXs[f悤ɂȂ̂ƂނĂ܂Aꂩ́AݍŁAwCgXs[𐧎~邽߂̎dȂƂȂɗĂƎv܂BQ҂̐SAɔQ󂯂Ăl邱ƂlȂ΂ȂȂƂƂłB
@wCgXs[߂Ă߂ɁAA񂪑I񂾒iƂ́AɗLƎv܂BAȏ̔Q̊gh߂Ƃ͂AȂQ҂ɖʂɗȂ΂Ȃ̂BiECsׂƂ]AɎ񓯈ӂ͂܂A̎Љ͂ȂQ҂ʂɗȂƖ肪łȂ̂BxvłB

@Ȃiɓݐ؂̂

\\񂪒iɓݐ؂o܂ɂċĂB

@sNꏉwZ̍ٔTAL𔭕\ĂߒŁAݓ狺󂯂悤ɂȂ܂B
@2013N29AVvۂŁAuVЉ^vƂĉ̎ÁAݓ^Ŕ؃f܂B̌11ɃcCb^[ŁuǂNlNlǂoBł́iMb̂Ɓj͎E낤vƂ݂AׂĂƁA񂾂̂͂ݓ̃o[ƂƂ킩܂B̐l200lK͂̃fÂĂlłAe͂lԂłA͌x@ɘA܂B́uyvCŏ悤łAuEvƌꂽ́A܂̂ł͂܂BƑOサāAlbg̃̕nhl[̐lɑ΂liGA˂悤ɂȂ܂B

c@lbgŗ񂪍U悤ɂȂ̂͂납łB

@l̔ԑgɏo2011N6A7납łB

c@łˁBݓRA\̂悤ȌŁuvIȃlɏoAǗ̓Ă܂ˁB̉fڂɂƂA͍𔲂قǋ܂BȂAȕsȋc_WJꏊɗĂяôBȂA͈lł̂悤ȏꏊɏoĂ̂Blւ̏oŗ̊ƖOvĂ܂A痛ւ̍ÛłˁBޏނтɁAu֋AvƂᑭȔliG܂B

@ƂƃcCb^[uOōݓRA͂ƍȖΏۂłBlbgEilbg̉Ej͍ݓRÃ~NVB̃R~jeBcCb^[̃XgĂ͍UĂ܂AcCb^[ł͍ݓƂŗ܂܂BlɏốAێIȎ]_ƂɎނ\񂾂ƂŃIt@[̂łBC^[A܂ŁAɐĐl悤ȍƂĂ܂ĂȂBlǂȉȂ̂͒mĂ܂AĂꏊɏoāAN҂ɂȂĂ܂ȂƂCłB

c@oƂ܂Ał邾AEF[̏ꏊɂ悤ɂĂ܂Bł͓{l̒jŁȀꍇ͂܂ႤB

@ȍ炷ɖqɂȂqǂłi΁jBmȂꏊɍsƂɂSO܂B

@܂Ȃx@

\\قǌx@ɑkꂽƂ̂ƂłAΉ͂ǂ̂悤Ȃ̂łB

@lbgł̎ւ̋ȂǂɂẮAǁAYƂċNi܂łBuEvȂǂƏ݂܂Ƃ߂f[^ĂAlbĝ܂܂Ȍ点ɂĂ܂Bݓ̍䐽ɑ΂ČܐB𑗂悤ƂbĂƂ܂BAlbg̒́AƂ̂Ƃ̂ŁAu茾tɔtł͂ȂvƁBAĂ͏̃Abvʐ^𑗂Ă邱ƂȂǂĂ܂A낢ƓǂނɑςȂƂlbgɏł킯łBłx@́Au摜ɂ̓UCNĂvƂĖɂĂ܂łB肪ȂȂłȂƂƎv܂BܐBɂĂuE\͂ȂvƂuۂɑꂽ킯ł͂ȂvƌĂ܂ˁB

c@x@͋Ǝ󂯎~߂ȂH

@łBłB14000l̉ĉÂlĂ킯łB̒ɂ͂ǂȐl邩킩ȂBi܂AǁAx@͎𖼎wāuEvƌޑɂȊÓA܂ƂɎ舵܂łB
@ޑɂȂAٌ̕m玦kɂƂA܂A͌x@ɍđ{肢܂Bk󂯂C͂ȂłB́AɁuEvƌĂlԂłȂÂĂݓ̉̍Ȃǂł邩łBŁAނ̐ӔCɒǋyׂx@ɑîłAx@͍đ{Ƃ͌̂́Aۂɂ͉܂łBłAx@ɍsĂʂƎv悤ɂȂ܂B
@ŁAٔɕKvȌo̐SẑłANwZ̍ٔł悢oゾ̂ŁAٌmɑkiɗĂāB

c@Œiꂽ킯łˁB

@ʂŋ҂yȂ

c@́Aݓ̍䂾ł͂ȂAC^[lbǵu܂Ƃ߃TCgvƌuێ瑬v̊Ǘl킹Ēi܂ˁB܂Ƃ߃TCg͂߂ĈŁA̖m炵߂Ȃ΂ȂȂ̂łAi锭z͎Ă܂łBȂi悤Ǝv̂łB

@́Aʂŋ҂ł邩łB

c@ʓIȕA˂ăANZXW߂āAAtBGCgA܂lbgLȂǂŋ҂łB߂ĉȕ\ōݓ@Ă2˂Ȃǂ̃lbgf͂̕u܂Ƃ߁vĂ킯łAƂƒN̂͂킩ȂBŒ߂Ă܂l킯ǁÁAЂǂ݂Wč\zĂ܂Ƃ߃TCgiB͂ƂĂIƎv܂B

@lbgɍʂłlԂłȂAĂlԂiȂ΂ȂȂAlɂꂽ̂łBsNwZ̍ٔł́A͏ؐlƂĂoĂȂB䂪퍐Ƃďo삵ȂƂBĂ{X̂̂ƂĂ邱Ƃ܂łB_Iɂςɂ͂Ȃ܂Ał͂͑iȂ΂ȂB

c@_łłɁuʁv͏oĂ܂ˁBuێ瑬vłȂÂ܂Ƃ߃TCg}܂BAقǌƂ̌JԂɂȂĂ܂܂A҂܂œȂΏ󋵂ςȂƂƂAłB

@lbgɖɂ鍷ʓIȏ݂⓮ɂΉ̂͑ςłAeؖ𑗂č폜߂΍폜邱ƂȂ܂B

c@TCg肾Ǝv̂́AwCgXs[̂܂ܐꗬɂĂ邱ƂłBHfƓl̔Q҂𐶂ł킯ŁAłB̐lԂe鍷ʓIȓɂĐVȔQ܂ĂƂւ̑z͂Ɗ@ӎATCg̉^cЂȂǂɌ@ĂB

@cCb^[ʓIȏ݂̂łA^cЂɒʕ񂵂ĂAԐMpȂłˁi΁jB{ŃT[rX񋟂Ă񂾂A{ŕԎĂقB

@lԂЉ󂷃wCgXs[

\\{̃wCgfɑ΂čAȂǂłOĂ܂AߔN̏󋵂ƂĂ͂ł傤B

c@ݓ̘HfɎQl͌Œ艻ĂĂ܂ˁAf̋K͂g債lĂƂƂ͂܂B
@A͖͍ݓł͂ȂƎvĂ܂Bݓ͈̏ےłāAݓC{̎ЉɍL܂邱ƂłBݓ̎咣HŐZ邱Ƃ́AJE^[݂ȏAȂƎv܂Bf鑤ɐguĂ݂ƁAJE^[甽̂͋낵Bōݓ̃fɎQȂȂlۂɒmĂ܂BJE^[́AMM̂Ƃōݓ̖\H~߂ĂꂽƎv܂B
@Ƃ͂A咣̂̂ւ̎^҂͂܂Ȃ܂BێhAEƂl̒ɂAHŁuˁvuEvƋԍݓɂ͎^͂łȂǂAݓ̓\\Ȃ̂͂Ȃ̂ł\\ɂ͔΂Ƃ咣̂̂͐ƍllԂ܂B̂ƂɁAƊ@قƎv܂BہA݂̐́Aݓ̎咣ɉ悤ȐłoĂĂ킯łBƂĂЉ̐ӔClȂƂȂB
@wCgXs[́AlԂĂ邾łȂAЉ󂵂ĂƂƂA͋Ǝv܂B

@lɏoƂA̐l݂͂ȍݓے肵Ă܂BłA݂ĂĂ̂͂Ȃł͂Ȃ̂AƓSł͎v܂ˁB݂ݓlBނ́u{v^āuێvCAuvƐɎ咣ȂA̎͂ɂlԂ邱ƂłĂȂBނ炪ݓOlz[XAVO}U[ƂЉI҂ɖڂ邱Ƃ͂܂B

c@Ƃق邱Ƃ͊ȒPŁANɂłłAnЉg̉Ŗ{ɍĂlɖڂ邱Ƃ͂߂ēBg߂Ȗɖڂ邱ƂȂAƂ؂ĂĘblĂ悤Ɏv܂Bg{\Ăӎ̂ł΁AЉ̈ƂĖ{ɍĂl̂߂ɉ̂₤ĂقBuێvĈł΁AnЉɗĒn߂Ȃ΂ȂȂ̂ɁAȂƂNBɂĐƎȎ낤ĕۂĂƂl܂ɂ܂B

@ׂẴ}CmeBWIƂ

@ŋ߁Ac񂪒OlJ҂⌤C̖ނĂƂɁA炽߂ĊoĂ܂B̌قŁuLqvJĈcĂтƂALqÂ肪ƂĂŋ܂BOlC̎ނĂ钆ŏɂȂłˁB͎g̖Őt̂łAcɏoẮA̎ЉňꏏɐĂ鑽̊OlɁAƖڂ悤Ǝv悤ɂȂ܂B

c@̖肾łςƎv̂ɁA񂪂ɓ{Љ̒̃}CmeB̖ƂĂƂ炦ȂĂ邱ƂɁAƂĂ܂BJE^[ɂV󂯎~߂܂ĂĂ悤Ɏv܂B}CmeBԂ̘̉Aтł΁Aꂼ̌l^ȂǂɂL肪oĂ̂ł͂Ȃł傤Bł́uǂ悤p[hvł́Aݓl̐lۂ@x肵Ă܂ˁB

@Zł铌sł̍ی𗬃tFXeBoɂ́AlQĂ܂B؍^[QbgɂwCgXs[ؒff܂AݓU̖𒆍ɂĂ܂Bނ͍IɃ^[QbgςāAǁA}CmeBȂNł^[QbgɂĂ܂B

c@̒ʂłBݓ̂悤ɁusێvƏ̂l^[Qbgɂ̂́AݓRAł͂܂Br܂̃Ci^EOł͒lǂoƂXsȂĂ܂B

@nsł̃JfƎ܂ˁB

c@iX̃n[PNCc̊܂ŎoĂāAuږǂovƂfĂ܂ˁBׂĂ̊Olr˂̑ΏۂɂȂĂ܂BɁAی󋋎҂Ⴊ҂ɑ΂obVOЂǂB́AЉI҂ƂĂlA㖯̒ł肬̌낤Ɖ^Ă݂ɑ΂obNbVƎ͍lĂ܂Bނ̓}XR~ᔻ܂߁A㖯Iȑ݂ւ̃obNbV̔gɏĂ̂łB
@a̖F芳҂̖ŁAҒĉ̉erŔƂAɂdbĂ悤ɂȂƂ{l畷܂BĂ͔ʒmŁu܂~̂vuȂɕ⏞߂̂vƂeƂ܂B܍ݓƂ܂zŁAa҂DzIȌĂ悤ɍlĂBҒĉ̉AԂ͂vĂ̂AƐq˂ꂽƂA͉ȂBȏ͂ȂƂقǋꂵ߂ĂQ҂AȂȂƂł܂ꂵ܂ȂƂȂ̂ł傤B
@Ƃ킯ےIȂ̂́A86ɍLōsȂݓ̃fłBj퐄iiB̐I咣sȂR͔F߂ɂĂAȂu픚ғvƂt܂ŔяoBق炢ÓAQ҂Ɨ܂ŏxI⏞łAuvƂƂɂւĂ܂BČ݂̍ő̖́AݓIȔz㉟悤ȎЉI͋C邱ƂłB

@logn

\\x@{܂ĂɂȂȂŁA̍ٔJE^[̐lX̓w͂A\̘͂Hォ̊gUhł̂łˁB

c@AWl[uŊJꂽAlψɍsĂ܂A{{ƊÖψƂ̃wCgXs[ɑ΂F̈ႢɊ܂BȂx@s̃JE^[ɑ΂ĉߏȌx̂Bx@̓CVXg̃fĂ悤ɂȂƂӌAëψ瑊̂́AR̂Ƃł͂܂A͂厖ȎwEƎv܂Bɑ΂Čx@́uSۂ߂̂œ̒ĉ邽߂ł͂ȂvƓقĂ܂AN̐SɂĂȂB炱Aoꂽlς̓{{ւ̊ɂAƂƐ荞܂ꂽ̂Ǝv܂B
@x@słȂAfBAꕔ̂Ă͂قƂǓĂ܂łB̈ӖŁA̍ٔfBAグ̂͂ƂĂ厖Ǝv܂BÂ߂ɗ񂪂ǂꂾ̋]𕥂Ă̂BƂĂlAɎȂΐ̒OiȂƂ󋵂́A̎ЉɐlԂ̈lƂĂ܂ɂAssƎvĂ܂B

@l͋Ȃ܂B̈Ԃ̖ڕẂA̔Q҂oȂƁBlognłB̗FluݓɋȂs̉v܂i΁jAႢlCyɊ撣悤Ȋ肽ƎvĂ܂BȂłɂĎٔȂ񂩁AƎvƂ܂A̐l̂߂̖^ꂽ̂܂B{A΂肵ȂĂłˁB

\\{͂肪Ƃ܂B

ii@{ҏWEFJLYj

e҂̃RgF
uEvi862 2014N11 gXjAMbƈc_ꎁ̃C^r[LB
̍ł́AuwCgXs[ȂЉցvƂWg܂ĂB
ł̓eɔAe҂ZpɕύXȂǂB

http://www.asyura2.com/14/idletalk41/msg/357.html
[eXg31] eXg
s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4Ionx
http://www.kenoh.com/2016/06/29_koike.html
2016N629@PI[EhbgR

@rFΎs28AL҉JA4Ɍsƌ̘AŁum312NԂɐvƂcmɓ͂A̓eLҔ\ƂȂǂ󂯂āAuqϓIncm]kbv𔭕\Acm4Ionx

@um312NԂɐv́̕Asƌ́A݂TF㉇̐E˗󂯂ƂŁA܂ł̒m̑Ή̂⌧ɂƂĂǂ̂悤ȉeƌʂ炵؂A܂Ƃ߂́B527ɒm̔鏑ʂĎs̖sƒ̏o_蒬͂AɓALҔ\B

@ł́AqǂÔEqĎxɂ錧̎sAkЂꂫ̏AkVɂ鍑ȂǂƂ̒͂߂Ƃ鑽AۑƂĎAucm̎󂯎~ߕ̐͂ɂĂAXśAm̐pS𖳎iȂǂɋN̂Ɨ𓾂ȂƍlĂAm̂܂܂̐𑱂Ȃ΁AɌVcA̐ɑ傫ȉeoƊ뜜ĂBvȂǁAs̐XvsƑ̓nӜAgĒ̘AŏĂB

@rśAߌ3ΎsŊJŁAkbƂ镶ǂݏグB́Au̒kb́AXsXƓӌ̎sƑ߂̕ł͂܂BvƋLA^̂ȂłJԂĂB

@āûѐV̐XsƓnӒAIɐcmeN镶oAɐrȉe^Ă邱Ƃɂ񂪂݁AqϓIɐcm]Ă݂̂ł܂vƁA\̌o܂bB

@sƒoꂽ́AXs܂Ƃ߂ꂽƂAu420̎s̐ȏœ˔@AX猴Ăꂽ́Bɑ΂āAl̎sm锭sA啔̎s͔ȂB̂ƁAX͓ƋvZsɎ܂Ƃ߂ĂƂňӌ͎̂ǂ܂ŘAĂقƂ̂Ƃł܂vB

@sIArs͐XɁu킽͂̎̍쐬ɂ͉܂vƓAXBAsŐE邽߂̎łAmɑ΂IȒeNƂĒځAmĂɏôƎv킸Aق̎sƎvƂAŖƂĂeɂĂ̔_Ɓucm̗Dꂽ_ɂāvȂǂLĐc]Am4IxB

@񓹋@ւ̎ł́Akb\̈Ӑ}ɂāAuXق̎s񂽂Ƒ߂ɏôł͂܂vƏqׂĂAu͂̕ĎIɐcmeN镶ɂȂĂvƌAǂ񂾐lucm͂߂łˁvƌĂAɂ߂ĐrȉeyڂĂƕ́Bsȕ]󂯂邱Ƃ͌ł͂ȂƎvBɐcm̒nłΎs̎sƂāAun̒msȎdł󂯂Ă悤ł́An̎sƂĂ͌ɂƂƐ\グȂ΂ȂȂvB

@܂A̓̒kb\̃^C~OɂĂ̎ŁAɎsLuXs̂ƂŘbƂƂAmĂ̂Ƃ̎ɁAu܂m܂vAu킽͂ق̎s񂽂Ƒ߂ɏo킯ł͂܂vB

@ɎQ@IOɂ؂̂̕m}}n\邱ƂɂĂǂ邩̖₢ɂ́AueȂ̂ƎvȂBmeNeɂȂĂ܂āA̖ڂ猩ΑÓłȂ̂vBIɎsƑAŏoƁAs݂ȐcmɂۂĂƂۂ^˂ȂƂāAus̑ӂł͂ȂvƂ̍lBuȂłȂɕKɂ͂ôAȂ񂩂قɈӐ}̂Ȃ̂킩ȂvƂB

@rsXĂoƂɁA̓e͈ႤȂǂ̎wERcȂǂ̂Ƃ̎ɂ́AuĂ܂BXق̎sƑC͂܂̂ŁvBAŏIIɂǂɂȂ̂Ƃɂ́AS̉cJƎvĂƌAuƂɂȃZZ[Viȕ͂o킯łA͂ȂJׂBȂ΂Ō܂AoƂ͓Kł͂ȂƁB@͂ȂłvƓĂB

@uqϓIncm]kbv́AΎs̃z[y[WPDFŌfڂĂB

֘AN

e҂ɂ֘ANF

ucRPQNԂɐvɂČ؂s܂
V^肨m点

sEɂ錧^cɑ΂錟ؓɂ
QWNUQX@cmL҉v|
V^mz[

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/507.html

[n13] s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4Ionx (PI[EhbgR)
s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4Ionx
http://www.kenoh.com/2016/06/29_koike.html
2016N629@PI[EhbgR

@rFΎs28AL҉JA4Ɍsƌ̘AŁum312NԂɐvƂcmɓ͂A̓eLҔ\ƂȂǂ󂯂āAuqϓIncm]kbv𔭕\Acm4Ionx

@um312NԂɐv́̕Asƌ́A݂TF㉇̐E˗󂯂ƂŁA܂ł̒m̑Ή̂⌧ɂƂĂǂ̂悤ȉeƌʂ炵؂A܂Ƃ߂́B527ɒm̔鏑ʂĎs̖sƒ̏o_蒬͂AɓALҔ\B

@ł́AqǂÔEqĎxɂ錧̎sAkЂꂫ̏AkVɂ鍑ȂǂƂ̒͂߂Ƃ鑽AۑƂĎAucm̎󂯎~ߕ̐͂ɂĂAXśAm̐pS𖳎iȂǂɋN̂Ɨ𓾂ȂƍlĂAm̂܂܂̐𑱂Ȃ΁AɌVcA̐ɑ傫ȉeoƊ뜜ĂBvȂǁAs̐XvsƑ̓nӜAgĒ̘AŏĂB

@rśAߌ3ΎsŊJŁAkbƂ镶ǂݏグB́Au̒kb́AXsXƓӌ̎sƑ߂̕ł͂܂BvƋLA^̂ȂłJԂĂB

@āûѐV̐XsƓnӒAIɐcmeN镶oAɐrȉe^Ă邱Ƃɂ񂪂݁AqϓIɐcm]Ă݂̂ł܂vƁA\̌o܂bB

@sƒoꂽ́AXs܂Ƃ߂ꂽƂAu420̎s̐ȏœ˔@AX猴Ăꂽ́Bɑ΂āAl̎sm锭sA啔̎s͔ȂB̂ƁAX͓ƋvZsɎ܂Ƃ߂ĂƂňӌ͎̂ǂ܂ŘAĂقƂ̂Ƃł܂vB

@sIArs͐XɁu킽͂̎̍쐬ɂ͉܂vƓAXBAsŐE邽߂̎łAmɑ΂IȒeNƂĒځAmĂɏôƎv킸Aق̎sƎvƂAŖƂĂeɂĂ̔_Ɓucm̗Dꂽ_ɂāvȂǂLĐc]Am4IxB

@񓹋@ւ̎ł́Akb\̈Ӑ}ɂāAuXق̎s񂽂Ƒ߂ɏôł͂܂vƏqׂĂAu͂̕ĎIɐcmeN镶ɂȂĂvƌAǂ񂾐lucm͂߂łˁvƌĂAɂ߂ĐrȉeyڂĂƕ́Bsȕ]󂯂邱Ƃ͌ł͂ȂƎvBɐcm̒nłΎs̎sƂāAun̒msȎdł󂯂Ă悤ł́An̎sƂĂ͌ɂƂƐ\グȂ΂ȂȂvB

@܂A̓̒kb\̃^C~OɂĂ̎ŁAɎsLuXs̂ƂŘbƂƂAmĂ̂Ƃ̎ɁAu܂m܂vAu킽͂ق̎s񂽂Ƒ߂ɏo킯ł͂܂vB

@ɎQ@IOɂ؂̂̕m}}n\邱ƂɂĂǂ邩̖₢ɂ́AueȂ̂ƎvȂBmeNeɂȂĂ܂āA̖ڂ猩ΑÓłȂ̂vBIɎsƑAŏoƁAs݂ȐcmɂۂĂƂۂ^˂ȂƂāAus̑ӂł͂ȂvƂ̍lBuȂłȂɕKɂ͂ôAȂ񂩂قɈӐ}̂Ȃ̂킩ȂvƂB

@rsXĂoƂɁA̓e͈ႤȂǂ̎wERcȂǂ̂Ƃ̎ɂ́AuĂ܂BXق̎sƑC͂܂̂ŁvBAŏIIɂǂɂȂ̂Ƃɂ́AS̉cJƎvĂƌAuƂɂȃZZ[Viȕ͂o킯łA͂ȂJׂBȂ΂Ō܂AoƂ͓Kł͂ȂƁB@͂ȂłvƓĂB

@uqϓIncm]kbv́AΎs̃z[y[WPDFŌfڂĂB

e҂ɂ֘ANF

ucRPQNԂɐvɂČ؂s܂
V^肨m点

sEɂ錧^cɑ΂錟ؓɂ
QWNUQX@cmL҉v|
V^mz[

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/736.html

[eXg31] eXg
qϓIncm]kb
http://www.city.kamo.niigata.jp/section/oshiraseban/shisei/kyakkantekikentikara280628.pdf
2016N628@Ύs rF

@̒kb́AXsXƓӌ̎sƑ߂̕ł͂܂B

@̂ѐV̐XsƓnӒAIɐcmeN镶oAɐrȉe^Ă邱Ƃɂ񂪂݁AqϓIɐcm]Ă݂̂ł܂B

@̂юsyђoꂽ́AXsƂ܂Ƃ߂ꂽł܂ASQO̐Vs̐ȏŁA˔@X猴Ăꂽ̂ł܂B

@ɑ΂āAl̎sāAm锭s܂BA啔̎śA܂łB̂ƁAXA͓̎isjƋvZsɎ܂Ƃ߂Ă̂ŁAӌ͎̂ǂ܂ŘAĂƂ̂Ƃł܂B

@sIA͒ɐXɉAu͂̎̍쐬ɂ͉܂BvƐ\グAXuȂ̗͂悭Ă̂ŁAŌ\łBvƂ܂B

@A̎́Acm񂩂sɐE˗Ă̂ŁǍ̂߂̎Ƃ̂ƂłAcmɑ΂IȒeNƂāAڒmĂɏôłƂ́ASvȂ̂ł܂B̎sƎv܂B

@Â悤Ȍ̏dvmĂɏôł΁AsS̉cJčŏIĂA𒼐ڒmĂɏoׂǂ܂߂āA\ɋc_ׂ̂ł܂B

@ɂ̂悤Ȏ葱͈؂ȂꂸAȂu{̎戵ɂẮAOɂm点ׂƂł͂܂AƂ̒ɂA}篂TQVɓsi{jyяяo_蒬ijA鏑ۂʂĐcmɂ͂܂B܂A{ALҔ\iIjƂƂɁA}Aɏ񋟂邱ƂƂĂ܂BvƂesĂ̕tāAɁA̒mɏoꂽė܂B

@cḿAu͎̕s̑ӂł͂ȂBvƌĂ܂Aȏ̌o܂猩āAm̌Ă邱Ƃ͊ԈႢ܂B

@ɁA̒eN̓eł܂Â悤ɑ̓_Őmł͂܂B

P@u⑼̊֌W@ւƂ̗ǍDȊ֌Wa݂BvƂ_ɂ

(1)@cḿAJȂƍyʏȂ畛mAėĂA̗ȒƂ̊֌ẂAɂ߂ėǍDłB̍̏ȒƂ̊֌WǍDł܂B

@܂AcḿA炽̂ėĂAceʂ邱Ƃقǂł܂B

(2)@iqƂ̊֌Wł܂Acmw͂ꂽ̂́AŠocɊւn̕ŜŁA炵ĂقƂƂłAƂiqɂoĂقƂƂł܂āAm̍s͗hł܂B

Q@umƐEƂ̈ӎvaʂ\łȂBvƂ_ɂ

@ǂƈꏏɎdĊ邱Ƃ́AmƐEƂ̈ӎvaʂ́A\ɍsĂ܂B

@ނAḿAɂ܂߂̂ł͂ȂƎvقǂł܂B

@̐EAs̈ӌ悭Ă܂B́Am񂪁Â悤ɎwĂ邩炾Ǝv܂B

R@umg̈ӌ̗̑RɂAƓɒxꂪĂBvƂ_

@ɌāAƓ̒x͂܂B̍A猧ɗ́Aǂ̌啝ɌĂ܂BVTł͂܂BŁAḿA悭Ă܂B

S@umswɂAsƂ̊֌W̒ł̖肪BvƂ_

(1)@_́AقǑ͂܂B_΁A֌WśAΕa@̎Yȓɂčs悤ɁAmɋ\グċc_𑱂čsׂłB

(2)@kЂꂫ̐Vł̏ɂāAm񂪓FĂ_́AÓƎv܂BVňꂽѐkЂꂫ΁Ǎ㎟Xɑʂ̂ꂫȂȂ܂BkЂꂫ́A˔\ттꂫłBːʂe͈͂̒ƂĂAʂʂɂȂ΁A˔\́A̓yɒ~ςAԂ̂ȂƂɂȂ邨ꂪ܂B

@ɑ΂鎩̖ʎq]ɂĂ撣ĂḿAhƎv܂B

T@c̗Dꂽ_ɂ

(1)@hБ̐

@m񂪒zグꂽV̖hБ̐́Aɂ߂ėDꂽ̂łB炭{ł傤BNƑłĂ΋悤ɑΉ闧hȂ̂łB

(2)@芠Hɂ

@ЂƂAAJ{{ɋً}̘AAuSBS͔RɂȂ̂ŁAꂪƁAknSɁAlZ߂ȂȂBvƂėƂĂ܂BKɂS͎蔲킯łB

@芠HɂASAR_܂Ă܂BAꂪ邱Ƃ΁AknAknA֓nт́ASNɂ킽ĐlZ߂ȂȂ邨ꂪ܂B

@Aq͔dȂǂƂ̂́A{̂悤ȋy̍ɂׂ̂ł͂ȂAƂ΍Lȍyɂׂ̂Ȃ̂łB̂𒣂āA茴̍ĊJɐTd_ƂȂĂcḿAhłB

U@c̕]

@ȏɂ񂪂݂΁A܂ł̐cɐcm̎lIے肷悤Ȏ́A܂B

@cḿAlIĂ悢тĂꂽƍl܂B

@eɍ痈啝Ɍ炳āA󋵂̒ł͂܂AlI̐cmɂ܂ẮAɈwseʂ̗v]悭AtȂĂāAeʂlЂƂɍKɂčsĉ悤]ނ̂ł܂B

֘ANF

v]EӌEȂ
Ύs

[n13] qϓIncm]kbiΎs rFj
qϓIncm]kb
http://www.city.kamo.niigata.jp/section/oshiraseban/shisei/kyakkantekikentikara280628.pdf
2016N628@Ύs@r F

@̒kb́AXsXƓӌ̎sƑ߂̕ł͂܂B

@̂ѐV̐XsƓnӒAIɐcmeN镶oAɐrȉe^Ă邱Ƃɂ񂪂݁AqϓIɐcm]Ă݂̂ł܂B

@̂юsyђoꂽ́AXsƂ܂Ƃ߂ꂽł܂ASQO̐Vs̐ȏŁA˔@X猴Ăꂽ̂ł܂B

@ɑ΂āAl̎sāAm锭s܂BA啔̎śA܂łB̂ƁAXA͓̎isjƋvZsɎ܂Ƃ߂Ă̂ŁAӌ͎̂ǂ܂ŘAĂƂ̂Ƃł܂B

@sIA͒ɐXɉAu͂̎̍쐬ɂ͉܂BvƐ\グAXuȂ̗͂悭Ă̂ŁAŌ\łBvƂ܂B

@A̎́Acm񂩂sɐE˗Ă̂ŁǍ̂߂̎Ƃ̂ƂłAcmɑ΂IȒeNƂāAڒmĂɏôłƂ́ASvȂ̂ł܂B̎sƎv܂B

@Â悤Ȍ̏dvmĂɏôł΁AsS̉cJčŏIĂA𒼐ڒmĂɏoׂǂ܂߂āA\ɋc_ׂ̂ł܂B

@ɂ̂悤Ȏ葱͈؂ȂꂸAȂu{̎戵ɂẮAOɂm点ׂƂł͂܂AƂ̒ɂA}篂TQVɓsi{jyяяo_蒬ijA鏑ۂʂĐcmɂ͂܂B܂A{ALҔ\iIjƂƂɁA}Aɏ񋟂邱ƂƂĂ܂BvƂesĂ̕tāAɁA̒mɏoꂽė܂B

@cḿAu͎̕s̑ӂł͂ȂBvƌĂ܂Aȏ̌o܂猩āAm̌Ă邱Ƃ͊ԈႢ܂B

@ɁA̒eN̓eł܂Â悤ɑ̓_Őmł͂܂B

P@u⑼̊֌W@ւƂ̗ǍDȊ֌Wa݂BvƂ_ɂ

(1)@cḿAJȂƍyʏȂ畛mAėĂA̗ȒƂ̊֌ẂAɂ߂ėǍDłB̍̏ȒƂ̊֌WǍDł܂B

@܂AcḿA炽̂ėĂAceʂ邱Ƃقǂł܂B

(2)@iqƂ̊֌Wł܂Acmw͂ꂽ̂́AŠocɊւn̕ŜŁA炵ĂقƂƂłAƂiqɂoĂقƂƂł܂āAm̍s͗hł܂B

Q@umƐEƂ̈ӎvaʂ\łȂBvƂ_ɂ

@ǂƈꏏɎdĊ邱Ƃ́AmƐEƂ̈ӎvaʂ́A\ɍsĂ܂B

@ނAḿAɂ܂߂̂ł͂ȂƎvقǂł܂B

@̐EAs̈ӌ悭Ă܂B́Am񂪁Â悤ɎwĂ邩炾Ǝv܂B

R@umg̈ӌ̗̑RɂAƓɒxꂪĂBvƂ_

@ɌāAƓ̒x͂܂B̍A猧ɗ́Aǂ̌啝ɌĂ܂BVTł͂܂BŁAḿA悭Ă܂B

S@umswɂAsƂ̊֌W̒ł̖肪BvƂ_

(1)@_́AقǑ͂܂B_΁A֌WśAΕa@̎Yȓɂčs悤ɁAmɋ\グċc_𑱂čsׂłB

(2)@kЂꂫ̐Vł̏ɂāAm񂪓FĂ_́AÓƎv܂BVňꂽѐkЂꂫ΁Ǎ㎟Xɑʂ̂ꂫȂȂ܂BkЂꂫ́A˔\ттꂫłBːʂe͈͂̒ƂĂAʂʂɂȂ΁A˔\́A̓yɒ~ςAԂ̂ȂƂɂȂ邨ꂪ܂B

@ɑ΂鎩̖ʎq]ɂĂ撣ĂḿAhƎv܂B

T@c̗Dꂽ_ɂ

(1)@hБ̐

@m񂪒zグꂽV̖hБ̐́Aɂ߂ėDꂽ̂łB炭{ł傤BNƑłĂ΋悤ɑΉ闧hȂ̂łB

(2)@芠Hɂ

@ЂƂAAJ{{ɋً}̘AAuSBS͔RɂȂ̂ŁAꂪƁAknSɁAlZ߂ȂȂBvƂėƂĂ܂BKɂS͎蔲킯łB

@芠HɂASAR_܂Ă܂BAꂪ邱Ƃ΁AknAknA֓nт́ASNɂ킽ĐlZ߂ȂȂ邨ꂪ܂B

@Aq͔dȂǂƂ̂́A{̂悤ȋy̍ɂׂ̂ł͂ȂAƂ΍Lȍyɂׂ̂Ȃ̂łB̂𒣂āA茴̍ĊJɐTd_ƂȂĂcḿAhłB

U@c̕]

@ȏɂ񂪂݂΁A܂ł̐cɐcm̎lIے肷悤Ȏ́A܂B

@cḿAlIĂ悢тĂꂽƍl܂B

@eɍ痈啝Ɍ炳āA󋵂̒ł͂܂AlI̐cmɂ܂ẮAɈwseʂ̗v]悭AtȂĂāAeʂlЂƂɍKɂčsĉ悤]ނ̂ł܂B

֘ANF

v]EӌEȂ
Ύs

[eXg31] eXg
ucR12NԂɐv̌؂ɂāi2016N527j
XviVsEsjEn粜AgiVEĒj

@cḿA{NQ̌cŎlIւ̏on\AɁÂюsyђɑ΂āAcm̌㉇琄E肪oꂽƂłB

@̐E̎舵ɂāAsyђ́A܂ł̒m̑ΉX̂VɂƂāAǂ̂悤ȉeƌʂ炵̂؂sAucR12NԂɐvƂĂ܂Ƃ߂B

@̒ł́AƎsƂ̖S𖳎m̎wɂsɍƁA⑼̋@ւɑ΂m̍s߂ΉɂsƓɒxꂪƁAm̎咣ӌɌŎ邠܂As̋Ɩ⎖Ɠɑ傫ȎxႪƁA哱ӔCĎgނƂꂽnoς̔W⌧̌Ɏ鐭􂪐iWĂȂƂȂǁA̖肪wEꂽB
@

@̎wEɂāAcm̎󂯎~ߕ̐͂ɂĂAXśAm̐pS𖳎iȂǂɋN̂Ɨ𓾂ȂƍlĂAm̂܂܂̐p𑱂Ȃ΁AɌVcA̐ɑ傫ȉeoƊ뜜ĂB

@YtucR12NԂɐv́Am܂łɍswΉȂǂɂƂȂp₤̂łA܂AuiʓYjcR12NԂɐɊւ̓IȎv́A莋̌o܂łB
@

@syђ́Ǎ؂𓥂܂ŁAcmǂ̂悤ɑΉӎv̂mFǍʂ𓥂܂ŐE肢ɑ΂c_[߂ĂƂƂĂB

@@QWNTQV

Vs@s@@X@ v@@@

V@Ē@@n 粁@A g@@@

@@Vm@ c@T F@l

֘ANF
[n13] ucR12NԂɐv̌؂ɂāiXvsEn粜AgĒj
ucR12NԂɐv̌؂ɂāi2016N527j
XviVsEsjEn粜AgiVEĒj

@cḿA{NQ̌cŎlIւ̏on\AɁÂюsyђɑ΂āAcm̌㉇琄E肪oꂽƂłB

@̐E̎舵ɂāAsyђ́A܂ł̒m̑ΉX̂VɂƂāAǂ̂悤ȉeƌʂ炵̂؂sAucR12NԂɐvƂĂ܂Ƃ߂B

@̒ł́AƎsƂ̖S𖳎m̎wɂsɍƁA⑼̋@ւɑ΂m̍s߂ΉɂsƓɒxꂪƁAm̎咣ӌɌŎ邠܂As̋Ɩ⎖Ɠɑ傫ȎxႪƁA哱ӔCĎgނƂꂽnoς̔W⌧̌Ɏ鐭􂪐iWĂȂƂȂǁA̖肪wEꂽB
@
@̎wEɂāAcm̎󂯎~ߕ̐͂ɂĂAXśAm̐pS𖳎iȂǂɋN̂Ɨ𓾂ȂƍlĂAm̂܂܂̐p𑱂Ȃ΁AɌVcA̐ɑ傫ȉeoƊ뜜ĂB

@YtucR12NԂɐv́Am܂łɍswΉȂǂɂƂȂp₤̂łA܂AuiʓYjcR12NԂɐɊւ̓IȎv́A莋̌o܂łB
@
@syђ́Ǎ؂𓥂܂ŁAcmǂ̂悤ɑΉӎv̂mFǍʂ𓥂܂ŐE肢ɑ΂c_[߂ĂƂƂĂB

@@QWNTQV

Vs@s@X@ @v@@@

V@Ē@n粁@Ag@@@

@@Vm@c@TF@l

֘ANF
ucRPQNԂɐvɂČ؂s܂i2016N0531j
iV^肨m点j
EucRPQNԂɐv(PDF)
EiʓYjuc312NԂɐɊւ̓Iȓev(PDF)

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/738.html
[EIEmgj208] s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4Ionx (PI[EhbgR)F nN
s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4Ionx (PI[EhbgR)
http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/736.html
e G̎ 2016 N 6 30 21:33:42
[m点EǗ21] 2016N6@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
94. [7] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N630 23:14:15 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[163]
eXge̒ɕsK؂ȃ^O߁A
́uyl[Ƃ̃RgṽtH[󂵂Ă܂܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/acpen/iUef9YLMjtI.html

̃eXge폜ĂȂł傤B

𐶂^O͂łB
3sڂɎ̂悤ɂ܂F

2016N628@Ύs rF

[m点EǗ21] 2016N6@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
95. [8] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N630 23:20:02 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[164]
>>94
^O\Ȃ̂ŏ܂B
XĐ\󂠂܂B

---------------------------------------------------------

eXge̒ɕsK؂ȃ^O߁A
́uyl[Ƃ̃RgṽtH[󂵂Ă܂܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/acpen/iUef9YLMjtI.html

̃eXge폜ĂȂł傤B

𐶂^O͂łB
3sڂɎ̂悤ɂ܂F

2016N628@Ύs rF

[m点EǗ21] 2016N6@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
96. [9] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N630 23:24:57 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[165]
>>95

^Ó@^@div@łB
dˏdː\󂠂܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/447.html#c96

[EIEmgj208] c͖ԁiD's notej

http://www.d-style.biz/weblog/15116/
2016N630@D's note
@
@
[O]

āAԓIɂ͎Q@I^B

AVł͂Ƃ͈ႤsȋCYĂ܂B

̏Hɂs錧mIɌĐcm4Ion\Ă܂Asƌcm悤ȕ𔭕\BVEerłeF邩̂悤ȕΌ񓹂ȂĂ肵܂B

܂ǍɂĉΎs͑Ss̑ӂł͂ȂƃtH[kboĂāÂ̗ɂďڂ͉Lj[XLłB

s̐c؂ɏrΎs_Acm̕]4IonxbPI[EhbgR
@
@
Omƈꕔ̎sA̒̂͐VȂCtĂƎv܂B

ɂĂǍ点̂悤ȉAȂ͂Ȃł傤B

cɑ΂]͐lꂼꂾƂĂAIɔfΌ_Őcmȏɒmɑl͌܂Bcx̎΂ĂӌɂȂ̂ł傤A猾킹ΐcm͌E̐Ƃ̒ł͓{gbvx̗DGŁAcm̂͐VɂƂđ傫ȃ}CiXƎv܂BzgȂ獑SĂ炢̐lłBɂ܂ŎvȂĂAcmF߂錧͑͂łB

Aꕔ̎s͐cm4Î͑j~BǂȉgĂłB

̈ꕔ̎s̊ԂĂƉƂȂĂ܂ˁB[AJȂ̂߂ɐkЃKLL揈ɗ悵ĎlȂH̋PɊw΂~܂Ă锐芠HĉғlȂH

܂͎̐łǁA܂͂ƂȂł傤ˁB}XR~܂߁Aɂ̂͒NȂ̂Âq܂B
@
@
x̎Q@IƓ[͒ႢAgɒmxłȂƂȂ[ႤAƎv܂BVssOsAȂƂȂœ[lőI΂ꂿĂ銴͂邵A͐cmȑwɑI΂Ăʂ܂B

łAς莄L҂͂ƒNǂȍlŉ悤ƂĂ̂Aɂ߂ē[ȂႢȂƎv̂łB

ȂƂȂŐcmI񂾐lłAcm܂łɉĂ悭m΁AȂƂȂł͂ȂłƎv͂BcmȂ畟͍ȃxōςޘbȂłˁBi삵ĂΎsƂĂ}gƂ悭킩͂łB^sm̂悤ɂ̖Ȃ܂킢́AꍇɂĂ͖ɂ܂ˁB

}XR~OɂȂēWJĂc͖ԁA񓹂̂܂܉Lۂ݂ɂɁA̗ɉBĂ̂lĎŖ؂JĂ܂傤B

x̎Q@Iłĉғ^c𑝂₷ƐVւ̈́EߕtƋȂ܂B

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo208/msg/664.html

[EIEmgj208] ȂfBA͓{c񓹂ĂȂ̂i슮j
ȂfBA͓{c񓹂ĂȂ̂
http://www.sugano.ne.jp/2016/07/01/post-187/
2016N71@sugano.ne.jp
@
@
ْw{čxoŌ̂QÃfBA{cɂĎނ󂯂B݂ȂAuȂׂȂłBBBvƑOuāAuȂ܂ŁAfBA͓{cɂĎグĂȂł傤HvƂBl͏ɓƂ𓚂B

l̓͂B

uނ炪̌ƂČւ̂́w@xłBނ̂̑̉^́AׂāAwΉ^xł邱ƂmłHvƂ܂mFB݂Ȃ񂲑mȂB̗B
u{ćAƂ킯אtaȗAwsȂ锽Ή^ćxɂȂĂłBHAwjQ攽΁xwԈw񓹔΁xwvwʐ΁xw甽΁xƁB40N߂ނ̗j́AƔΉ^̗jȂłvƁA̗B

ŁAŖĺAuāA񋓂Ă݂܂ACÂɂȂƂ܂񂩁HvƐq˂Ă݂BƂ݂ȂA|J[ƂB炻ɕ⏕B

uނ炪Ή^N̂́AjQɂĂAԈw񓹂ɂĂAvwʐɂĂAɂĂASAwqx̘bȂłvƁB܂ŘbĂA̐l͋CÂȂB

xOBujQɂĂAԈw񓹂ɂĂAvwʐɂĂAɂĂASAwqx̘błBAFAfBA̐lXAĂ̎vTChłXЉAłoJɂ镪̘błˁHvƔOB܂łƔ

u܂FƊF̕񓹂̏҂łlsЉAwq̘bǂłxƓՎĂ΂Aނ炪ĂAނ̉^񓹂ȂłB܂{cƉX͗ƂQҁvƂbB

ɑBuԈw񓹂łłˁHԈw񓹂́Aǂ̃TCĥ̂łAw_񓹁xɂȂĂBw{̌B؍xƁBASɁw̐lxĊϓ_Ă܂ˁH񓹂ȂłˁHvƁB

ɑu10NقǁA{cvȍstB[hƂĂ̂́AwZłB甽΂AewA]˂Aē̊یNサBwq̘bxƂāAǂyĂƂ날܂񂩁HvƁB
܂ŘbƁAL҂ƂROȉ̋L҂ƊOfBA̋L҂͖{ɌȂ܂łɁAuIIڂ炤낱IvƂBAL҂͑SRCÂȂBXɏd˂B

uĺA{cĂl[~OƎvłBĂłHނ炪Ă邱Ƃ́AVchڂBۂɂĂ邱Ƃ́AUԂ悤ɁAq̘b΂B܂́wq͖قĂxƌ킯BAwjb|̃IbTxłˁHvƁB

u{c͏BAނ炪y[Ă̂́wjb|̃IbT̃^eBxBł@łȂBȂɂĂȈ̂ȂƂĂl̒ɂ邩ȂhhƂ~\Wj[y[Ă񂾂Ałv

ɑBuƁAlƁAނ炪c_ŁAwً}ԏxƁwƑxɂ闝R킩łHً}ɂ͏q͂ǂƁBƑ̌Ƃ𕷂ƁBvƁB
@
܂łƂقڂXO̐lĂBAŌ܂ŗłȂ̂́AĥL

BŌ܂ŗȂ̂́AhnfBÂL҂łȂATfBA̐l̒ɂ܂ɂBO҂̏ꍇ́AuAȂƂ͂ȂA}͍Ɛ_̕ڎwĂBBBvƂȂƂB҂́AŌ܂Łủ́HvĊĂB

TfBA̐lŌ܂ŗłȂ̂́AEƕdȂƎvBĂfBAȂ񂾂Bu{cāwjb|̃IbTcxȂ񂷂HvĘbĂu[ȁB͂̃IbTqȂ̂ŁvĘbȂłˁBsvcȂ̂́AhnfBÅ

ςuEh^čl̂߂炾낤ł傤ˁH́AsȂ~\Wj[^}Y^łHvƓĂA̐l͗ĂȂBčŌɂ́uƂāA牽Ȃ̂HvƂBuȂƂAXK[@Ɛ_[vƂȂ

܂Ab悤ƂAAGrfXAAGLȂǂׂĂ݂ĂASOȏ̍hnfBA̐lX́AuȂƂ͂ȂIIII푈肽Ă񂾂IIIIvƈӌŒnɂȂĕȂBჁfBA{ĉƂȂ͂ˁB

܂Ȉ̂ȂƂĂ邯ǂA2NO̖lȂ炱̗ɋCÂȂBɃN\Aɐl邩𒼎ȂȂAς悤ƁAS͂āAJEZOɒʂAa@ɒʂAƂɏ߂Ã~\Wj[𗝉ł

l~\Wj[ł̂AȂ}Y𓩖ł̂Algł͂킩ȂB̂͏ɑl]ׂ̂Bujb|̃IbTvƂ͏͋ûł͂ȂƂ͎vB̂܂܍sĂĺA{c̃CxgŌN̂Ă邾낤B

l̍u𕷂ɂꂽlȂ炲mƎv܂Al̍u̍ŌQԂ́Auq̘bƃoJɂʁAq̘b^ɘMl炪͂̎@ɂȂBQSȂłIq̘bƂȏoJɂ̂߂܂傤vƐ⋩ďIBAl͎ɌĂł

܂ĂˁAl͎̂Ƃ߂邽߂ɂAŎɒ^邽߂ɂAufBA~\Wj[łȂ{cfCA͏ȂłvĘbܐHĂ܂BA{̃IbT̐_oAtł܂Ȃ̂ˁB̂AsȁudԂvł傤Ȃ
@
@
֘A
u{c͒Jt搶̐\qłv@2016N421
Eyz430w{čxXII ? Jt搶ɋA܂傤E@2016N419-20
TNĖ{Ƀ_ȂƎvB@2016N55
Sn͐搶ɂ@2016N226

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo208/msg/712.html

[EIEmgj209] u{cvɒҁE슮uǂFȂ̂H J_viTj
u{cvɒҁE슮uǂFȂ̂H J_v
http://dot.asahi.com/wa/2016070500156.html
2016N76 (XV 2016/7/6 07:00)@qTrbdot.hbg Vo

ucvێ̊eǂ݂܂Aނʂے肵Ă̂͊Od̋Ln߁A̎dł͂Ȃ̂΂ŁA̒ɂĂ͔ےłĂȂBcvێ̎咣ł́w{čx{c̎ǂׂwAA排Ȃ150Jȏx̖ӏƂ̂ƂłA͓Rł傤B҂ǂŖӏȂ̂Ȃď͂ȂBAcvێ͎̒̎vȘ__ɂĖmɎFwEłĂȂBǁA̖{ȁiƂj߂ړIŏꂽƌ́AϓIȈۘ_ɉ߂܂Bcvێ͉ƌĂghɉ߂ȂBw{čxłwEʂASl͎̊LOłv
@
@쎁͒̒ŁA{c̊Iɋ̂͊ȂǁẢƂ̌M҂𒆐SƂlXƎwEBAcvێ͓{c̑gDɂāAqAACAƁAʂ̑gDƓBij̐lfłgDł͂ȂrƔ_B

ucvێ̔_ɂʂA{c͎̒ołꂽ̐[AŌ̕}KЂɑ΂āA̖ŏoŒ~߂\ꏑ𑗂ĂĂ܂BȂΊOIȕłȂAɉ߂Ȃ̖őĂ̂BȂɑ̋coꂽ̂Bwʂ̑gDxƂ咣Ɩ̂ł͂ȂB

@łāAfBAŔ_鎞ɂ͍̂悤ɓcvێoĂB̎咣Ɉ٘_Ƃ̂ȂA\ꏑ̖lł銑g\ɏoĂĎƌJ_ł΂v
@
@쎁͓{c̉^헪ƂāAnc𓮂ČcȂǂlA̗͂č𓮂p^[ƎwEBcvێ́q͂̂Ƃ肾BẢ̂HrƎƔF߂ĂB

@@@@@@@@

ucvێ́AĂƎF߂Ă킯łˁBAȂɑ傫Ȑ^Ăɂ炸A{c͒PȂCӒĉłB̌\͂ǂȂĂł傤BȂAx񍐏̒o鐭ĉƂē͂oׂȂ̂ł͂Ȃł傤v
@
@쎁{ce[}ɑIŎނn߂@͉Ȃ̂B

uǂlĂ{WO񑊂ɋe^ĂgDłB2015N2ɁA}@i{̑Dc{ijƈ{񑊂bāA@̔c16NĂ̎Q@Iƌ؂B̑Dc̔ǂĂƁA܂ً͋}ԏƂbĂāA{cȑO咣ĂƂƈꏏBAl^͓{c񂾂ƁBɁA{iIɓ{c̐l𒲂׎n߂łv
@
@ӊOA쎁͓{ću̍ĵhO}ŌтĂWcł͂ȂvƌBł͉͗͂̌Ȃ̂B

u{c̓͌咣ҁAނ炩猩wTNxIȎ҂nXgIɓG邱ƂłB܂ł̊ĂƁAwjQ掖Ɣ΁xwvwʐ΁xw]RԈw񓹔΁xwWF_[t[΁xAāAwOlQ΁xƁAΉ^قƂǂłB咣͂܂AwAqǂAOl͖قĂxƂƂĂɓBjDʂ̎ЉRƎvĂāA҂咣ƁwقĂxAOl咣Ɓw悻҂͏oĂxƌBłA咣Ă̂́A{cȂłˁH@{̃IbTāAFȂłB{ćÁg{̃IbTchȂłB̃IbT̎咣̂AfBA͂ƕuĎグĂȂv
@
@00Nȍ~AZ瑽̃W[iXgȂǂ{cɊւ_o悤ɂȂAc͈قȂƂB

u1980Nォ炢{cӂ̐lX͊댯ƌx炵Ă̂̓tF~jXgłBfBA͂̌ǓƂȐ킢𖳎BfBA܂A̒ƓŒjDʂłBw{cƂ͉Ȃ̂HxƕꂽAwOxƂ悤ȂB͓{̏k}ȂłBA{cĖ{ɗǂl[~OƎv܂B悭ȂƁv

@@@@@@@@

@Q@Ił́A͂32ƕ񂶂ĂB{c͉ڎŵ낤B

u{c̍ŏ̌ɋĂً̂}ԏ̒ǉłBv́w펞Ȃ񂾂K^K^ȁxƂ̂@BwAqǂ͖قĂxƂlƓłBً}Ԗ@ɓƍق~ĉ􂪂̂Ȃ΁A^Ȃ̂̂܂łBƂ낪A{c̎咣Ƃ̂́wア҂͖قĂxŏIĂ܂B̐悪ȂłBꂪ{̍̂畜Ƃ̂Ȃ΁Aȍ̂̓N\炦łv
@
@ӊOȂƂɁA쎁͎ĝƂuɉEێҁvƋK肷B

u͌@ے肵܂BAX͌ɐĂ킯ŁAȂƂl{IlȂǋߑ鏔lے肵Ă͂ȂBƂ낪}̉ĂȂǂAlςے肵ĂB̈Ӗł́A{cɏWlX͂ǂȊvV}ƃfBJȁAwE̊v́xƌł傤B}ێ璆̍GrؗjNuichĵ悤ȁAŌΊݓcYOKrȂǂ肵ĂΗǂłA{񑊂̏oghŐ̂{cƐea̋aVĂ܂ĂB̂ȂAaVȂĐMȂƁBێ҂ƂāAv͂Ƃ͐Ȃ΂ȂȂƎvĂ܂v

@@@@@@@@@@@@

@{͓{cL񕔂ɓcvۉAƐ쎁Ƃ̑Βk\񂾂A񓚂͈ȉ̒ʂ肾B

q{쎁Ƃ̉kɉ邱Ƃ͂܂B쎁́AoňȑOcCb^[Ŗ{yіU锭JԂĂÂ悤Ȏ҂Ƃ̉kɉ邱Ƃ͍܂B쎁̌_͖{l̎RłA{̊֒mƂł͂܂񂪁AU̐⎖FɂẮAʓrwEĂ܂܂r
@
@쎁wEA}KЂɏoŒ~\ꂵo܂ɂẮÂ悤ɉ񓚂B

q\ꏑt͓XłAԂ}vߖԂŘAĕ쐬܂BȂA{甭o镶́AeɉAقȂEҖŔꍇ܂r
@
@܂AĉƂē͂oȂRɂĂ͂B

q{́A𐭎ĉƂ͔FĂ܂B{ćAncɂ܂܂Ȑ芈sȂĂ܂A茠WEЂ̎R͌@ŕۏႳꂽłAsg銈c̓o^Â̂ł͂܂ri{Ekj

T @2016N715

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo209/msg/141.html

[n13] 2[̎\Q@IVIiVj
2[̎@Q@IVI い@@
2016N712@Vm1ʁn@@

@Q@Iŗ^}͉Iߔ61cȂASIɂ͌oϐuAxm~NXv̒ǂƂȂBŌ̈ƂĒڂW߂ĂVIiI1jł́A}ŖE̐XTqi60) i}AY}AЖ}A̓}EA}E̒ꎁi57)}E킵AԂ炢B萔팸ɂ110[]^}Dm̌́A킸2[Â𕪂B}gD𒧂񂾎}A}̑Oɂ̔sނiڐ̎TB

 @@@@@@}@@@@@

ɂތAA}{{
@@@ IՖҒǂ͂

@u}Ă̑I킾An̗͂ŏ悤ȊՂÂ肪̉ۑɂȂv
@Q@IVIŁA̗ImƂȂ10[Ble܂΂ɂȂwcIΎiVsjŁA˓cYQ@cs𑍊B
@}{ēu}Iv́A613Ɏn܂B}AƂ̑ł킹ŗ}{̖Ζؕq[I΍ψ̓{B

@uV͉ĂȂȂvȗI͂ƂĂ邼vuI̎iߓ͒Nv
@AI΂̐헪lڕW[܂ĂȂȂǁA}{w肵ud_v̂eȎmA@Ζ؎́A˓cIΕ{ɎwBȌA˓cAƂ̑ƂA}{哱ŉ^WJB

@@@@@@@@@@@@

@uoƂȂvB ďA낦قǁA}{̒͂͂܂Bux̗ 5[vƌ{WO񑊂3xB̊[J_ꊲAiY_ѕ犲XƉɖKꂽB
@XɌAI΂͈܂Bcsc㉇gDt]AՂƂȂێw̎xł߂ɖzB}{Ƃ͕ʂɁAKh鏑c𑽂6l荞݁AƁEĉ̎xtɓB
@ȗI蓮vƘbcAscAu򐨂̃X^[gviIΖ{EɍvAjI͍ŏIՂɂȂāuƕ񂾁vƂ݂ꂽB}{̐_ł킸ɑB
@ɂ炸AIɂ͈͂ȂB
@@@@@@@@@@@@

@VЂȂǂ10Ɏ{Q@Ǐoł́A݂݂̋@ɕ\ꂽB
@X͐E󂯂i}AY}xw9AЖ}xw8ł߂BA͎}xw9߂܂Ƃ߂A E󂯂}x7ɂƂǂ܂ĂB
@[̐}ʓ[ł́A}͖486[A}͖92[lB̕[̂܂ܑIɗĂ΁AX578[ɒBvZɂȂ邪A̎xwłߐ؂ȂB}h̎x͖30ɂƂǂ܂A65̐XɍꂽB
@u}{ɁAԂɕ̂ȂvB10[AÎ܂ƂߖSC͔sk󂯁AUiB
@œ}{Iɐ킢d؂邱ƂŁA啨َm΂ɒڂW܂A{lւ̃As[ɒȂƂB
@Z͂܂B[60߂ɏオA}hwɐZXLтB쎁́uőł55ƍlĂvƑłB
@XƂ̕[͖2[BIΖ{̐쎁̒nsł͖4[y΂ȂBwc͐UԂBu2cȂ1cȂɌĂA}ȂvƂ͋CŌ܂łBĂ悤₭ڂo߂Ƃɂ́Axv

2[̎@Q@IVI @@
2016N713@Vm1ʁn@@

 @@@@@@ }@@@@@

iEێw؂
@@@ɂAg R߂

@10AQ@IVIiI1jőSĂ̓[3ԔB҂тXTqi60jm̕񂪓A}4}̌炪W܂͊ɕ܂ꂽB킸2279[BuՓIȏviXjB
@u3NȎOI̖}̕[W߂ΏĂv\B X4{ɖ}Ɍ܂AY}܂ޏ߂Ă̋łāAwc̃[h͏蒲qBAEꎁi57j𗧂Ă鎩}622̌Oҗȑ͐ɏoƂŕ͋C͈ρAɊ@Əłɕ܂悤ɂȂB
@7߁AȂς݂KvƔfXwc͂܂łɂȂɓݏoBЂɒn_ (JAjn߂̂B
@ڐ𐧂錮͕ێw̐؂Ɠ񂾐wćA_umAgiTPPjւ̔_ƕ[vɒ߂BJAO[v̐gD͒E߂ĂAXwćuTPPɔ΂vƑiĉB_Ǝ҂ւ̒ڂ̌Ăъ|߂BZԂ̉^ł͂AɐXẍӎvXɎĂJAꂽB
@_ƕ[̓ے̂ARԒñR_Ƃ𑽂zsB_Ɗ֌W҂ɑpCvwcSɂȂāA}̊Ŕ􂾂˕ʏ⏞x̕iB
@zsO@6́ATPPS̓t{b𖱂߂鎩}ECꎁ̒nՁB_Ɩ@loc҂́uTPPɔ΂Ă̂ɁAɂ܂ŏoȂB̔_Ƃ݂͂Ȃ{ĂvƘR炷B4̎scIŐ͂L΂Y}ȂǂɓAʂɔ_ƕ[悹łƂŁAő̖8[B

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@̐S̖}4}̎xł߂͐TdĐi߂BI΂݂͐A}Ƃɕ[ςݏd˂ɂ₩ȘAgɁB\҂IɉJĉ^eȂǂLƂB
@ɖ}1}̖i}ɁAY}Ƃ̋ɔ߂Bi}͍I΂ȂƂŁugDɓ킯ł͂ȂvƁAx҂ɗĂъ|B
@i}̑基Áuő񐔓IȌŁAn[VNƂȂőPsvƐUԂBVЂȂǂ̏oŐX͖ixw95ł߁A}hwȂǂɂLZB
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@ߋɗ̂Ȃ}tXwcAȃoXłłgg݂A܂܂܂ČʂoƂBԈႦΘgg݂AᔻɊׂ肩˂ȂB
@sĉe}̒Ŝ́AuDs݁vwEĂBe}̎xԐɂxAȂǂ߂ĐwcňӌΗ邱ƂB
@X̓[͖56[ŁAOI̖}̍v58[ɂ͒BȂBʂ蔖X̏B
@Q@̒萔ɂA̍I͑SĂu1lvɂȂB̖}̑IC܂łɂ͑ȘJ͂ƒԂvĂAU邩ȂO@Iɂ܂pł邩͕sB

2[̎@Q@IVI @@
2016N714@Vm3ʁn@@

 @@@@m@@I@@@@

sk̎ Ήɉe
@ ӔC_A}̍UhE

@Q@IVI悪J[ꂽ10AcTFm̎ṕA}EEꎁ̑IɂB ߌ9OAقǋ߂ɓBuȂA܂v\B͂͂ԂB
@10̒mI4Ion̈ӌĂcBQ@In܂622ɂ͒ƁA}̌EEXTq̏owꐺɂꂼꕛmhABg͑ỏɓ炸A7{ɂ̓vWƕčɏoBIԒ̊OV͑O2013NQ@IɑĂ̂ƂB
@ꂪJ[ɂ́ȂIɑXɓBeȑoŗDAcɋ߂c炪ƂBułoAmIŗ݂͂ĂقƂӎv\vB钆c͓ǂ݉B
@13̋L҉ŗK̐^ӂԂꂽćumI߂Al̎v͂邪mƂĂ͍TvƖmɂȂB
@č㉇͎}Ai}A}AЖ}̌gDɐEvĂBł}͏Ic͂ɎxĂB
@uIŉȂ̂ɁÂ̂ĂBȂvBIɗc𕡎GȎvŌ錧cBǁA͗IB2Ԕ݂Ȃɉ߂ćAɎɂB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@Q@IŖ}ɋ蕉éA}̒mIΉɂe𗎂ƂB
@s킩閾11A ɍvA͕񓹐wmIɌ}c̂ƊԂAfBu7͂ȂB~I炾vB܂ŁuQ@IvƂĂXPW[肵B
@wiɂ̂́AQ@IsḱuӔC_vBIΖ{ƂėՂ񂾐쎁͌LcȂAnsŐXɖ3700[ꂽB
@}ɂ͒m𐄂͂ƁAI̕QsƂ̊֌Ẅ𗝗RɁAcɔ΂鐨͂̂ⓖĂĂB쎁͐cɋ߂u돂vƂ鑶݁BmIΉ̐扄΂͎Q@I̐ӔC_ƂƂɁAm_킷uԉ҂vƂ₩B
@쎁̐ӔC_}{AAŋ܂΁Acćuchv𑝂͕̂KB}̋삯͌Ȃ肻B
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@X𗧂āAQ@Iɏ}̒mIΉ͓ʗlqƂȂ肻B
@i}͐c琄E߂ꂽA}{E3܂łƂĂAuBcɑΗԂĂY}́Ai͍BcɗƂ̑Ж}Ή͖肾BQ@Iɑuṽ[h͂ȂB
@mI929ɍA1016ɓJ[BX56[A558[B2[Â𕪂Q@IIAx͒mIɂ񂾍Uh{iB

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/740.html
[eXg31] eXg
{̐HƔ_ƂTgɎxz܂icߎqj

u_ƁvƁuḦSvȂ
wx2016N5ip.194]205j

{̐HƔ_ƂTgɎxz܂@cߎq

TgЈHׂȂflHi

\\@ćwEqxi}ЁjŁAqg݊ifljHïSƕăTgЂɂH̎xzɌx炵Ă܂B
c@flHi͈SmFĂȂɂ炸AEŐHׂĂ̂łBflHil̂ɂǂ̂悤ȉeyۂ͖炩ɂȂĂ܂B
@flHioꂵ̂1996NłBN11AAJ͐Eɂfl哤̗Ao͂߂܂BAJ̓oCIeNmW[ɂ鐶wiɁAE̔_ƂHxzƂƐ헪ɊÂāAfl앨L߂Ă܂B
@̒S̓TgƂƂłBTg͂ăxgi푈ɂāAxgi͗t܂Jw[J[̂łǍ_ƃoCIeNmW[ɐioĂfl앨̊JWJBɎqЂ̔JԂA݂ł͐E̎qsŃVGA1ʂւƐIƂłB
@TǵippjubV哝̂̃oCIeNmW[YƂobNAbvKɘaAȂ킿 flHi͋KȂƂĵƁAKľ̈S]̗p܂BĔɓmȈSɁAfl哤AoĂ̂łB
@AflHi̊댯N悭mĂ̂͑ȂʃTgЈłBׂƂɁA pTgЂ̎ЈHł͂flHisgpfĂ邻łBނ͐EɁuflHi͈SvƌĂȂA͐HׂȂ̂łm1nB
@Ȃ̂ɑO҂ɂfl앨̈Šɂ́Ap̂flq̒񋟂ނƂ͂Ƃ萔X̖WQsĂ܂BȉATgЂ̈͂ ȂȊw҂̌ʂЉ܂m2nB
@1998NAp[EGbg̃A[pbhEvV^CḿAflWKC̏iv悷p{̗vɂ}EXւflWKC^s܂B̌ʂ́A\zǑʂŁA}EX̖Ɖu͒ቺA]ȆEΊۂ̔sSAݒ̍\ωƍזEBmFꂽ̂łB
@[EFbg̓CMX{ƃTgЂ猤Ă܂BihɕssȂ̌ʂׂ܂ɁAvV^Cm͋}AerԑgɐoĎʂ𖾂炩ɂAu͐΂ɐHׂȂvubgɂĂ͂ȂȂvƌx炵܂B2Aނ͌ق܂B
@2005NAVAȊwAJf~[̃G}R@ḿAX̃}EXɁADPoYfl哤iTgАja܂BƁAe}EX̐3TԈȓ̎S50ȏiʏ56{jƂׂʂo܂Bce}EXɂ͊EsSE\ȂǂmF܂Bɕ}EX͔DPqǂ̐AŸ玙܂B̌͂fl哤ʂɐHׂĂ{lɋx炷̂łB
@2012NAJ[w̃Z[jm𒆐SƂ錤[flgERViTgАj^ʁA񗦂⋐ȎᇂmF܂iŐ}m3njBɕώO̎S̓IX60%iʏ2{jAX80%iʏ4{jƂMȂl̂łB

\\@fl앨Ƃ͉Ȃ̂łB
c@iꂽ̂ōł̂ATg̏܁uEhAbvvɑϐuEhAbvfBvi哤AgERVA؎AȂȂǁjƂ앨łBEhAbv͋͂ȏ܂ŁAGł͂Ȃ앨܂Ō͂Ă܂̂ŁA앨YĂ鎞͎gpł܂łBEhAbv𗁂тĂ͂Ȃ悤Ɉq{ꂽEhAbvfBȂΈĂ܂BTǵuȂ珜̎ԂȂ܂vƂGꍞ݂ŁAEhAbvƃEhAbvfBZbgŔ̔Ă܂B
@EhAbv͌NQEj̊댯wEĂ܂Bfl앨̖O͔|LʐςōsĂnCBł́Aʂ̏܁EE܂󒆎Uz_̎͂ŌNQĂ܂BǏ͔aE畆QEVُȂǂłB_Uzn܂Ǝqǂ@o蓪ɂڂ̒ɂ݂i肷̂ŁAwZxZɂȂ邱Ƃ͂܂B
@E3ʂ̂fl앨͔|A[ł́AEhAbv̋󒆎UzɂĔaE畆ᇁEQAZɔoĂ܂B܂EhAbvUzȃT^tFB𒲍ƂABł͑Sςɔ10{̊̑A3{݂̈E̔mF܂B2003Nɂ̓f}[ŇAEhAbv͒nNƔ\܂B
@fl앨ɂ͂fl앨Hׂ邱Ƃ̊댯ł͂ȂAfl앨邱Ƃ̊댯̂łB

xz郂Tg

\\@Tg͂fl앨ʂāAǂ̂悤ȃrWlXĂ̂łB
c@Tg͎qxz邱ƂŁAȗvグĂ܂BTg͂fl앨̎qɓĂ܂Bqgp邽߂ɂ̓TgɓxKvAfŎgpΔ܂B肪NQƂƍ߂ɂȂĂ܂̂łB
@܂̂flq͎qiɓ悹Ă܂Aɉēq瓾n̔ɑ΂ē{iCZXj藧ĂĂ̂łBuWł500̔_Ƃ̓dƂė̕Ԋ҂߂ăTgiĂ܂B
@ɃTg͔_ƂɖNq𔃂킹邽߂ɁA𖳈ӖɂĂ܂uqEvZpJ܂B앨Ɏ2ڂ̎qɓł𔭐AEZp̓^[~l[^[ZpƌĂ΂Ă܂BqɃ^[~l[^[ZpvO~OĂ܂΁A_Ƃ͕̎Iɕs\ɂȂ܂B̈̋ZpJƂŁA Tg͎̐̂v̂߂Ȃ牽ł锽ЉI~ƂłƐEɎN̂łB
@RAE狭΂̐NATǵu^[~l[^[Zp͉pȂvƐ錾܂BǍuHpł͉pȂvƌςAflȉԂł̉p\AĔ_Ȃ͂flȉԂł̃^[~l[^[Zp̗pFĂ܂B

\\@Tg͎ɓłflqǗĂB
c@ꂪQrWlXɌq܂BTg͓fl앨fō͔|ĂƂĔ_ƂɑQ߂iׂN̂łB
@̑\ႪJi_̔_ƃV}CU[̃P[XłB1998NATǵuȂ̔_ɂ킪Ђ̓앨Ă̂mFBNQ̔xȂΒivƒʍ܂B V}CU[́ugɊoȂvƌčٔ󂯂ė܂Aōق܂ŐĔsi܂B̔́A앨̎qÂڂɂ̂ł낤ƁA⒎Aɉ^΂ĎƂĂA앨ĂNQɂƂׂ̂łm4nB
@ĐHiSZ^[2007N̒ɂ΁ATg͓NQ̘a1700018600hW߂Ă܂Bōz̓m[XJCiB̔_Ƃ305hBTg͑QrWlX邽߂ɁAN1000hEl75̑iוݒuĂ܂B
@ɃTg|XƌĂ΂lA_ƂNQĂȂĎĂ܂BTg͒Tقł͂ȂA_ƊԂ̖サĂ܂B̌ʁAn拤̂̐lԊ֌W{{ɂĂ܂B
@Tg̎qƐ肷rWlX@́A͂rWlẌ𒴂Ă܂B͔_ƂxzAE̐Hxz悤ƂĂƔĂd܂B

\\@fl앨͔|Ă_Ƃ͖LɂȂĂ̂łB
c@Ƃ͌܂BƂ΃Chɂ̓TgP̃}qRЂƂqƂ܂BCh̔_́uQɋAnʂvƂGꍞ݂Ń}qRЂ̂flȉԂĂɓ܂B nCh̖ȉԔ_͎؋č̂flȉԂ̎q엿A_w܂A ʂ͕slɌAz̗vȂƂ΂΋N܂B
@̌ʁAChł͕͈Ƃ@邱ƂA̔_ÊłBChƔƍߋL^ǂ̒ł́AE_Ƃ 2002N10NԂ17lɏĂ܂Bɂ̓EhAbvŎEP[XȂ܂B

{l͂flHiȂȂ

\\@soołflHi͂ǂȂ̂łB
c@܂fl앨EflHiɂĐḦSES͕󂷂ł傤B݁A{ł͑哤AgERVA΂ꂢA؎AȎAAt@t@A Ă؁AppC8ނłfli킪FĂ܂Aꉞfl̕\܂B
@{{́AuflHi\܂߁AHi̕\vɊւ{̐x̕ύXKvƂȂK݂͐ĂȂvƐĂ܂BƂ{i邱ƂłhrcrɂāAflHi̕\ȋׂΏۂɂȂ\܂BTg炪Auwqg݊sgpxƂ\́A flHi͗ǂȂƂC[W҂ɐAtĂBsȍʓIfՏǂvƂœ{{iAƂŕ\KPp鋰ꂪ܂B
@܂Asooɂ́usasifՂ̋ZpIQjvƂ܂B@Jł͂fl̕\͕svłA{̕\́uZpIQvƂēPp𔗂\܂B
@soo΁Afl̕\K͊ɘaEPpł傤B҂͂ǂ̐HiflȂ̂fłA{l͂fl앨邱ƂłȂȂ܂B

\\@{͂soo؍ӂ̈ꕔuTvvƂĔ\܂m5nB
c@sO[v󂵂Ăꂽ菑ǂ݂܂ƁA̖肪܂m6nBƂ΁A@Ăfl앨fՂ̒fAVKF𑣐iƂĂ܂B
@ɂfl앨ɊւSRfl\̐RcɃTgȂǊJƂQ邱ƂɂȂĂ̂łBSK\K͍ɂAflHi̗ʂCɊg傷邱Ƃ͖ڂɌĂ܂Bfl앨̗AołAJ̎Oȃ[łAflHi̗Aog_̂łB
@A肪ƂĂA͐^m炳܂B݂łflHiɊւRćuƓ̔閧邽߁vƂŔJɂȂĂ܂B͓{HiqŔFɉ{ł\āA߂ďڍׂm邱Ƃł̂łA{݂̂ŕʂBeւĂ܂Bɂ͍ȟ܂Bsoo΁AumILvɉ{͐^ɂȂ̂ł͂ȂƊ䂵܂B
@uTvv́AQ֌W҂ɐRcւ̎QF߂̂́AƂɑ΂āuvmۂ邽߂搂Ă܂BłA{̗Q֌W҂ł鍑ɑ΂uv͈ڂɂĂ܂BRc͊Ƃɂ͓ĂAɂ̓ubN{bNXłB̈ꎖȂĂĂAsoo̐̂Ƃ̗v̂߂ɍ]ɂ̂ƂƂ͖炩łB

\\@̏ŁAǂ̂悤ȂflHiĂ̂łB
c@܃Tg͓{̊֐œPpEKPpɓāAAJłflflĂ̏ƍ͔|_ĂƎv܂Błɂfl͏i\Ă܂BA{̏oC[́AAJłfl̐Yn܂΁A͔Ȃ̂ŁAflEfl킸AJ͔̏ȂƂӎv߁AAJ̏Y҂͂flɔ΂AAJ{͔FĂ܂łBA{łflKɘa΁AAJłflflĂ̐Yn܂A{ɗAo邱ƂɂȂł傤B
@Tg͍ނł͂ȂAfl؂ɂ肵Ă܂B܂ATgł͂܂񂪁Aflʕ̊JĂ܂B؂ĂFɂȂȂSr^~oiiAaCɂȂɂIWȂǂłB
ɂfl܂ŊJĂ܂BăANAoEeBEeNmW[YЂ́AȂƂflTPĴłB͐zo悤Ɉq삵TPŁAʂ̃TP2{̑xŐ܂Bo׃TCYɂȂ鎔Ԃōςނ킯łAoׂȂł25{̑傫ɂ܂Ő邻łB
@z펞債AזE􂪐Ȃ߂̃XNɌq̂ł͂ȂƎwEĂ܂BflTP̓Ji_ƃpi}̗ɐݒuRN[g̃v[ŗ{BĂ܂Aw҂́AuCɕꂽꍇAVR̃TPłĂ܂̂ł͂ȂvƋTĂ܂B
@flTP2015N11AĐHiiǁiec) ɂĕ\ȂŐHiƂĔ̔邱ƂF߂ꂽ̂łAN12AAMc@͂flTP̕\A\xX^[g܂Ŕ̔͂Ă͂ȂȂƌ肵܂BAJ̗Ao͓ʂȂłAJi_pi}Ȃǂ̑I񂵂ē{֗Ao\͔ےł܂B

\\@flHiȊOɂ͂܂B
c@{{͂sooƕsāAē񍑊ԋctA͍Ӎς݂łB̌́uqAuirorjvƂڂɂ́AunOyюnɎgphJr܁AHiYA[AR[QōӂvƏĂ܂B
@܂Au{͍ŋ֎~Ăn_i|Xgn[xXgjF߂܂BAJ݂ɐHiY𑝂₵܂Bå댯鋍R̃[AR[QF߂܂vƂƂłBSɋ^̎cHiAJ{֐ꍞނƂɂȂƎv܂B

{_Ƃ̓Tgɏ

\\@sooŐḦSES͉łĂ܂܂B
c@soo͐ḦSESł͂ȂA{̐ḦSۏႻ̂̂󂳂܂B܍łxׂ́A{ł̂fl앨̐YJnłBł{ŗʂF߂ꂽfl앨͖@Iɂ͐Ył܂B܂ł\ȂǐŔ_Ƃɂfl哤̐Y݂܂AӔ_ƂsA̔_ۂȂǂ̒RɂāAƂj~Ă܂B
@݁A{̉ŋKvcƂ̔_nL̋Kɘai߂Ă܂B̌㉟wiɁAƂ{Cłfl앨̐Yɏo΁Aj~邱Ƃ͍ɂȂ܂B
@łɍƐ헪́u_ƓvɎw肳ꂽɌ{sł́AOnƂ̔_nL܂ŔF߂Ă܂BTg{łfl앨𐶎ÝA܂ŗĂ̂łBfl̐SzȂȂǈSłuYṽuh܂B
@{̔_Ƃ͋nɗ܂B֐œPpňĂAl_Ył͂ȂÅƔ_ƂƂ̋ɎNATgɂNQ̑i׃XN܂BƂfl앨ɏ芷ĂAN𔃂킳A̓xɓƓ{𕥂킳܂B{_Ƃ͔jY郊XNB
@Ȃ΁ATgn߂ƂƂpƂ_Ƃ̍knLāAfl앨͔̍|˂܂B{̓nClA_n̉ɏZAwZAa@ȂǂאڂĂ邽߁Aߗ׏Z̓EhAbvȂǔ_̑ʂ̋󒆎UzɂČNQ󂯂邱ƂɂȂ܂BCAy␅Aւ̊i݂܂BzɊׂ댯͔ɍƎv܂B
@{Ƃł͍ς݂܂BTgqYƂɏoƂ́A19952000N܂ł̂킸5NԂŁAE50Јȏ̎qЂ𔃎܂BsooɂĊOɂl̋Kɘa΁ATJ^gL^ȂǓ݂̂{̎ƂۂƓۂ݂܂Ă܂댯܂B
@sooɎQ΁A{͒xꑁATg̎qxz̐ɑgݍ܂ł傤Bł{͐E̐HAłAAJ͐E̐HAołBăAJ͐H헪ƌȂAuH̓AJɂƂčŏIłvi1974NAbh|[gjƍlĂ܂BɃTgЂ͓{̔_Ƃ̎qǗɒuƂł傤BtrsqiĒʏ\ĵsoo_ƎȌɂ́ATg̃rCXgACĂ̂łB
@{{͓{̐HǗ錠A܂uH匠vAJ{ETgɍoƂɂȂ܂B

{flHi𐄐iĂ

\\@Tg͋낵ƂłB
c@ہATǵuET^vƝAEᔻĂ܂B2011Nɂ́ANTCguiE\TCGeB[vulԂ̌Nъ̗ɋЂ^ĂvƂāAu[XgPƁv̗oĂ܂B2013NɂȂꂽuTgsivɂ́AE200lȏオQ܂B
@Tg͖̓Ԃɗ܂܂Bdt2014Nɂfl앨͔̍|Ɋւ锻feɈςˁA2819flI܂BVAfl앨͔̍|֎~Ă܂B܂̓AJYgERV̈ꕔɂflgERVĂƂėAۂɓݐ؂AAJɂƂ30h̑QƂȂ܂BN230g̑哤AĂp{͂̂сAwZHSĂɂfl앨̎gp֎~܂B
@̃AJłAflHiɔ΂@^܂Ă܂BAJw2010NɁAflHĩgAƈS̎{AflHi̕\߂ƂƂɁADwcɂflHiHׂȂ悤ɎwKvƎwEĂ܂B܂2013Nɂ̓nCBAo[gBA[BȂ13BflHi̕\ÂB@𐬗Ă܂B
@EIɂfl앨ɑ΂鍑Ƃ̋K܂Ăɂ炸A{͐E̒ɋtsŁATg̈ӌɉAJ̗vBXXƎ󂯓Ă̂łB͂sooɔ΂AAJɁumnIvƌ鐭Ȃ΂Ȃ܂B

\\@fl͂sooł͂ȂEŜ̖łB
c@̒ʂłBfl앨𒆐SƂ_Ƃ̂̂EɂȂ܂B݁AEhAbvł͂ȂG\ނ܂Ă܂B܂P邤AGϐlĂ܂̂łBŃTg̓EhAbv苭͂ȏ܁Aꂱxgi푈Ŏgꂽ񐫂̍͗t܂̎gpi߂Ă܂Błɂ𗁂тĂ͂Ȃfl哤͓{ŔFĂ܂B
@͂Ȍ͗t܂͂΂炭͌܂A₪Č͗t܂ł͂ȂGoĂł傤BĎRƂ̂JԂĂԂɌNQEi݁AlԂZ߂ȂȂĂ܂yn邾ł͂Ȃł傤B
@ނɂ͎Rւ̈؂ꂪ܂BɓF߂Ƃẑ̂łB
@q͐_̗̈łBȊw҂̓qg̈q̔z𖾂炩ɂ܂Â߂ɂ̂ȂqR܂B̌A疳p̒ƎvĂq́A͖Ă邾ŁAGȑ݂̃lbg[N̂ȂŕKvȎɖڂo܂ēƂƂ킩Ă܂B̂ƂATǵuLpȈqvėpƂzAɔ؂ȉȊwł邩Ǝv܂B
@qg݊Zp͌q͂Ɠ悤ɎԂ̂ȂN܂Blɂĉςꂽq͂̐̎ɓ܂Bꂩ琶܂Ă鐶͉iqĂ܂̂łB RE킹An̐Ԍnc߂Ă܂̂łB炱E̐lX΂Ă̂łB厩R␶̖ɐ_ȑ݂A؂ꑸŋɐĂ̑c悽B̊Ăъo܂Am̂悤Ɏ邱Ƃ͊ԈĂƔ΂̐グׂłB

cߎqi₷Ej
HZ^[urW21v\BɁwEqxi}ЁjȂǁB
2016N325

1 upTgЂ̎ЈHł͂flHisgpfĂ邻łvuނ͐EɁuflHi͈SvƌĂȂA͐HׂȂ̂łv

2 uTgЂ̈͂ ȂȊw҂̌ʂЉ܂v
ŏЉĂvV^CAG}R@уZ[ǰ[ɂ錤ɂẮA@f[^߂߂āAƂ̔ᔻE炵BA_w҂ɂ2007N̑eɂ΁AɑĒ{uwI悤Ƃ铮͂قƂǌȂƂB̌̌ɂĂ͂킩ȂA݂ł̓m[x܂܂Ȋw҂i_110jqg앨ѐHïSɑ۔JȂ𔭕\ɂĂBS̍ƂẮAĚEK@ւJԂmFĉ肪ȂvƂĂB
Scientific and regulatory agencies around the world have repeatedly and consistently found crops and foods improved through biotechnology to be as safe as, if not safer than those derived from any other method of production. There has never been a single confirmed case of a negative health outcome for humans or animals from their consumption. Their environmental impacts have been shown repeatedly to be less damaging to the environment, and a boon to global biodiversity.
Laureates Letter Supporting Precision Agriculture (GMOs)

3 uŐ}v

4 u̔́A앨̎qÂڂɂ̂ł낤ƁA⒎Aɉ^΂ĎƂĂA앨ĂNQɂƂׂ̂łv
ɂĂTgЂ͔_ĂBV}CU[́Ãi^lɍĂfli^lEhAbv܂gpۂɕʂĎnƂŁAӐ}IɓNQĂB܂̃i^lɈĂfli^lRɍ̂Ƃ͍lȂBӐ}IłȂfl앨̍ɂāATgЂ_Ƃi邱Ƃ͂ȂƁB
p[V[EV}CU[ɂāiPercy Schmeiserj
Percy Schmeiser
Myth: Monsanto Sues Farmers When GMOs or GM Seed is Accidentally in Their Fields

5 u{͂soo؍ӂ̈ꕔuTvvƂĔ\܂v
́uTvv͂߂Ƃ֘A񑊊@TCgŌJĂB
sooimp[gi[Vbvj

6 usO[v󂵂Ăꂽ菑ǂ݂܂ƁA̖肪܂v
ǂ̎sO[vŵ͂肵ȂAƂΎRcFAcqɂuTPP蕪̓|[gvQƁB
TPP̑S̑Ɩ_\sĉɂ镪͕񍐁\Ver.4i2016/4/3j
[14] {̐HƔ_ƂTgɎxz܂icߎqj
u_ƁvƁuḦSvȂ@
wx2016N5ip.194]205j

{̐HƔ_ƂTgɎxz܂@cߎq

TgЈHׂȂflHi

\\@ćwEqxi}ЁjŁAqg݊ifljHïSƕăTgЂɂH̎xzɌx炵Ă܂B
c@flHi͈SmFĂȂɂ炸AEŐHׂĂ̂łBflHil̂ɂǂ̂悤ȉeyۂ͖炩ɂȂĂ܂B
@flHioꂵ̂1996NłBN11AAJ͐Eɂfl哤̗Ao͂߂܂BAJ̓oCIeNmW[ɂ鐶wiɁAE̔_ƂHxzƂƐ헪ɊÂāAfl앨L߂Ă܂B
@̒S̓TgƂƂłBTg͂ăxgi푈ɂāAxgi͗t܂Jw[J[̂łǍ_ƃoCIeNmW[ɐioĂfl앨̊JWJBɎqЂ̔JԂA݂ł͐E̎qsŃVGA1ʂւƐIƂłB
@TǵippjubV哝̂̃oCIeNmW[YƂobNAbvKɘaAȂ킿 flHi͋KȂƂĵƁAKľ̈S]̗p܂BĔɓmȈSɁAfl哤AoĂ̂łB
@AflHi̊댯N悭mĂ̂͑ȂʃTgЈłBׂƂɁA pTgЂ̎ЈHł͂flHisgpfĂ邻łm1nBނ͐EɁuflHi͈SvƌĂȂA͐HׂȂ̂łB
@Ȃ̂ɑO҂ɂfl앨̈Šɂ́Ap̂flq̒񋟂ނƂ͂Ƃ萔X̖WQsĂ܂BȉATgЂ̈͂ ȂȊw҂̌ʂЉ܂m2nB
@1998NAp[EGbg̃A[pbhEvV^CḿAflWKC̏iv悷p{̗vɂ}EXւflWKC^s܂B̌ʂ́A\zǑʂŁA}EX̖Ɖu͒ቺA]ȆEΊۂ̔sSAݒ̍\ωƍזEBmFꂽ̂łB
@[EFbg̓CMX{ƃTgЂ猤Ă܂BihɕssȂ̌ʂׂ܂ɁAvV^Cm͋}AerԑgɐoĎʂ𖾂炩ɂAu͐΂ɐHׂȂvubgɂĂ͂ȂȂvƌx炵܂B2Aނ͌ق܂B
@2005NAVAȊwAJf~[̃G}R@ḿAX̃}EXɁADPoYfl哤iTgАja܂BƁAe}EX̐3TԈȓ̎S50ȏiʏ56{jƂׂʂo܂Bce}EXɂ͊EsSE\ȂǂmF܂Bɕ}EX͔DPqǂ̐AŸ玙܂B̌͂fl哤ʂɐHׂĂ{lɋx炷̂łB
@2012NAJ[w̃Z[jm𒆐SƂ錤[flgERViTgАj^ʁA񗦂⋐ȎᇂmF܂iŐ}m3njBɕώO̎S̓IX60%iʏ2{jAX80%iʏ4{jƂMȂl̂łB

\\@fl앨Ƃ͉Ȃ̂łB
c@iꂽ̂ōł̂ATg̏܁uEhAbvvɑϐuEhAbvfBvi哤AgERVA؎AȂȂǁjƂ앨łBEhAbv͋͂ȏ܂ŁAGł͂Ȃ앨܂Ō͂Ă܂̂ŁA앨YĂ鎞͎gpł܂łBEhAbv𗁂тĂ͂Ȃ悤Ɉq{ꂽEhAbvfBȂΈĂ܂BTǵuȂ珜̎ԂȂ܂vƂGꍞ݂ŁAEhAbvƃEhAbvfBZbgŔ̔Ă܂B
@EhAbv͌NQEj̊댯wEĂ܂Bfl앨̖O͔|LʐςōsĂnCBł́Aʂ̏܁EE܂󒆎Uz_̎͂ŌNQĂ܂BǏ͔aE畆QEVُȂǂłB_Uzn܂Ǝqǂ@o蓪ɂڂ̒ɂ݂i肷̂ŁAwZxZɂȂ邱Ƃ͂܂B
@E3ʂ̂fl앨͔|A[ł́AEhAbv̋󒆎UzɂĔaE畆ᇁEQAZɔoĂ܂B܂EhAbvUzȃT^tFB𒲍ƂABł͑Sςɔ10{̊̑A3{݂̈E̔mF܂B2003Nɂ̓f}[ŇAEhAbv͒nNƔ\܂B
@fl앨ɂ͂fl앨Hׂ邱Ƃ̊댯ł͂ȂAfl앨邱Ƃ̊댯̂łB

xz郂Tg

\\@Tg͂fl앨ʂāAǂ̂悤ȃrWlXĂ̂łB
c@Tg͎qxz邱ƂŁAȗvグĂ܂BTg͂fl앨̎qɓĂ܂Bqgp邽߂ɂ̓TgɓxKvAfŎgpΔ܂B肪NQƂƍ߂ɂȂĂ܂̂łB
@܂̂flq͎qiɓ悹Ă܂Aɉēq瓾n̔ɑ΂ē{iCZXj藧ĂĂ̂łBuWł500̔_Ƃ̓dƂė̕Ԋ҂߂ăTgiĂ܂B
@ɃTg͔_ƂɖNq𔃂킹邽߂ɁA𖳈ӖɂĂ܂uqEvZpJ܂B앨Ɏ2ڂ̎qɓł𔭐AEZp̓^[~l[^[ZpƌĂ΂Ă܂BqɃ^[~l[^[ZpvO~OĂ܂΁A_Ƃ͕̎Iɕs\ɂȂ܂B̈̋ZpJƂŁA Tg͎̐̂v̂߂Ȃ牽ł锽ЉI~ƂłƐEɎN̂łB
@RAE狭΂̐NATǵu^[~l[^[Zp͉pȂvƐ錾܂BǍuHpł͉pȂvƌςAflȉԂł̉p\AĔ_Ȃ͂flȉԂł̃^[~l[^[Zp̗pFĂ܂B

\\@Tg͎ɓłflqǗĂB
c@ꂪQrWlXɌq܂BTg͓fl앨fō͔|ĂƂĔ_ƂɑQ߂iׂN̂łB
@̑\ႪJi_̔_ƃV}CU[̃P[XłB1998NATǵuȂ̔_ɂ킪Ђ̓앨Ă̂mFBNQ̔xȂΒivƒʍ܂B V}CU[́ugɊoȂvƌčٔ󂯂ė܂Aōق܂ŐĔsi܂B̔́A앨̎qÂڂɂ̂ł낤ƁA⒎Aɉ^΂ĎƂĂA앨ĂNQɂƂׂ̂łm4nB
@ĐHiSZ^[2007N̒ɂ΁ATg͓NQ̘a1700018600hW߂Ă܂Bōz̓m[XJCiB̔_Ƃ305hBTg͑QrWlX邽߂ɁAN1000hEl75̑iוݒuĂ܂B
@ɃTg|XƌĂ΂lA_ƂNQĂȂĎĂ܂BTg͒Tقł͂ȂA_ƊԂ̖サĂ܂B̌ʁAn拤̂̐lԊ֌W{{ɂĂ܂B
@Tg̎qƐ肷rWlX@́A͂rWlẌ𒴂Ă܂B͔_ƂxzAE̐Hxz悤ƂĂƔĂd܂B

\\@fl앨͔|Ă_Ƃ͖LɂȂĂ̂łB
c@Ƃ͌܂BƂ΃Chɂ̓TgP̃}qRЂƂqƂ܂BCh̔_́uQɋAnʂvƂGꍞ݂Ń}qRЂ̂flȉԂĂɓ܂B nCh̖ȉԔ_͎؋č̂flȉԂ̎q엿A_w܂A ʂ͕slɌAz̗vȂƂ΂΋N܂B
@̌ʁAChł͕͈Ƃ@邱ƂA̔_ÊłBChƔƍߋL^ǂ̒ł́AE_Ƃ 2002N10NԂ17lɏĂ܂Bɂ̓EhAbvŎEP[XȂ܂B

{l͂flHiȂȂ

\\@soołflHi͂ǂȂ̂łB
c@܂fl앨EflHiɂĐḦSES͕󂷂ł傤B݁A{ł͑哤AgERVA΂ꂢA؎AȎAAt@t@A Ă؁AppC8ނłfli킪FĂ܂Aꉞfl̕\܂B
@{{́AuflHi\܂߁AHi̕\vɊւ{̐x̕ύXKvƂȂK݂͐ĂȂvƐĂ܂BƂ{i邱ƂłhrcrɂāAflHi̕\ȋׂΏۂɂȂ\܂BTg炪Auwqg݊sgpxƂ\́A flHi͗ǂȂƂC[W҂ɐAtĂBsȍʓIfՏǂvƂœ{{iAƂŕ\KPp鋰ꂪ܂B
@܂Asooɂ́usasifՂ̋ZpIQjvƂ܂B@Jł͂fl̕\͕svłA{̕\́uZpIQvƂēPp𔗂\܂B
@soo΁Afl̕\K͊ɘaEPpł傤B҂͂ǂ̐HiflȂ̂fłA{l͂fl앨邱ƂłȂȂ܂B

\\@{͂soo؍ӂ̈ꕔuTvvƂĔ\܂m5nB
c@sO[v󂵂Ăꂽ菑ǂ݂܂ƁA̖肪܂m6nBƂ΁A@Ăfl앨fՂ̒fAVKF𑣐iƂĂ܂B
@ɂfl앨ɊւSRfl\̐RcɃTgȂǊJƂQ邱ƂɂȂĂ̂łBSK\K͍ɂAflHi̗ʂCɊg傷邱Ƃ͖ڂɌĂ܂Bfl앨̗AołAJ̎Oȃ[łAflHi̗Aog_̂łB
@A肪ƂĂA͐^m炳܂B݂łflHiɊւRćuƓ̔閧邽߁vƂŔJɂȂĂ܂B͓{HiqŔFɉ{ł\āA߂ďڍׂm邱Ƃł̂łA{݂̂ŕʂBeւĂ܂Bɂ͍ȟ܂Bsoo΁AumILvɉ{͐^ɂȂ̂ł͂ȂƊ䂵܂B
@uTvv́AQ֌W҂ɐRcւ̎QF߂̂́AƂɑ΂āuvmۂ邽߂搂Ă܂BłA{̗Q֌W҂ł鍑ɑ΂uv͈ڂɂĂ܂BRc͊Ƃɂ͓ĂAɂ̓ubN{bNXłB̈ꎖȂĂĂAsoo̐̂Ƃ̗v̂߂ɍ]ɂ̂ƂƂ͖炩łB

\\@̏ŁAǂ̂悤ȂflHiĂ̂łB
c@܃Tg͓{̊֐œPpEKPpɓāAAJłflflĂ̏ƍ͔|_ĂƎv܂Błɂfl͏i\Ă܂BA{̏oC[́AAJłfl̐Yn܂΁A͔Ȃ̂ŁAflEfl킸AJ͔̏ȂƂӎv߁AAJ̏Y҂͂flɔ΂AAJ{͔FĂ܂łBA{łflKɘa΁AAJłflflĂ̐Yn܂A{ɗAo邱ƂɂȂł傤B
@Tg͍ނł͂ȂAfl؂ɂ肵Ă܂B܂ATgł͂܂񂪁Aflʕ̊JĂ܂B؂ĂFɂȂȂSr^~oiiAaCɂȂɂIWȂǂłB
ɂfl܂ŊJĂ܂BăANAoEeBEeNmW[YЂ́AȂƂflTPĴłB͐zo悤Ɉq삵TPŁAʂ̃TP2{̑xŐ܂Bo׃TCYɂȂ鎔Ԃōςނ킯łAoׂȂł25{̑傫ɂ܂Ő邻łB
@z펞債AזE􂪐Ȃ߂̃XNɌq̂ł͂ȂƎwEĂ܂BflTP̓Ji_ƃpi}̗ɐݒuRN[g̃v[ŗ{BĂ܂Aw҂́AuCɕꂽꍇAVR̃TPłĂ܂̂ł͂ȂvƋTĂ܂B
@flTP2015N11AĐHiiǁiec) ɂĕ\ȂŐHiƂĔ̔邱ƂF߂ꂽ̂łAN12AAMc@͂flTP̕\A\xX^[g܂Ŕ̔͂Ă͂ȂȂƌ肵܂BAJ̗Ao͓ʂȂłAJi_pi}Ȃǂ̑I񂵂ē{֗Ao\͔ےł܂B

\\@flHiȊOɂ͂܂B
c@{{͂sooƕsāAē񍑊ԋctA͍Ӎς݂łB̌́uqAuirorjvƂڂɂ́AunOyюnɎgphJr܁AHiYA[AR[QōӂvƏĂ܂B
@܂Au{͍ŋ֎~Ăn_i|Xgn[xXgjF߂܂BAJ݂ɐHiY𑝂₵܂Bå댯鋍R̃[AR[QF߂܂vƂƂłBSɋ^̎cHiAJ{֐ꍞނƂɂȂƎv܂B

{_Ƃ̓Tgɏ

\\@sooŐḦSES͉łĂ܂܂B
c@soo͐ḦSESł͂ȂA{̐ḦSۏႻ̂̂󂳂܂B܍łxׂ́A{ł̂fl앨̐YJnłBł{ŗʂF߂ꂽfl앨͖@Iɂ͐Ył܂B܂ł\ȂǐŔ_Ƃɂfl哤̐Y݂܂AӔ_ƂsA̔_ۂȂǂ̒RɂāAƂj~Ă܂B
@݁A{̉ŋKvcƂ̔_nL̋Kɘai߂Ă܂B̌㉟wiɁAƂ{Cłfl앨̐Yɏo΁Aj~邱Ƃ͍ɂȂ܂B
@łɍƐ헪́u_ƓvɎw肳ꂽɌ{sł́AOnƂ̔_nL܂ŔF߂Ă܂BTg{łfl앨𐶎ÝA܂ŗĂ̂łBfl̐SzȂȂǈSłuYṽuh܂B
@{̔_Ƃ͋nɗ܂B֐œPpňĂAl_Ył͂ȂÅƔ_ƂƂ̋ɎNATgɂNQ̑i׃XN܂BƂfl앨ɏ芷ĂAN𔃂킳A̓xɓƓ{𕥂킳܂B{_Ƃ͔jY郊XNB
@Ȃ΁ATgn߂ƂƂpƂ_Ƃ̍knLāAfl앨͔̍|˂܂B{̓nClA_n̉ɏZAwZAa@ȂǂאڂĂ邽߁Aߗ׏Z̓EhAbvȂǔ_̑ʂ̋󒆎UzɂČNQ󂯂邱ƂɂȂ܂BCAy␅Aւ̊i݂܂BzɊׂ댯͔ɍƎv܂B
@{Ƃł͍ς݂܂BTgqYƂɏoƂ́A19952000N܂ł̂킸5NԂŁAE50Јȏ̎qЂ𔃎܂BsooɂĊOɂl̋Kɘa΁ATJ^gL^ȂǓ݂̂{̎ƂۂƓۂ݂܂Ă܂댯܂B
@sooɎQ΁A{͒xꑁATg̎qxz̐ɑgݍ܂ł傤Bł{͐E̐HAłAAJ͐E̐HAołBăAJ͐H헪ƌȂAuH̓AJɂƂčŏIłvi1974NAbh|[gjƍlĂ܂BɃTgЂ͓{̔_Ƃ̎qǗɒuƂł傤BtrsqiĒʏ\ĵsoo_ƎȌɂ́ATg̃rCXgACĂ̂łB
@{{͓{̐HǗ錠A܂uH匠vAJ{ETgɍoƂɂȂ܂B

{flHi𐄐iĂ

\\@Tg͋낵ƂłB
c@ہATǵuET^vƝAEᔻĂ܂B2011Nɂ́ANTCguiE\TCGeB[vulԂ̌Nъ̗ɋЂ^ĂvƂāAu[XgPƁv̗oĂ܂B2013NɂȂꂽuTgsivɂ́AE200lȏオQ܂B
@Tg͖̓Ԃɗ܂܂Bdt2014Nɂfl앨͔̍|Ɋւ锻feɈςˁA2819flI܂BVAfl앨͔̍|֎~Ă܂B܂̓AJYgERV̈ꕔɂflgERVĂƂėAۂɓݐ؂AAJɂƂ30h̑QƂȂ܂BN230g̑哤AĂp{͂̂сAwZHSĂɂfl앨̎gp֎~܂B
@̃AJłAflHiɔ΂@^܂Ă܂BAJw2010NɁAflHĩgAƈS̎{AflHi̕\߂ƂƂɁADwcɂflHiHׂȂ悤ɎwKvƎwEĂ܂B܂2013Nɂ̓nCBAo[gBA[BȂ13BflHi̕\ÂB@𐬗Ă܂B
@EIɂfl앨ɑ΂鍑Ƃ̋K܂Ăɂ炸A{͐E̒ɋtsŁATg̈ӌɉAJ̗vBXXƎ󂯓Ă̂łB͂sooɔ΂AAJɁumnIvƌ鐭Ȃ΂Ȃ܂B

\\@fl͂sooł͂ȂEŜ̖łB
c@̒ʂłBfl앨𒆐SƂ_Ƃ̂̂EɂȂ܂B݁AEhAbvł͂ȂG\ނ܂Ă܂B܂P邤AGϐlĂ܂̂łBŃTg̓EhAbv苭͂ȏ܁Aꂱxgi푈Ŏgꂽ񐫂̍͗t܂̎gpi߂Ă܂Błɂ𗁂тĂ͂Ȃfl哤͓{ŔFĂ܂B
@͂Ȍ͗t܂͂΂炭͌܂A₪Č͗t܂ł͂ȂGoĂł傤BĎRƂ̂JԂĂԂɌNQEi݁AlԂZ߂ȂȂĂ܂yn邾ł͂Ȃł傤B
@ނɂ͎Rւ̈؂ꂪ܂BɓF߂Ƃẑ̂łB
@q͐_̗̈łBȊw҂̓qg̈q̔z𖾂炩ɂ܂Â߂ɂ̂ȂqR܂B̌A疳p̒ƎvĂq́A͖Ă邾ŁAGȑ݂̃lbg[N̂ȂŕKvȎɖڂo܂ēƂƂ킩Ă܂B̂ƂATǵuLpȈqvėpƂzAɔ؂ȉȊwł邩Ǝv܂B
@qg݊Zp͌q͂Ɠ悤ɎԂ̂ȂN܂Blɂĉςꂽq͂̐̎ɓ܂Bꂩ琶܂Ă鐶͉iqĂ܂̂łB RE킹An̐Ԍnc߂Ă܂̂łB炱E̐lX΂Ă̂łB厩R␶̖ɐ_ȑ݂A؂ꑸŋɐĂ̑c悽B̊Ăъo܂Am̂悤Ɏ邱Ƃ͊ԈĂƔ΂̐グׂłB

cߎqi₷Ej
HZ^[urW21v\BɁwEqxi}ЁjȂǁB
2016N325

1 upTgЂ̎ЈHł͂flHisgpfĂ邻łv

2 uTgЂ̈͂ ȂȊw҂̌ʂЉ܂v
ŏЉĂvV^CAG}R@уZ[ǰ[ɂ錤ɂẮA@f[^߂߂āAƂ̔ᔻE炵BA_w҂ɂ2007N̑eɂ΁AɑĒ{uwI悤Ƃ铮͂قƂǌȂƂB̌̌ɂĂ͂킩ȂA݂ł̓m[x܂܂Ȋw҂i_110jqg앨ѐHïSɑ۔JȂ𔭕\ɂĂBS̍ƂẮAĚEK@ւJԂmFĉ肪ȂvƂĂB
Scientific and regulatory agencies around the world have repeatedly and consistently found crops and foods improved through biotechnology to be as safe as, if not safer than those derived from any other method of production. There has never been a single confirmed case of a negative health outcome for humans or animals from their consumption. Their environmental impacts have been shown repeatedly to be less damaging to the environment, and a boon to global biodiversity.
Laureates Letter Supporting Precision Agriculture (GMOs)

3 uŐ}v

4 u̔́A앨̎qÂڂɂ̂ł낤ƁA⒎Aɉ^΂ĎƂĂA앨ĂNQɂƂׂ̂łv
ɂĂTgЂ͔_ĂBV}CU[́Ãi^lɍĂfli^lEhAbv܂gpۂɕʂĎnƂŁAӐ}IɓNQĂB܂̃i^lɈĂfli^lRɍ̂Ƃ͍lȂBӐ}IłȂfl앨̍ɂāATgЂ_Ƃi邱Ƃ͂ȂƁB
p[V[EV}CU[ɂāiPercy Schmeiserj
Percy Schmeiser
Myth: Monsanto Sues Farmers When GMOs or GM Seed is Accidentally in Their Fields

5 u{͂soo؍ӂ̈ꕔuTvvƂĔ\܂v
́uTvv͂߂Ƃ֘A񑊊@TCgŌJĂB
sooimp[gi[Vbvj

6 usO[v󂵂Ăꂽ菑ǂ݂܂ƁA̖肪܂v
ǂ̎sO[vŵ͂肵ȂAƂΎRcFAcqɂuTPP蕪̓|[gvQƁB
TPP̑S̑Ɩ_\sĉɂ镪͕񍐁\Ver.4i2016/4/3j

http://www.asyura2.com/16/kokusai14/msg/604.html
[14] {̐HƔ_ƂTgɎxz܂icߎqj G̎
2. [10] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N718 15:41:54 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[192]
oTɌL܂B
> wx2016N5
Ƃ܂Áw{x2016N5łB
ւ񎸗炵܂B

e

w{x2016N5
http://gekkan-nippon.com/?p=8975
http://www.asyura2.com/16/kokusai14/msg/604.html#c2

[m点EǗ21] 2016N7@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
80. [11] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N719 19:36:04 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[194]
̋LRg폜܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/16/kokusai14/msg/604.html

폜ꂽRg#3#4ŁARg҂ɂ̂łB
̃Rg݂͌y[W̃\[XɐԎŕ\Ă̂œǂނƂł܂A
폜Ȃ΂ȂȂقǂ̖肪Ƃ͎v܂B
̂RgɂĂ͂ӂ͔\ɂȂ邾ł̔\RƗĂ܂ÃRgSɍ폜ꂽƂɂ͓ʂȗR̂ł傤B
폜̂̊ԈႢł΁A2̃Rg𕜊ĂAԈႢł͂ȂƂƂł΁AȂΗRĂB
낵肢܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/451.html#c80

[m点EǗ21] 2016N7@폜˗E폜񍐁EeAꏊBˑRełȂȂ͌ĂBQde폜˗ Ǘl
84. [12] iUef9YLMjtI 2016N720 17:55:18 : Oozg29Kcag : Qiiwq5NaXgQ[196]
>>82
Rg폜ꂽRł܂B
Rg̑֕@̂ɂĂӂ܂B
http://www.asyura2.com/13/kanri21/msg/451.html#c84
[eXg31] eXg
http://kaleido11.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-4502.html

### {I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[Om

{AJƉZ̍ɑւ悤ƂĂ{BsmIłA~j哝̑IȂ̐킪WJĂB

sm̑ćAa􌤋(bNtF[CFR̃JE^[p[g)̈{WOƐXNIsbNɈ낤Ƒ荞񂾑㗝lłB

̏rSq̔wɂ͏򏃈Y̐삪߂ĂBǂa􌤋B@΁AłoB

c͒PȂ铖ĔnBvɒĂ鎩̖{͏rSqBޏ{WOƋOɂ҂B
́u򌀏ṽo[WĂ̂łB

SSl̃KEToCo[ӂ̂ǂɒ@ƂrSqƂ̎c

uꂪIłvEEE

ȂIɗŁA}̏tB

ЂƂ́AsmỈŁAg}_]ihƏrSqzrYɂĂČtłB

ЂƂ́AQ@IAOm{WỎAbɉƂAޏmɌtłB

uꂪIłvEEEsmIAQ@IƁAVG[V͈قȂ邪ArSqA{bƂɁÄӖƂ͓łB

܂Aޏ́AuIł͑Η|߂ȂAߌȌvƌĂ̂łBƂAꂪRłĂEEE

R̐lij]ҁA}̊ېオAcŎӂȂ悤ȃW΂ĂƂ͗ǂmĂB
{WÓAuW͋c̉؂vƌB

WɂẮAWÔقAĊېɕĂ͂ȂB

ƂArSq̃ẂAWOې̃WAԂ񍂕iB

|߂ȂAǂȔ排łAǂȉRłCłĂ܂I@ꂪAu}̕vȂ̂łB

̈A}C^[lbgT|[^[NuƂ_\͏WcôB

u}̕vł́A񌾖ڂɂ́uL҂ɒJɂāEEvoĂ邪A^_̈xɐƂȂB

ǂ납A}xwBwɂđB悤ƁAXAx̃eNjbN𖁂Ă̂łB
ꂪA}̋xĂAꂩAlĂ邩łB

AEn̏rSq̒zɑ΂鍡̍ʓIȔ́Au}̕v͂邩ɈEĂB

ŕAЂƂȂĂ钹zrYual̖𗧂vƈەt悤ƁAO̖ʑOŐ𒣂グȂAuaݏオ̐lAAĂ΂Ƃ̂ł͂ȂłIvƂĂ܂̂łB

́ANĂKa҂ɑ΂鍷łB
ł́AǂȕٖłȂB

Ȃ舫łAޏ̐A⍓AƑAڗ򂳂ׂ̂ĂfIĂ܂Ƃ_ł͒vIƂȂB

̌t𕷂uԁArSq悤ƏHt̊X̏ɏW܂ÓAޏ̗⍓ɁA؂ɂ̔M܂ꂽB

ŁAuI@IvƊ|āȀɏW܂OĂ̂́Ar̃vx҂łB

AŕA{ɂȔjpȂƂ̂낤EEEBł́AmɁuaݏオł͖ɗȂvƂӖ̂ƂĂB

A}XR~̋L҂͊XIr܂āAuǂӖł̂ł傤HvƖ₢B

̂悤ɁAww΂ȂAúAƃt@Ng()\グvƔޏ͌B

zɂāAuȂ̐ȂAaݏオK҂ł͖ɗȂvƂ͎̂܂łAƏr͔ÔłB

Az͎Q@ǏʂāAuȂƂȂ΁AƋ}ɓsmIւ̏on߂̂ŏsvƃerԑgɏo邽тɗL҂ɒfĂB

uȂ̐ȂvƂ̂́AނrSq̂猾ꑱĂ邱ŁA邭]XV̂悤ɁÂƂǂ̓sɂāAXƐ}nƂu}_]XVvƌ悤ɂȂB

̐Ђ傫ȔgĂтȗ\Ăɂ炸Aʂ̋L҂ɂ܂ēƂuꂽŕAłEEE

uӖŌ̂ł͂ȂA(z)CłĂAƂƂvƁAx180xAt̂ƌĂB
uȐhvƂ́ÂƂłB

͕̃er񓹂ŗĂ܂B

ẑƂuaݏオvƔl|邱ƂAzuCłĂvƂ邱ƂɂȂAƔޏ͐B

ޏ̊ołΐƂɂȂĂ͂ȂȂBCJĂ邩łB

OɕȂ΁Aڂ̑OɂēXƉR

ƂƁArSq́AGWvg̃Nt̃s~bh̒ɏĐU葳pł𗧂Ăςȓ{lƂėLɂȂB

A̒ł́AȂƂĂAޏb̂ƂɁAǁ[悤ȂN[rY𕁋yƁAāAɖhqbɂȂƂAq̔NԂ̓_YfiCO2j̔roʂ͐Sgɏ邱Ƃň̊jƂȂAuq́AnCubh퓬@ƂRdrԂɐ؂ւׂvƌčRƂÃC[WB

AOAsmI̓_ŁAuIXvC͕KvB@͊ɗD炾vƌBZ̈SD̍lƂ݂ƁAiX̗DwvzɉĂ邱Ƃ͖łB

nϑzB

KaҁẢƑ\\Sl̐lX߂݂̂ǂɒ@ƂAł͖O炸A⍓ȌtŎ҂˂悤Ȗ\frɑ΂āAerǂɖҗȍRc̓dbE邱ƂOɎ@mĎł̂B

̓19̌ߌA3ľ҂AEĩtWer̂̔ԑguoCLOvɏoBi҂ʂɁAځA_킹Ă炤AƂłB

ŁAźArSqɁAu{ɁAȂƂ̂vƁA₢B

ޏ́A点ȂÂ悤ɉRʂB

r:u͂͂͂AĂȂłˁALɂȂłˁvB

r:ułAACɂȂĂ邶ȂłvB

r:u₢A(ƂȂ)LɂȂłpvB

z:uɌꂽ̂́AƂ܂傤B
KEToCo[Ƃl͉\ASƂ܂BƑ܂BlɁA񂪂ɂȂAȂɂłȂAƂʓIȃC[W^vB

r:uꂪAIȂłA(i)コvB

܂ŉR邱Ƃ̈ӖAǂɂ̂B

rSq́AӍ߂ΑIɕƂ|SAS̃Ka҂ƁAƂɃKƓĂƑGɉ񂵂Ă܂B

zRcĂ̂́Â߂ł͂ȂAKƓĂlX̋CقƓɁArSq̂悤Ȑ̕肫}ɘf킳ȁAƌxĂ̂łB

́AKƓȂƑgSlԂł΍gɂ݂ĂB̗⍓Ɏv킸w؂B

ÄlƂāAr̐SɐS߂Ka҂Ax邲ƑAaCƓC͂Ă܂ƂSzB

źAނAW[iXgƂāAKƓĂlXƂ̉Ƒ̂߂ɓ{̂łB

ނ͂҂i삷邽߂ɁAr̂悤ȍE͎҂ƐĂ̂łB

ntBg|XǵAurӍ߂vƏĂ邪AςAr͎Ӎ߂ĂȂBǂl߂āAꂪȂȂdȂu邤܂vƌ̂́AӍ߂ł͂ȂȕېgłB̂قAɂƂē炾B

́AW[iXeBbNȖڂŐ̒ĂlԂłȂƗłȂmȂBAr̂悤ȒtقȐlԂɂAƂȒPxĂ܂̂łB

܂ŕĂAr̂悤ȐlԂsmɐƂĂL҂ƂƂɂ͐MȂB

򐭌̂ƂArSq́Ałٓ򏃈Ŷ銯@ɓ͂ĂBT́AúlvƏĂB
mɁAŎZƌvZÂŁAr͏򏃈YŐڋĂB

ȂƂArSq́AˑRApƂB
ԁApȂrɑ΂āAT́AuxAƂ][ǂBƂBȂdĂ炵vƏĂB

ē䂾B

ɓ́A10NȏOĂ鏬r̊w̋^fB
ɂăGWvgog̃^gAr̊ŵ^oBɑ΂ďr̔͂ȂB
ꂪłȂƂȂAƂ̐ӔCƂ10Nȏ^f̃}}ɂĂƂ͍lȂB

āAu}̂ЂƂ̕vƂĒ蒅Ă鐭A͂蕂サĂB

Au30~̖LvƂ悤ȃPȘbł͂ȂAƑ傫ȐB

r̎x҂̒ɂ́AXs񓹂ɂč̖ڂ炷߂ɏTɃ[NĂ{@rׂĂAƐMĂlB

AzrỸXL_ŁARsyTCg呛BArSq̃XL_ɂ͐GȂB

ޏ́AuޘHf(}̐E𓾂邱Ƃł)Al̓vƑĂ邪A͍IȉołB

zɃer̐ԑgŁuaݏオ蔭v₢l߂ꂽBuerJ̑Oł́AsV悭ΊłˁvBOxƂł΁AǂȉRłCł̂łBꂪu}̕vB

ÁlBr͏򏃈YgLȐp\\uŔvgĂ̂B

ŕAȂ}̘AuŔvɌĂāAusmɂȂAɓscUvƐ錾ĂB

Au}AԂ󂷁IvƍꂵB

AA΂̂Ƃ̂B
ŕAKт̐pqɂ̉oāAĂт𗘗pĂɉ߂ȂB

q̃JgEEEA͎OmƂłƂߌ

ЂƂ́uꂪIłvƌ̂́A{WÕCJ[AbB

Omɐ\͂Ȃǂ납APȂƌ{wcAu{͈̂vƁA]TĎOm̎荞݂̂߂ɋ߂ÂĂ̂łB

̂ƂAbmɁAuvłAꂪIłvƌāAgѓdbň{WOɎpƁAm̓cC[gĂBłARƌ̂낤B

mAuvEJmvƁBɂ̃iVYɐE΂ĂB

ḿA{WOƌgѓdbŒZb킵ƂAuAȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łBO͂܂ȂłvƁAȂ̏ɋCƂEEE

āAu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vƁA菺bɂقĂ܂B

A{WOƔނ̊@̖󂯂āAĊC̃IXvCсiwpbhj݂\nu]v@500l𓊓Ĕ΂鉫̎srB

bA˂ɎOmɋ߂ÂĂ̂́Au]vŋN邱ƂAuȂƂtFXvŊgUȂ悤ɂ邽߂łAƍlloĂĂ_łȂB

ȂAḿAuȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łvȂ̂B

@500ĺAn̐lԂł͂ȂA͂ߊen玄̐ŋŏW߂ꂽhłB

ȂAḿu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vȂǂƌ̂B

قǁA̐lX̎vɂĔMm͉R̂B́AłƍĂB

ǁAOm̂悤Ȓr[ȍӂA{Ƃ̂悤ȖӖړIȑΕď]h̑䓪Ă܂̂łB

weR̈{bƂɁAƂȒPɉ_ꂽmA{WO͌΂̃StŁASuȂStyłƂmȂ͂͂ȂB

ꌩāAʏLĺAuOm̌Ă邱Ƃ͞BŁAׂĎ^͂łȂA҂ꐶɂȂĉiĂBƂ肠悤vƎvĂB

̎Q@Ił́AuNAǂ̐}Iׂ΂̂ȂAAIɂ͍sȂvEEEȊlƁÁuv҂vvvɓƂŁAĎԂĂ܂B

ނ͖̑搂ȂÁA܂ĂȂAgAIoĂ邾ł邩^̂B

́AuI25΂BŊāAЉɒ@ċ҂ôȂl͑Iɍsׂł͂ȂvƂ咣ĂB
Љ̖s𗝂ɐGǍǋ悤ƂCɂȂĂ͂߂Č҂̕i߂ł悤ɂȂ̂B

u18΂̎q́A{[CthK[tĥƂœ̒ϑz炯ɂāAŗVłIvƂ̂_B

ꂪAˑRACGXELXĝ悤ȃiVXNƁAuŐ(vł)vECeQɑς肾B

Om̉ɗ܂ƂoJ͑B
ȗ܂ȂA̎q̂߂ɋBpXi̎q̂߂ɋB̋\ԐɔfoB

̓2A3{ςĂ݂Aɂ͗mÂA܂ȂB

{lł΁Am̌Ă邱Ƃ͓OāAu͂͂AĂB炻̐́vƂƂɂȂ͂B

ՂD́uvҁvI_ɂEEE̂Ƃ

Om̐헪́AuIɍsȂ҂̖ڐɍ킹Č|vƂƂ炵B

̎̌ƒmA\̂ȂlC肪ړI̐lԂɂƂāAu֐SwɈՂ肩đIɍsvƂt͍IȓƂĎgB
̖mƌvZɉBĂ邩炾B

AIOɁÂ悤ɏB

EEEɁAނ邵qQ͂₵܂܂ŁA₵悤ȂǂƁAL҂Ȃ߂Ă̂AƌĂdȂB
u̐MH@܂̂́Hv@Ȃ̎̂Ă܂ȁB

fBAE[ɐsȂ񂩏W߂đʖڂB
܂́ÂAMł߂邱Ƃ蒼B

ʂNƎv̂B
̃{eBA̐s̃fBA[̈lƂAmN̂Ђ点邱ƂłȂ̂łΌʂ͐ĒmׂB

mNŏɂׂƂ́A̎アSƐ키ƂB

Om̖ЂĂL҂͑BjƃMڂA邱ƂAz邩炾B

AlX́AmᔻĂ̂ł͂ȂB

܂tŁAuЂȂΓ[ȂvƌĂL҂ۂɑ邱ƂmĂ邩炱AāAԂ̋Cǂł邩炱AāAmɓIĂق炱AЂׂƌĂ̂łB

u炵肽vȂǂƁAWEm̂悤ȂƂ΁A𖯂΂̓{ł͎󂯂B

AC܂ȋVlAOmKɂȂĉĂ𖯂́AɂȂāu؂ꂽvƔނɔwn߂B肵ĂȂ{lȂł́EEu̗F͍̓GvEEE̂ƂłB

uItFXv̖{́A~[WVOm̃v[VECxgɉ߂ȂBނ͂̑IptH[}[łB

tŏW߂1750~Ƃ́\\Aނ͖{̈ӖŐ͂Ȃ̂\\́uItFXvƂCxg̎QƎv΂̂B

Aꑊ̋񂾃CxgɂẮAgy͂ȂB

IptH[}[ȂAORP̕iDĂBނ́AȂƁAsmIɗ₵2007N̎_ŁAłɓ{O[oYɎ荞܂邱ƂmĂB

Aḿułł΂B͉A ȂB h am what I am.vƊJĂB

OḿA{bɉĂ͂ȂȂB
ނ́AxĂĂlX̎vΎނłȂC܂ȒjłB

m܂ŎxĂx҂uOAȂɂ킩ႢȂvƂł͂ȂBmƂjAl̋ɕ񂢂jǂƂƂłB

ނ́AƂƂɂĂ͂ȂȂlԂłB
x҂̎vAul̐D悷vƂ̂ł΁AȂǂł͂ȂB

ꂩ́Aî񂿂VƂĐĂ̂u炵vBu͉vAނ̐g̏TCY̐EłB邱Ƃ͂Ȃ̂B̐тʂ΂̂B

AAŋgĐ̐EłȁIƌĂ̂B

woĝǂ̃}RAɂĎ̍l܂Ƃ߂ĂB
̒ŁAޏ͂ĂB

uNȂƂƁǍl낢댾ƁA ͂̕Xɂlߊ悤ƁAŌ̈lɂȂ낤ƁAłÁAꌴ̂̑Ή͊ԈĂƎv܂AƌȂĂ̓_A āAXȂƁAςȂ񂾁AƎv̂łˁBv

͐lXX̗ŎRɍl邱ƂՂB
Ǎ݂݂ĂlX̂łB{ĺAɂƂsȍB

ނ́u]o߂Aōl邱ƂHĂvƎvłB

o𗘗pĎ[Ă͂ȂȂBg̃AOŌȂƋ𖯂͉iɋ𖯂̂܂܂B

As]邽߂ɂ́AƂɊ҂Ă͂ȂȂƂƂB
܂ĂAƂɉʂȂǂƁA܂ł҈ˑIĂĂ͂ȂȂB

{WOƊ@ɂāAAȌ_XA܂Ă邱Ƃ畆oŕĂ̂ł΁Aނ炪󂵂悤ƂĂ񂪊OɏoĂ悤ɂāAlll@𑝂₷ƂAׂĂn܂̂łB

Ar⑝cȂ̌҂͓KCł͂ȂBނ́uBv̐lԂł邩炾B

BAzrYȂA܂ł̓smƂ͑S΂ŉBĂ̑OɑSJɂ邾낤B̏ŁAlX́Aꂼ̍l\z邱Ƃł̂B

㐙₵Ă邪Aނ́AƂƍlĂȂ悤ɌBAǂĂȂĂ܂B

ɂĂAOmƂm[eLȒjĂlX́A₪Ĕނᔻ鑤ɉ邾낤B
lXǍƂ͖牓̂ƂӖBAꂪ̏EEElX́AɌĂB

̃O[^jAzrỶɒSoƂyBzI΍􎖖́AOmVbgAEg悤ɁB

AmAtǂĝAtĂꂽlɉ炩̃RgoKv邾낤B

́A{񑊎ẤuvɌĂ΂ėLV̑cɁucAO͗pĂ񂾂vƎBǁAc͉Ԍɍsĕvw񂩂uB

ɂ{珵ҏ󂪓͖͂B

ނĂmɂƂ낤B

A勴̐iȂAOmɂ͉Ȃ낤Bނ́AʂŒĝȂXj匙炾B

lX͋CÂĂȂA{̏󋵂͂Ȃ[B͉s\ȃx܂ŗĂ܂ĂB

smI̓J[31B

me҃n JChXR[vB e悤ƂĂALςĂ邱ƂɋCB Ȃ͂̕ǉÂȂɂ͂낢@B ɂȂĂグĂȂ΁A߂ĂꂪeĂ炨B
http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/529.html
[eXg31] eXg

### {I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[Om

{AJƉZ̍ɑւ悤ƂĂ{BsmIłA~j哝̑IȂ̐킪WJĂB

sm̑ćAa􌤋(bNtF[CFR̃JE^[p[g)̈{WOƐXNIsbNɈ낤Ƒ荞񂾑㗝lłB

̏rSq̔wɂ͏򏃈Y̐삪߂ĂBɂAa􌤋̖S삪߈˂ĂBA@΁AłoB

c͒PȂ铖ĔnBvɒĂ鎩̖{͏rSqBޏ{WOƋOɂ҂B

}{́Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƌĂ邪AΌقǁArɎx҂W܂邱ƂmĂB
܂AusḿAł͂ȂAxz҂łꎩ}߂Ă̂vƌĂ̂łB

rSq́AɁAlŗĂƁB

́AłɁu򌀏ṽo[WĂ̂łB

SSl̃KEToCo[ӂ̂ǂɒ@ƂrSqƂ̎c

uꂪIłvEEE

ȂIɗŁA}̏tB

ЂƂ́AsmỈŁAg}_]ihƏrSqzrYɂĂČtłB

ЂƂ́AQ@IAOm{WỎAbɉƂAޏmɌtłB

uꂪIłvEEEsmIAQ@IƁAVG[V͈قȂ邪ArSqA{bƂɁÄӖƂ͓łB

܂Aޏ́AuIł͑Η|߂ȂAߌȌvƌĂ̂łBƂAꂪRłĂEEE

R̐lij]ҁA}̊ېオAcŎӂȂ悤ȃW΂ĂƂ͗ǂmĂB
{WÓAuW͋c̉؂vƌB

WɂẮAWÔقAĊېɕĂ͂ȂB

ƂArSq̃ẂAWOې̃WAԂ񍂕iB

|߂ȂAǂȔ排łAǂȉRłCłĂ܂I@ꂪAu}̕vȂ̂łB

̈A}C^[lbgT|[^[NuƂ_\͏WcôB

u}̕vł́A񌾖ڂɂ́uL҂ɒJɂāEEvoĂ邪A^_̈xɐƂȂB

ǂ납A}xwBwɂđB悤ƁAXAx̃eNjbN𖁂Ă̂łB
ꂪA}̋xĂAꂩAlĂ邩łB

AEn̏rSq̒zɑ΂鍡̍ʓIȔ́Au}̕v͂邩ɈEĂB

ŕAЂƂȂĂ钹zrYual̖𗧂vƈەt悤ƁAO̖ʑOŐ𒣂グȂAuaݏオ̐lAAĂ΂Ƃ̂ł͂ȂłIvƂĂ܂̂łB

́ANĂKa҂ɑ΂鍷łB
ł́AǂȕٖłȂB

Ȃ舫łAޏ̐A⍓AƑAڗ򂳂ׂ̂ĂfIĂ܂Ƃ_ł͒vIƂȂB

̌t𕷂uԁArSq悤ƏHt̊X̏ɏW܂ÓAޏ̗⍓ɁA؂ɂ̔M܂ꂽB

ŁAuI@IvƊ|āȀɏW܂OĂ̂́Ar̃vx҂łB

AŕA{ɂȔjpȂƂ̂낤EEEBł́AmɁuaݏオł͖ɗȂvƂӖ̂ƂĂB

A}XR~̋L҂͊XIr܂āAuǂӖł̂ł傤HvƖ₢B

̂悤ɁAww΂ȂAúAƃt@Ng()\グvƔޏ͌B

zɂāAuȂ̐ȂAaݏオK҂ł͖ɗȂvƂ͎̂܂łAƏr͔ÔłB

Az͎Q@ǏʂāAuȂƂȂ΁AƋ}ɓsmIւ̏on߂̂ŏsvƃerԑgɏo邽тɗL҂ɒfĂB

uȂ̐ȂvƂ̂́Aނ돬rSq̂猾ꑱĂ邱ƂŁA邭]XV̂悤ɁÂƂǂ̓sɂāAXƐ}nƂu}_]XVvƌ悤ɂȂB

̐Ђ傫ȔgĂтȗ\Ăɂ炸Aʂ̋L҂ɂ܂ēƂuꂽŕAłEEE

uӖŌ̂ł͂ȂA(z)CłĂAƂƂvƁAx180xAt̂ƌĂB
uȐhvƂ́ÂƂłB

͕̃er񓹂ŗĂ܂B

ẑƂuaݏオvƔl|邱ƂAzuCłĂvƂ邱ƂɂȂAƔޏ͐B

ޏ̊ołΐƂɂȂĂ͂ȂȂBCJĂ邩łB

AẑƂSzOɁAޏ̂ق(ꂩ珑)][ǂ̌ǂŁAȎvlłȂȂĂ邱Ƃ^̂B

OɕȂ΁Aڂ̑OɂēXƉR

ƂƁArSq́AGWvg̃Nt̃s~bh̒ɏĐU葳pł𗧂Ăςȓ{lƂėLɂȂB

A̒ł́AȂƂĂAޏb̂ƂɁAǁ[悤ȂN[rY𕁋yƁAāAɖhqbɂȂƂAq̔NԂ̓_YfiCO2j̔roʂ͐Sgɏ邱Ƃň̊jƂȂAuq́AnCubh퓬@ƂRdrԂɐ؂ւׂvƌčRƂÃC[WB

AOAsmI̓_ŁAuIXvC͕KvB@͊ɗD炾vƌBZ̈SD̍lƂ݂ƁAiX̗DwvzɉĂ邱Ƃ͖łB

nϑzB

KaҁẢƑ[[Sl̐lX߂݂̂ǂɒ@ƂAł͖O炸A⍓ȌtŎ҂˂悤Ȗ\frɑ΂āAerǂɖҗȍRc̓dbE邱ƂOɎ@mĎł̂B

̓19̌ߌA3ľ҂AEĩtWer̂̔ԑguoCLOvɏoBi҂ʂɁAځA_킹Ă炤AƂłB

ŁAźArSqɁAu{ɁAȂƂ̂vƁA₢B

ޏ́A点ȂÂ悤ɉRʂB

r:u͂͂͂AĂȂłˁALɂȂłˁvB

r:ułAACɂȂĂ邶ȂłvB

r:u₢A(ƂȂ)LɂȂłpvB

z:uɌꂽ̂́AƂ܂傤B
KEToCo[Ƃl͉\ASƂ܂BƑ܂BlɁA񂪂ɂȂAȂɂłȂAƂʓIȃC[W^vB

r:uꂪAIȂłA(i)コvB

܂ŉR邱Ƃ̈ӖAǂɂ̂B

rSq́AӍ߂ΑIɕƂ|SAS̃Ka҂ƁAƂɃKƓĂƑGɉ񂵂Ă܂B

zRcĂ̂́Â߂ł͂ȂAKƓĂlX̋CقƓɁArSq̂悤Ȑ̕肫}ɘf킳ȁAƌxĂ̂łB

́AKƓȂƑgSlԂł΍gɂ݂ĂB̗⍓Ɏv킸w؂B

ÄlƂāAr̐SɐS߂Ka҂Ax邲ƑAaCƓC͂Ă܂ƂSzB

źAނAW[iXgƂāAKƓĂlXƂ̉Ƒ̂߂ɓ{̂łB

ނ͂҂i삷邽߂ɁAr̂悤ȍE͎҂ƐĂ̂łB

ntBg|XǵAurӍ߂vƏĂ邪AςAr͎Ӎ߂ĂȂBǂl߂āAꂪȂȂdȂu邤܂vƌ̂́AӍ߂ł͂ȂȕېgłB̂قAɂƂē炾B

ޏ́AOIɒǂl߂ȂƁAĔF߂ȂB

rSqb̂ƂAåҐ؂̂ĂlԂƂėLłB́Aۂ̐a҂̏،łB ĹAOAB̍uŁAmFB

rSqӍ߂邱ƂƂ΁ÁAIƂlIƂȀƂƂ܂łB
ɂƂāA邱ƂvɂȂ邩ǂŌ߂Ă̂łB

܂A܂⍓ƑŎZłBޏ́ulvłȂAŜ̂łB
{WOɕCG钴댯ȍcȂ̂łB

́AW[iXeBbNȖڂŐ̒ĂlԂłȂƗłȂmȂBAr̂悤ȒtقȐlԂɂAƂȒPxĂ܂̂łB

܂ŕĂAr̂悤ȐlԂsmɐƂĂL҂ƂƂɂ͐MȂB

򐭌̂ƂArSq́Ałٓ򏃈Ŷ銯@ɓ͂ĂBT́AúlvƏĂB
mɁAŎZƌvZÂŁAr͏򏃈YŐڋĂB

ȂƂArSq́AˑRApƂB ԁApȂrɑ΂āAT́AuxAƂ][ǂBƂBȂdĂ炵vƏĂB

ē䂾B

ɓ́A10NȏOĂ鏬r̊w̋^fB ɂăGWvgog̃^gAr̊ŵ^oBɑ΂ďr̔͂ȂB
ꂪłȂƂȂAƂ̐ӔCƂ10Nȏ^f̃}}ɂĂƂƂ͂ȂB

āAu}̂ЂƂ̕vƂĒ蒅Ă鐭A͂蕂サĂB

Au30~̖LvƂ悤ȃPȘbł͂ȂAƑ傫ȐB

r̎x҂̒ɂ́AXs񓹂ɂč̖ڂ炷߂ɏTɃ[NĂ{@rׂĂAƐMĂlB

ƍߎҁA{WÓAxTtgĒzrYɊւsLAIWQd|Ă

{WO̖󂯂́AzrỸXL_d|ĂBRsyTCgA͂呛B

AsvcȂƂɁArSq̔ƍߐ𔺂R̃XL_ɂ͐GȂB

̒z̝sXL_LfڂTt́AȗIWQvœnɌYiꂻB

ATt{̐Ƃ̋LڂƂ́A{ɒmĂ͍邱ƂBƂłAɂ͓t[@gĂƍlĊԈႢȂB́A̕ŋŎ]Ă̂łB

̘AAIsbNɂ₩낤ƎvĂ̂낤B{ł́AƂ匠҂ł鍑ɓG΂悤ɂȂĂ܂B

ޏ́AuޘHf(}̐E𓾂邱Ƃł)Al̓vƑĂ邪A܂AIȉołB

ꂾłȂArSqsm̌TCgɁuɊj~TCvAujvAu}R@cvAuq̍ő̌͗jĂ邱ƁvȂǂȂǁAȂ̎q̖D߂̃j[Yƕł̂łB

zɃer̐ԑgŁuaݏオ蔭v₢l߂ꂽBuerJ̑Oł́AsV悭ΊłˁvB OxƂł΁AǂȉRłCłȂ̂łBꂪu}̕v񂾓T^IȋcB

ÁlBr͏򏃈YgLȐp[[uŔvgĂ̂B

ŕAȂ}̘AuŔvɌĂāAusmɂȂAɓscUvƐ錾ĂB

Au}AԂ󂷁IvƍꂵB

AA΂̂Ƃ̂B
ŕAKт̐pqɂ̉oāAĂт𗘗pĂɉ߂ȂB

q̃JgEEEA͎OmƂłƂߌ

ЂƂ́uꂪIłvƌ̂́A{WÕCJ[AbB

Omɐ\͂Ȃǂ납APȂƌ{wcAu{͈̂vƁA]TĎOm̎荞݂̂߂ɋ߂ÂĂ̂łB

ޏWO̎wɂāAȂmÛA̗ŔAŌɏĂuȂő̐lAOmMɎx̂A킩悤ȋC܂BvƂt炤m邱ƂłB

Rgǂ߂΁AOm̎x҂AXƏb}WbNɎ荞܂Ălqm邱ƂłBm̎x҂ɂ́AyĂBuHvƂB

̂ƂAbmɁAuvłAꂪIłvƌāAgѓdbň{WOɎpƁAm̓cC[gĂBłARƌ̂낤B

mAuvEJmvƁBɂ̃iVYɐE΂ĂB

ḿA{WOƌgѓdbŒZb킵ƂAuAȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łBO͂܂ȂłvƁAȂ̏ɋCƂEEE

āAu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vƁA菺bɂقĂ܂B

A{WOƔނ̊@̖󂯂āAĊC̃IXvCсiwpbhj݂\nu]v@500l𓊓Ĕ΂鉫̎srB

bA˂ɎOmɋ߂ÂĂ̂́Au]vŋN邱ƂAuȂƂtFXvŊgUȂ悤ɂ邽߂łAƍlloĂĂ_łȂB

ȂAḿAuȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łvȂ̂B

@500ĺAn̐lԂł͂ȂA͂ߊen玄̐ŋŏW߂ꂽhłB

ȂAḿu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vȂǂƌ̂B̐lX́AOmƂ؂Ȓj̖{māAzƂĂB

قǁA̐lX̎vɂĔMm͉R̂B́AłƍĂB

ǁAOm̂悤Ȓr[ȍӂA{Ƃ̂悤ȖӖړIȑΕď]h̑䓪Ă܂̂łB

weR̈{bƂɁAƂȒPɉ_ꂽmA{WO͌΂̃StŁASuȂStył邱ƂmȂ͂͂ȂB

WOSt̂ƌĂ̂ł͂ȂBmĂmƌĂ̂łȂB
OḿA̕ЎԂɎ舵ꂽƂӖlAƌĂ̂łB

sAꎞ́ubǂ݁vƂ܂ŕ񂶂ꂽ{bAāA}{Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƂ܂ŌꂽrSqB

ӂƂAłuΈ{WOvAuΎ}vƌȂBlD̋𖯂́Aޏ̐̂A܂ȂB

bɊւČȂAmɌĉғ̐ɂĂ畏ꂽB

AIɏv}XR~PAȑO悤Ɂu}ٔC_v܂Ƃ₩ɚɂȂāA{鍑̎p䩗mƕ悤ɂȂĂƁA̖؂āAvXɓ̌𔭊ȂĂ̂B

Yo΁Ab͕vƃ}XR~Ačƌ͂ɕiāAiX̓IԂƌ߂̂łBꂪAޏ̖{łB

ꌩāAʏLĺAuOm̌Ă邱Ƃ͞BŁAׂĎ^͂łȂA҂ꐶɂȂĉiĂBƂ肠悤vƎvĂB

̎Q@Ił́AuNAǂ̐}Iׂ΂̂ȂAAIɂ͍sȂvEEEȊlƁÁuv҂vvvɓƂŁAĎԂĂ܂B

ނ͖̑搂ȂÁA܂ĂȂAgAIoĂ邾ł邩^̂B

́AuI25΂BŊāAЉɒ@ċ҂ôȂl͑Iɍsׂł͂ȂvƂ咣ĂB
Љ̖s𗝂ɐGǍǋ悤ƂCɂȂĂ͂߂Č҂̕i߂ł悤ɂȂ̂B

u18΂̎q́A{[CthK[tĥƂœ̒ϑz炯ɂāAŗVłIvƂ̂_B

ꂪAˑRACGXELXĝ悤ȃiVXNƁAuŐ(vł)vECeQɑς肾B

Om̉ɗ܂ƂoJ͑B
ȗ܂ȂA̎q̂߂ɋBpXi̎q̂߂ɋB̋\ԐɔfoB

ł͖{̂ƂĂ낤B
umɗ܂vƏĂA̔́A҂łAۂ͗܂ȂǗĂȂB

̔̂́Aɔ̘ÁAm̎x҂łȂAނǂƂƂĂAłBoJ̘An܂Ă̂łB

̓2A3{ςĂ݂Aɂ͗mÂA܂ȂB

{lł΁Am̌Ă邱Ƃ͓OāAu͂͂AĂB炻̐́vƂƂɂȂ͂B

ՂD́uvҁvI_ɂEEE̂Ƃ

Om̐헪́AuIɍsȂ҂̖ڐɍ킹Č|vƂƂ炵B

̎̌ƒmA\̂ȂlC肪ړI̐lԂɂƂāAu֐SwɈՂ肩đIɍsvƂt͍IȓƂĎgB
̖mƌvZɉBĂ邩炾B

AIOɁÂ悤ɏB

EEEɁAނ邵qQ͂₵܂܂ŁA₵悤ȂǂƁAL҂Ȃ߂Ă̂AƌĂdȂB u̐MH@܂̂́Hv@Ȃ̎̂Ă܂ȁB

fBAE[ɐsȂ񂩏W߂đʖڂB
܂́ÂAMł߂邱Ƃ蒼B

ʂNƎv̂B
̃{eBA̐s̃fBA[̈lƂAmN̂Ђ点邱ƂłȂ̂łΌʂ͐ĒmׂB

mNŏɂׂƂ́A̎アSƐ키ƂB

uOmvŃO[OƁA炸Ɨm^LAXƏoėB̃y[WA̎EEE

̒̑Au{eBA̐s̃fBA[vƂ炪LłB

͋tʂłB
lbgAuOmvFɂΓ[Ǝvł̂B

{ɗDꂽIvi[Ã{eBÃ[̒Ɉlł΁AOmɔᔻIȋLIɓꍞł͂B

Om̖ЂĂL҂͑BjƃMڂA邱ƂAz邩炾B

AlX́AmᔻĂ̂ł͂ȂB

܂tŁAuЂȂΓ[ȂvƌĂL҂ۂɑ邱ƂmĂ邩炱AāAԂ̋Cǂł邩炱AāAmɓIĂق炱AЂׂƌĂ̂łB

uЂvƌĂ̂́ANł͂ȂBOmƓNォAƎႢlXłB
ނ́AЉlŉЂ̏igȂ݂ɂĐFXĂB

ꂪƂƂł͂ȂAŒ́u߁v炢͂BƌĂ̂łB

ḿAIAuJ[w𒆐SƂ}h̐VȐՂzvƌĂB

J[wH@Ȃ݂̑ȂB
̂́AAwBwAƂCwłB

L҂̐S͏ҐSƂ͈ႤA܂ĂAɃ}[PeBÕZI[𓖂Ă͂߂ĂNX^[邱Ǝ̂iZXłB

m̌Ă邱ƂAɃyeAƂmȂƕȂ낤AƂāA̒x̂ƂŁu񂤂vĂw҂L҂邱Ƃ̂قA|Ȃ̂łB

u炵肽vȂǂƁAWEm̂悤ȂƂ΁A𖯂΂̓{ł͎󂯂B

AC܂ȋVlAOmKɂȂĉĂA̋𖯂́AɂȂāu؂ꂽvƔނɔwn߂B肵ĂȂ{lȂł́EEu̗F͍̓GvEEE̂ƂłB

ǁAuItFXv̖{́A~[WVOm̃v[VECxgɉ߂ȂƂėB
́AssƉAm͂̑IptH[}[Ƃđ苎낤B

́Auv𗘗pĂBł́AɒǂĂ܂B

SEALDslByƃbv񂾑I^ɂ͒ӂȂ΂ȂȂB́A𖯂̏WquɑȂȂB

̍܂̓EbhXgbN̑gNB
̌ʁAcEEEʂ̑喃(}t@i)͂߂Ƃ閃K҂ƔƍߎҁAɐli҂B

EbhXgbN𐄐i҂́A喃i}t@ij֎~́ARƎ{ɓG΂̂łāA̎R𔛂̂łAƂԈɂƂÂ咣ĂB

EbhXgbNɂĒ_ɒB喃i}t@ij։^́Aj[GCWE[goĂ̂łB̃j[GCW^̃X|T[́AbNtF[łB
҂𖃖őޔp邱ƂɂāAxzeՂɂ悤Ƃ_̂łB

ł́AW[WE\XpŁAč̊eBő喃i}t@ij@i߂ĂBʁA\NFEMAo悤ƂԂɂȂĂB

uv́Aɓ̗ǂ别}ɗpĂBނ́AɂĔȗvグĂB

xz҂́A푈NċׂDIȔƍߎ҂łAɁA𗘗pāAׂ͂}IȔƍߎ҂ł̂B
xz҂́AŋׂB𗼌ĎƂB

p̂́A܂ĂB
AmŋȎ҂ɂԂ炩EEEB

ő̌J҂̓r[gYłBނɂ́App鍑M͂ꂽB

@v[̃śAł̓iCgłAOɁuT[vB

r[gY̎d|ĺA^BXgbNlԊ֌WłB

̃X|T[ł鐢Exzwɏ]ł|[E}bJ[gj[́Ahܗւ̊JŁAÉ̂߂ɁAVIjXgE_̂߂̉yuwCEW[hv̂h_ɂB

΂ɁA̓tƂėpꂽƂɋCtWEḿuނvɈÎEꂽB

OmɂȀLBނ́A₪ĐM180xς邾낤B

ނ́AʂāAu|[ɂȂ邩AWɂȂ邩vEEE܂ŗmグĂ΁Aނ̃t@當͏oȂ낤B

tŏW߂1750~Ƃ́[[Aނ͖{̈ӖŐ͂Ȃ̂[[́uItFXvƂCxg̎QƎv΂̂B

Aꑊ̋񂾃CxgɂẮAgy͂ȂB

IptH[}[ȂAORP̕iDĂBނ́AȂƁAsmIɗ₵2007N̎_ŁAłɓ{O[oYɎ荞܂邱ƂmĂB

ނJԂĂuQĂ鏭hvA̐8NoAu99̑hvɂȂĂƂ킯łB
܂ŁAuhvɂ͂̒wÅԂɏXɕ󂵂āACAẮuhvɑgݍ܂ĂAƂƂłB

ԑw{ׂ͂̕x́AIȎdg݂oāAuh̒̏hvłu1vɈړ]̂B

{̕ɉSn[̓Jj

OḿA{bɉĂ͂ȂȂB

A{̃vpK_EYoV́Aubvl{WO񑊂ƈӋCvƂofĈۑn߂B
{̕fH삪n܂̂B

ɁAOḿAꂩoė邳܂܂ȍoώwWނ̎x҂ɁAu{̕ɉSn[̓JjvƂ܂Ō邾낤B

b͐WO̍ȂƂāAhɓ̌𔭊ĂAƂ킯łB

ނ́AxĂĂlX̎vΎނłȂoJȋC܂jłB

Aḿułł΂B͉A ȂB h am what I am.vƊJĂB

ł́Aɔᔻ̌t𗁂тn߂x҂ɑ΂āAuOAȂɂ킩ႢȂvƌĂ悤Ɏ󂯎ꂩ˂ȂBmƂjAl̋ɕ񂢂jǂAɂ߂Ȃ΂ȂȂBނ́Ał͂ȂB

ނ́AƂƂɂĂ͂ȂȂlԂłB
x҂̎vAul̐D悷vƂ̂ł΁AȂǂł͂ȂB

ꂩ́Aî񂿂VƂĐĂ̂u炵vBu͉vAނ̐g̏TCY̐EłB邱Ƃ͂Ȃ̂B̐тʂ΂̂B

AAŋgĐ̐EłĂ͍IƌĂ̂B

woĝǂ̃}RAɂĎ̍l܂Ƃ߂ĂB
̒ŁAޏ͂ĂB

uNȂƂƁǍl낢댾ƁA ͂̕Xɂlߊ悤ƁAŌ̈lɂȂ낤ƁAłÁAꌴ̂̑Ή͊ԈĂƎv܂AƌȂĂ̓_A āAXȂƁAςȂ񂾁AƎv̂łˁBv

ޏ́A{̈ӖŖ𗝉ĂB

ɁA̘_ŉ؂낤Ƃu썇vAj󂷂邱ƂmĂB
Ƃ́A𖯂ɗ^Ƌɕς鏔ňł邱ƂmĂB

ޏ́AmŁAӎuŖтƂĂBȐlB

Aޏ͑l̎^邽߂ɐgK؂ĊĂ킯ł͂ȂB
A瓾鎊̕ʂ́Aޏɂ^ȂAޏɂłȂB

cOȂƂɁAȂ100̐lX́Ał͂ȂBƂƏIȐlXȂ̂łB

Am̑ItFXɉlA\lW܂AƐĂ𖯂̂ƂłB
ƂāAނ炪AĐłƎvł킯ł͂ȂƂ炢ĂB

́AւƂ܏Hɒǂ܂Ă܂Ă邱ƂȂ̂B
܂AOmɖu҈ˑƂvɖĂ܂Ă̂łB

ɂ́A̎vl͂ȂB

͐lXX̗ŎRɍl邱ƂՂB
Ǎ݂݂ĂlX̂łBɎ咣A܂ɂ肽{ĺAɂƂsȍB

ނ́u]o߂Aōl邱ƂHĂvƎvłB

o𗘗pĎ[Ă͂ȂȂBg̃AOŌȂƋ𖯂͉iɋ𖯂̂܂܂B

As]邽߂ɂ́AƂɊ҂Ă͂ȂȂƂƂB
܂ĂAƂɉʂȂǂƁA܂ł҈ˑIĂĂ͂ȂȂB

{WOƊ@ɂāAAȌ_XA܂Ă邱Ƃ畆oŕĂ̂ł΁Aނ炪󂵂悤ƂĂ񂪊OɏoĂ悤ɂāAlll@𑝂₷ƂAׂĂn܂̂łB

Ar⑝cȂ̌҂͓KCł͂ȂBނ́uBv̐lԂł邩炾B

BAzrYȂA܂ł̓smƂ͑S΂ŉBĂ̑OɑSJɂ邾낤B̏ŁAlX́Aꂼ̍l\z邱Ƃł̂B

㐙₵Ă邪Aނ́AƂƍlĂȂ悤ɌBAǂĂȂĂ܂B

Ã}XR~ŕ񂶂ȂJ_̓ςĉ邾낤B
712Aɐ삯ēEԍ▯z[ōsꂽJ_̈ꖋłBÎ҂́A{NcłB

}bNԍuƑ҂Iԍx@Ăł܂IEI@ᔽ̌sƁI͖炩ɖȂIꕔ̌҂dɏオāIvB

}bNԍ⎁́AIWTłH

2ÔƂł͂邪Ǎ͍ςłB
́A}bNԍ⎁܂̂łāA͂̐lXĂ̂łBԈႢȂAÎґ̓{NĉقEI@ᔽłB

ANlĂB

{ΑقǁAlX͗_󂪌ɂȂĂ̂łB

킸̊ԂɁA܂܂ɂȂBł͊֐SȂEEECtȂEEE

ɂĂAOmƂm[eLȒjĂlX́A₪Ĕނᔻ鑤ɉ邾낤B
lXǍƂ͖牓̂ƂӖBAꂪ̏EEElX́AɌĂB

̃O[^jAzrỶɒSoƂyBzI΍􎖖́AOmVbgAEg悤ɁB

AmAtǂĝAtĂꂽlɉ炩̃RgoKv邾낤B

́A{񑊎ẤuvɌĂ΂ėLV̑cɁucAO͗pĂ񂾂vƎBǁAc͉Ԍɍsĕvw񂩂uB

ɂ{珵ҏ󂪓͖͂B

ނĂmɂƂ낤B

A勴̐iȂAOmɂ͉Ȃ낤Bނ́AʂŒĝȂXj匙炾B

lX͋CÂĂȂA{̏󋵂͂Ȃ[B͉s\ȃx܂ŗĂ܂ĂB

{WÓAĂ̒Ax̑IłxBWÓAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂA΂łIvJԂL҂ɂĂB

IŏƂoϐʂCĂB(܂́AoV)

Ƃ̐̂ɃAxm~NX͔j]Ă̂ɁA܂MĂ̂́A{ɐEœ{̍Ȃ̂łB
ǂ̉pꌗ̃fBAłAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂvȂǂƏĂ郁fBÁÄȂB

ꂾłȂA29ɂ́AGPIF̔Nɂ呹(͉̐ߏ]Ă)oāA҂̐ljłꂽƂm邾낤BpjbNNȂƂFB

smI̓J[31B

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/530.html
[eXg31] eXg
{I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[OmiJChXR[vj

{I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[Om
http://kaleido11.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-4502.html
2016N0720@JChXR[v

{AJƉZ̍ɑւ悤ƂĂ{BsmIłA~j哝̑IȂ̐킪WJĂB

sm̑ćAa􌤋(bNtF[CFR̃JE^[p[g)̈{WOƐXNIsbNɈ낤Ƒ荞񂾑㗝lłB

̏rSq̔wɂ͏򏃈Y̐삪߂ĂBɂAa􌤋̖S삪߈˂ĂBA@΁AłoB

c͒PȂ铖ĔnBvɒĂ鎩̖{͏rSqBޏ{WOƋOɂ҂B

}{́Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƌĂ邪AΌقǁArɎx҂W܂邱ƂmĂB
܂AusḿAł͂ȂAxz҂łꎩ}߂Ă̂vƌĂ̂łB

rSq́AɁAlŗĂƁB

́AłɁu򌀏ṽo[WĂ̂łB

SSl̃KEToCo[ӂ̂ǂɒ@ƂrSqƂ̎c

uꂪIłvEEE

ȂIɗŁA}̏tB

ЂƂ́AsmỈŁAg}_]ihƏrSqzrYɂĂČtłB

ЂƂ́AQ@IAOm{WỎAbɉƂAޏmɌtłB

uꂪIłvEEEsmIAQ@IƁAVG[V͈قȂ邪ArSqA{bƂɁÄӖƂ͓łB

܂Aޏ́AuIł͑Η|߂ȂAߌȌvƌĂ̂łBƂAꂪRłĂEEE

R̐lij]ҁA}̊ېオAcŎӂȂ悤ȃW΂ĂƂ͗ǂmĂB
{WÓAuW͋c̉؂vƌB

WɂẮAWÔقAĊېɕĂ͂ȂB

ƂArSq̃ẂAWOې̃WAԂ񍂕iB

|߂ȂAǂȔ排łAǂȉRłCłĂ܂I@ꂪAu}̕vȂ̂łB

̈A}C^[lbgT|[^[NuƂ_\͏WcôB

u}̕vł́A񌾖ڂɂ́uL҂ɒJɂāEEvoĂ邪A^_̈xɐƂȂB

ǂ납A}xwBwɂđB悤ƁAXAx̃eNjbN𖁂Ă̂łB
ꂪA}̋xĂAꂩAlĂ邩łB

AEn̏rSq̒zɑ΂鍡̍ʓIȔ́Au}̕v͂邩ɈEĂB

ŕAЂƂȂĂ钹zrYual̖𗧂vƈەt悤ƁAO̖ʑOŐ𒣂グȂAuaݏオ̐lAAĂ΂Ƃ̂ł͂ȂłIvƂĂ܂̂łB

́ANĂKa҂ɑ΂鍷łB
ł́AǂȕٖłȂB

Ȃ舫łAޏ̐A⍓AƑAڗ򂳂ׂ̂ĂfIĂ܂Ƃ_ł͒vIƂȂB

̌t𕷂uԁArSq悤ƏHt̊X̏ɏW܂ÓAޏ̗⍓ɁA؂ɂ̔M܂ꂽB

ŁAuI@IvƊ|āȀɏW܂OĂ̂́Ar̃vx҂łB

AŕA{ɂȔjpȂƂ̂낤EEEBł́AmɁuaݏオł͖ɗȂvƂӖ̂ƂĂB

A}XR~̋L҂͊XIr܂āAuǂӖł̂ł傤HvƖ₢B

̂悤ɁAww΂ȂAúAƃt@Ng()\グvƔޏ͌B

zɂāAuȂ̐ȂAaݏオK҂ł͖ɗȂvƂ͎̂܂łAƏr͔ÔłB

Az͎Q@ǏʂāAuȂƂȂ΁AƋ}ɓsmIւ̏on߂̂ŏsvƃerԑgɏo邽тɗL҂ɒfĂB

uȂ̐ȂvƂ̂́AނrSq̂猾ꑱĂ邱ŁA邭]XV̂悤ɁÂƂǂ̓sɂāAXƐ}nƂu}_]XVvƌ悤ɂȂB

̐Ђ傫ȔgĂтȗ\Ăɂ炸Aʂ̋L҂ɂ܂ēƂuꂽŕAłEEE

uӖŌ̂ł͂ȂA(z)CłĂAƂƂvƁAx180xAt̂ƌĂB
uȐhvƂ́ÂƂłB

͕̃er񓹂ŗĂ܂B

ẑƂuaݏオvƔl|邱ƂAzuCłĂvƂ邱ƂɂȂAƔޏ͐B

ޏ̊ołΐƂɂȂĂ͂ȂȂBCJĂ邩łB

AẑƂSzOɁAޏ̂ق(ꂩ珑)][ǂ̌ǂŁAȎvlłȂȂĂ邱Ƃ^̂B

OɕȂ΁Aڂ̑OɂēXƉR

ƂƁArSq́AGWvg̃Nt̃s~bh̒ɏĐU葳pł𗧂Ăςȓ{lƂėLɂȂB

A̒ł́AȂƂĂAޏb̂ƂɁAǁ[悤ȂN[rY𕁋yƁAāAɖhqbɂȂƂAq̔NԂ̓_YfiCO2j̔roʂ͐Sgɏ邱Ƃň̊jƂȂAuq́AnCubh퓬@ƂRdrԂɐ؂ւׂvƌčRƂÃC[WB

AOAsmI̓_ŁAuIXvC͕KvB@͊ɗD炾vƌBZ̈SD̍lƂ݂ƁAiX̗DwvzɉĂ邱Ƃ͖łB

nϑzB

KaҁẢƑ[[Sl̐lX߂݂̂ǂɒ@ƂAł͖O炸A⍓ȌtŎ҂˂悤Ȗ\frɑ΂āAerǂɖҗȍRc̓dbE邱ƂOɎ@mĎł̂B

̓19̌ߌA3ľ҂AEĩtWer̂̔ԑguoCLOvɏoBi҂ʂɁAځA_킹Ă炤AƂłB

ŁAźArSqɁAu{ɁAȂƂ̂vƁA₢B

ޏ́A点ȂÂ悤ɉRʂB

r:u͂͂͂AĂȂłˁALɂȂłˁvB

r:ułAACɂȂĂ邶ȂłvB

r:u₢A(ƂȂ)LɂȂłpvB

z:uɌꂽ̂́AƂ܂傤B
KEToCo[Ƃl͉\ASƂ܂BƑ܂BlɁA񂪂ɂȂAȂɂłȂAƂʓIȃC[W^vB

r:uꂪAIȂłA(i)コvB

܂ŉR邱Ƃ̈ӖAǂɂ̂B

rSq́AӍ߂ΑIɕƂ|SAS̃Ka҂ƁAƂɃKƓĂƑGɉ񂵂Ă܂B

zRcĂ̂́Â߂ł͂ȂAKƓĂlX̋CقƓɁArSq̂悤Ȑ̕肫}ɘf킳ȁAƌxĂ̂łB

́AKƓȂƑgSlԂł΍gɂ݂ĂB̗⍓Ɏv킸w؂B

ÄlƂāAr̐SɐS߂Ka҂Ax邲ƑAaCƓC͂Ă܂ƂSzB

źAނAW[iXgƂāAKƓĂlXƂ̉Ƒ̂߂ɓ{̂łB

ނ͂҂i삷邽߂ɁAr̂悤ȍE͎҂ƐĂ̂łB

ntBg|XǵAurӍ߂vƏĂ邪AςAr͎Ӎ߂ĂȂBǂl߂āAꂪȂȂdȂu邤܂vƌ̂́AӍ߂ł͂ȂȕېgłB̂قAɂƂē炾B

ޏ́AOIɒǂl߂ȂƁAĔF߂ȂB

rSqb̂ƂAåҐ؂̂ĂlԂƂėLłB́Aۂ̐a҂̏،łB ĹAOAB̍uŁAmFB

rSqӍ߂邱ƂƂ΁ÁAIƂlIƂȀƂƂ܂łB
ɂƂāA邱ƂvɂȂ邩ǂŌ߂Ă̂łB

܂A܂⍓ƑŎZłBޏ́ulvłȂAŜ̂łB
{WOɕCG钴댯ȍcȂ̂łB

́AW[iXeBbNȖڂŐ̒ĂlԂłȂƗłȂmȂBAr̂悤ȒtقȐlԂɂAƂȒPxĂ܂̂łB

܂ŕĂAr̂悤ȐlԂsmɐƂĂL҂ƂƂɂ͐MȂB

򐭌̂ƂArSq́Ałٓ򏃈Ŷ銯@ɓ͂ĂBT́AúlvƏĂB
mɁAŎZƌvZÂŁAr͏򏃈YŐڋĂB

ȂƂArSq́AˑRApƂB ԁApȂrɑ΂āAT́AuxAƂ][ǂBƂBȂdĂ炵vƏĂB

ē䂾B

ɓ́A10NȏOĂ鏬r̊w̋^fB ɂăGWvgog̃^gAr̊ŵ^oBɑ΂ďr̔͂ȂB
ꂪłȂƂȂAƂ̐ӔCƂ10Nȏ^f̃}}ɂĂƂƂ͂ȂB

āAu}̂ЂƂ̕vƂĒ蒅Ă鐭A͂蕂サĂB

Au30~̖LvƂ悤ȃPȘbł͂ȂAƑ傫ȐB

r̎x҂̒ɂ́AXs񓹂ɂč̖ڂ炷߂ɏTɃ[NĂ{@rׂĂAƐMĂlB

ƍߎҁA{WÓAxTtgĒzrYɊւsLAIWQd|Ă

{WO̖󂯂́AzrỸXL_d|ĂBRsyTCgA͂呛B

AsvcȂƂɁArSq̔ƍߐ𔺂R̃XL_ɂ͐GȂB

̒z̝sXL_LfڂTt́AȗIWQvœnɌYiꂻB

ATt{̐Ƃ̋LڂƂ́A{ɒmĂ͍邱ƂBƂłAɂ͓t[@gĂƍlĊԈႢȂB́A̕ŋŎ]Ă̂łB

̘AAIsbNɂ₩낤ƎvĂ̂낤B{ł́AƂ匠҂ł鍑ɓG΂悤ɂȂĂ܂B

ޏ́AuޘHf(}̐E𓾂邱Ƃł)Al̓vƑĂ邪A܂AIȉołB

ꂾłȂArSqsm̌TCgɁuɊj~TCvAujvAu}R@cvAuq̍ő̌͗jĂ邱ƁvȂǂȂǁAȂ̎q̖D߂̃j[Yƕł̂łB

zɃer̐ԑgŁuaݏオ蔭v₢l߂ꂽBuerJ̑Oł́AsV悭ΊłˁvB OxƂł΁AǂȉRłCłȂ̂łBꂪu}̕v񂾓T^IȋcB

ÁlBr͏򏃈YgLȐp[[uŔvgĂ̂B

ŕAȂ}̘AuŔvɌĂāAusmɂȂAɓscUvƐ錾ĂB

Au}AԂ󂷁IvƍꂵB

AA΂̂Ƃ̂B
ŕAKт̐pqɂ̉oāAĂт𗘗pĂɉ߂ȂB

q̃JgEEEA͎OmƂłƂߌ

ЂƂ́uꂪIłvƌ̂́A{WÕCJ[AbB

Omɐ\͂Ȃǂ납APȂƌ{wcAu{͈̂vƁA]TĎOm̎荞݂̂߂ɋ߂ÂĂ̂łB

ޏWO̎wɂāAȂmÛA̗ŔAŌɏĂuȂő̐lAOmMɎx̂A킩悤ȋC܂BvƂt炤m邱ƂłB

Rgǂ߂΁AOm̎x҂AXƏb}WbNɎ荞܂Ălqm邱ƂłBm̎x҂ɂ́AyĂBuHvƂB

̂ƂAbmɁAuvłAꂪIłvƌāAgѓdbň{WOɎpƁAm̓cC[gĂBłARƌ̂낤B

mAuvEJmvƁBɂ̃iVYɐE΂ĂB

ḿA{WOƌgѓdbŒZb킵ƂAuAȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łBO͂܂ȂłvƁAȂ̏ɋCƂEEE

āAu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vƁA菺bɂقĂ܂B

A{WOƔނ̊@̖󂯂āAĊC̃IXvCсiwpbhj݂\nu]v@500l𓊓Ĕ΂鉫̎srB

bA˂ɎOmɋ߂ÂĂ̂́Au]vŋN邱ƂAuȂƂtFXvŊgUȂ悤ɂ邽߂łAƍlloĂĂ_łȂB

ȂAḿAuȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łvȂ̂B

@500ĺAn̐lԂł͂ȂA͂ߊen玄̐ŋŏW߂ꂽhłB

ȂAḿu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vȂǂƌ̂B̐lX́AOmƂ؂Ȓj̖{māAzƂĂB

قǁA̐lX̎vɂĔMm͉R̂B́AłƍĂB

ǁAOm̂悤Ȓr[ȍӂA{Ƃ̂悤ȖӖړIȑΕď]h̑䓪Ă܂̂łB

weR̈{bƂɁAƂȒPɉ_ꂽmA{WO͌΂̃StŁASuȂStył邱ƂmȂ͂͂ȂB

WOSt̂ƌĂ̂ł͂ȂBmĂmƌĂ̂łȂB
OḿA̕ЎԂɎ舵ꂽƂӖlAƌĂ̂łB

sAꎞ́ubǂ݁vƂ܂ŕ񂶂ꂽ{bAāA}{Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƂ܂ŌꂽrSqB

ӂƂAłuΈ{WOvAuΎ}vƌȂBlD̋𖯂́Aޏ̐̂A܂ȂB

bɊւČȂAmɌĉғ̐ɂĂ畏ꂽB

AIɏv}XR~PAȑO悤Ɂu}ٔC_v܂Ƃ₩ɚɂȂāA{鍑̎p䩗mƕ悤ɂȂĂƁA̖؂āAvXɓ̌𔭊ȂĂ̂B

Yo΁Ab͕vƃ}XR~Ačƌ͂ɕiāAiX̓IԂƌ߂̂łBꂪAޏ̖{łB

ꌩāAʏLĺAuOm̌Ă邱Ƃ͞BŁAׂĎ^͂łȂA҂ꐶɂȂĉiĂBƂ肠悤vƎvĂB

̎Q@Ił́AuNAǂ̐}Iׂ΂̂ȂAAIɂ͍sȂvEEEȊlƁÁuv҂vvvɓƂŁAĎԂĂ܂B

ނ͖̑搂ȂÁA܂ĂȂAgAIoĂ邾ł邩^̂B

́AuI25΂BŊāAЉɒ@ċ҂ôȂl͑Iɍsׂł͂ȂvƂ咣ĂB
Љ̖s𗝂ɐGǍǋ悤ƂCɂȂĂ͂߂Č҂̕i߂ł悤ɂȂ̂B

u18΂̎q́A{[CthK[tĥƂœ̒ϑz炯ɂāAŗVłIvƂ̂_B

ꂪAˑRACGXELXĝ悤ȃiVXNƁAuŐ(vł)vECeQɑς肾B

Om̉ɗ܂ƂoJ͑B
ȗ܂ȂA̎q̂߂ɋBpXi̎q̂߂ɋB̋\ԐɔfoB

ł͖{̂ƂĂ낤B
umɗ܂vƏĂA̔́A҂łAۂ͗܂ȂǗĂȂB

̔̂́Aɔ̘ÁAm̎x҂łȂAނǂƂƂĂAłBoJ̘An܂Ă̂łB

̓2A3{ςĂ݂Aɂ͗mÂA܂ȂB

{lł΁Am̌Ă邱Ƃ͓OāAu͂͂AĂB炻̐́vƂƂɂȂ͂B

ՂD́uvҁvI_ɂEEE̂Ƃ

Om̐헪́AuIɍsȂ҂̖ڐɍ킹Č|vƂƂ炵B

̎̌ƒmA\̂ȂlC肪ړI̐lԂɂƂāAu֐SwɈՂ肩đIɍsvƂt͍IȓƂĎgB
̖mƌvZɉBĂ邩炾B

AIOɁÂ悤ɏB

EEEɁAނ邵qQ͂₵܂܂ŁA₵悤ȂǂƁAL҂Ȃ߂Ă̂AƌĂdȂB u̐MH@܂̂́Hv@Ȃ̎̂Ă܂ȁB

fBAE[ɐsȂ񂩏W߂đʖڂB
܂́ÂAMł߂邱Ƃ蒼B

ʂNƎv̂B
̃{eBA̐s̃fBA[̈lƂAmN̂Ђ点邱ƂłȂ̂łΌʂ͐ĒmׂB

mNŏɂׂƂ́A̎アSƐ키ƂB

uOmvŃO[OƁA炸Ɨm^LAXƏoėB̃y[WA̎EEE

̒̑Au{eBA̐s̃fBA[vƂ炪LłB

͋tʂłB
lbgAuOmvFɂΓ[Ǝvł̂B

{ɗDꂽIvi[Ã{eBÃ[̒Ɉlł΁AOmɔᔻIȋLIɓꍞł͂B

Om̖ЂĂL҂͑BjƃMڂA邱ƂAz邩炾B

AlX́AmᔻĂ̂ł͂ȂB

܂tŁAuЂȂΓ[ȂvƌĂL҂ۂɑ邱ƂmĂ邩炱AāAԂ̋Cǂł邩炱AāAmɓIĂق炱AЂׂƌĂ̂łB

uЂvƌĂ̂́ANł͂ȂBOmƓNォAƎႢlXłB
ނ́AЉlŉЂ̏igȂ݂ɂĐFXĂB

ꂪƂƂł͂ȂAŒ́u߁v炢͂BƌĂ̂łB

ḿAIAuJ[w𒆐SƂ}h̐VȐՂzvƌĂB

J[wH@Ȃ݂̑ȂB
̂́AAwBwAƂCwłB

L҂̐S͏ҐSƂ͈ႤA܂ĂAɃ}[PeBÕZI[𓖂Ă͂߂ĂNX^[邱Ǝ̂iZXłB

m̌Ă邱ƂAɃyeAƂmȂƕȂ낤AƂāA̒x̂ƂŁu񂤂vĂw҂L҂邱Ƃ̂قA|Ȃ̂łB

u炵肽vȂǂƁAWEm̂悤ȂƂ΁A𖯂΂̓{ł͎󂯂B

AC܂ȋVlAOmKɂȂĉĂA̋𖯂́AɂȂāu؂ꂽvƔނɔwn߂B肵ĂȂ{lȂł́EEu̗F͍̓GvEEE̂ƂłB

ǁAuItFXv̖{́A~[WVOm̃v[VECxgɉ߂ȂƂėB
́AssƉAm͂̑IptH[}[Ƃđ苎낤B

́Auv𗘗pĂBł́AɒǂĂ܂B

SEALDslByƃbv񂾑I^ɂ͒ӂȂ΂ȂȂB́A𖯂̏WquɑȂȂB

̍܂̓EbhXgbN̑gNB
̌ʁAcEEEʂ̑喃(}t@i)͂߂Ƃ閃K҂ƔƍߎҁAɐli҂B

EbhXgbN𐄐i҂́A喃i}t@ij֎~́ARƎ{ɓG΂̂łāA̎R𔛂̂łAƂԈɂƂÂ咣ĂB

EbhXgbNɂĒ_ɒB喃i}t@ij։^́Aj[GCWE[goĂ̂łB̃j[GCW^̃X|T[́AbNtF[łB
҂𖃖őޔp邱ƂɂāAxzeՂɂ悤Ƃ_̂łB

ł́AW[WE\XpŁAč̊eBő喃i}t@ij@i߂ĂBʁA\NFEMAo悤ƂԂɂȂĂB

uv́Aɓ̗ǂ别}ɗpĂBނ́AɂĔȗvグĂB

xz҂́A푈NċׂDIȔƍߎ҂łAɁA𗘗pāAׂ͂}IȔƍߎ҂ł̂B
xz҂́AŋׂB𗼌ĎƂB

p̂́A܂ĂB
AmŋȎ҂ɂԂ炩EEEB

ő̌J҂̓r[gYłBނɂ́App鍑M͂ꂽB

@v[̃śAł̓iCgłAOɁuT[vB

r[gY̎d|ĺA^BXgbNlԊ֌WłB

̃X|T[ł鐢Exzwɏ]ł|[E}bJ[gj[́Ahܗւ̊JŁAÉ̂߂ɁAVIjXgE_̂߂̉yuwCEW[hv̂h_ɂB

΂ɁA̓tƂėpꂽƂɋCtWEḿuނvɈÎEꂽB

OmɂȀLBނ́A₪ĐM180xς邾낤B

ނ́AʂāAu|[ɂȂ邩AWɂȂ邩vEEE܂ŗmグĂ΁Aނ̃t@當͏oȂ낤B

tŏW߂1750~Ƃ́[[Aނ͖{̈ӖŐ͂Ȃ̂[[́uItFXvƂCxg̎QƎv΂̂B

Aꑊ̋񂾃CxgɂẮAgy͂ȂB

IptH[}[ȂAORP̕iDĂBނ́AȂƁAsmIɗ₵2007N̎_ŁAłɓ{O[oYɎ荞܂邱ƂmĂB

ނJԂĂuQĂ鏭hvA̐8NoAu99̑hvɂȂĂƂ킯łB
܂ŁAuhvɂ͂̒wÅԂɏXɕ󂵂āACAẮuhvɑgݍ܂ĂAƂƂłB

ԑw{ׂ͂̕x́AIȎdg݂oāAuh̒̏hvłu1vɈړ]̂B

{̕ɉSn[̓Jj

OḿA{bɉĂ͂ȂȂB

A{̃vpK_EYoV́Aubvl{WO񑊂ƈӋCvƂofĈۑn߂B
{̕fH삪n܂̂B

ɁAOḿAꂩoė邳܂܂ȍoώwWނ̎x҂ɁAu{̕ɉSn[̓JjvƂ܂Ō邾낤B

b͐WO̍ȂƂāAhɓ̌𔭊ĂAƂ킯łB

ނ́AxĂĂlX̎vΎނłȂoJȋC܂jłB

Aḿułł΂B͉A ȂB h am what I am.vƊJĂB

ł́Aɔᔻ̌t𗁂тn߂x҂ɑ΂āAuOAȂɂ킩ႢȂvƌĂ悤Ɏ󂯎ꂩ˂ȂBmƂjAl̋ɕ񂢂jǂAɂ߂Ȃ΂ȂȂBނ́Ał͂ȂB

ނ́AƂƂɂĂ͂ȂȂlԂłB
x҂̎vAul̐D悷vƂ̂ł΁AȂǂł͂ȂB

ꂩ́Aî񂿂VƂĐĂ̂u炵vBu͉vAނ̐g̏TCY̐EłB邱Ƃ͂Ȃ̂B̐тʂ΂̂B

AAŋgĐ̐EłĂ͍IƌĂ̂B

woĝǂ̃}RAɂĎ̍l܂Ƃ߂ĂB
̒ŁAޏ͂ĂB

uNȂƂƁǍl낢댾ƁA ͂̕Xɂlߊ悤ƁAŌ̈lɂȂ낤ƁAłÁAꌴ̂̑Ή͊ԈĂƎv܂AƌȂĂ̓_A āAXȂƁAςȂ񂾁AƎv̂łˁBv

ޏ́A{̈ӖŖ𗝉ĂB

ɁA̘_ŉ؂낤Ƃu썇vAj󂷂邱ƂmĂB
Ƃ́A𖯂ɗ^Ƌɕς鏔ňł邱ƂmĂB

ޏ́AmŁAӎuŖтƂĂBȐlB

Aޏ͑l̎^邽߂ɐgK؂ĊĂ킯ł͂ȂB
A瓾鎊̕ʂ́Aޏɂ^ȂAޏɂłȂB

cOȂƂɁAȂ100̐lX́Ał͂ȂBƂƏIȐlXȂ̂łB

Am̑ItFXɉlA\lW܂AƐĂ𖯂̂ƂłB
ƂāAނ炪AĐłƎvł킯ł͂ȂƂ炢ĂB

́AւƂ܏Hɒǂ܂Ă܂Ă邱ƂȂ̂B
܂AOmɖu҈ˑƂvɖĂ܂Ă̂łB

ɂ́A̎vl͂ȂB

͐lXX̗ŎRɍl邱ƂՂB
Ǎ݂݂ĂlX̂łBɎ咣A܂ɂ肽{ĺAɂƂsȍB

ނ́u]o߂Aōl邱ƂHĂvƎvłB

o𗘗pĎ[Ă͂ȂȂBg̃AOŌȂƋ𖯂͉iɋ𖯂̂܂܂B

As]邽߂ɂ́AƂɊ҂Ă͂ȂȂƂƂB
܂ĂAƂɉʂȂǂƁA܂ł҈ˑIĂĂ͂ȂȂB

{WOƊ@ɂāAAȌ_XA܂Ă邱Ƃ畆oŕĂ̂ł΁Aނ炪󂵂悤ƂĂ񂪊OɏoĂ悤ɂāAlll@𑝂₷ƂAׂĂn܂̂łB

Ar⑝cȂ̌҂͓KCł͂ȂBނ́uBv̐lԂł邩炾B

BAzrYȂA܂ł̓smƂ͑S΂ŉBĂ̑OɑSJɂ邾낤B̏ŁAlX́Aꂼ̍l\z邱Ƃł̂B

㐙₵Ă邪Aނ́AƂƍlĂȂ悤ɌBAǂĂȂĂ܂B

Ã}XR~ŕ񂶂ȂJ_̓ςĉ邾낤B
712Aɐ삯ēEԍ▯z[ōsꂽJ_̈ꖋłBÎ҂́A{NcłB

}bNԍuƑ҂Iԍx@Ăł܂IEI@ᔽ̌sƁI͖炩ɖȂIꕔ̌҂dɏオāIvB

}bNԍ⎁́AIWTłH

2ÔƂł͂邪Ǎ͍ςłB
́A}bNԍ⎁܂̂łāA͂̐lXĂ̂łBԈႢȂAÎґ̓{NĉقEI@ᔽłB

ANlĂB

{ΑقǁAlX͗_󂪌ɂȂĂ̂łB

킸̊ԂɁA܂܂ɂȂBł͊֐SȂEEECtȂEEE

ɂĂAOmƂm[eLȒjĂlX́A₪Ĕނᔻ鑤ɉ邾낤B
lXǍƂ͖牓̂ƂӖBAꂪ̏EEElX́AɌĂB

̃O[^jAzrỶɒSoƂyBzI΍􎖖́AOmVbgAEg悤ɁB

AmAtǂĝAtĂꂽlɉ炩̃RgoKv邾낤B

́A{񑊎ẤuvɌĂ΂ėLV̑cɁucAO͗pĂ񂾂vƎBǁAc͉Ԍɍsĕvw񂩂uB

ɂ{珵ҏ󂪓͖͂B

ނĂmɂƂ낤B

A勴̐iȂAOmɂ͉Ȃ낤Bނ́AʂŒĝȂXj匙炾B

lX͋CÂĂȂA{̏󋵂͂Ȃ[B͉s\ȃx܂ŗĂ܂ĂB

{WÓAĂ̒Ax̑IłxBWÓAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂA΂łIvJԂL҂ɂĂB

IŏƂoϐʂCĂB(܂́AoV)

Ƃ̐̂ɃAxm~NX͔j]Ă̂ɁA܂MĂ̂́A{ɐEœ{̍Ȃ̂łB
ǂ̉pꌗ̃fBAłAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂvȂǂƏĂ郁fBÁÄȂB

ꂾłȂA29ɂ́AGPIF̔Nɂ呹(͉̐ߏ]Ă)oāA҂̐ljłꂽƂm邾낤BpjbNNȂƂFB

smI̓J[31B

e҂̃Rg

2016N720̖ɂ̋LǂŁACfɓeƎvBCf̏Zlɂ́AJChXR[vɂĂ̓Rsye҂ƂȂV̋L𒼐ڃFbNƂl̂ł͂Ȃ낤Bŋ߁AɎOm̕]߂ĈCfłӌΗĂȂŁAJChXR[vmȂlɏЉBeҌl̎Om]OOƗhꓮĂBJChXR[v̈ӌɂSɔ[ł킯ł͂ȂB
ȂA̋ĹAJꂽł̓̂ɂȂ啝ŏdvȒǋLȂꂽB̒ǋLȂǂ肦Ȃ͂Ȃ̂ŁALQƂ邱Ƃ߂B

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/531.html
[EIEmgj209] {I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[OmiJChXR[vj

{I悳ꂽrSqƑIptH[}[Om
http://kaleido11.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-4502.html
2016N0720@JChXR[v

{AJƉZ̍ɑւ悤ƂĂ{BsmIłA~j哝̑IȂ̐킪WJĂB

sm̑ćAa􌤋(bNtF[CFR̃JE^[p[g)̈{WOƐXNIsbNɈ낤Ƒ荞񂾑㗝lłB

̏rSq̔wɂ͏򏃈Y̐삪߂ĂBɂAa􌤋̖S삪߈˂ĂBA@΁AłoB

c͒PȂ铖ĔnBvɒĂ鎩̖{͏rSqBޏ{WOƋOɂ҂B

}{́Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƌĂ邪AΌقǁArɎx҂W܂邱ƂmĂB
܂AusḿAł͂ȂAxz҂łꎩ}߂Ă̂vƌĂ̂łB

rSq́AɁAlŗĂƁB

́AłɁu򌀏ṽo[WĂ̂łB

SSl̃KEToCo[ӂ̂ǂɒ@ƂrSqƂ̎c

uꂪIłvEEE

ȂIɗŁA}̏tB

ЂƂ́AsmỈŁAg}_]ihƏrSqzrYɂĂČtłB

ЂƂ́AQ@IAOm{WỎAbɉƂAޏmɌtłB

uꂪIłvEEEsmIAQ@IƁAVG[V͈قȂ邪ArSqA{bƂɁÄӖƂ͓łB

܂Aޏ́AuIł͑Η|߂ȂAߌȌvƌĂ̂łBƂAꂪRłĂEEE

R̐lij]ҁA}̊ېオAcŎӂȂ悤ȃW΂ĂƂ͗ǂmĂB
{WÓAuW͋c̉؂vƌB

WɂẮAWÔقAĊېɕĂ͂ȂB

ƂArSq̃ẂAWOې̃WAԂ񍂕iB

|߂ȂAǂȔ排łAǂȉRłCłĂ܂I@ꂪAu}̕vȂ̂łB

̈A}C^[lbgT|[^[NuƂ_\͏WcôB

u}̕vł́A񌾖ڂɂ́uL҂ɒJɂāEEvoĂ邪A^_̈xɐƂȂB

ǂ납A}xwBwɂđB悤ƁAXAx̃eNjbN𖁂Ă̂łB
ꂪA}̋xĂAꂩAlĂ邩łB

AEn̏rSq̒zɑ΂鍡̍ʓIȔ́Au}̕v͂邩ɈEĂB

ŕAЂƂȂĂ钹zrYual̖𗧂vƈەt悤ƁAO̖ʑOŐ𒣂グȂAuaݏオ̐lAAĂ΂Ƃ̂ł͂ȂłIvƂĂ܂̂łB

́ANĂKa҂ɑ΂鍷łB
ł́AǂȕٖłȂB

Ȃ舫łAޏ̐A⍓AƑAڗ򂳂ׂ̂ĂfIĂ܂Ƃ_ł͒vIƂȂB

̌t𕷂uԁArSq悤ƏHt̊X̏ɏW܂ÓAޏ̗⍓ɁA؂ɂ̔M܂ꂽB

ŁAuI@IvƊ|āȀɏW܂OĂ̂́Ar̃vx҂łB

AŕA{ɂȔjpȂƂ̂낤EEEBł́AmɁuaݏオł͖ɗȂvƂӖ̂ƂĂB

A}XR~̋L҂͊XIr܂āAuǂӖł̂ł傤HvƖ₢B

̂悤ɁAww΂ȂAúAƃt@Ng()\グvƔޏ͌B

zɂāAuȂ̐ȂAaݏオK҂ł͖ɗȂvƂ͎̂܂łAƏr͔ÔłB

Az͎Q@ǏʂāAuȂƂȂ΁AƋ}ɓsmIւ̏on߂̂ŏsvƃerԑgɏo邽тɗL҂ɒfĂB

uȂ̐ȂvƂ̂́AނrSq̂猾ꑱĂ邱ŁA邭]XV̂悤ɁÂƂǂ̓sɂāAXƐ}nƂu}_]XVvƌ悤ɂȂB

̐Ђ傫ȔgĂтȗ\Ăɂ炸Aʂ̋L҂ɂ܂ēƂuꂽŕAłEEE

uӖŌ̂ł͂ȂA(z)CłĂAƂƂvƁAx180xAt̂ƌĂB
uȐhvƂ́ÂƂłB

͕̃er񓹂ŗĂ܂B

ẑƂuaݏオvƔl|邱ƂAzuCłĂvƂ邱ƂɂȂAƔޏ͐B

ޏ̊ołΐƂɂȂĂ͂ȂȂBCJĂ邩łB

AẑƂSzOɁAޏ̂ق(ꂩ珑)][ǂ̌ǂŁAȎvlłȂȂĂ邱Ƃ^̂B

OɕȂ΁Aڂ̑OɂēXƉR

ƂƁArSq́AGWvg̃Nt̃s~bh̒ɏĐU葳pł𗧂Ăςȓ{lƂėLɂȂB

A̒ł́AȂƂĂAޏb̂ƂɁAǁ[悤ȂN[rY𕁋yƁAāAɖhqbɂȂƂAq̔NԂ̓_YfiCO2j̔roʂ͐Sgɏ邱Ƃň̊jƂȂAuq́AnCubh퓬@ƂRdrԂɐ؂ւׂvƌčRƂÃC[WB

AOAsmI̓_ŁAuIXvC͕KvB@͊ɗD炾vƌBZ̈SD̍lƂ݂ƁAiX̗DwvzɉĂ邱Ƃ͖łB

nϑzB

KaҁẢƑ[[Sl̐lX߂݂̂ǂɒ@ƂAł͖O炸A⍓ȌtŎ҂˂悤Ȗ\frɑ΂āAerǂɖҗȍRc̓dbE邱ƂOɎ@mĎł̂B

̓19̌ߌA3ľ҂AEĩtWer̂̔ԑguoCLOvɏoBi҂ʂɁAځA_킹Ă炤AƂłB

ŁAźArSqɁAu{ɁAȂƂ̂vƁA₢B

ޏ́A点ȂÂ悤ɉRʂB

r:u͂͂͂AĂȂłˁALɂȂłˁvB

r:ułAACɂȂĂ邶ȂłvB

r:u₢A(ƂȂ)LɂȂłpvB

z:uɌꂽ̂́AƂ܂傤B
KEToCo[Ƃl͉\ASƂ܂BƑ܂BlɁA񂪂ɂȂAȂɂłȂAƂʓIȃC[W^vB

r:uꂪAIȂłA(i)コvB

܂ŉR邱Ƃ̈ӖAǂɂ̂B

rSq́AӍ߂ΑIɕƂ|SAS̃Ka҂ƁAƂɃKƓĂƑGɉ񂵂Ă܂B

zRcĂ̂́Â߂ł͂ȂAKƓĂlX̋CقƓɁArSq̂悤Ȑ̕肫}ɘf킳ȁAƌxĂ̂łB

́AKƓȂƑgSlԂł΍gɂ݂ĂB̗⍓Ɏv킸w؂B

ÄlƂāAr̐SɐS߂Ka҂Ax邲ƑAaCƓC͂Ă܂ƂSzB

źAނAW[iXgƂāAKƓĂlXƂ̉Ƒ̂߂ɓ{̂łB

ނ͂҂i삷邽߂ɁAr̂悤ȍE͎҂ƐĂ̂łB

ntBg|XǵAurӍ߂vƏĂ邪AςAr͎Ӎ߂ĂȂBǂl߂āAꂪȂȂdȂu邤܂vƌ̂́AӍ߂ł͂ȂȕېgłB̂قAɂƂē炾B

ޏ́AOIɒǂl߂ȂƁAĔF߂ȂB

rSqb̂ƂAåҐ؂̂ĂlԂƂėLłB́Aۂ̐a҂̏،łB ĹAOAB̍uŁAmFB

rSqӍ߂邱ƂƂ΁ÁAIƂlIƂȀƂƂ܂łB
ɂƂāA邱ƂvɂȂ邩ǂŌ߂Ă̂łB

܂A܂⍓ƑŎZłBޏ́ulvłȂAŜ̂łB
{WOɕCG钴댯ȍcȂ̂łB

́AW[iXeBbNȖڂŐ̒ĂlԂłȂƗłȂmȂBAr̂悤ȒtقȐlԂɂAƂȒPxĂ܂̂łB

܂ŕĂAr̂悤ȐlԂsmɐƂĂL҂ƂƂɂ͐MȂB

򐭌̂ƂArSq́Ałٓ򏃈Ŷ銯@ɓ͂ĂBT́AúlvƏĂB
mɁAŎZƌvZÂŁAr͏򏃈YŐڋĂB

ȂƂArSq́AˑRApƂB ԁApȂrɑ΂āAT́AuxAƂ][ǂBƂBȂdĂ炵vƏĂB

ē䂾B

ɓ́A10NȏOĂ鏬r̊w̋^fB ɂăGWvgog̃^gAr̊ŵ^oBɑ΂ďr̔͂ȂB
ꂪłȂƂȂAƂ̐ӔCƂ10Nȏ^f̃}}ɂĂƂƂ͂ȂB

āAu}̂ЂƂ̕vƂĒ蒅Ă鐭A͂蕂サĂB

Au30~̖LvƂ悤ȃPȘbł͂ȂAƑ傫ȐB

r̎x҂̒ɂ́AXs񓹂ɂč̖ڂ炷߂ɏTɃ[NĂ{@rׂĂAƐMĂlB

ƍߎҁA{WÓAxTtgĒzrYɊւsLAIWQd|Ă

{WO̖󂯂́AzrỸXL_d|ĂBRsyTCgA͂呛B

AsvcȂƂɁArSq̔ƍߐ𔺂R̃XL_ɂ͐GȂB

̒z̝sXL_LfڂTt́AȗIWQvœnɌYiꂻB

ATt{̐Ƃ̋LڂƂ́A{ɒmĂ͍邱ƂBƂłAɂ͓t[@gĂƍlĊԈႢȂB́A̕ŋŎ]Ă̂łB

̘AAIsbNɂ₩낤ƎvĂ̂낤B{ł́AƂ匠҂ł鍑ɓG΂悤ɂȂĂ܂B

ޏ́AuޘHf(}̐E𓾂邱Ƃł)Al̓vƑĂ邪A܂AIȉołB

ꂾłȂArSqsm̌TCgɁuɊj~TCvAujvAu}R@cvAuq̍ő̌͗jĂ邱ƁvȂǂȂǁAȂ̎q̖D߂̃j[Yƕł̂łB

zɃer̐ԑgŁuaݏオ蔭v₢l߂ꂽBuerJ̑Oł́AsV悭ΊłˁvB OxƂł΁AǂȉRłCłȂ̂łBꂪu}̕v񂾓T^IȋcB

ÁlBr͏򏃈YgLȐp[[uŔvgĂ̂B

ŕAȂ}̘AuŔvɌĂāAusmɂȂAɓscUvƐ錾ĂB

Au}AԂ󂷁IvƍꂵB

AA΂̂Ƃ̂B
ŕAKт̐pqɂ̉oāAĂт𗘗pĂɉ߂ȂB

q̃JgEEEA͎OmƂłƂߌ

ЂƂ́uꂪIłvƌ̂́A{WÕCJ[AbB

Omɐ\͂Ȃǂ납APȂƌ{wcAu{͈̂vƁA]TĎOm̎荞݂̂߂ɋ߂ÂĂ̂łB

ޏWO̎wɂāAȂmÛA̗ŔAŌɏĂuȂő̐lAOmMɎx̂A킩悤ȋC܂BvƂt炤m邱ƂłB

Rgǂ߂΁AOm̎x҂AXƏb}WbNɎ荞܂Ălqm邱ƂłBm̎x҂ɂ́AyĂBuHvƂB

̂ƂAbmɁAuvłAꂪIłvƌāAgѓdbň{WOɎpƁAm̓cC[gĂBłARƌ̂낤B

mAuvEJmvƁBɂ̃iVYɐE΂ĂB

ḿA{WOƌgѓdbŒZb킵ƂAuAȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łBO͂܂ȂłvƁAȂ̏ɋCƂEEE

āAu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vƁA菺bɂقĂ܂B

A{WOƔނ̊@̖󂯂āAĊC̃IXvCсiwpbhj݂\nu]v@500l𓊓Ĕ΂鉫̎srB

bA˂ɎOmɋ߂ÂĂ̂́Au]vŋN邱ƂAuȂƂtFXvŊgUȂ悤ɂ邽߂łAƍlloĂĂ_łȂB

ȂAḿAuȂꏏ]ɍs܂񂩁AƂ͉]܂łvȂ̂B

@500ĺAn̐lԂł͂ȂA͂ߊen玄̐ŋŏW߂ꂽhłB

ȂAḿu]̏Z̋C߂āuokinawa noproblemvcapbɗa܂vȂǂƌ̂B̐lX́AOmƂ؂Ȓj̖{māAzƂĂB

قǁA̐lX̎vɂĔMm͉R̂B́AłƍĂB

ǁAOm̂悤Ȓr[ȍӂA{Ƃ̂悤ȖӖړIȑΕď]h̑䓪Ă܂̂łB

weR̈{bƂɁAƂȒPɉ_ꂽmA{WO͌΂̃StŁASuȂStył邱ƂmȂ͂͂ȂB

WOSt̂ƌĂ̂ł͂ȂBmĂmƌĂ̂łȂB
OḿA̕ЎԂɎ舵ꂽƂӖlAƌĂ̂łB

sAꎞ́ubǂ݁vƂ܂ŕ񂶂ꂽ{bAāA}{Au^҂ɓsC킯ɂ͂ȂvƂ܂ŌꂽrSqB

ӂƂAłuΈ{WOvAuΎ}vƌȂBlD̋𖯂́Aޏ̐̂A܂ȂB

bɊւČȂAmɌĉғ̐ɂĂ畏ꂽB

AIɏv}XR~PAȑO悤Ɂu}ٔC_v܂Ƃ₩ɚɂȂāA{鍑̎p䩗mƕ悤ɂȂĂƁA̖؂āAvXɓ̌𔭊ȂĂ̂B

Yo΁Ab͕vƃ}XR~Ačƌ͂ɕiāAiX̓IԂƌ߂̂łBꂪAޏ̖{łB

ꌩāAʏLĺAuOm̌Ă邱Ƃ͞BŁAׂĎ^͂łȂA҂ꐶɂȂĉiĂBƂ肠悤vƎvĂB

̎Q@Ił́AuNAǂ̐}Iׂ΂̂ȂAAIɂ͍sȂvEEEȊlƁÁuv҂vvvɓƂŁAĎԂĂ܂B

ނ͖̑搂ȂÁA܂ĂȂAgAIoĂ邾ł邩^̂B

́AuI25΂BŊāAЉɒ@ċ҂ôȂl͑Iɍsׂł͂ȂvƂ咣ĂB
Љ̖s𗝂ɐGǍǋ悤ƂCɂȂĂ͂߂Č҂̕i߂ł悤ɂȂ̂B

u18΂̎q́A{[CthK[tĥƂœ̒ϑz炯ɂāAŗVłIvƂ̂_B

ꂪAˑRACGXELXĝ悤ȃiVXNƁAuŐ(vł)vECeQɑς肾B

Om̉ɗ܂ƂoJ͑B
ȗ܂ȂA̎q̂߂ɋBpXi̎q̂߂ɋB̋\ԐɔfoB

ł͖{̂ƂĂ낤B
umɗ܂vƏĂA̔́A҂łAۂ͗܂ȂǗĂȂB

̔̂́Aɔ̘ÁAm̎x҂łȂAނǂƂƂĂAłBoJ̘An܂Ă̂łB

̓2A3{ςĂ݂Aɂ͗mÂA܂ȂB

{lł΁Am̌Ă邱Ƃ͓OāAu͂͂AĂB炻̐́vƂƂɂȂ͂B

ՂD́uvҁvI_ɂEEE̂Ƃ

Om̐헪́AuIɍsȂ҂̖ڐɍ킹Č|vƂƂ炵B

̎̌ƒmA\̂ȂlC肪ړI̐lԂɂƂāAu֐SwɈՂ肩đIɍsvƂt͍IȓƂĎgB
̖mƌvZɉBĂ邩炾B

AIOɁÂ悤ɏB

EEEɁAނ邵qQ͂₵܂܂ŁA₵悤ȂǂƁAL҂Ȃ߂Ă̂AƌĂdȂB u̐MH@܂̂́Hv@Ȃ̎̂Ă܂ȁB

fBAE[ɐsȂ񂩏W߂đʖڂB
܂́ÂAMł߂邱Ƃ蒼B

ʂNƎv̂B
̃{eBA̐s̃fBA[̈lƂAmN̂Ђ点邱ƂłȂ̂łΌʂ͐ĒmׂB

mNŏɂׂƂ́A̎アSƐ키ƂB

uOmvŃO[OƁA炸Ɨm^LAXƏoėB̃y[WA̎EEE

̒̑Au{eBA̐s̃fBA[vƂ炪LłB

͋tʂłB
lbgAuOmvFɂΓ[Ǝvł̂B

{ɗDꂽIvi[Ã{eBÃ[̒Ɉlł΁AOmɔᔻIȋLIɓꍞł͂B

Om̖ЂĂL҂͑BjƃMڂA邱ƂAz邩炾B

AlX́AmᔻĂ̂ł͂ȂB

܂tŁAuЂȂΓ[ȂvƌĂL҂ۂɑ邱ƂmĂ邩炱AāAԂ̋Cǂł邩炱AāAmɓIĂق炱AЂׂƌĂ̂łB

uЂvƌĂ̂́ANł͂ȂBOmƓNォAƎႢlXłB
ނ́AЉlŉЂ̏igȂ݂ɂĐFXĂB

ꂪƂƂł͂ȂAŒ́u߁v炢͂BƌĂ̂łB

ḿAIAuJ[w𒆐SƂ}h̐VȐՂzvƌĂB

J[wH@Ȃ݂̑ȂB
̂́AAwBwAƂCwłB

L҂̐S͏ҐSƂ͈ႤA܂ĂAɃ}[PeBÕZI[𓖂Ă͂߂ĂNX^[邱Ǝ̂iZXłB

m̌Ă邱ƂAɃyeAƂmȂƕȂ낤AƂāA̒x̂ƂŁu񂤂vĂw҂L҂邱Ƃ̂قA|Ȃ̂łB

u炵肽vȂǂƁAWEm̂悤ȂƂ΁A𖯂΂̓{ł͎󂯂B

AC܂ȋVlAOmKɂȂĉĂA̋𖯂́AɂȂāu؂ꂽvƔނɔwn߂B肵ĂȂ{lȂł́EEu̗F͍̓GvEEE̂ƂłB

ǁAuItFXv̖{́A~[WVOm̃v[VECxgɉ߂ȂƂėB
́AssƉAm͂̑IptH[}[Ƃđ苎낤B

́Auv𗘗pĂBł́AɒǂĂ܂B

SEALDslByƃbv񂾑I^ɂ͒ӂȂ΂ȂȂB́A𖯂̏WquɑȂȂB

̍܂̓EbhXgbN̑gNB
̌ʁAcEEEʂ̑喃(}t@i)͂߂Ƃ閃K҂ƔƍߎҁAɐli҂B

EbhXgbN𐄐i҂́A喃i}t@ij֎~́ARƎ{ɓG΂̂łāA̎R𔛂̂łAƂԈɂƂÂ咣ĂB

EbhXgbNɂĒ_ɒB喃i}t@ij։^́Aj[GCWE[goĂ̂łB̃j[GCW^̃X|T[́AbNtF[łB
҂𖃖őޔp邱ƂɂāAxzeՂɂ悤Ƃ_̂łB

ł́AW[WE\XpŁAč̊eBő喃i}t@ij@i߂ĂBʁA\NFEMAo悤ƂԂɂȂĂB

uv́Aɓ̗ǂ别}ɗpĂBނ́AɂĔȗvグĂB

xz҂́A푈NċׂDIȔƍߎ҂łAɁA𗘗pāAׂ͂}IȔƍߎ҂ł̂B
xz҂́AŋׂB𗼌ĎƂB

p̂́A܂ĂB
AmŋȎ҂ɂԂ炩EEEB

ő̌J҂̓r[gYłBނɂ́App鍑M͂ꂽB

@v[̃śAł̓iCgłAOɁuT[vB

r[gY̎d|ĺA^BXgbNlԊ֌WłB

̃X|T[ł鐢Exzwɏ]ł|[E}bJ[gj[́Ahܗւ̊JŁAÉ̂߂ɁAVIjXgE_̂߂̉yuwCEW[hv̂h_ɂB

΂ɁA̓tƂėpꂽƂɋCtWEḿuނvɈÎEꂽB

OmɂȀLBނ́A₪ĐM180xς邾낤B

ނ́AʂāAu|[ɂȂ邩AWɂȂ邩vEEE܂ŗmグĂ΁Aނ̃t@當͏oȂ낤B

tŏW߂1750~Ƃ́[[Aނ͖{̈ӖŐ͂Ȃ̂[[́uItFXvƂCxg̎QƎv΂̂B

Aꑊ̋񂾃CxgɂẮAgy͂ȂB

IptH[}[ȂAORP̕iDĂBނ́AȂƁAsmIɗ₵2007N̎_ŁAłɓ{O[oYɎ荞܂邱ƂmĂB

ނJԂĂuQĂ鏭hvA̐8NoAu99̑hvɂȂĂƂ킯łB
܂ŁAuhvɂ͂̒wÅԂɏXɕ󂵂āACAẮuhvɑgݍ܂ĂAƂƂłB

ԑw{ׂ͂̕x́AIȎdg݂oāAuh̒̏hvłu1vɈړ]̂B

{̕ɉSn[̓Jj

OḿA{bɉĂ͂ȂȂB

A{̃vpK_EYoV́Aubvl{WO񑊂ƈӋCvƂofĈۑn߂B
{̕fH삪n܂̂B

ɁAOḿAꂩoė邳܂܂ȍoώwWނ̎x҂ɁAu{̕ɉSn[̓JjvƂ܂Ō邾낤B

b͐WO̍ȂƂāAhɓ̌𔭊ĂAƂ킯łB

ނ́AxĂĂlX̎vΎނłȂoJȋC܂jłB

Aḿułł΂B͉A ȂB h am what I am.vƊJĂB

ł́Aɔᔻ̌t𗁂тn߂x҂ɑ΂āAuOAȂɂ킩ႢȂvƌĂ悤Ɏ󂯎ꂩ˂ȂBmƂjAl̋ɕ񂢂jǂAɂ߂Ȃ΂ȂȂBނ́Ał͂ȂB

ނ́AƂƂɂĂ͂ȂȂlԂłB
x҂̎vAul̐D悷vƂ̂ł΁AȂǂł͂ȂB

ꂩ́Aî񂿂VƂĐĂ̂u炵vBu͉vAނ̐g̏TCY̐EłB邱Ƃ͂Ȃ̂B̐тʂ΂̂B

AAŋgĐ̐EłĂ͍IƌĂ̂B

woĝǂ̃}RAɂĎ̍l܂Ƃ߂ĂB
̒ŁAޏ͂ĂB

uNȂƂƁǍl낢댾ƁA ͂̕Xɂlߊ悤ƁAŌ̈lɂȂ낤ƁAłÁAꌴ̂̑Ή͊ԈĂƎv܂AƌȂĂ̓_A āAXȂƁAςȂ񂾁AƎv̂łˁBv

ޏ́A{̈ӖŖ𗝉ĂB

ɁA̘_ŉ؂낤Ƃu썇vAj󂷂邱ƂmĂB
Ƃ́A𖯂ɗ^Ƌɕς鏔ňł邱ƂmĂB

ޏ́AmŁAӎuŖтƂĂBȐlB

Aޏ͑l̎^邽߂ɐgK؂ĊĂ킯ł͂ȂB
A瓾鎊̕ʂ́Aޏɂ^ȂAޏɂłȂB

cOȂƂɁAȂ100̐lX́Ał͂ȂBƂƏIȐlXȂ̂łB

Am̑ItFXɉlA\lW܂AƐĂ𖯂̂ƂłB
ƂāAނ炪AĐłƎvł킯ł͂ȂƂ炢ĂB

́AւƂ܏Hɒǂ܂Ă܂Ă邱ƂȂ̂B
܂AOmɖu҈ˑƂvɖĂ܂Ă̂łB

ɂ́A̎vl͂ȂB

͐lXX̗ŎRɍl邱ƂՂB
Ǎ݂݂ĂlX̂łBɎ咣A܂ɂ肽{ĺAɂƂsȍB

ނ́u]o߂Aōl邱ƂHĂvƎvłB

o𗘗pĎ[Ă͂ȂȂBg̃AOŌȂƋ𖯂͉iɋ𖯂̂܂܂B

As]邽߂ɂ́AƂɊ҂Ă͂ȂȂƂƂB
܂ĂAƂɉʂȂǂƁA܂ł҈ˑIĂĂ͂ȂȂB

{WOƊ@ɂāAAȌ_XA܂Ă邱Ƃ畆oŕĂ̂ł΁Aނ炪󂵂悤ƂĂ񂪊OɏoĂ悤ɂāAlll@𑝂₷ƂAׂĂn܂̂łB

Ar⑝cȂ̌҂͓KCł͂ȂBނ́uBv̐lԂł邩炾B

BAzrYȂA܂ł̓smƂ͑S΂ŉBĂ̑OɑSJɂ邾낤B̏ŁAlX́Aꂼ̍l\z邱Ƃł̂B

㐙₵Ă邪Aނ́AƂƍlĂȂ悤ɌBAǂĂȂĂ܂B

Ã}XR~ŕ񂶂ȂJ_̓ςĉ邾낤B
712Aɐ삯ēEԍ▯z[ōsꂽJ_̈ꖋłBÎ҂́A{NcłB

}bNԍuƑ҂Iԍx@Ăł܂IEI@ᔽ̌sƁI͖炩ɖȂIꕔ̌҂dɏオāIvB

}bNԍ⎁́AIWTłH

2ÔƂł͂邪Ǎ͍ςłB
́A}bNԍ⎁܂̂łāA͂̐lXĂ̂łBԈႢȂAÎґ̓{NĉقEI@ᔽłB

ANlĂB

{ΑقǁAlX͗_󂪌ɂȂĂ̂łB

킸̊ԂɁA܂܂ɂȂBł͊֐SȂEEECtȂEEE

ɂĂAOmƂm[eLȒjĂlX́A₪Ĕނᔻ鑤ɉ邾낤B
lXǍƂ͖牓̂ƂӖBAꂪ̏EEElX́AɌĂB

̃O[^jAzrỶɒSoƂyBzI΍􎖖́AOmVbgAEg悤ɁB

AmAtǂĝAtĂꂽlɉ炩̃RgoKv邾낤B

́A{񑊎ẤuvɌĂ΂ėLV̑cɁucAO͗pĂ񂾂vƎBǁAc͉Ԍɍsĕvw񂩂uB

ɂ{珵ҏ󂪓͖͂B

ނĂmɂƂ낤B

A勴̐iȂAOmɂ͉Ȃ낤Bނ́AʂŒĝȂXj匙炾B

lX͋CÂĂȂA{̏󋵂͂Ȃ[B͉s\ȃx܂ŗĂ܂ĂB

{WÓAĂ̒Ax̑IłxBWÓAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂA΂łIvJԂL҂ɂĂB

IŏƂoϐʂCĂB(܂́AoV)

Ƃ̐̂ɃAxm~NX͔j]Ă̂ɁA܂MĂ̂́A{ɐEœ{̍Ȃ̂łB
ǂ̉pꌗ̃fBAłAuAxm~NX͎sĂȂvȂǂƏĂ郁fBÁÄȂB

ꂾłȂA29ɂ́AGPIF̔Nɂ呹(͉̐ߏ]Ă)oāA҂̐ljłꂽƂm邾낤BpjbNNȂƂFB

smI̓J[31B

e҂̃Rg

2016N720̖ɂ̋LǂŁACfɓeƎvBCf̏Zlɂ́AJChXR[vɂĂ̓Rsye҂ƂȂV̋L𒼐ڃFbNƂl̂ł͂Ȃ낤Bŋ߁AɎOm̕]߂ĈCfłӌΗĂȂŁAJChXR[vmȂlɏЉBeҌl̎Om]OOƗhꓮĂB
ȂA̋ĹAJꂽł̓̂ɂȂ啝ŏdvȒǋLȂꂽB̒ǋLȂǂ肦Ȃ͂Ȃ̂ŁALQƂ邱Ƃ߂B

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo209/msg/841.html
[EIEmgj210] ǃiAzbjNIiLj\ ӌfuO
ǃiAzbjNIiLj

̂т̃IL\́AȂRɂA͌̏ႪҎEƂOサĐꍨuvƂB҂ɂ͂Ȃ֌WȂƌΌ邯ǂAĚɃIL𕷂A邢̓IL\䩂ƂsCdxႪ҂̎EzĂ܂̂́Aǂɂ̂ȂƂBےƌ悤Vc͓VcȂ̂łAq̌rƂƂ̊֌W^֌Wӂ肩ƂA邵̕|CƐ킫ƂȂ̂͂ȂB

Ⴊ҂̎{݂͂qr̋Z悩牓ꂽBaVcenuKvƂAqm}ӂqǂ̑Oɂ́A܂āuNё̊iDǁvȂ鎙ꂽB݂̓Vc̗łAǂ͎OɁA_Ⴊ҂FmǊ҂OoȂ悤̒nɒڊԐځAH삵ĂƂBXMɂ܂邱Ƃǂ̎uvɂ́AsȐ_߂܂AꂶA₩ɋiԁj głB

̃Nj̃[mtHrAixenophobiaj́AȂׂāAȂXMBٗlȂقǂɁBXM̓IL\ɂAȂ̂ƂɌyȂ̂BqNl͎ˁANl͑ȁr\\ȂǂƁA񂶂ČĂ͂ȂʁAccc@͔肫Ȃ̂ƁBXMuƂĎЉɓ݂vĂƂ́AǂƂB݂u݁vƂ́AXMAƂĂB

XMAȂ͋\Ȃ̂B\ɂȂ̂BڋŔڏȁA邪͎҂炦AȃtBNVȂ̂B̂悤Ȃ̂Ƃĉ\ꂽq݁rq݁rȂ̂BƂȂAĊAQҎE̐NƓĺA쒷ځE@ځE^ځE@ځEqgȁEqgȁEqgȁEqgEqgEqgEqgłɂ炸A\邱ƂvꂽЂƂȂ̂B

łȂAIL͂͂ǔvłׂłAXM͂̓ɁAqgƂĉȂ΂ȂȂBāǔv\ł́Aވʂł͂Ȃpʂ̊]AȂ킿AVcp~̈ӌׂłBtłBXM̓XMɂȂ肫A͎҂̎vfǂA\ƂƂ肿ĂBqgłȂ΁AɉEbւ̔F؎Ȃ΂悩̂BǔvƂ͂ƂB

āAQҎE̐NAXMhĂ̂ł͂ȂB
i2016/08/10j
@@
@@
AzbjNiӌfuOjm񓚐̌LɒǉĂ𔲐n
http://yo-hemmi.net/article/440874162.html
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo210/msg/926.html

[n13] XvmIon\iVj
XvmIon\
̍ĐAM񕜌f
http://www.niigata-nippo.co.jp/news/politics/20160810272709.html
V@2016/08/10 20:30
@@
@@
@SsŌs߂XvEsiUVj͂POAŋL҉AXQXAPOPUJ[̒mIɗ₷邱Ƃ𐳎ɕ\BX́uꂽ̐M߂vƋBsȂǂƂ̊֌WPÁuĐE퉻vi߂l𖾂炩ɂB

@E̐cTFmiTRj͖ł̂SIon\ĂAIƂȂ邱ƂmɂȂB

@sƌ͂TAcm̌^cᔻ錟،ʂ܂Ƃ߂BUɂ͎񒷗LuTlXɗvBX͖ŏonAv}AeĉȂǂɐE߂jB

@ŐX́uc̓Ǝ̎咣ɂAV͍keAsƌ֌WɂȂĂvƎwEAu̐M񕜂ʂƂ̎gvƏqׂB

@RPQN̐cɂāu󂯐g̎pŁwsׁxƂBϋɓIɑOɏo鐭􂪂ȂvƔᔻBsߗ׌Ƌ͂Aɑ΂Ď咣邾łȂ̗͂oȂ琭smڎwƂB

@哱{CfqH̑Dwł́uۓIMpɊւ肾BƏJA[ł}vƑiB

@d͔芠H̍ĉғł́üSB؂vƂB

@X͒sogœ呲BݏȊoĂPXXXNɒsɏIB݂TځB

@mIonɔAHɒsIs錩ʂAX͎sE͖̎Apw͂ȂƂB
http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/742.html

[n13] sAPOJ[̌mI֏on𐳎\i{oϐVj
@s̐Xvsi67j10ɐVŋL҉ACɔVmIiX29A1016J[jɏonƐɕ\BX͂SڂڎwE̐cTFmi53jɂāuƎ̎咣ō⌧sƂ̊֌WvȂǂƔᔻBu̐M񕜂ʂAɉۂꂽgvƏonRB

@X͖ڎwmƂƂāüӌɎXA̒mb𐶂vuɎ咣邾łȂ̗͂ovuEMACovȂǂUڂB

@q͐܂ߋ̓IȌɂāA͉̓񓚂ȂBüӌ𕷂Ȃ珇A\vƏqׂɂƂǂ߂B̏Łu͒NɂłBɌfmł΁AׂĂ͎̐słvƃ[_[Vbv̏dvJԂB

@X͍N11ɂTIʂ΂Bs̔CRNȏcĂ̏onɂȂ邪um̗ꂩ璷sA邱Ƃs̔Wɂ^vƎsɗ߂B

@X͍AAAiȂǂ̊e}֐E߂B

@2012N̑OIł͋Ye}c𐄑EA͌_Ŋe}͐c狁߂Ă鐄EɂđԓxۗĂBc̊Ԃ́u}ɂ͐cɋ߂͂ƐXɋ߂͂A{͓vijAuXc̒m̑ΉĔfvijȂǂ̈ӌRB

@X𖱂߂VsAӂƂĐX𐄑E邩sBOs̍ElsɂƁA10lȏ̌񒷂XxjƂBAΎs̏rFscx񒷂B

@O̒mIł́AcƂ̐􋦋c݂̏ȂǂƂ]BƂē𐄑EĂB

@̏onĂ͂UɎOs␹ĒȂǌTs̎񒷂XɖʉAf𑣂Bc͂QASڂڎwďon\ĂB

@X͒sogBHw𑲋ƌAݏȂɓȁB1999N̒sIŏIB2009N͑Ss˂ĂB

@sƂđ݊𔭊͍̂ЊQ΍􂾁B04N10̒znkł͋RÎuisj̑SZ󂯓ȂǑΉwBSsXnł́AiqwOɎs{ɂړ]āA^CxgJÂł镡_uAI[vJȂǂB
http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/743.html

[n13] uc̗fv@XmIon\iYoj[Xj
uc̗fv@XmIon\
http://www.sankei.com/region/news/160811/rgn1608110043-n1.html
Yoj[X@2016.8.11 07:04
@
@
@s̐XvsiUVj͂POAŋL҉AXQXAPOPUJ[̒mIɖŏonl\B𖾂炩ɂ̂͌E̐cTFmiTRjɑAQlځBX́uc̈fA̐M񕜂ʂɉۂꂽgƊmMBƈꏏɌĐvƏqׁAĉSIj~@ƐBLɎxu}v{pɂƂB

@X́ARPQNԂɂ킽cɂāum͎g̈ӌƎ咣ɂAߗ׌A̎sƌ֌WɂȂĂvƔᔻB̏ōŋ߂́gh̗ƂāA{CfqHvŎgtF[̌_guグǔłꂪvƎwEBÁE֘A̖@v悪肾Ƃɂyuւ̐Mp傫ĂAE̎mCቺ̂ł͂ȂvƂB

@̓IȐ͎Ȃ̂́AڎwmƂāÄӌɎX̒mb𐶂s̒mbƃp[𐶂ߗ׌Ƌ͂ăvWFNg遤̗͂oEMACosĉƋp[o|̂UfAɁuvƗ͂߂B

@onɔACcRNȏ゠钷sTړrőޔC邱ƂɊւẮus̊҂𗠐؂sׂɉf邩ȂAcs傫ȃ}CiXvƏqׁAs܂ތ̎̂̔WɂȂ錈fƂBޔĆAmɂȂB

@Os̍Els猧̎񒷂TlUɎ󂯂onvɂẮu̒ɂ܂Ă̂ɉ΂Biońj܂ꂽł͂ȂvƏqׁA󂯐g̎pł͂ȂƋB

@Acm͐X̏on\󂯂āuǂȂ₳悤Ƃ̐ESEYA̔WɑS͂svƂ̃Rg𔭕\Bq͖hЂ߂AbB픘iЂ΂jy胈Ef܂́uOzz̘bł͂𓾂ȂvƐXᔻƂƂɁAq͖hЂ̌Ɉӗ~B
@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@
@Xvs̉ł̎Ȉꓚ͎̒ʂB

@\\on̗R

@u{CfqHvȂǂ̖͌̐Mp傫ĂAE̎mCቺĂƐSzĂBnldˁA錈fv

@\\ő̌ߎ

@uLûTsionvɁjĂꂽƂƁiš㉇́jwui݂j̉x̗ꂽƂ傫Aɉ߂Ȃv

@\\ڎwmƌ

@us̒mbƃp[gċߗ׌ƂAg̗͂oƂł΁ASĂ̐słBíjԑ厖Ȍ̈SES邱Ƃ{ɁAnƂƂɌ؂Ăv

@\\XšpҎw

@uȂBs߂邱ƂŁA߂邱Ƃł͂ȂBN₷邩ɂ߂člv

@\\s̑ޔC

@uAŜ̃XPW[̒ōlBiXsc؂ɂ̂j̍lv
http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/744.html

[EIEmgj211] uےVc͐lԎȂ̂AےVc͐O̍̂ƒf₵Ă̂Al͈ႤƎvBFZFzvikJǁj
uےVc͐lԎȂ̂AےVc͐O̍̂ƒf₵Ă̂Al͈ႤƎvBFZFzv@
http://sun.ap.teacup.com/souun/20543.html
kJǁ@2016/8/12
@
@
@
@lhĂBxl𐮗邽߂ɃcC[gB炩ߌĂAcT͂ĐOވʂF߂邱Ƃ̗͌]n͂邪ATdɂ悢ƂlBu߂鎩RvF߂Ɓu鎩RvF߂邴ȂȂA͌@̖ɂȂ邩炾B

AےVcSVxƍlAVc̐lԐeF邱Ƃ̐x⋭A炱OވʂƂVcĺulԂ炵RvF߂邱Ƃ́AےVc݂̍ɏグ̂Ƃc_̂ƂȂA͂Ȃx悢B

BVclԎIȕɓ̂ےVc̊łƂ錩Ƃ͐΂ɁAOވʂے肷҂蛂Ȏ狌hA͐OA^̘̍_҂Ƃ݂Ȃ̂́A͂茵ȍl@BےVc͐lԎȂ̂AےVc͐O̍̂ƒf₵Ă̂Al͈ႤƎvB

CےVc̓Vcɂ܂܂ȎR񂳂ĂA{sȂF߂錠^ĂȂƂ͒NF߂ƂBjn̒jqcʌpȂ̂͐ÓunvĂ؋BCfIM[AVcЉɊY҂łƂ̂͐OB

DȂΓVcɂlH {AlTO͌NƂIȐgEƂ̑΍RŏoẮBRȂuVcɂlvƌȂ̂͂_Ɗ֌W邵A̎𓥂܂Čs@ĂBVcւ̐lԎIȎv͓VcƍƂ̌uՂɃtbgɂĂ܂B

EVcƍƂ̊֌WlԎIȂ̂ƂĈʒuÂAxzExzƂx̊֌WE@O̊֌WA20IɓĐVɍ̂ɕt^ꂾCfIM[BbIœIȊ֌WN֌W̖{Ƃ̂V̘_łAꂱ쎝ꂽ̂B

F1946N11ɏaVcuV{ُ݂̏vŁAVcƍƂ̊Ԃ̕Rт́uMƌhvǐt͍̓Vc̒kbɂoꂷjƂɂĉÂ猋΂ĂƉߋÁutvulԐ錾vƌĂ΂̂́A͂Ӗ[Ȃ̂B

GaVc͈ȏ̂悤ȐV̎vž̎񂾂Aɑ匳ł茻l_łBMiÕW[iXgŔš@̎vo[jcj܂ŏےVc_͐O瑶݂A܂V̘_ƐeaIłB

HȂ킿aVc͂łɑ{鍑@̑̐ŃJX}łAAg𓝍ےƌ͕̂sRł͂Ȃ낤B̈ӖŁAaVc͂łɁuےVcvŁuvA݂̓VćuےVcvŁu낤vƂ邱ƂŏےVc̒nʂɂƌ邾낤B

Ixhꂽ݂̓VcuےVcvƂāAŐߑVcƂ͋ʂꂽVc̓Iɒǋ鑶݂ł΂قǁAVcƍƂ̊Ԃ̏QiuN̛@vj͔rAO{ŌꂽVȍ̎vzɋ߂ÂƂtBjƂ͂܂ʂB

J璺oɁAN҂łB́Ǎł͓VcƂǂl̓ʂɊłȂ̂ŁA璺Љ̓VčlIȒLƂĔzƌĂB̐𗣂ꂽ̓Vc͐b̓ʂɓ荞݁Ab̃ACfeBeB̈pB

K̓Vc̒kbł@̐lAVcƂꂩ痣ČlƂċCƌĂBlƂĂ̓Vc̔̊ĂŁȀےƂĂ̓VcƂĈlЂƂ肪傢Ȃ銴󂯂B͂VcC݂ő݊ȂȂǒNvȂB

LAcT͉sȂēVc̐OވʂF߂Ă̂ȂA͂肵Ă鎖́A̔[̂͂܂ȂuVclƂĂ̋Cv̔IłBIȗɂVc匠҂𓮂A͂̓VcƓlԂƂĔF߂OႪłB

MAVc̒kb͘^悳ĂƕĂ̂ŁAςɕҏWȂC肾A͂ȂłAtɑSɌĒڌ肩邻́ud|vɂ͒ӂKvƎvB

N낢jm҂ƂČOA̒kbiKêƂł͂ȂjjƂƂẮu΂炵vƂ͌ȂGĂB^΂͂茾Ȃǂ͂痈ĂBuvlvāu~vƂƂɂȂĂ̂̂߁Bij

ymF @doinakamura
wߓ{@xiя@jBzꎁucT͂̉ɂđވʐx݂邱Ƃ͂\ł邪AʓIȗ@_ƂĂ΁AOވʂ̉\F߂邱Ƃ́Acʂ𐭎IȂ}hIȑΗɂ܂ނꂪƂAlȂ΂ȂȂv

̂ɂłA܂{@͐̌RuvƌĂs׋҂邪AȂBvOɁA܂@̌@Ă͂߁A@ߒł̍Ȃǂ̐Rcߒł̋c_邪BxAVɐ{Ă̏܂ŒǉĂB

{@uꂽv̌@ǍRuv@ȂǂƂ̂͐V́usjρvBs풼̓{̎xzwi{⍑c⊯jLĂȒmlwȂ߂Ă͂ȂB

c쎠 @kakitama
@{sA@w҂́u{͕̍̂ς܂BɎ匠ڂ̂łBWPT͊vvƌA{(X𔭈Ď҂Ƃ)dÝû͌쎝ꂽvƌB̂Ⴂ͍ŏ獡܂őĂB

@w҂͂킴𓾂܂B͖̂@Ȏ݂łA̕܂߂ĂׂĐOƐオf₵ĂƂ͖̂܂iZgÂ@̊Oɒu܂jBumXv_͂_Ă܂ˁB

ITO Toshikazu @toshiitoh
́utv͏ےVc̒Iȑɑ傫ȖʂƎvA͕ʂɁulvł͂ȂāA|낵قǑŗOȐƂƂ^ꂽB

܂񂵁AےVc̗zǋ邠܂A▭ȃoXŌ@ƁuavĂVc傫A傫ȕϊvĂԉ\Ă邩܂B

iȂȂjBےVcƂ̂́AuȂAz^ǋĂ͂Ȃ̂ȂB܂ɋĈ悤ȑ݂ł邱ƁAꂪ߂ꂽ̂ȂBےVcɕĴAuVc̐lvɂȂƂ͔̂iȂƂɂȂ邩jB

c쎠 @kakitama
OɂƓVću@KIȁv̊֌WA@̘gщzɌq댯B̌O͕BɂĂ͖@̘gщzuv͐΂ɏoȂBuH͂Ȃvƌ鎖ŗH͏BuH삪h飂ƋقǂɁAH͖{ɑhłB

H͎Љ̎dg݂ɉقǂeyڂȂłAl悤ȍ̎vzK̖͂Ƃ̂́uvƂɊւAlтƂE܂B錛@w҂悤ɂ̖͗ɂƂẴALXFłB

Ȃ킿́AtIłu@Ovɂ鍑̎vz⓹ɂĕ⊮܂BȂȂ猋ǁAx̂͐l͂łBc󐶂̖𕶊w⌾t̖ɍLčl@Ă܂B

яVƂ̋Ғẃu@vƂ͉xi폑XjɎڂĂc_ƐٍeQƉB

{OO @matsumotot68@
̌@Ɂu푈vƏA̕aƈS͎Ɩ{CōlĂĺA܂ÊǂɂȂł傤BȎȂ琢E̓oFłB{CōlĂ{l̂ȂA؍xgiENCiɍsāAMSɂ̕@E߂Ăꂽ@ł傤B

Simon_Sin @Simon_Sin
Ě}΂ЂƂúASE̍AЂƂ|ƌRƂAâɐ錠L邱ƂmFBvƓR̂Ƃ𓖑RłׂƋ𒼂ɐ錾Ă錛@ÔقlƂėhƂ@

@Ɂu푈v畽aۂĂ̂ƌl͌@킩ĂȂB@͑NĂ邱ƂXgbv閂@̌tł͂ȂǍ͂͂gĖ\Ȃ悤ɂ邽߂̂̂BɌ@OɍێЉւ̐M\{͉łȂ̂ɁB
@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@
ɏЉĂ镶͂́AZFz @akisumitomoɂÃcC[głBɓe҂ЉɂAuIvȍׂƃCAEg̕ύXȂBukJǁv̌LQƂ̏Ae͂BLɂ͏ЉĂȂcC[gŗv_RpNgɂ܂Ƃ܂Ă̂̂ŁAłɏЉĂBieҁj
@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@
O̍̎vzƂĂɑlłB̂@Ƃđ闝邩Ǝv΁A@zƂđ闝܂BႦΌN͎xzExz̊֌Wł͂ȂIȊ֌WɂƂN̘_̈Bi1/3j

݁A͓VćuCvl邱ƂdvƂA܂̓Vc̒kbł͓Vc͍ɊYƂĂ܂BO̍̎vzɋ߂̂܂Bi2/3j

@̎ł͍͕̂ςAVcƍƂ̐liIȊ֌WƂĂ͐O̘̍_cĂƖl͍lĂ܂BQƁْwc{̃fNV[xiLuɁjBi3/3j
http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo211/msg/139.html

[EIEmgj210] ǃiAzbjNIiL2j\ ӌfuO
ǃiAzbjNIiL2j

L̐ܕSH̐̃Nj́AhWǂ́A^hWn̐_ɂȂ΁Av̂BXMuOވʁṽILƂ́u悩vƁB̂AhW񂽂93p[Zg߂BǂƂ̂Bł́AhWnɖ₤B͌̏ႪҎE̐ŃAYƎvǂ_A͂93p[Zgȏ̃hWǂuCGXvƓ̂ł͂ȂB͂ȂɂӖ̂B

݂̍HÓƂӂ̌ʏhW񓇂ɂẮAVc^ƎYx^~RƂ܂ÂĂBȂHXM͂񂪂Ƃ邾낤BȂ́AuGvus򎋁vƓVc̊֌WɂāA̂܂ƂȂЂƂƂāA[vƂ̂낤HuGvus򎋁vꂽ퍷ʒn̐ĺAXMƓlɁAwIɂ͗쒷ځE@ځE^ځE@ځEqgȁEqgȁEqgȁEqgEqgEqgEqgłɂ炸AȂ₠Ȃ̕ɈwłG邱Ƃ͌킸ȁAԗɂČ邱ƂȂB

㌒͂߂ĂłBVc邩獷ʂB񂶂ȎłB̂悤Ȏ|̂Ƃ𐶑O{\bƂԂ₢BłB͌̏ႪҎ{݂́AȂ͌ɂ̂BȂscł͂Ȃ̂BL̐ܕSH̐̃Nj̍iÝAXMvw̒aA{̏dvsAcƂȂȂ悤ɁAfƂĎsĂ̂͂ȂBu{̍cAɓɐAƂЉɓAlX̊҂ɉĂlAɎĂ܂v\\́A]΁AuGvus򎋁vuqvƂhWIK̉i錾ɂЂƂB

܂łނ񂪂܂łȂ̂ȂˁBcT͂炸ɂ邱Ƃ͂BႢc̕Xɂ傱Ɓu߂JvĂĂ͂ǂBƂ΁uubNƑ܁vɃm~l[gĂAcƑ㖢EߘJEEȋEjƂł̃oCg邢͔hJBTA7Ԃ̐[JAߌ3 ߑO3 ̕X܂12 Ԃ̘AJBxeԂȂAxo΁AIȃ{eBAAA̔l|ECWÃgC|ACccB

XMAXM𗘊pƍߓIƂǂAuЉɓv̂́Aȏ̂悤ȁAƂĂȂssƕnAƐ키ӎvȕےvƂ[BāAOވʂł͂ȂAOpʂBΖ炳AJA̕X́uPЂƂvł͂܂Ȃ̂BƂŁAIܗւIA܂Ȃ邾낤AꂪBiY̎sBԂAL̐ܕSH̐̃Nj̃hWǂ́AقڑSA炩ƒmʂӂ邾낤B
i2016/08/11j

[EIEmgj210] ǃiAzbjNIiL3j\ ӌfuO
ǃiAzbjNIiL3j
@
ǂɍĉ邭ƁAЂǂnƂBɂقЂ́A炩JVRLA^ւ̗ł͂ȂBnL͂ЂȂA炩炱ւƂĂBꂠ肪A肪Ɣn̂ɂςĂ̂ǂ͂ʂAhWǂ͂ȂBtȂǂȂ̂B瑤̔ñN\AЂƂ̃N\̂ɂقЂ֒ɂȂꂱ񂾂AAA킪ÂłrނƂӂ̂B H Ȃ n()߂ ɍs ̉ԌɁ@XN\ЂcB肦ȂBȂ̃GgXǂƒnZAcł͂ȂAl̑̃N\ُLՒfɌ邾낤B
@
V@SbXY͔s̗N̍قŁAVcuƂ̏ےƂA̒SƂďh邱Ƃ͓{l̍I{łȂ΂ȂȂvm1nƓقĂBcׁA͂܁AɑSʓIɎꂽ̂B}XR~́uILvuIRgovłȂu䉺vu䎸ցvuEvuAvuvuFmi{Pjv܂łAcpƂāuL҃nhubNvɒǉ邩ȂBēVcij𐒔quI{vȂ̂ǂAqm}∮ӂāuNl͎ˁIvuNl͑ȁIvƂ߂̂BAȂ߂Ă͂ȂȂB
@
_{t@VXgŒƎ҂̋kFOY͂ւȗ_ƂłAXŁuNl͎ˁIvȂǂƋ񂾂͂Ȃ炵BA܁E܎ɎQuނɂ܂ʎvƂuȂ邩񂩖Ӗ܂AЂɑcāvƂBɂĂЂƂ͏BuȂsAoĂAގgɂĂ͐łvm2nicȎOwVcƂ̎xzx1966NjBłBuȂ邩񂩖Ӗ܂AЂɑcāv\\́ucv́AuvuNvugDvu}vuЁvuVvȂǂƑւ\łBuȂ邩񂩖Ӗ܂AЂɑcāv̐_́ÃhWRNɂĂ͂āAE̐́iY}Y}nj̕ʂȂAEleuvłBVcɍݓvꂽ̐ŚA܂{Iɂ͕ςĂȂB
@
ǂǂ납ȂłBႪҎÊ̐NɂāA킽́uȂsAoĂAގgɂĂ͐łṽZeXƁuȂ邩񂩖Ӗ܂AЂɑcāv́AɃoĴB726̎ŚA̐Ńuv̌ʂłA܂ȂKNłB͓|Љ炦A𒥂̉eGłB̎ЉɁAXMAȂ́u݁vAȂ[u݁vÂ悤Ƃ̂B
i2016/08/12j
@
AzbjNiӌfuOjm񓚐̌Lɒǉꂽ𔲐n
http://yo-hemmi.net/article/440874162.html
@
@
@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@
@
eҒm1n
@
uɚ铂Ɖ]ӂƂ̈Ӗł܂邪A͌̂₤ȍl֕\PnƎvЂ܂ARҚ铂̌t͌Ĉɂ͎g͂ċ܂ʁA쎮ɚ铂Ɖ]ӌtg͂ꂽȘҁA͑̑Oɂ邩m܂ʂAX趑ȈӖɗpЂċ̂ł܂AȂV{IȗŌȂŁAʂ̏펯ɏƂčlւČ܂鎞ɁA@Ȃ̂ł炤AS铂̐S̒ɊXƂāA@ӂׂ@ӂׂɂ炸Ả\͂ނ̉\͂Ȃ̂́AxX\ċ܂₤ɁAVc𓲂̒SƂ隠̐ŠqƉ]ӂƂł܂A{ƂĚƂ݂ċ邱ƂA铂Ɖ]ӌtŌċ̂Ǝvӂ̂ł܂Ayɕt܂Ă͐⛔ɉX̂͝Ƃ͂ȂAҝׂ̂̂łȂƐMċ܂āA铕ŝ̌͂茾͂𓾂ȂƎvӂ̂ł܂v
@
XYiM@90{c23@a21m1946nN0826@[30/36] j
@
@
u͓Vc̖{čnʂ͉X̐S̍qƂ̌qɉĂ̂łAĈЂ̖@Ȃč蓾̂łȂA@Ȃď̂łȂA{̔MȂ錌tċAX̑S_Ƃ̌qɉēVčnʂ͂ƚ̐S̒ɍ݂̂ł邵AkČΗj̒ɂ͂茻ċÅ{̍lւČւ΁A{̖{c̎pł͂ȂA̖{c̎pƌւ΁A͑铂Ɖ]ӌt̈ӖƂČЕ\̂ł͂ȂA펯Iɚ铂ƌċ鑴̎pł͂Ȃ炤ȂỎɍ̚铂Ɖ]ӂ͓̂{̐S̚[ċ鑴̓VcƂ̌qƉ]ӂ̂ɉē{Ɖ]ӂ̂͌AɊĚƂo҂ċA̓Fӂ̂łƉ]Ӑċ̂ł܂āA͍ɉđ̍l̂łƎvЁAył͂Ȃ\܂A쌴N͈̎ȋ\ԂłƁAył͂Ȃ\桂܂ʂA̎ȋ\ԂłƋɂȂ܂At̎gЕ͕ʂƂ܂āA͑SӔCȂĎȋ\ԂƐMċȂƉ]ӂƂ𖾌vƍlւċ̂ł܂AɎzȊb̉ɉ܂ēVčnʂ͂ǂł邩Ɖ]ӓIʂɉ܂ẮA̗jƐSƂ̒ɏhċAʂ̖̐ʁA@̖ʂɉ^ј҂܂鎞ɔ@ɂ邩Ɖ]ӂƂNĘ҂A猛@̖ƂȂĘ҂̂ł܂AȑO͌@̈ȑO̖ł܂A̖{@ɐ\ĐÌ܂鏊@̑꞊ł܂AuVc͓{̏ےł{̏ےvłƓVčnʂ͓{ӁAƊ̌ƂȂ鏊́u{̎ӂɊvƋK肵Ă̂ł܂āA䢂ɂ͂蚠Ɗ̌ƂȂ隠ӂɊVčnʂ_OIȂl݂̂ɊĐ̂ł͂ȂAms̗jƚ̐S̒ɍċƉ]ӂƂ͂肵̂ł܂A̓VčnʂƉ]ӂ̂́A{Z̎q嫂A^p߂΍pݓ₤Ȑ_bbƂē{̊bK肵Ɖ]ӂƂ́AǂĂ]ӂƂꂽłsvcɎv͂̂ł܂AVɈ˂ĖVčnʂׂ͌Ɛ\Ƃoғł܂AzɓVčnʂ͂ƚ@ɔF肵Ƃ́A쌴N\܂ʂA̒mAW߂ƓɁA{̒ɔċȂB𑸏dȂ΂ȂʂƉ]ӌcƎvЂ܂A{̐S̒SƂȂĂłɂȂӂɈ˂Ě̏ےłƉ]ӕɒ߂邱Ƃ́AɓK؂łƍlւċ܂v
@
XYiM@90{c24@a21m1946nN0827@[8/66] j
@
@
uX͚̂Ƃ͎vċ܂ʁAX̚Ƃ͈l̓VcA͉ߋyћ҂ɘiĂ̈т隠̗ϗISłA͓Vc𓲂̒SłƐ\܂Ƃ́A͑肷A͂ΖɉČӏ̌tł܂āAKImȂeƂ͌͂Ȃł܂AccmɌւΌǚ̐SVcɌqāA[ɗqo҂ċAVɈ˂ē{Ƃms̈̌铂ƂȂċƉ]ӂƂł܂āÄӖɉ܂ĉX̂̂͝Ƃ͎vċ܂ʁA獟̈Ӗɉ܂āAX͉Ƃ̊{F̂͝ċȂ̂łAƂ͓ꐫċ̂łƍlւċ̂ł܂A䢂ɚ铂Ɖ]ӈӋpИ҂Ȃ΁A铂͕s̂łƉ]ӂƂɂȂA͑̌tւAĘ҂ċ܂A͂Ȃ铂̂͝ʂƂ͐\Ă͋܂ʁv

u{̚Ƃ͗jɌċ܂኱́̕A_bbƂĚɔ[ӂ邪@p悵ċ܂AXߋ̚ł_bɈ˂ėUꂽ̂܂Â݂Ɉ˂č̓{̚Ƃċ̂Ƃ͎v͂܂ʁAߑI̗jƂ̘_暂鏊Ɉ˂܂΁AyɉđcȂ̂̂ł܂A͗jƂł͂܂ʁAnĕIȂ錩nɗĂꂼ̗jƂ̈ӌFOɓr͂܂ʂAX̒m蓾ׂߋ̗jɑkẢ݂X̐SɌڂ݂܂āAVcȂāǍẗ͂Γ̒SƂAVɈ˂ēꂹĘ҂Ɖ]ӂƂ͌ǐ͙VR鎖łAz̔@płƉ]ӂƂ́AӖړIɚ̞ܗ͂ɕnċ̂ł͂܂ʁAӎIɕnċ̂łAĕnċ̂łȂ΁A_SჂĕnċ桂ł͂܂ʁA̎X̎pɉ܂ẮA@̋KA_b̋ւƉ]ӂ̂͋pċm܂ʂAS̒ɉ܂āA͂莩Ȃ̈ӎvƉ]ӂ̂ɁAJlF߂ċƉ]ӂƂ́Aߋ̕{A͎኱̎A̐l̏Ɖ]ӂ̂ʂĕs\ȂFߓł炤ƎvЂ܂A̗ɗāAV𔽏Ȓv܂鎞ɁAX͉ߋɉĕs\ł͂ǂA܂͖莄̐\܂₤ɁAƂ̈ӎv̌򂽂̂AS铂ɂƉ]ӟċ̂łA͂ꂪ͂ӎȂŁAÔɌċ̂łAKv𐶂Azdɜ䂶ĐSS߂ɁAX䢂ɔFz𐶂̂łAFzꎩǵAИIɌđ傫ȎłA͔FzƌāAȂƂ͐\܂ʁA\܂̂Ȑł͂܂邯ǂAVAn荟̏ꍇcƂ̂ł܂āAF̂ƂĂA̖{̂ȂƉ]ӂƂɉ܂āA{̚Ƃ͊SȂѐċ̂łAɓ{̚ƂтċƂ΁AGɐ\qׂ܂ʂAƂ̈ѐɔāA@͖@IѐċǍ@̈ѐȂāA铂̂čsƉ]ӂƂ́AK@ɐFċX̂ł͂Ȃ炤ƁAzɎ͍lւċ鎟ł܂v

XYiM@90{c25@a21m1946nN0827@[11/27] j
@
@
ǔ@Ă̍qƒv܂́AVc𓲂̒SƂjƚ̊ƂɊ{̎A{̌Ɖ]ӂ̂͂cċ܂āA̍{̎vzɊĐIȚ@IȐȄɌoĘ҂̂ŁA̚@IȐEɉ܂ẮÅ{̎ƖڂāAVc͚̏ےłƉ]Ӛ@IȒnʂ͂A͐_bɊɔ񂸁A̖@Ɋɔ񂸁AӂɊĂƉ]ӊmȂՂVɔF߂܂āAđ̏ےVccЊւ܂΁ANĂVcƂɈ˂ĚƂF߁AVcƂɈ˂ĚɈӎƉ]Ӗ@IȂnʂ炵߁A̓VčnʂXɏ[ਂɁǍ@ĂɎ܂邪@A炸炴KcȂܔ\Vč䓭̒ɟd߂āAꂩ݁XꕾQNēVč䓿AƂ̐^sɎv͂ȂFʂ̐邱Ƃ́ALHvȂĔVr̂ł܂A@I̍ىƉ]ӂ₤ȐϋɓIȂӎvs̞ܔ\͔V𑶍݂߂ȂƂɂāA؂̍sਂɕtēt̏ƏFƉ]ӈ̗vɌq炵ނAz]ӂƂɈ˂܂āA̗LʂKvȂxɉēKɐ荞ނƉ]ӂƂ̌@̐_ł܂v

XYiM@90{c26@a21m1946nN0829@[11/18] j
@
ȏu鍑cc^VXev@http://teikokugikai-i.ndl.go.jp/
@
@
eҒm2n
@
u{t@VYAC^[Et@VHiYɂƔrāAu⏬vĂ邱Ƃ́AłɂꂽiɂĒmĂB̐̃vZXAȁuϊvvɂ̂ł͂ȂāAQIȑ͐퍑Ƃւ̈ڍsɂēÂ邱ƁB̉^̃[_[́AfNV[ʂɑ΂鎩Ȃ̔ےՓAȂ̐IAY𕐊ƂāAOAIЂœ|AȂ̐͂lĂ̂ł͂ȂāA˂ɋɓIɂ͊̍Ƌ@\ƂɌR̈ꕔɈˑpłƂ^΂ȂƁBĂׂẴt@VXǵAIɂ͓Vc̑OɌhiȂbłAۓIɂ́AEے݂閳ނ̍UIjqYƂẴiYɑ΂đ؂ꂵȂǐtH[łȂƁB炷ׂĂ̓Ƃ́AuvƌĂ΂ߒɂĂ܂Aɓ{Љ̗jIo߂mȃLڂȂAĂ̂ƂɑΉāǍo߂cސlԂAɗjIAՒf邾̎̓IsĂAƂƂłBvip.119j
@
u{ł́Ay͍Ƃ̋yłBy𗣂ꂽlȂ΁Ay𗣂ꂽƂȂ̂łBȂ鍑łʂɓssɂẮA@B̒xisɂāAl̑Sʂɂ킽閜Ղ̋KisȂ邩Ał͑ćAIl̒ɂł͂ȂAƊϔO̒ɂ̂ݑ݂悤ɂȂAƂXĂBɂʓIoƍƂ̑ݗR̍IFȂꍇɂ́AӎɂÉAɗeՂɔʉBĖȗ̓{ɂẮAIȒóAЂƂÔ݂Ȃ炸ȂKwɂ݂ȂBƂ́uꑺƁv̉łAƂƑɂSliIȐSIɌIȍƒ̎xłƂĂ̂łiFvjBēssɂāAu}ЉviɓjƂ̂ȂƂ́AɑcƂłBŁAߑ㍑ێЉ̌͐I󋵂ɑΏׂAssƋ@BƗvĂBɂẮAƎ̂AƗƍƐS̋I܂Ă̂łBvip.120-121j
@
uýAē{̑ΊOIْ債A{Q̑Ō_ɂĐ[ƂƂɁAcy̓GUȂ痧BiViỸAgƁuƉv̐SI咣AЉ̉I@\Ass̖KɔB̐ꐧA}̕sA{ߑЉ̕aۂ́AׂĂɌтꂽBΊOIɐƍ̋KI@\̕ãgȂ̂łB܂䍑×玩RɐxɊ҂ׂłBu̐vƂĂ̋y咣̂Au͎҂̖߂ɏ]ȂƉ]ӂ̂ł͂ȂȀS𖞑vƂ|̂Ƃɉ^NiȗQƗ̊vAw_x1932N6jB̗̍jId琶ꂽxƋ@\̘IGlM[𔭊͂߂BA̐x́uRv̂łċK͈ӎɊ܂ނ̂ł͂ȂÁuSv̗͂UȂBgDIsׂ͐]nȂBs̐ƂKvłBuj󉮁vAҋ@ĂBĥ悤ɁuX͔j󂯂ğooł̂A݈Ă̂Ƃ܂Ō悤Ɖ]ӋC͂ȂviwxjƉ]āAuvœ|ɔMAEu}it@VYv^̈̗ތ^łBނ^Ƃ͋yĂ̂ł͂ȂāAtɂ𗣂āuzvBނ́AyƔ_̂߂ɁuVcevׂAIȐEɊ􂷂uumvłƍlĂB炵ĖAޓ̍ŝ̂́AAEgE[ŶłĂA_ɂẮAVcɑ΂OIɒ҂łBނtIA҂邱ƂɂăAEgE[YĂɉ߂ȂB@ȂsK͂F߂ȂjqXgł͂ȂAōlւ̌gɂđׂ̂Ă𖳎łƎvオĂłBނiw҂ƂɈُ҂ł͂邯ǂAiE[_[̃qXebNȔM͂܂łȂ̏Փ甭̂ɑ΂āA{̋ĆAʐlɂ͐^̏oȂuVcMvɋÂł܂ẮuV@v^̃IKiCU[łɂȂB^Cv̐lԂǂđUāuvł̂Bv
ip.121-123j

uVĉƂł́AuVc͓Il̎̂łȂAIɐΌ͎҂łȂƂ炵āAϗIӎv̋̓I߂sȂΓIΎ҂ƂȂAĐbʂׂ͂āAߑɂĎ̜ӂΉāAꖔΓIΎ҂ƂȂBł́AΎ҂̑Ή͑ΓIΎ҂̕ՉłviْĵAVc΂̌Oǂ܂łтčŝ́AVcׂẮuӓIȑΓIΎҁv܂茠͎҂ɔR邱ƂłB{ŁAYׂẲ^NX[KƂ̂́A𗘗pƂʂĂAē{ɂ锽Ɓuv̎傽|{̃CfIM[̒ɂBVcIƂ́AO͓Vc̐΂F߂ĂāAۂ͎̜ӂтƂAVcl̋ɖړIƂ̂ł͂ȂāA̗go̒PȂ铹Wiɋ߂ÂA͂ɋ߂̂ɋ߂Â̓w͂̒nWjƂĂ܂̂ł邩AVcuړIv́Â悤ȓVcu݁vXɑ΂镮S̗͂ƂȂ̂łBvip.123j
@
uǂAy͖AuRv̂ł邩炱A]悤ɁAāuߐHZĵƂ𗣂Ȃv̂Ȃ̂łBȗ̓Vc̎Љ@\̒ӂɒuāuƂ̊bvƂďd̎Ƃ́A͂ꎩgƂēƗđ݂邱ƂȂ׎R̋̂ł炱Ał́ua瀊ɘapviɓjĂǂAɂ͕ՓIK͐_̂Ȃ݂̂ȂBĖK͂̐Eł́Ax͓IڐGɂĂ̂݁A͈̔͂ł̂ݑ݂BuR̗~v̑݊֌WyłƂ΁iAOf_jAy̓퐶߂ēẑ́Ay̎x𓾂邱Ƃ͏oȂB狽ýARɁu̓Iv̉lȂAɍuŐoĂBČЉɂu̓IvdAƂɋQɂẮA퐶̂x͔̍ȂB̍۔_ƌoc̍́AuR̗~v𖞂Ƃ̂ł邩AɃiɍsāAꂪʐÉuSvƂ͌ĂȂ̂łB͎̓Isׂł͂ȂāAR̉^ł邩AЉoϏ̐Y֌Wϊv悤ƂȂ͖̂ܘ_AȂ鐸_E̕ω炳ȂBႦ΁A}it@bV̒̈ތ^ȂĂ鈤mkFOŶ悤Ɂuz݉^vsȂĂ̂̏ꍇBނ͍UƔj󂾂sȂ̂ł͂ȂByiނ͌Z푺ƌĂ񂾁j̕ocʂŁA{YgԙfÏ܂Ő݂ĉǉ^ӂȂikFOYwʐMx1934NjB݂̂Ȃ炸Eu^[ḿwCMXoϔBjxƂeEIbynC}[́wЉw̌nxƂɂĎЉȊwMSɕ׋Č肷B̓_͉eR̂悤Ɂu_vSۂ̂Ƃ͑GIłB̍͑SlԓIȍقł͂ȂBḱAAl̐Eł䩔ƂčȈoȂyy҂łAs̐Eł́Au߂ނɛ߂܂ʎvA؂̍Iz𖳎Č܁E܎ɎQ̂łBčsʂɂẮAuȂ邩񂩖Ӗ܂AЂɑcāvƏBR鉿lς甭uv̌ʂ́Amȉl̏oȂ̂RłBɂ͉lf̃Ƃړx̂̂Ȃ̂BЂɑc΁AŉlƍsƂ͖ȂȂBȂsAoĂAގgɂĂ͐łBu΂悢vƂ̐_тƂA̐̂́Aꂪ̌Ă{^j֌WłB͐eq̉֌WƖڂɘAĂBɁuR̗~v̑̌nłBVc_̎̂͂łBāA~]R̂Ƃɂ͂ǂȍsׂēR̂̂ƂĕB퐶̍ЉȊw̌̈ꕔłɉ߂ȂBk₻̒qѐOimƁj̒ʐMƁAnCJȗm⌴ւ̊֐SAV@IȐSIMuׂĂɊӉx݂̂łviႦΗсjƂR̉^ւ̓OIȏ]ƁA䓖lɂ͉̕svcȂŁAȐDȂ狤ĂB_\A{t@VÝuƉvLڂȂsȂ킵߂̂łBVc̓ɑ݂ߑ㍑ƂƂĂ̍I@\ƑOߑIԂƂĂ̓IS̉lƂ́A̌Xݏo[ȖAX߂Ĕ}D̂́A_ȊOɂ͂ȂBAŜ܂܂ɉ܂ōsił䂭mȂ~]iYɈ̌Eu΂悢BɑSԓIȋy̒łsȂ킹悤ƂA^̋yB͖ȗ̓{Ɉтđ݂ċ̂łāAkȂǂ́A̕aۂɂȂ̂ł邪Aa勰Qɂ́AƂ̑S@ւ̉󂯂āAƑK͂ɁAWJꂽBNcA_mAYƑgȂǂ̉^łBvip.125-127j
@
cȎOuVcƃt@VYviwVcƂ̎xzx1966N Ёj

݂݂[oĂB
http://www.msz.co.jp/book/detail/08347.html@
@
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
@
@
ӌf͈̉Ă̂낤B|ĺu݁vЂ˂悤Ȉ̖\͓Iȁu݁v̂ƂBR̂ƂȂAqȂł͋ԂƑ呛ɂȂBq͌ǁA{ƌŷƎ]𖳗肨݂₰ɎāAABABǂǂABݓ̃fւ̃JE^[Ōƈ𓯎ɂ΂̍앗ɂʂƂ낪肻BႤC邪ART[g߂LȃsAjXĝƂAzBq炳܂ɋ₵ȂAɃhWɂăAzbւ́iтȂXMɂjhe̋Ĉ悤Ȃ̂ĂuЁXvł̕ӌf̑ԓx́Avɐ̂̉B҂␔҂ɂɂ킵̂B

[EIEmgj211] uNNȂÊvӌfi@rantyo3141j

V@12
Čfz͌EQҁEEuN@N@Ȃ@Ê@Eviӌfj
@rantyo3141@2016N813 00:17
@

͌ႪҎEuNNȂÊvӌfij@
@͌̏QҎ{ݎEŁAƂ̕ӌfɂĂ̎vÂe񂹂m1nB
iV@2016N811j@

### @SƂ肩݁^Ȃ̌̐[

@킽͑̂ɑ傫ȌÁXƂĐĂB̋󂵂ɂCÂĂ͂B˂Ƃ߂悤Ƃ͂ȂB́AȂ̐[B݂ŔłAAȂɂ邩킩̂ł͂ȂBAȂǂȂӂB󂵂͋󂵂̂܂܂ɁB͌̂܂܂ɁAقĂB̌J܂܏΂BBɂׂBł͂ȂAɂāBЂ悤ɏ΂AA󂵂ׂB̒ɁA낪藎Ă䂭B
@͌̏ႪҎE̗e^҂͂Ƃɂ܂ĂBANANAȂÊ\Ȋ̐SȂƂ悭킩ȂB̂ǂƂɂ肠ĂĂ̂͂Btɂ悤ƂBt{{ƂB󂷂ƁA킽͖钆Ɏv킸j􂵂Ă܂Błɂ悤ɂ܂̂ɂɂނ̂ł͂ȂBlԂɂƂĂقǂ̏d厖Ȃ̂ɁA "c" 낤ƂĂAǂĂ܂肦ȂłȂA킽̓̌AƂ݂̂ł܂̂BŋĂB
@Sق̌Ă̂́Alɂ͇@uɒl鑶݁vAuɒlȂ݁v\2ނƗe^҂̐N_ɕނ炵ƂB̓񕪖@uCvƒfނ邯ǂAƂAlނ́uCv̓LjȗǂEƂȂƂɂȂ肩˂ȂBɒl閽ۂ\Ƃݘ_Iݖ́A̂ƂÓTIȂłA_cƔϖ́ANwłwł@ł肩AƂ푈̉Bꂽe[}ł̂B
@ԂAႢ̂낤B̖ɒl邩ǂAƂ_cƋYɂ́A܂łɂт㏞xAƂɌAƂƎvĂ̂́B͌A͂܂ƂĂȂ̂łB閽ɒl\̗O͎ł͂ȂB[̂BlĂ݂ĂقB閽ɒlƖӎɎvĂlтƂłA͂̐Nւׂ̂YEs͂ނȂƎm̂ł͂Ȃ낤B܂uɒl鑶݁vƁuɒlȂ݁v̎ʂƑIʂAԐړIɎ󂯂AɓIɂ͌҂́uEv݂ȂŖَE邱ƂɂȂ͂ȂB
@ƂcƁA킽͘fBƂ΁AYƂ̂́uEvȂƂȂى߂lтƂƁAuEvЂƂŎsƂ̋́A̂ƂȂ݂Ȃقǂɉ킯ł͂Ȃ̂ł͂ȂBȂƂA͒nÂ̞Dɂ܁AɌȂāAڂƂłƌ͂ȂB
@iY͕Bjb|R͖łтBDs̎vz͏BVl͂܂˂nɂЂ낪ĂB낤H ЂƂiYjb|ŔuvAƂ悻āAܑ𐁂Ă͂ȂB726̒܂ɗꂽԂ́AĐ̓̎cƂłłȂBuꉭЉv̈pӂł݂̌łB͋ߖ́Aɑʂ̌𒥂Ă͂ȂB
@̐N͂܁AȂɂlĂ邾낤B炳߂āAӂ邦Ă邾낤Bɂ̓qgSVƂIL邾낤Buv̂悤ȎdIƂłvĂ邾낤BpȂOIȎ҂AāAƂuɒl鑶݁vł邩Ȃ\ȎvǑAɗ̔]ɈM邱Ƃ͂Ȃ̂낤B
@

͌ႪҎEuNNȂÊvӌfij@
iV@2016N812j@

### @z񂷂鐢ÊȂŁ^ÂȒT₱Kv

@ڂނɋÎȂ΁A{ɁÂǂ̉Œn̂悤ɒႭȂ߂iAEɂ͂ӂĂBu{ŐیȂ΁Aɂɂł܂ƂݓȂ΁AȂɂȂIvB悾Ă̓smI̊XŁAOlr˂҂AȂɂ͂΂炸͂肠AO甏肪킢ƂB114[ȏ𓾕[ĂB킽̗\z̔{ȏゾBƑ͌̎E̔wi𒼐Iɂނт̂͑vɂ邾낤BǂA̐E܁AeŌŝ͂zǏĂ͔̂ےłȂB
@ŝ̓ǍAE̓|PGŐÂAeŕu^Ẵz[ifjԁvɁAIܗ֒pBAƃAÂȂڂ͂肵ȂB΁APӂƈӂ̋EԂ񂠂܂ɂȂĂBႪ19l肸E߂NɁAƍs̔ƂȂ鎝IȈӂ⑞AԂBɂׂ́AE҂̐łAꂪuPsvuvugvƂĂȂꂽ\łB
@ŠAɁuCvɋ߂̂́Aꌩ킩₷Aɂ邾낤BuNNȂÊv̗ÂȒT₱ȂȂ΂ȂȂBEłe܂uNNȂÊvAɂ͕sȁAՂȂ΁Alς̍󋵉łĂzłBǏ͂Ȃɂn҂̃êُ݂̈ł͂ȂB
@ČRꕔ2011NApLX^ŃAJC_w҃ET}ErfBÎEȂOiŁAǁiCIAj̃XpC|IEN̗\hڎ悻ărfBƑDNA̎悵ĂƂ͂悭mĂBNڎ킪|Ił̂߂ł͂ȂAÎÊ߂ɗpꂽ̂BʁApLX^Ń|I̗\hڎɂPӂ̈Ï]҂ւ̕sM̂AăQ̕WIƂȂĎE鎖ƂÂĂB|Ił͒xĂBłĐ{̓rfBEQւBuč̐vƂāB
@ƑPӂƑ "ٕ" 򉻁iNWOj̗~AIŕaIȈӏ炵AEōz񂵂ĂB726̂łƂ͂̂ȂłAʎ̃ełƂ킽͎vB̐N "pȂ^" wɊAڂ₩ĕԂ茌𗁂т̂ȂBꂪȁuPƔƁvłǂ́AɓIɂĂł͂ȂBΌTYsḿAOIɏႪҎ{݂KꂽƂɁAulĂ̂͐lîˁvƌĂ̂BVoOff "ُ" wl90ȏオIĂ\Ȃɂ𕨌̂B
@uɒl鑶݁vƁuɒlȂ݁v̓񕪖@IlԊς́A܂ꂽƂ̂ȂAĂ錴߂łB狁߂邱Ƃ̋Hȑ݂邱Ƃ́A}ނB炱Ä͑BN͂𗝉OɁAEĂ܂B͂̉eł͂ȂBiƁj
@

ւ݁E悤@44N{錧܂B96N܂ŋʐML҂ƂĖkAnmChȂǂCBuNuvŊH܁Au̐HlтƁvōukЃmtBNV܁AWuvŒ܁AůCvō܂܁BߊɁułPXRViCN~ijvB
@

m1n
2016N0902t(I)́uӌfuOvLɂΎ̒ʂB

_luNNȂEvʐMzM
͌̏ႪҎEɂĂ̕ӌfM̘_luNNȂÊvi㉺2jAʐMuʊevƂĉeɔzM܂B́uSƂ肩݁vÁuz񂷂鐢ÊȂŁṽ^CgĂ܂BV̍sŊe160sB
M҂́ÂłƂ錩n炫߂Đ[ɂƂ߂ĂȀIʐMҏWψoe̋LƂāA߂܂BAuILv⃊Iܗւ̑̌ɂAVfڗ͒ႢƂ݂܂܂Bł̂ŁAǂ̐VٍefڂAǂĖ{uOłm点܂̂ŁA낵炲ǂB
ႪҎEiӌfuO@2016N0902j

uVfڗ͒ႢƂ݂܂vƂĂ̋LfڂV͂قɂ낤ŁAV̋L̐؂蔲cC[gĂꂽ@rantyo3141ɊӂBieҁj@

֘AeN

VcÉ́uCv\ɂā@ӌf@CTCgł́uVc̐lv咣铊e΂@I͂ǂ炩 i_Ci@2016N89j
ǃiAzbjNIiLj\ ӌfuOiG̎ҁ@2016N811j
ǃiAzbjNIiL2j\ ӌfuOiG̎ҁ@2016N812j
ǃiAzbjNIiL3j\ ӌfuOiG̎ҁ@2016N813j

́uӌfuOvɁuЁXvƂČJꐔɂ킽ĒǋLꂽ͂AłɌuOł͍폜ĂBgӎGLIȁuЁXv͂͂̕ɍ폜Ă܂BȂ莄IȐi̋͂łƂƂOɂŁA܂ǂłȂΕēǂł݂邱Ƃ߂Bieҁj

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo211/msg/275.html

[eXg31] eXg

łĂ݂铊J[ʂ́̕\܂̓f[^̓

#### J[ʕ͂ւ̂Ȃ

I̓J[ʂx͎ŕ͂ł悤ɂȂ肽BJ[ʂ̃f[^ɂƂIʂ̘_]ɂāAɌ؂ʂ̊px番͂肵Ȃ邱ƂB邢́A܂傫ȘbɂȂȂIł́A_]̂ȂĎ͂ŕ͂ȂĂ͂ȂȂꍇ肤B낤Ƃ͂̕łĂAƂɐI|WV̈قȂl̔ᔻIȌ؂ʂāAȂɋqϐ߂ĂƂ҂łȂ낤B

#### smI̕sI^f

smIȂꂽBsmIɂ́AJ[f[^̒Pȕ͌ʂɂƂÂsI^fB́A2014NCYvOmII̊J[ʂɂđ苝^O\ƂŘbɂȂBeJ[ł̑CY̓[̑OIœI̓[̂ق48łꂢɂĂ邱Ƃ܂ɕsRƂwEB̓smIłl͌̕ʂ߂lBɂĂ̔f킽͂܂ۗĂB̂悤ȕ͂ȂƂɂ鐔lɂĂ̌omȂ̂ŁAuق48vƂ̂sRƂقǂ̂̂ǂȂ炾Bق̒mI␭ߎsIȂǂ𓯂悤ɕ͂ǂȂ̂낤Bŝ悤ȃp^[͂͂蒿̂Ȃ̂B܂̂悤Ȃ܂ɂ{IȌ؂ȂĂȂ̂ȂA邢͂ȂĂƂĂɏ\[łȂ΁AłĂ݂邵Ȃ B

@mI͎IȐMC[ɂȂĂ邱Ƃ̂ŁAsmI̔rΏۂɂȂI͌ꂻBłɓsƓ悤Ȑl̃p^[ƂĂAꂾł2014NsmÍusRvے肷鍪ɂȂȂB̗ގႪނVȋ^f̑ΏۂɂȂ肩˂ȂBƂ炷ƁA߂ڂIʂ͂ꂩƂɕ͂ĂƂĂȂB

#### {͋qϓIȃf[^

ɏЉsI̋^fA͂J[f[^͌̕ʂ̋ȉ߂ɂĐ̂Ƃ悤BƂĂAɑ̐lJ[f[^͂̕Ɋ֐S悤ȂƂΑ傫ȈӋ B
IǗψ̌JĂ铊J[ʂ̃f[^ǂ̂悤ɕ͂A߂炢̂Bǂ̂悤ȃOt}ɂ̂킩₷̂BsmIƂȂƑ̘_]LB̂Ȃɂ͎łĂ݂Ȃ悤ȃf[^͂BrI񂽂ɂłȂ̂ƂẮAƂΊJ[悲Ƃ̓[ZoĒn}ɗƂĂ݂ȂǁBLQlɁA݂悤݂܂˂őIʂ𕪐͂Ă݂B10ɂ́ȀZސVłmIȂBcTFm4I߂Ă邪AIȐMC[OOXƂ͈قȂA܂܂ł̎xՂɑ傫ȕϓĂ̂ŁA\f邳ȂBǂ̂悤ȌʂɂȂɂA͎łJ[ʂ𕪐͂Ă݂悤B

@莁Ȃǂ̕sI̖NŃf[^͂ɂƂɑ傫Ȋ֐S悤ɂȂƂĺAۂɂ͂قǑȂ̂ȂBsI̋^f̑Ώۂɂ͂ɂ܂܂Ȃ̂邩炾BA1𗧏؂邾łւȍƂƎvBf[^͂ɂsI^f̉𖾂ɂĂ΁AIʂ̂ӂ͂̕xKĂ璅肷̂Ȃł͂Ȃ낤B

#### J[ʂ̃f[^

āA悤₭炪{̂肾BЂƂɓJ[ʂŕ͂ƂĂAƂȂƕ~Ȃ荂͂B̍ŏ̍̓f[^̓ɂB

܂AJ[ʂ͊ễTCgɌ\Ă邪AǂɒuĂ̂킩ɂꍇBIǗψ̃z[y[WJĂIʂ̃NȂƂ͂߂炵ȂB47s{̋ߔN̒mǏʂɓIڂAIʂւ̃N̂y[W܂Ƃ߂Ă݂ [1]B

ɁAIʂ̃f[^̖肪Bf[^͂̕ɂ̓GNZȂǂ̕\vZ\tgiXvbhV[gjgp邪As{ɂẮA\vZ\tgŒڊJƂ̂łȂPDFt@CHTMLy[WɑIʂ\ĂB̃f[^\vZt@CɕϊA邢̓f[^XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@A񂽂ɏЉ [2]B

ŌɁA͂ɐ旧ăf[^̕ҏWKvɂȂ邱ƂBƂ΁A莁Љ̂A߂̑Iߋ̑IƔr悤ƂƂAs{ɂĂ͎s撬œJ[悪傫ωĂ܂Ă邽߂ɁAJ[悲Ƃ̔rłȂB͉ߋ̑Iɂ̂ڂēJ[𓝍邱ƂŁAꉞ̔rł悤ɂȂBȂ̎Ԃ邤ɁA~XȂǂ悭FbNȂƂȂBߋ4񕪂̐VmIɂĒ߂̑Iɂ킹ēJ[ҏŴATvƂĂĂ [3]B

łȂƂf[^łB

#### f[^̋L͍̉ۑ

ɂĂAf[^̓肩番͂܂ł̍ƂeꂼꂨȂƂ̂͂ɂB͂liʓ|炸ɁH oɂ݂ɁH p炸ɁHjf[^܂Ō\Kł炢̂ɂƎv B

@̂̃[UmGNZ̃t@C𒼐ڂƂ肷邱Ƃ́AZLeB̃XN̂ōD܂ȂBق̌̃t@C̔zzEFuy[Wւ̓\tƁAƂɃZ̐̎󂯓nłȂƂ_BŏɓJ[̕ҏWTvƂĂVmĨf[^ [3] ɂẮAGooglehCũXvbhV[gŌJƂĂ݂B_E[hȂĂemF邱ƂłA_E[h悤ƂGoogleɂEBXXL͂炭 B킽͂ӂGoogleXvbhV[g܂gĂȂAGNZƔrƂ̒낢Ƃ悤BfbgƂẮA[ȔW܂A̖cȃf[^ɂƂĒvIȂňpȂƂȂGooglẽT[rẌłƂƂA̍{IȖƂĂBmł̃f[^̋ĹA̎i炵ĂY܂B

[1] 47s{̑Iʃy[W

s{ߋ̑IʃNf[^
kCߋ̑ImHTMn
Xߋ̑Iʋyѓ[mPDFn
ǏʁE\mExceln
{錧mPDFn
Hcߋ̑ImExceln
ReImExceln
IʁEe펑mExceln
ߋ̑ImExceln
Ȗ،I̗\EmHTMLnmExceln
QnI̋L^i19Nȍ~̓J[ʁjmHTMLnmPDFn
ʌIf[^mExceln
tߋ̑I(E)mExceln
ssI/f[^mPDFnmExceln
_ސ쌧_ސ쌧IǗψmPDFn
VVIǗψ̃z[y[WmPDFn
xRImExceln
ΐ쌧ΐ쌧IǗψmPDFn
ImPDFn
RIʁf[^mPDFn
ߋ̑I Cy[WmPDFn
򕌌򕌌IǗψmExceln
ÉIǗψmHTMLnmPDFnmExceln
mI̋L^mPDFn
OdI̋L^mPDFnmExceln
ImPDFn
s{eǏmPDFn
{ߋ̑ImHTMn
ɌIf[^WmPDFn
ޗǌeǏʂɂmPDFn
a̎RIf[^mPDFn
ߋ̑ImPDFn
IǗψmHTMLn
RIǗψmPDFn
Lߋ̑ImPDFn
ReI̓J[mHTMn
ImExceln
쌧IǗψmPDFnmExceln
QI֘Af[^-ߋ̑ImPDFn
mIǗψmPDFn
IǗψmPDFn
I֌Wiߋ܂ށjmPDFn
[ʁEJ[mPDFn
F{ImPDFn

{茧If[^Cu[mExceln
ImPDFnmExceln
mE[mPDFnmExceln

[2] Iʃf[^̃GNZt@Cւ̕ϊE荞

#### PDFt@CGNZt@Cɕϊ@

\tgłŒ̗p͑BICT[rXĝyB킽Smallpdf悭gBA1Ԃ2܂ł̉񐔐B
\tgp\RɃCXg[邱ƂłBŋuPDFϊ9̑̌łgĂ݂BȂɖł鐫\Ǎł͎pԓi15ԁjgȂB܂A3y[W܂łϊłȂƂĂi4y[Wȍ~ɂĂ̓y[Ww肵ĕʌɕϊ΂̂AƂ1̃GNZt@Cɂ܂Ƃ߂ƂԂjB

@QlLF PDFt@CExcelɕϊ@it[\tgLjiExcel Hackj

#### HTMLy[W̕\(TABLEf[^)XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@

ׂ͒Ă݂ƂĂ񂽂񂾂B荞݂͈͂}EXőIăRs[AXvbhV[gɓ\t邾Bp\RɕۑHTMLy[W\vZ\tgJiC|[gjƂ@邪A܂ł̂Ƃ̓Rs[&y[XgŗpĂB

[3] J[f[^ҏWTvt@C

ȉ̕ҏWσf[^ьf[^́Ae҂GooglehCuɕۑꂽGNZixlsxjt@CłAGoogleXvbhV[gƂĊJB{ȊOɃ_E[hƃRg\B

#### ҏWσf[^

1224(20002012)N@VmI
@[ʁmҏWρnmExceln
@J[ʁmҏWρnmExceln

ҏWe
i1jy[WAB
i2j߂̕24NIɍ킹Âs撬̓J[ߋɂ̂ڂēB

#### f[^

24(2012)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
20(2008)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
16(2004)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
12(2000)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln

IWi̓J[PDFt@Cĩ\[XQƁjGNZixlsxjt@CɕϊA̍قƂƂ̂B

#### \[XFVIǗψɂ铊J[

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/546.html
[eXg31] eXg

łĂ݂铊J[ʂ́̕\܂̓f[^̓

#### J[ʕ͂ւ̂Ȃ

I̓J[ʂx͎ŕ͂ł悤ɂȂ肽BJ[ʂ̃f[^ɂƂIʂ̘_]ɂāAɌ؂ʂ̊px番͂肵Ȃ邱ƂB邢́A܂傫ȘbɂȂȂIł́A_]̂ȂĎ͂ŕ͂ȂĂ͂ȂȂꍇ肤B낤Ƃ͂̕łĂAƂɐI|WV̈قȂl̔ᔻIȌ؂ʂāAȂɋqϐ߂ĂƂ҂łȂ낤B

#### smI̕sI^f

smIȂꂽBsmIɂ́AJ[f[^̒Pȕ͌ʂɂƂÂsI^fB́A2014NCYvOmII̊J[ʂɂđ苝^O\ƂŘbɂȂBeJ[ł̑CY̓[̑OIœI̓[̂ق48łꂢɂĂ邱Ƃ܂ɕsRƂwEB̓smIłl͌̕ʂ߂lBɂĂ̔f킽͂܂ۗĂB̂悤ȕ͂ȂƂɂ鐔lɂĂ̌omȂ̂ŁAuق48vƂ̂sRƂقǂ̂̂ǂȂ炾Bق̒mI␭ߎsIȂǂ𓯂悤ɕ͂ǂȂ̂낤Bŝ悤ȃp^[͂͂蒿̂Ȃ̂B܂̂悤Ȃ܂ɂ{IȌ؂ȂĂȂ̂ȂA邢͂ȂĂƂĂɏ\[łȂ΁AłĂ݂邵Ȃ B

@mI͎IȐMC[ɂȂĂ邱Ƃ̂ŁAsmI̔rΏۂɂȂI͌ꂻBłɓsƓ悤Ȑl̃p^[ƂĂAꂾł2014NsmÍusRvے肷鍪ɂȂȂB̗ގႪނVȋ^f̑ΏۂɂȂ肩˂ȂBƂ炷ƁA߂ڂIʂ͂ꂩƂɕ͂ĂƂĂȂB

#### {͋qϓIȃf[^

ɏЉsI̋^fA͂J[f[^͌̕ʂ̋ȉ߂ɂĐ̂Ƃ悤BƂĂAɑ̐lJ[f[^͂̕Ɋ֐S悤ȂƂΑ傫ȈӋ B
IǗψ̌JĂ铊J[ʂ̃f[^ǂ̂悤ɕ͂A߂炢̂Bǂ̂悤ȃOt}ɂ̂킩₷̂BsmIƂȂƑ̘_]LB̂Ȃɂ͎łĂ݂Ȃ悤ȃf[^͂BrI񂽂ɂłȂ̂ƂẮAƂΊJ[悲Ƃ̓[ZoĒn}ɗƂĂ݂ȂǁBLQlɁA݂悤݂܂˂őIʂ𕪐͂Ă݂B10ɂ́ȀZސVłmIȂBcTFm4I߂Ă邪AIȐMC[OOXƂ͈قȂA܂܂ł̎xՂɑ傫ȕϓĂ̂ŁA\f邳ȂBǂ̂悤ȌʂɂȂɂA͎łJ[ʂ𕪐͂Ă݂悤B

@莁Ȃǂ̕sI̖NŃf[^͂ɂƂɑ傫Ȋ֐S悤ɂȂƂĺAۂɂ͂قǑȂ̂ȂBsI̋^f̑Ώۂɂ͂ɂ܂܂Ȃ̂邩炾BA1𗧏؂邾łւȍƂƎvBf[^͂ɂsI^f̉𖾂ɂĂ΁AIʂ̂ӂ͂̕xKĂ璅肷̂Ȃł͂Ȃ낤B

#### J[ʂ̃f[^

āA悤₭炪{̂肾BЂƂɓJ[ʂŕ͂ƂĂAƂȂƕ~Ȃ荂͂B̍ŏ̍̓f[^̓ɂB

܂AJ[ʂ͊ễTCgɌ\Ă邪AǂɒuĂ̂킩ɂꍇBIǗψ̃z[y[WJđIʂւ̃NȂ炢܂BƂ肠ߔN̒mǏʂɓIڂA47s{ɂđIʂւ̃N̂y[W܂Ƃ߂Ă݂ [1]B

ɁAIʂ̃f[^̖肪Bf[^͂̕ɂ̓GNZȂǂ̕\vZ\tgiXvbhV[gjgp邪As{ɂẮA\vZ\tgŒڊJƂ̂łȂPDFt@CHTMLy[WɑIʂ\ĂB̃f[^\vZt@CɕϊA邢̓f[^XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@A񂽂ɏЉ [2]B

ŌɁA͂ɐ旧ăf[^̕ҏWKvɂȂ邱ƂBƂ΁A莁Љ̂A߂̑Iߋ̑IƔr悤ƂƂAs{ɂĂ͎s撬œJ[悪傫ωĂ܂Ă邽߂ɁAJ[悲Ƃ̔rłȂB͉ߋ̑Iɂ̂ڂēJ[𓝍邱ƂŁAꉞ̔rł悤ɂȂBȂ̎Ԃ邤ɁA~XȂǂ悭FbNȂƂȂBߋ4񕪂̐VmIɂĒ߂̑Iɂ킹ēJ[ҏŴATvƂĂĂ [3]B

łȂƂf[^łB

#### f[^̋L͍̉ۑ

ɂĂAf[^̓肩番͂܂ł̍ƂeꂼꂨȂƂ̂͂ɂB͂liʓ|炸ɁH oɂ݂ɁH p炸ɁHjf[^܂Ō\Kł炢̂ɂƎv B

@̂̃[UmGNZ̃t@C𒼐ڂƂ肷邱Ƃ́AZLeB̃XN̂ōD܂ȂBق̌̃t@C̔zzEFuy[Wւ̓\tƁAƂɃZ̐̎󂯓nłȂƂ_BŏɓJ[̕ҏWTvƂĂVmĨf[^ [3] ɂẮAGooglehCũXvbhV[gŌJƂĂ݂B_E[hȂĂemF邱ƂłA_E[h悤ƂGoogleɂEBXXL͂炭 B킽͂ӂGoogleXvbhV[g܂gĂȂAGNZƔrƂ̒낢Ƃ悤BfbgƂẮA[ȔW܂A̖cȃf[^ɂƂĒvIȂňpȂƂȂGooglẽT[rẌłƂƂA̍{IȖƂĂBpʂł́AGNZƂ̌݊ɂǂĂEBmł̃f[^̋ĹA̎i炵ĂY܂B

[1] 47s{̑Iʃy[W

 s{ ߋ̑IʃN@ f[^@ kC ߋ̑I mHTMn X ߋ̑Iʋyѓ[EXmI̋L^ mPDFn 茧 ǏʁE\ mExceln {錧 Ǐ mPDFn Hc ߋ̑I mExceln R eImsȂ̂n mExceln IʁEe펑 mExceln 錧 ߋ̑I mExceln Ȗ، I̗\E mHTMLnmExceln Qn I̋L^ mHTMLnmPDFn ʌ If[^ mExceln t ߋ̑I(E) mExceln s sI/f[^ mPDFnmExceln _ސ쌧 _ސ쌧IǗψ mPDFn V VIǗψ̃z[y[W mPDFn xR I mExceln ΐ쌧 ΐ쌧IǗψ mPDFn 䌧 I mPDFn R Iʁf[^ mPDFn 쌧 ߋ̑I Cy[W mPDFn 򕌌 򕌌IǗψ mExceln É IǗψ mHTMLnmPDFnmExceln m I̋L^ mPDFn Od I̋L^ mPDFnmExceln ꌧ I mPDFn s{ eǏ mPDFn { ߋ̑I mHTMn Ɍ If[^W mPDFn ޗǌ eǏʂɂ mPDFn a̎R If[^ mPDFn 挧 ߋ̑I mPDFn IǗψmڍׂȌʂsn mHTMLn R IǗψ mPDFn/ [HTML][Excel] L ߋ̑I mPDFn R eI̓J[ mHTMn I mExceln 쌧 쌧IǗψ mPDFnmExceln Q I֘Af[^-ߋ̑I mPDFn m IǗψ mPDFn IǗψ mPDFn ꌧ I֌Wiߋ܂ށj mPDFn 茧 [ʁEJ[ mPDFn F{ I mPDFn 啪 啪̑I mPDFn {茧 If[^Cu[ mExceln I mPDFnmExceln ꌧ mE[ mPDFnmExcelnmGIFn

[2] Iʃf[^̃GNZt@Cւ̕ϊE荞

#### PDFt@CGNZt@Cɕϊ@

\tgłŒ̗p͑BICT[rXĝyB킽Smallpdf悭gBA1Ԃ2܂ł̉񐔐B
\tgp\RɃCXg[邱ƂłBŋuPDFϊ9̑̌łgĂ݂BȂɖł鐫\Ǎł͎pԓi15ԁjgȂB܂A3y[W܂łϊłȂƂĂi4y[Wȍ~ɂĂ̓y[Ww肵ĕʌɕϊ΂̂AƂ1̃GNZt@Cɂ܂Ƃ߂ƂԂjB

@QlLF PDFt@CExcelɕϊ@it[\tgLjiExcel Hackj

#### HTMLy[W̕\(TABLEf[^)XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@

ׂ͒Ă݂ƂĂ񂽂񂾂B荞݂͈͂}EXőIăRs[AXvbhV[gɓ\t邾Bp\RɕۑHTMLy[W\vZ\tgJiC|[gjƂ@邪A܂ł̂Ƃ̓Rs[&y[XgŗpĂB

[3] J[f[^ҏWTvt@C

ȉ̕ҏWσf[^ьf[^́Ae҂GooglehCuɕۑꂽGNZixlsxjt@CłAGoogleXvbhV[gƂĊJB{ȊOɃ_E[hƃRg\B

#### ҏWσf[^

1224(20002012)N@VmI
@[ʁmҏWρnmExceln
@J[ʁmҏWρnmExceln

ҏWe
i1jy[WAB
i2j߂̕24NIɍ킹Âs撬̓J[ߋɂ̂ڂēB

#### f[^

24(2012)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
20(2008)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
16(2004)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
12(2000)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln

IWi̓J[PDFt@Cĩ\[XQƁjGNZixlsxjt@CɕϊA̍قƂƂ̂B

#### \[XFVIǗψɂ铊J[

http://www.asyura2.com/14/test31/msg/547.html
[EIEmgj211] łĂ݂铊J[ʂ́̕\܂̓f[^̓

#### J[ʕ͂ւ̂Ȃ

I̓J[ʂx͎ŕ͂ł悤ɂȂ肽BJ[ʂ̃f[^ɂƂIʂ̘_]ɂāAɌ؂ʂ̊px番͂肵Ȃ邱ƂB邢́A܂傫ȘbɂȂȂIł́A_]̂ȂĎ͂ŕ͂ȂĂ͂ȂȂꍇ肤B낤Ƃ͂̕łĂAƂɐI|WV̈قȂl̔ᔻIȌ؂ʂāAȂɋqϐ߂ĂƂ҂łȂ낤B

#### smI̕sI^f

smIȂꂽBsmIɂ́AJ[f[^̒Pȕ͌ʂɂƂÂsI^fB́A2014NCYvOmII̊J[ʂɂđ苝^O\ƂŘbɂȂBeJ[ł̑CY̓[̑OIœI̓[̂ق48łꂢɂĂ邱Ƃ܂ɕsRƂwEB̓smIłl͌̕ʂ߂lBɂĂ̔f킽͂܂ۗĂB̂悤ȕ͂ȂƂɂ鐔lɂĂ̌omȂ̂ŁAuق48vƂ̂sRƂقǂ̂̂ǂȂ炾Bق̒mI␭ߎsIȂǂ𓯂悤ɕ͂ǂȂ̂낤Bŝ悤ȃp^[͂͂蒿̂Ȃ̂B܂̂悤Ȃ܂ɂ{IȌ؂ȂĂȂƂA邢͂łɂȂĂĂ\ɔ[łȂ΁AłĂ݂邵Ȃ B

@mI͎IȐMC[ɂȂĂ邱Ƃ̂ŁAsmI̔rΏۂɂȂI͌ꂻBłɓsƓ悤Ȑl̃p^[ƂĂAꂾł2014NsmÍusRvے肷鍪ɂȂȂB̗ގႪނVȋ^f̑ΏۂɂȂ肩˂ȂBƂ炷ƁA߂ڂIʂ͂ꂩƂɕ͂ĂƂĂȂB

#### {͋qϓIȃf[^

ɏЉsI̋^fA͂J[f[^͌̕ʂ̋ȉ߂ɂĐ̂Ƃ悤BƂĂAɑ̐lJ[f[^͂̕Ɋ֐S悤ȂƂΑ傫ȈӋ B
IǗψ̌JĂ铊J[ʂ̃f[^ǂ̂悤ɕ͂A߂炢̂Bǂ̂悤ȃOt}ɂ̂킩₷̂BsmIƂȂƑ̘_]LB̂Ȃɂ͎łĂ݂Ȃ悤ȃf[^͂BrI񂽂ɂłȂ̂ƂẮAƂΊJ[悲Ƃ̓[ZoĒn}ɗƂĂ݂ȂǁBLQlɁA݂悤݂܂˂őIʂ𕪐͂Ă݂B10ɂ́ȀZސVłmIȂBcTFm4I߂Ă邪AIȐMC[OOXƂ͈قȂA܂܂ł̎xՂɑ傫ȕϓĂ̂ŁA\f邳ȂBǂ̂悤ȌʂɂȂɂA͎łJ[ʂ𕪐͂Ă݂悤B

@莁Ȃǂ̕sI̖NŃf[^͂ɂƂɑ傫Ȋ֐S悤ɂȂƂĺAۂɂ͂قǑȂ̂ȂBsI̋^f̑Ώۂɂ͂ɂ܂܂Ȃ̂邩炾BA1𗧏؂邾łւȍƂƎvBf[^͂ɂsI^f̉𖾂ɂĂ΁AIʂ̂ӂ͂̕xKĂ璅肷̂Ȃł͂Ȃ낤B

#### J[ʂ̃f[^

āA悤₭炪{̂肾BЂƂɓJ[ʂŕ͂ƂĂAƂȂƕ~Ȃ荂͂B̍ŏ̍̓f[^̓ɂB

܂AJ[ʂ͊ễTCgɌ\Ă邪AǂɒuĂ̂킩ɂꍇBIǗψ̃z[y[WJđIʂւ̃NȂ炢܂BƂ肠47s{̋ߔN̒mǏʂɓIڂAIʂւ̃N̂y[W܂Ƃ߂Ă݂ [1]B

ɁAIʂ̃f[^̖肪Bf[^͂̕ɂ̓GNZȂǂ̕\vZ\tgiXvbhV[gjgp邪As{ɂẮA\vZ\tgŒڊJƂ̂łȂPDFt@CHTMLy[WɑIʂ\ĂB̃f[^\vZt@CɕϊA邢̓f[^XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@A񂽂ɏЉ [2]B

ŌɁA͂ɐ旧ăf[^̕ҏWKvɂȂ邱ƂBƂ΁A莁Љ̂A߂̑Iߋ̑IƔr悤ƂƂAs{ɂĂ͎s撬œJ[悪傫ωĂ܂Ă邽߂ɁAJ[悲Ƃ̔rłȂB͉ߋ̑Iɂ̂ڂēJ[𓝍邱ƂŁAꉞ̔rł悤ɂȂBȂ̎Ԃ邤ɁA~XȂǂ悭FbNȂƂȂBߋ4񕪂̐VmIɂĒ߂̑Iɂ킹ēJ[ҏŴATvƂĂĂ [3]B

łȂƂf[^łB

#### ̓f[^̋L͍̉ۑ

ɂĂAf[^̓肩番͂܂ł̍ƂeꂼɂȂƂ̂́AɂB͂liʓ|炸ɁH oɂ݂ɁH p炸ɁHjf[^܂Ō\Kł炢̂ɂƎv B

@̂̃[UmGNZ̃t@C𒼐ڂƂ肷邱Ƃ́AZLeB̃XN̂ōD܂ȂBق̌̃t@C̔zzEFuy[Wւ̓\tƁAƂɃZ̐̎󂯓nłȂƂ_BŏɓJ[̕ҏWTvƂĂVmĨf[^ [3] ɂẮAGooglehCũXvbhV[gŌJƂĂ݂B_E[hȂĂemF邱ƂłA_E[h悤ƂGoogleɂEBXXL͂炭 B킽͂ӂGoogleXvbhV[g܂gĂȂAGNZƔrƂ̒낢Ƃ悤BfbgƂẮA[ȔW܂A̖cȃf[^ɂƂĒvIȂňpȂƂȂGooglẽT[rẌłƂƂA̍{IȖƂĂBpʂł́AGNZƂ̌݊ɂǂĂEBmł̃f[^̋ĹA̎i炵ĂY܂B

[1] 47s{̑Iʃy[W

 s{ ߋ̑IʃN@ f[^@ kC ߋ̑I mHTMn X ߋ̑Iʋyѓ[EXmI̋L^ mPDFn 茧 ǏʁE\ mExceln {錧 Ǐ mPDFn Hc ߋ̑I mExceln R eImsȂ̂n mExceln IʁEe펑 mExceln 錧 ߋ̑I mExceln Ȗ، I̗\E mHTMLnmExceln Qn I̋L^ mHTMLnmPDFn ʌ If[^ mExceln t ߋ̑I(E) mExceln s sI/f[^ mPDFnmExceln _ސ쌧 _ސ쌧IǗψ mPDFn V VIǗψ̃z[y[W mPDFn xR I mExceln ΐ쌧 ΐ쌧IǗψ mPDFn 䌧 I mPDFn R Iʁf[^ mPDFn 쌧 ߋ̑I Cy[W mPDFn 򕌌 򕌌IǗψ mExceln É IǗψ mHTMLnmPDFnmExceln m I̋L^ mPDFn Od I̋L^ mPDFnmExceln ꌧ I mPDFn s{ eǏ mPDFn { ߋ̑I mHTMn Ɍ If[^W mPDFn ޗǌ eǏʂɂ mPDFn a̎R If[^ mPDFn 挧 ߋ̑I mPDFn IǗψmڍׂȌʂsn mHTMLn R IǗψ mPDFn/ [HTML][Excel] L ߋ̑I mPDFn R eI̓J[ mHTMn I mExceln 쌧 쌧IǗψ mPDFnmExceln Q I֘Af[^-ߋ̑I mPDFn m IǗψ mPDFn IǗψ mPDFn ꌧ I֌Wiߋ܂ށj mPDFn 茧 [ʁEJ[ mPDFn F{ I mPDFn 啪 啪̑I mPDFn {茧 If[^Cu[ mExceln I mPDFnmExceln ꌧ mE[ mPDFnmExcelnmGIFn

[2] Iʃf[^̃GNZt@Cւ̕ϊE荞

#### PDFt@CGNZt@Cɕϊ@

\tgłŒ̗p͑BICT[rXĝyB킽Smallpdf悭gBA1Ԃ2܂ł̉񐔐B
\tgp\RɃCXg[邱ƂłBŋuPDFϊ9̑̌łgĂ݂BȂɖł鐫\Ǎł͎pԓi15ԁjgȂB܂A3y[W܂łϊłȂƂĂi4y[Wȍ~ɂĂ̓y[Ww肵ĕʌɕϊ΂̂AƂ1̃GNZt@Cɂ܂Ƃ߂ƂԂjB

@QlLF PDFt@CExcelɕϊ@it[\tgLjiExcel Hackj

#### HTMLy[W̕\(TABLEf[^)XvbhV[gɎ荞ޕ@

ׂ͒Ă݂ƂĂ񂽂񂾂B荞݂͈͂}EXőIăRs[AXvbhV[gɓ\t邾Bp\RɕۑHTMLy[W\vZ\tgJiC|[gjƂ@邪A܂ł̂Ƃ̓Rs[&y[XgŗpĂB

[3] J[f[^ҏWTvt@C

ȉ̕ҏWσf[^ьf[^́Ae҂GooglehCuɕۑꂽGNZixlsxjt@CłAGoogleXvbhV[gƂĊJB{ȊOɃ_E[hƃRg\B

#### ҏWσf[^

1224(20002012)N@VmI
@[ʁmҏWρnmExceln
@J[ʁmҏWρnmExceln

ҏWe
i1jy[WAB
i2j߂̕24NIɍ킹Âs撬̓J[ߋɂ̂ڂēB

#### f[^

24(2012)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
20(2008)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
16(2004)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln
12(2000)N@VmI
@[ʁmnmExceln
@J[ʁmnmExceln

IWi̓J[PDFt@Cĩ\[XQƁjGNZixlsxjt@CɕϊA̍قƂƂ̂B

#### \[XFVIǗψɂ铊J[

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo211/msg/531.html
[n13] i}ET|[^[@Aő7000liVj
i}ET|[^[@Aő7000l
V@2016N820
@
@
@i}A2016Nxi66_j̓}ET|[^[o^}̑ONx362lAߋő7353lƂȂB7̎Q@IɌĊexx҂ւ̌Ăъ|߂ƂƂ݂A7l𒴂̂͏߂āBASWv͖ڕW30l傫242907lɂƂǂ܂AŐAېV}̍v3l߂炵B}̐LєY݂͑ĂA}ET|[^[Q9̓}\Ił́A}xgɌg݂_ɂȂ肻B

Q@IŌĂъ|^SAO3l

@15Nx̖}A̓}ET|[^[6991lAېV̓}̓}40lقǁBPv̖7030lƖi}}16NxƂ̔rł͖320lƂȂBɋېV̋c͂炸A͂قڋ}̋c̊ɂ̂Ƃ݂B
@A֌W҂ɂƁA7ɎQ@IقA Hɑ\ITĂƂ獑cnc}ET|[^[̊lɊɓB܂A14N12̏O@Iŋ}c2l4lɔ{A1NԃtɊď߂Ă̏WvƂȂƂvɂ悤B
@A̎}24l̂ɔׂ31ɂȂBi}Ȃ基́uXĂ͍̂cncꐶʁBA肵ՂƂȂĂƂ͂܂ȂB}ɑ΍R邽߂ɂ͂Ƒ₳Ȃ΂ȂȂvƘbB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@SWvƁA}̒Pv傫炵Bi}}O̖}̓}ET|[^[͖233lAېV̓}̈ʓ}͖36lBPvŖ27lɒB͂Aۂ͖243lB炵vɂĖi}́u}1ɑ΂󂯈M̌WƂҊłoĂȂvƏȂ݂B
@鋌}T|[^[́uȂOɓo^AĐőĂBi}łĔɂȂA߂ēo^̈ӎvmFꂽ̂ŁA@ɂ߂vƑłBېV֌W҂́uېV}͑命ێB}Ƃ̍ɋ^ԂA}ɂȂȂlvƌB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@\Iɗ\@u\s͐_ŐlCu}ET|[^[[ň|vƂ̌BɑOiOⒷvhqb炪onӗ~ĂBIƂȂ΁A}g􂪖邱ƂɂȂB
@基ÁuȐ_cWJA}ɑʂȐlނ邱Ƃ߂ɂI킪]܂vƎ咣BuĂѐ_悤ȑԐ𐮂A}T|[^[ƂĎxȂ悤ȓ}ɂȂ΂ȂȂB\ȊɂȂƂȂvƋĂB

e҂ɂ֘AL

i}VAz[y[W
http://dp-niigata.jp/
http://archive.is/dPcxii2016N821݂̃LbVj

}ET|[^[o^lŁAߋō7,000l
http://dp-niigata.jp/activity20150701/
i}VxAii} VAj@2015N71

[n13] c^X^e}c_MiVj
c^X^e}c_M
Vm3ʁn@2016N827

@cɖL[^EЁE@uv\zڎw

929A1016J[̒mÍA4IڎwcTFmi53j2ɗ\Ĉȍ~Aǂ̐}Ή߂Ȃ󋵂ĂA s̐Xvsi67j10ɏon\ACɗBɂċc_MттĂB}͌c}ẍӌn߁A26ɂ͉JđΉcBƎ〈Œ鋤Y}͎Ж}A̓}ƘAgAuv\zlB3}Hg𑗂ꂽi}͐Tdȍ\݂B

i͘AgɐTd

@č㉇͑O񐄑E𓾂AiAAЖA5}ɍEvBX͂5}ɉAY}ɂE˗ĂB
@}A26AcŊgJÂBmIւ̑Ή߂Ęb22̉ɑ̂ŁAoȂc͐cAXꂼ𐄂ӌoB
@cőh̎}́AIc𐄑EA^cł돂ƂȂĂB́AcƎs̊֌ẄAuI̕QvO鐺A}͑傫B
@J̉AA̕򐳎O͕񓹐wɁu܂܂ӌ̏Wɂ͎ȂBȂǂKXJATdɐi߂vƏqׂɂƂǂ߂BA͎ẍӌ95܂ŁAcɂ閳L[2܂ōsAΉ̔fޗƂB㔼قǂ}ƂȂB
@}Ɠߋ3̒mIŐc𐄑E}Ή͖肾Bu3͈؂vƋ錧{̎ucMj\́u9Őc12N؁AfĂvƌB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@ߋ30N̒mIœƎ̌FAE𗧂ĂĂY}́A͗iɌXĂBЖA}ƘAgA7̎Q@IVIɑĒmIłuv_߂B
@Y}ψ̔nmvψ́u܂ȂvƁuvBAĉғɔ΂AcxɑOȎЖ}ȀRF\́ugDƂĂ͌܂ĂȂARicxɁjȂƎvvƊҊɂ܂B
@Q@Ił̘͋gg݂ɖi}Ai}̎xĉ̘AVĂB̓}A̍XؖΊ́ui}Ȃǂ̍ldđΉ߂vƏqׁA݂낦ƂB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@i}}ƓlA }ŐcAX̂ǂ𐄂ĂBi}Ȃ基́uQ@IƌƂ͐؂蕪ȂƂȂB肫ł͂ȂA܂œ}̔fƂČvƋB
@AV24ɎsψŐXӌ𕷂BJg̈ӌ9߂܂łɂ܂Ƃ߁AΉ߂jB
@̓AɋY}̔f͑Iɉe^\B
@Xx鎩}̃xećuY}Ƃ͈ꏏɂȂBЋŐc𐄂΂vƌB3}cɂ΁A}͐cłȂƌĂB
@i}A͋̂^⎋Buœ_ɂ̂낤Ał͑ɂ̉ۑ肪vƎwEB

t̐V ֘ALie҂ɂЉj

4c XEm1ʁn
v|F tAȈtA܎tAŌ싦ꂼ̐ĉX𐄑Ejł߂B̔wiƂẮAƂΈÁE̖@4v肵ĂȂ ɂĂ̐cւ̕sMB

V̕Sv斢@čρuȂviYoj[X@2016N41j
http://www.sankei.com/region/news/160401/rgn1604010012-n1.html

28N331 cmՎL҉v|iVmz[y[W@2016N41j
http://chiji.pref.niigata.jp/2016/04/post-0fd6.html

[n13] ̊ Ȃ^}3}ATpiVj
̊ Ȃ^}3}ATp
Vm1ʁn@2016N918

@mIł̖}̉\TA܂Ɋ􂾂B17ɓWJꂽYAЖA3}ƎsO[vɂ閯i}O@5摍xEĎRꎁi49j̗iB}ƌ}ɎxOsEXvi67jɑ΍RׂAu哊[v߂悤Ƃ閯i}A]̉OɎĂ͂AȂ}ɔے肳ꂽB7̎Q@IVIɑL͂ȋ\z͕Aœ_3}̒₪o邩ɍiꂽB
@i}ȀCn܂ߑO11OAsO[vĂъ|l̍X؊Vۏw͉̃zeɎ]ԂŏtB
@QAS҂Ɏn̂́uĎRꎁsLǔ҂ƂėiA̖}3}ƈꏏɐĂ܂肽vƂċ͂߂vB O[3}ӂA܂Ƃ߂̂B
@x悤ƂĂcTFm8304Ion߂\Ĉȍ~A}3}͎sO[vƂƂɑ΍Rn̗i͍ĂB
@Ai}ƂCʂȂi߂ҒT͓qBi}A13AƎ̗ifOƂƂɁAX𐄑EȂƂ߂B
@̎Ԃ󂯎sO[v3}AɌŌ̐؂DƂĖڂt̂i}̕ĎRBEcł͂ȂAېV̓}̈ڍsgœ}hFrIB}_ƂĎRAĉғɐTdpƂB
@Ai}ɂƂĂ͎󂯓bł͂ȂBĎR̖O͓}ňꎞサ̂́A}Ƃ̋c̒ŒfOo܂Bxĉ̘AV͐Xx߁AΉ󋵂ƂȂĂBuȏc_΂Ό̐MvƂ̔fBAƂėv͎󗝂ȂB
@̌i3}̎Ɉς˂邱ƂɂȂB{̒mIŉߋɖ[ɂȂ͂ȂB
@Ж}ȀRF\́uƂĂIȂ΂ȂvƂA̓}A\̐XTqQ@cuӔCʂvƁAT𑱂lBN𗧂ĂĂY}ψ̔nmvψuڎwOA܂łĂo傾vƗ͂߂BcꂽԂ͏ȂA@ƏőYĂB

t̐V ֘ALie҂ɂЉj

i哊[^ĎRi 󂯓ꂸm1ʁn
ĎŔu}ƂđΗA݂Ȃł܂Ƃ܂ȂΏĂȂB}𖳎Člłl͂ȂvƏqׂB̑A̃EFuŋLƂقړeB

VmIA}3}̗iœ_^ĎR〈i2016/09/18 09:30j
http://www.niigata-nippo.co.jp/news/politics/20160918280368.html

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/751.html

[n13] }"" ̗ٗi^ĎRA3}̎xŏon\iVj
}"" ̗ٗi^ĎRA3}̎xŏon\
Vm3ʁn@2016N924

]v^Pނ̖iAɔ

@u̖łv
@23̋L҉ŗfꂽĎRꎁ͋ΌɘbB
@22AĎR̎pJRVwŐY}ψ3KɂBȂ̂͐̓}A\̐XTqQ@c͂߁A鋤YAЖ}gD̑\ƁAusAVv̋\𖱂߂sc̃o[Bߌ10߂܂ŋy񂾂̉ŁAĎR͎Q҂ɏon̈ӎvƂB IA邢\Ő}֌W҂炪oĂ钆1lAĎR͌AuȂvƌJԂBf̏dwĂ悤ȋْY킹ĂB

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@}3}ŕĎR̗i}̂́A13ɖi}ƎfOゾBŐfɌŎȂǌҒTq钆A˂Ĉӗ~ĂĎR𓝈Ƃ邱ƂōӁB17ɖi}Aɋ͂߂voB
@Ai}͎󂯕tɎ哊[肵BĎR̖O͑iK3}ɑŐfĂAƌ3}ۂo܂炾BĎŔugĎɂ͏]vƖA\͂ڂ񂾂ɌB
@ĎŔAuiviĂĂ̎_]Bł́uԈĂvƖAu؂Ȃčĉғ̋c_͂łȂvƐcTFmƓ咣B

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

@3}ƕĎRLĂ̂́Ai}̉_̕KvBf_́u哊[͑d邪AĎRo邱Ƃ͔F߂Ăقv\Ƃ́BXTq͉ȂǂŁuƎiɓw͂ĂƂɂ͌hӂ\vƌJԂAi}ւ̔zB֌W҂ɂƁAĎRu󋵂ςȂΏoȂvƌJԂAېV̓}ォ̐lē}{ɂAv[ĂƂB
@AO@ǏƂȂ鑍x}̎xŏoƂɁAA̔͋B1ĺul̓}̐lԂɎ˂ŁAȂɂ܂̂Ȃ񂾁vƐrmρnAÎQ}́uxƂĂ̐ӔCĂȂvƕɂBxĉ̘AVɐXv̎x߂Ă邱ƂwiɂAAɕĎRx鐺͏ȂB
@ĎR͉Oɂ͌A̍Fm\ƖʉA}͂oB⎁͖ʉAuǍꗂƓAӎvB5Ă킯ŁA̓̂ĂقvƔꂽ\ŌB
@Ƃ͂Ai}XɒmIuPށvA}1}łȂL҂ɑIȂ͎̂B23ɓ}{ł@u\̋L҉ł́AL҂猧ȂΉᔻ鎿ԂB@u\́uA̎葱r͂ȂAAǂ̂悤ȍlĂ邩̓qAOvƘbB

t̐V ֘ALie҂ɂЉj

A̍Lx^} ĉғōm3ʁn
wc̏󋵂ƍŐV̓A֌W҂̃RgЉLBȉB

}̉ۑ͎Ԃ̂ȂB̓}A\̐XTqQ@c͉Łuׂ͂ꂩ狦cŔ\BvƘbB|X^[쐬AI̊mۂƂ29̍ɂ݁A}sbŐi߂ĂBsXvKŒǂB

I̊}B芠H̍ĉғ͂߂Ƃ鑽̌ۑɂĂ̘_̊ҁB͂ȑΉŃ[_[VbvłȂi}ւ̔ᔻB
АȂ̂ŐVEFuTCgɌfڂ͂A_ł͂܂oĂȂB
VАy[W

ĎRAmIon\^ĉғucHpvm1ʁn
L̎v͐VEFuTCgœǂ߂Bʂł͂ɉĂB
ĎRmI𐳎\^cHpi2016/09/23 22:27j

_ ܂m31ʁn
̐ނďЉĂB

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/753.html

[EIEmgj213] mI݂Ɩւ̐ӔCiĎR10N̂߂Ɂj
mI@݂Ɩւ̐ӔC
http://www.election.ne.jp/10840/99166.html
ĎR10N̂߂Ɂ@2016N923 23:28:09
@
@
@{Ai}𗣓}āAVmIւ̗\܂B

@i}̗}͎ƂĂ͐ScOłAނ𓾂Ȃ̂Ǝv܂B

@̗R͏΂ł̂łAꌾŌȂAu݂Ɩɑ΂AӔCʂׂBvƎvłB

@̑Ȋ傫ȑ_芠H̍ĉғł邱Ƃ́A_҂܂BɊeŎwEĂʂA͂ČihłBÁAueF̂ł͂ȂASŁASȌq͋Zp̊JŖׂBvƌ̂łB
@Aꌴ̂ƁǍTNołAS̖̎ړrȂāA͈ӌς܂BX́Aq͔dƂZpɔ댯̑SSĂȂ̂łB́Aꌴ̂̌Ƃ̔vZX̓OIȋÂ̌Nւ̉e̓OIȋAĖꎖ̂Nꍇ̈Smہij̎i̓OIȋ̂R̋ȂȂAĉғ̋c_͎n߂ȂƂcm̘H́A݂ƁAĖ́A̖ƌNɐӔC̂ƂēRƎv܂B

@͒mIÃCV[őׂƂ͑Sv܂B͖ܘ_ƂĂdvȖłA{Iɂ̓XNǗ̖łāẢl𐶂ݏoA񋟂̂ł͂ȂłB

@ł͉𐶂ݏoƖꂽ玄́A܂ɁAqāAÁÅ𐮔āÅFɁAVŁASSāAqY݁AāAÂ󂯁Aĉ󂯂肽ƓƎv܂BA{̈ÁÁA}ȍɂāAɌĕ̊@ɕmĂ܂BÁA̐x͍̂łA̎s@ւ͌łB̐x͈͓̔łĂÁÁAŌʓIȎsA\Z̏d_zAđnӍHvɂāA̐VŁASňSȕ̊邱Ƃ͉\Ǝv܂Ałɋ߂Â߂̓w͂邱ƂA݂Ɩɑ΂鐭̐ӔCłƎv܂B

@YƐ́AɌč̐xɈˋƂ낪傫̂łAႦΔ_ƌł킪ɂƂĔɑ傫ȖłsooɂẮA{܂Ƃ߂ɂĉ䂪ƂĂ̖_͂ƎwEA˕ʏ⏞x́AmŎ̂΍ɋ߂Ǝv܂B
@čɉ䂪̗v]ImɓƓɁAႦΐV̐VV̐ŐV̗֐コƓɁA_ƁAHƁAƂɂēw͂Ƃ~ɃrWlXi߂𐮂āAٗp̑}肽Ǝv܂B

@ĉA𐶂Xʂׂő̖ւ̐ӔĆAɂɂAłBAZ̎s@ւł錧́ANA̔\͂ɉāA̍󂯂邱ƂłAő̓wׂ͂Ǝv܂A̓w͂ɂāÁAq̖AČ̖AۂɌコ邱ƂłƁAMĂ܂BbƂȂĂ鍑̏w̕s\ȓ_ɂẮÃxŁA₤wĂƂKvł傤B

@ȏ͊TIɋ̂ɂ܂񂪁ÁÂ킪̗lXȐۑAɁAʓIɁAnӍHvĎs邱ƂŁAB́A݂ƁAĖւ̐ӔCʂĂƎvĂ܂B
@Ăׂ̈ɁAS͂őI킢ƁAv܂B

@猧ɃtB[hς܂ANAssȎv邱ƂȂA肠lłЉ肽Ƃ̎úAςĂ܂Bςʂx𒸂܂悤AS炨肢\グ܂B

e҂̃RgF

e҂͕ĎRxB

ɂāA830ɐcTFmP񂵂Ă炷񂾂̐VmIł́A芠H̍ĉғƂ뜜u瑤v̐wcĂƂCȂBĎŔAi}VT摍x̒nʂȂĂ̗BmˑR䩑RƂĂɂƂĖ{ɂ肪̂肬̔f́Ał͖ӔCǂꂾᔻꂽƂĂ̂Ȃ̂łB͗]vȂb낤AI獡̐ǂȂ̂Be҂͕̔ĎRɕĂB

ĎR̐ɂĂscBTPP̂ƂBĎRTPPRfՂ߂ƂĂƂ炦ĂȂ߂B1񒲂ׂĂ݂ĂقBƂΌocAیoϖ{VjAEAhoCU[̋KƂlɂ鎟̋LȂǂ́Ȁ݂ɋCÂ߂̂ƂƂĂ͂悳B

ȂčɂƂĂTPPƓ{ɂƂĂTPP͂ȂɈႤ̂FOrTPP܂ł̓
iK@Eoϕ]_IMPACT@2016N523j
mnN[O}ɂ΁Cčł̓xȌoϊw҂TPPɔMSɎ^Ăl͒NȂ炵B{̂܂ƂȌoϊw҂ŃO[oȎ_TPP΂̘_w𒣂Ăw҂ǕɂĒmȂB

TPPxȂő̗R̋́Aۂɂ͖fՂɊւ̂ł͂Ȃ
i|[EN[O}@rWlX 2015N530 archive.is LbVj
mnTPPɂāAłɒႢ֐łɒႭȂ邩ȂBĂĂ鋦̎́Ai̓f̒쌠Ȃǂ̒mIY邱ƁAĊƂ⍑Ɋւ镴@ς邱ƂɂB

ŌɁA芠HTPP̖ł́AʂĐV̌oϔW̕ĂBtĂn̂悤Ȍoϐɂ͊҂ĂȂBĎRɂ́AeneEew̐l͂𔭊łyƂȂ悤Ȋ{Iȕ񎦂ĂقB

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo213/msg/377.html

[n13] AV@⎁̉oȔF߂^mIΉ莋iVj
AV@⎁̉oȔF߂^mIΉ莋
http://www.niigata-nippo.co.jp/news/politics/20160929282322.html
V񃂃A@2016/09/29 11:03

@AV͂QWAi}A̍Fm\AV̉ɓʁAoȂȂƂ߂B\ÂAsւ̘AV̏oȂBmIŌAu哊[v߂ɂ炸Ai}O@VT摍xĎRꎁ̖}R}ɗiďon鎖Ԃ莋Bő̎xĉ}Aɑ΂Ĉٗ̌[uōRcŁAe͔B

@mIŖi}A͓ƎifOĎ哊[ƂAAV͐Xv́uxv߂ĂAΉĂB

@AVɖ莋̂́AA}A̗ifO󂯂ĐXx߂ɂ炸ǍɕĎRonƂBYAAЖR}ɂĎRi̓{iĈȍ~AAV́ugD^cエB}̐ӔCƂđΉĂ炢vƌAɐ\ĂƂB

@AĎR͂QRɗ}on\B̒Oɍ\Ƒ基ĎRƖʉA|ӂ邱Ƃ͂łȂB

@ȂΉł́AĎR𖯐i}哱ŗił\ɁAAs̕sۂۗƂȂBAɂ́A\玷sւ̕sM܂ĂB

@sψ̌AAV̐ēq͎ނɁA\\ȐȂƂŁůԂ̑Ή͑ψ⊶ŁAs𓾂ȂB̊֌W͌A悾vƏqׂB

@V̎Q@IɑĒmIłƎ𗧂ĂȂi}AB̑ΉɂĂ͌AA\ꕔŕj߂ĂƂāu̎vƂ̔ᔻBO@U荹钆AAVƂ̊Ԃɂa鎖ԂƂȂAӔC肪シ\B

@\͕ĎRon\QRAӔC_₤LҒc̎ɁuTvƘbB
http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/754.html

[n13] m2016VmIn_𕷂qriVj
_𕷂qr
Vm3ʁn@2016N105
@
@mI16̓J[ɌAՐɓB҂͌c̐E̎O_ꎁi70jVcsAOs̐Xvi67jsAt̕ĎRꎁi49jsAsm̌㓡_i55jns̖Vl4lBA}EXƁAYAAЖ3}EĎR킢WJĂB肪ڂW߂邪Ảۑ͑ɂ킽B̑_ɂĊeɍlA𕷂B
eҒF@OA㓡̉񓚂ɂĂ͊BpLłAXAĎRɔ䂵ĎÖ̃Xy[XĂȂB
@
@mn
@d͔芠H6A7@ɑ΂錴q͋Kψ̐RʂVm̔Cɏo錩ʂłBĉғȂǂɂǂ̂悤ȎpŗՂ݂܂B
@
@mʐn
@V̗piAANZXPAzEkV̊pAnʂ̈ێApUAΊ݌𗬂ȂǁAʂۑɂǂg݂܂B
@
@mƁn
@HA͐AsXnJȂǂ̃Ct͗֐nUAhЂɊւۑłAIȐ܂Bi߂ƂƁȂ_́B
@

@
X vi67j V

̈S Ή
VɁ^Sʑi
@
@yz
@ɂẮÄSmۂŗDۑƂČΉBq͋Kψid͔芠ḦSɊւj_oAs⌧ZpψȂǂ̈ӌ𕷂A؂BⓌdɑ΂ČׂƂ͂Ǝ咣B
@܂őSsƂāAȂǂɌɂƂƑiĂBs̐͂ĂBq͖hЂɊւĂA̗͕ςȂBJԂÄSmۂŗD悾BVRKXdM̗pȂǂɖ{ARGlM[匧ڎwB
@
@yʁz
@HzV\z̋̉ɎgށB̓Iɂ͐X܂œ{CcтVԂ\zA{Cy𐮂BzV̐VBH܂ߊʂ̑d́A{̋_ɂȂAЊQ̑֋@\ƂĈSmۂɂ𗧂B
@ł؂Ȃ̂͋ߗ׌Ƃ̂ȂAgA͂厖ɂ邱ƁBLό[głLBƂ̐ړ_ɂȂ։zȂǁAߗ׌ԓSԂ̊KvɂȂBsݗkz}s̗֐AoXH̊ɂw߂B
@^N[YDUv邽߁AVⒼ]Í̍p@\𐮔AB]Í̓GlM[pƂĂ̋_ڎwB
@
@yƁz
@nk␅QAyAAΎRȂǍЊQɋyÂwiÄSƈSmۂBH⋴A͐hAhACݕۑSȂǖhЁEЊQΉ̋ɊւCtϋɓIɐBێǗOꂵASȗpɂȂB
@{AHiHjgcoCpXȂǊH̐BHcARƘAgA{Cݓkԓ̑SJʂi߂BʊwḦS΍M@̐ݒudvB
@

@
ĎR ꎁi49j V
@
̂̌ ŗD
fqHČ^œ
@
@yz
@d͕1̂̌؂Ȃɍĉғ̋c_͂łȂƂcTFm̘HpB̂̌ANƐւ̉eAv̎̌؁A̎O̋łȂAĉғ̋c_͎n߂ȂB
@ihÂȂ󋵂člςB×̂ŎloĂ͂ȂȂBȂĂGlM[邱Ƃ͎̌ɏؖꂽB̂̃XNːp̏󋵂lƁǍ݂͗E𓾂ȂƎvB
@؂I΁iĉғ́jc_͂B͌̈ӌsΗĂ邪A͘bŌȂƂȂBc_͕̂ȂB،ʂƍL񂵁AŏIIɌ[Ɉς˂邱ƂlĂƎvB
@
@yʁz
@VƐṼANZXP͉ۑ肾B̎ZȂzV𒼐ڏĂA̎Zꂸɑ̗\Z悤ȂAčlȂ΂ȂȂB܂܂ȎiׂB
@V͓̂HiqmۂAƕςƂăjbiԁjŐĉ헪ɂȂƎvB
@{CfqHv͎Ƃ̐iߕtCOCBVAȂǂƂ̍qH𗬂͖̂bA̎Z܂߂ĂxŁApǂ߂B
@
@yƁz
@^Ƃے͂ȂAΕK֐オƂlׂ͌BƑ΍͂邪Aliޒł́A^͈̌ȂB̕ω𑨂ȂƂȂB
@ƂƂĂׂ͍ĂA̐lɊւ鏬K͂ȌƂɎgBႦΏa؂邽߂ׂ̍ȓH̐AX̌qǂłȂleXy[XɂȂǂB萶^̌ƂɃVtgĂB

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/755.html
[n13] m2016VmIn_𕷂qriVj
_𕷂qr
Vm3ʁn@2016N106
@
@
@m_ƁETPPn
@{̓R̈YnŔ_ƌłBmAgiT PPjɂ_Y̗A̋A󋵂ɂ܂BǂU܂B

@mYƐUn
@Ŵ߂ɂ́AƂ͂߂ƂYƂ̐U܂BƂnYn̊AxȂǂԂ܂Aǂ̂悤Ɏg݂܂B
@
@m^cn
@m͌ƂgD𗦂郊[_[łBgD̈ӎvaʂȂǂɉۑ肪Ƃ̎wE܂Aǂ̂悤Ȏpŉ^cłB
@

@
X vi67j V
@
_ƌoc̈艻}
Yi̘Hg^s̘b
@
@y_ƁETPPz
@oc肵Ă_Ǝ҂̂{􂾁B{̖LȐH𐢊EɃAs[ƂƂɁA肵_ƌocł𐮔AւƂȂ鋭_Ƃ߂B
@S̈쌧ƂāAIƏWɂVȏ⏞x̑n݁AS琬x̊g[ȂǁARɒ񌾂ĂB_Ƃ͍̐ɍE镔傫B̐͂邱Ƃ؂B
@R͓ɁA̔헪ƂȂBṼR͂܂Ƃ]邤ɐEɔ荞łB
@|_Ƃɂ͕ocɌxAYgɎgށBRԒn_Ƃ͕Ln搮ƘAĎ蔲BыƂ⋙ƂȂǂɊւĂ̓uh𐄐iB
@
@yYƐUz
@nYƂւ̎xBAO𗼎s̕ẪGlM[͂BCOɐioĂƂBŐDꂽHƕiȂǂCOAo邽߁AAWA≢Ăł̏i{sɐϋɓIɎQA̘Hgɓw߂B
@ۋ̌𓥂܂AƂ̐Vւ̎ƓWJViJx邽߁AZpJ⎑ZȂǂ̎xsBw̌AE𑝂₷߁AnƂ⌧wAnł̏AEڎwwƘAgAxB
@όYƂĂ͒nߗ׌Ƌ͂Ċό[gݒAOlόq̗Uv𑣂BnR̐EYo^ڎwB̂̊όĕ]A͂錧ynB
@
@y̑gD^cz
@ɕʂ̗ǂgDBxvłȂAVl܂߂ĐE̘b𕷂pS|Bs̏ꍇAxłȂS҂ĉcB̐EłcĂB
@mFȂ܂܂̊̐ł͂܂ȂBs̍l𕷂pтBmɂ炸A̐𕷂ĕmڎwB
@

@
ĎR ꎁi49j V
@
S̊m
NƂ֎xx^̈ӌd
@
@y_ƁETPPz
@{TPPŏdˁARȂǔ_Ədv5ڂ܂ĂȂBCÕRĕĉeɂȂĂB{YœIȑŌ󂯂BȂ̂ɍ͏JĂȂBɑ΂AOIȏ̊JƁA˕ʏ⏞x̓Ȃǎ̂΍߂ĂB
@_Ƃ邽߂ɂ́AS̊mۂdvB߂𓾂Ȃ_Ƃ͂킯ŁAČp҂ƃ}bOVXe݂B艻̑n݂ȂǁAĉxڎZ̗͈͂Ɏ߂{KvɂȂB
@U߂_ƁvڎwAYĩvhƂƂɁAAőɂgłB
@
@yYƐUz
@n̊ƁEYƂ̐Uɏd_uBɂ͍LꏊlނAVNƂł|eVBNƎȂǂ̎xxn݂B
@VYƂł́AuŃO[j[fB[vƂĎRGlM[ƂɎxقANɊւurbOf[^vpĈÁEYƂ̐UɂȂĂB
@ی{s̊JÂ⌧Ƃ̊COioxȂǁArWlX̏ÂɂϋɓIɊ֗^BꂪŒ̃AbvɂȂB
@
@y̑gD^cz
@łȂ̂̌Aʂ̂悢gDɂB̈ӌオĂȂAƂŔ悤ȑgDɂ͐΂ɂȂBImȂƂĂ΁Aǂȗ̐lłĂK邵ǍʂƃX|XB
@܂łAЂ⎖Ƃ[𗦂ĂoBgbv̖ڂ́AオĂƂ𕷂āAق邱ƁBNĂƂÄӌɍĂ邩Ƃ͋CɂȂB̂̓tFAɔf邵AŌ͉lf̖ƂȂA ߂ƂƂɂB
@
@
eҒF XAĎR̂قɗ₵ĂOA㓡̉񓚂ɂĂ͊B

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/757.html
[EIEmgj214] VVmI ĎR XiVwj2016.10.7mIWJ悩̏Nn
VmI ĎR XiVwj \َm Y} uʘavψA̓} Y\AЖ} ݂ٕ}Ai} 엊vO@c 2016.10.7
http://iwj.co.jp/wj/open/archives/336703
2016.10.7@IWJ Independent Web Journal
@

Broadcast live streaming video on Ustream
@
[00:45:55 / 01:06:27]
@
@ǂ݂ȂA΂́BVmĎRłBȂɂ݂̂ȂɏW܂ĂāA{ɊĂ܂Bւ񂠂肪Ƃ܂B
@
@{AVXԂőĉ܂BƂĂĈłB݂Ȃ񂶂Ȃł傤BƂĂĈHŁA󂪐āAR͗΂ŁACłāAAӂ邳ƂĂȁBVĂȁBvĉĂ܂B킽̂ӂ邳Ƌsʂ܂B̂ӂ邳ƂAȂȂĂ܂l܂B̐Vɂ́A܂Ol𒴂XĂāA܂A邱Ƃł܂B̒̂lAɒɂ̊XԂɗāA܂Bu킽̂ӂ邳Ƃ͂ȂȂĂ܂B킽̏Zł͂Z߂ȂBvȎvlA̐VŁA{ŁAlĂ͂ȂB݂̂Ȃ̎vAāA݂Ȃll厖ɂĂӂ邳Ƃւ̎vA킽ɗĂ܂B{ɂ肪Ƃ܂B
@
[00:47:50 / 01:06:27]
@
@cmB̂̓̕OIȌ؂Ȃčĉғ̋c_͎n߂ȂBHło܂Bb܂BƂȂłBOȂłB킽̘͂HAƎ󂯌pĂ܂BÂ̌̓OIȌ؁B̎̂킽́Aqǂ̌NAĐɗ^e̓OIȌ؁BČ̂NꍇɈSɔ@̌؁B3̌؂ȂȂAĉғ̋c_͎n߂ȂB͂\グƎv܂B
@
@
@傫Șb܂Bɂ݂Ȃ̎v͂B230̐ƍɓ˂BƂĂ傫ȘbłB̐gk܂Błɂ킽͎vłB͖{͂ƂĂ₩Ȋ肢ȂłBӂ邳ƂňSɕ炵Bqǂ̖肽BCzBRB̂܂܂łĂقB₩Ȋ肢ȂłB̈ll̂₩Ȋ肢ȂȂBȐႢȂłB킽́A݂Ȃll̂₩ŁAł؎Ȃ̊肢AȂĂBƎvĂ܂B
@
[00:52:35 / 01:06:27]
@
@̉ۑB񂠂܂B
@bĂ܂BqĎxBÁBBtƂĂ̌o𐶂āA{̐V点ĂƎv܂BꂳAւłBaۈB͂ꂳĂāAq񂪕aCɂȂĂASėaāA΂߂łāAAĂƊŕałBV点ĂƎv܂B̂b܂B҂BVł͑܂BtƂāAtȂ΋~Ȃ邱Ƃ͂悭킩Ă܂BƂ̐VŁAɍ͂܂Bt̊mۂɑS͂sĂāA~V点ĂBBƂĂւłB킽͉̌ňÂɌgĂ܂BVVB񂪁AFmǂɂȂĂ܂΂ꐶ삵āA삵āAł͓˂āA񂪓|Ă܂BȌڌ܂Bl̂܂܂ɂĂ͂ȂłB̐EB܂BҋPāA𑝂₵āA{݂𑝂₵āAĉoϓIȗRŉ󂯂ȂAȐlȂ悤ɁBɑ΂xx点ĂāAVɏZނ݂Ȃ݂͂ȂSď\ȉ󂯂āÂӂ邳ƂŘV𑗂B炵ĂBV点ĂƎv܂B
@
[00:54:28 / 01:06:27]
@
@TPPBƂĂւȖłBЉ悤ɋs̏ogłBĂHׂĈ炿܂BقƂ͂ȂĂ邱Ƃm܂łBɍsĂт肵܂B̂āB̂܂TPPi񂾂܂B̋āA_Ƃ͏_ƂقƂǂȂłB݂ȕKɐĂłBTPPłĂ̒liAłAVłA_Ƃŕ炵ĂƂ͂łȂȂ܂BȂƂ͋Ă͂ȂłBOIȏJ߂āA˕ʏ⏞x̂悤ɂƔ_Ƃ~鐧xccmHnāAĂ݂Ȃ̗͂؂āAƂigāÁcc܂B̂ӂ邳Ƃł猾Ă܂܂BV̕čTPP点ĂB肢܂B
@
[00:55:40 / 01:06:27]
@
@ēꏊBƂĂ厖ȂłB́A킽ˁccĂ͏΂邩܂B₪܂œHAHAHAHccČ̂łAu͌ƃCV[vƁAuH΂Ă񂶂ȂvČĂ܂łˁA킽HȂƎvĂƎvłǂAƍ点Ă܂BƈSȓHgB֗ɏa؂̂ȂHgB؎Ȋ肢ȂłB̐VwBVBƃANZX߂ĂāA{AVɗAEAȍVɗB̊όq񂱂̐VKĂBĂVŕ炷݂Ȃ񂪁AVł΂钆Ƃ肪΂悤ɁAAoxB{sJBȂƂāAē݂Ȃ̍Œグ𐮂āAЂ̐VBٗp񂠂ALɓASēV点ĂB
@
[00:57:00 / 01:06:27]
@
@čŌɁccŌɂ킽܂AƂ݂Ȃ͂킩ł傤Bʂׂő̐ӔCA͐΁ccmHnĂB͋łBBȂłB̐V́A{́A琢Ế̖AVɐ܂ĈĂ邨q񂽂łB̂q񂽂{ŁAEŋ𒣂ĂBllOlllܐl\lm[x܂邩ȂB{̋AwZAwZAЂ̐Vɍ点ĂBwZAwZoq񂪁Aƒ낪oϓIɌb܂Ȃ獂ZɍsȂBwɍsȂBȂƂĂ͐΂ɂ܂BuԂȂĂBvVł̋t^w点ĂāAVɐ܂q݂͂Ȏ̎u]ɉčZɍsBwɍsB𒣂ĎЉɐĂBV点ĂB
@
@݂ȂB킽͂΂܂B̐V́AVɕ炷݂Ȃ̂qA񂽂́Aqǂ̖邽߂ɁAS͂s܂B̐gāA݂ƂĖ̐ӔCʂ܂BǂAǂAV̐V[_[ƂāAĎRIł܂ƂS炨肢܂āÄAƂĂ܂Bւ񂠂肪Ƃ܂B
@

JԂƊe̊Jn
@
[00:12:30 / 01:06:27]@i XTqiQc@cAIΖ{j
[00:13:20 / 01:06:27]@X؊iVɐV[_[a\AVۏwj
[00:16:30 / 01:06:27]@َ݂iЉ}}AQc@cj
[00:23:00 / 01:06:27]@uʘavi{Y}ψAOc@cj
[00:35:40 / 01:06:27]@Yi̓}ƎR{YƂȂ܂\AOc@cj
[00:45:40 / 01:06:27]@ĎRꎁiVmIAj
[00:59:40 / 01:06:27]@엊viOc@cAi}j

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo214/msg/143.html
[n13] m2016VmIniA݂iVj
iA݂
Vm27 VŁn@2016N107
@
AXxudv
@
@킪JLĂmIŁAi}݂̓B}ƂĎ哊[ƂAx̘̂AVA}Eւ́uxv߁Agɂ󋵂ĂƂB
@
@4As̃X[p[OŁAi}ŉsESIIo̍qhcAt̕ĎRꎁi49) YAЖAEƕŃ}CNB1TԂAAcŕĎR̎xɕ\ē̂͏߂ĂBq́As̈ꕔd͔芠H甼a30LɂĂ邱ƂɐGAu玄ꐶȂłBšאx𐥐鋭v̂ĎRȂ̂łvƑiB
@q͎ނɁAIIo̎cтđOs̐Xv (67jAExȂAx҂uiĎRjȂłȂ񂾁vƂ傫Aun̐ɐĎ̎vvƖB
@Ǎc⌧Io̍ćA\ĂȂB
@ĎRx錧ćuA̐XxƂ̂͏dvƘbB܂AAƂ̊֌WʂɂĂA}̎哊[𑸏dAx҂ɓ̌ȂƂcB
@O̍c͂ĂĊBĎRwcɂ́A}h̔O[vɏ鈢mqO@cߓ}\ŋ삯B
@ߓ5AނɁuV̏dv󂯎~߂Ăl͂ƎvBX̋cfAӋčsĂ΂vƘbBېVォĎRƊւ肪ؓFO@cV肵B
@cxł́AX̒nAsEOSIo̍LLcAXxɉB}哊[߂O玖JɂoȀowɂ񂾁B
@mIɂ́Ac̐E̎O_ꎁi70jAsm̌㓡_i55j₵ĂB@icj

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/758.html
[n13] m2016VmIn_𕷂qriVj
_𕷂qr
Vm3ʁn@2016N107
@
@
@mq΍EqĎxn
@l[A͏q΍qĎx̋]ސオĂ܂BSĎqǂY݁AĂЉǂz܂B

@mÁEn
@tEŌtsÑ͖̐̐{̒N̉ۑłBiޒŁAx̏[߂܂BÁE͂ǂȐd܂B
@
@mn
@w͌⋳̉ߏdJAZ̍ĕ҂Ȃǋ番ۑ͎RςłB̕S̏d͏q̈Ƃ܂B͉ɏd_u܂B
@

@
X vi67j V

awۈx
iL߂^F鍂Z
@
@yqEqāz
@qǂÔ̏▢EaۈƊwۈ̏[ACyɎqđkłuqẲwv̐ݒu͂߁AssFxBnJ^̊Ɠۈ珊ȂǁAႢvwȂqĂłĂB
@̖́AšɗȂƂBɂuqẲwv͈xȂBs̕s͂傫Bs̎dcŎxsBɕsĂ҂̑k̐𐮔AƂɍlB@
@
@yÁEz
@a@͊ŌtsBSʊJ@ڎwB~~}@\m邽߁Aa@ɊB
@tAŌts͒n悲Ƃ̕a@Ԃ̘Ag𒲍ŁAǂ̒xsĂ̂cBt̊mہAŌt{邱ƂOɈÌvKvB
@ł΁Aʗ{Vlz[@邪Aŉ\hANi߂ĈÔ}A{̎v炷ƂłB͎sAÂ̖͌傫Bs̐icAL߂B
@
@yz
@oϓIȗRŏAwȎ҂ɑ΂錧PƂ̏wxg[ĂB̉zx̔zui߂B
@Z͈K͈ȉɂȂ瓝pƂ̕jɁAnł͕s܂ĂBnɂ͓FŎcƂv]Bs̊CmẐ悤ȓFwZÂxB
@wZƍZɒf₪B̌𗬂ȂAw܂ŒnƓ̗jĂA͎̐s̎𗣂銴BnƂ̐ړ_قƂǂȂZ\Bt^[ïӖłAƎ̋ZpLn̍HKǍƂLAsƘAgčsBӂ邳ƂɌւqǂĂB
@

@
ĎR ꎁi49j V
@
Nw̘JP
tmۂɑŚ^̕Sy
@
@yqEqāz
@qǂƂłȂ傫ȗR̈ɁA炵̖肪BNwւ̐xJ̉PŁAnŕ炷lĂB
@o͈꒩[ɏオ̂ł͂ȂBIȎ_ŕ炵₷AqǂY݈Ă₷Ƃ̂{IȕBifƂƂājoŸꎞȂǁAł{AǂxcB
@qĎx̕M͕aۈ炾Bqǂ}ɕaCɂȂƁAedx܂Ȃ΂ȂȂȂBĂe炵B
@
@yÁEz
@tȂBJ𐮔Aťoƒm𐶂ĈtEŌt̊mۂɑS͂ŎgށBVłƕςȂÂ󂯂̐B
@a@Aa@́ASʓIȊJƁE^pڎwBa@ƒn̈Ë@ւƂ̘Ag߁ARԒnł̈Ñ̐ێB
@͓̌l{݂ȂBoϓIȗR{݂𗘗płȂluVVv錻ĂB쌻̓ǂAȆҋPƏ⏕BoϓIȗRŉ󂯂ȂloȂ悤AxuB
@sƋ͂ALIɎ{݂̔zu萔̔zlĂBɒRԒn̎{݂͉^c⏕KvƍlB
@
@yz
@̎߁Au{̋猧vڎwBnȌCʂÃx߂ĂB
@̍ڎwOƂāȂҋ̉PɂgށBȂǂł͊O̐Ƃ̗͂p鐧xA̕SyB
@ɂxBoϓIȗRŊ]̐iHɐi߂ȂƂĂ͂ȂȂBԍϕsv̋t^wxn݂B̏wx_₢AllLȋ󂯂鐧xB
@
@
eҒF قɗ₵ĂOƌ㓡̉񓚂ɂĂ͊BpLł̈B

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/759.html
[n13] m2016VmInmI҂̉iVj
mI҂̉
Vm22 VŁn 2016N108

iE͂oAN͓[݁Alp͂ݐ}͐Ej
XAĎR̂قɗ₵ĂO_ꎁƌ㓡_ɂĂ͊BLł̈Bieҁj
@
X vi67jV m|n
@
DC CzYꂸ
@
@Nォ痝ȌnNB̏WV̊ϑɔMBɓwAlɋoāAn̒łlԂHwzwȂɐi񂾁B
@DȌzƂ́A̐݌vǋARzȍ앗ŒmOOBul͎̂̂̂ɂ͂łȂB炱vB͂ARXg{Hl̋JȂǂlĂ܂ƂB
@uqǂ̂납搶̌Ƃ𒉎Ɏ󂯂Ċw̒Ԃ𓝗D^CvvƎȕ͂Bw̐kIɂ͗IAZł͐JʂAk𖱂߂B
@wƌAԂ̐݌vł2NԂ̋ΖoČݏȁiEyʏȁj ɓȂCz͑BقƂǈ߂ȂBɉWɓOĖ邢An̉̂̂ď𐷂グB͓̂ӂuӋCȎ҂ȋOŏɉ̂ƍJ鐢EB킴Ɖɉ̂vƐUԂB\Ԃ̋Ȃ́ũnCqHvB
@߁A17NOAsIɗ₵Bւł͓@wogAzwȏoǵulʂōʂĂvƕs𗝂ĂƂA̋sW܂ĎRȔzł܂ÂĂsɍVƎvƂBAsĂVeBz[vUuAI[v́AEIɒȌzƂŊwȂ̌yAGႳ񂪐݌vSBsŴāȕW听vƎB
@͉򏄂BԂ^]ÂقƂǂ̉ɓB̂ŁAǂ̓Hǂ󋵂oŕĂBumȂA͂łȂvMOB

@
ĎR i49jV m||n
@
tŕٌm ʎ
@
@mIւ̗\O̖AcCb^[łr񂾁B
@̂ĂĂ Ԑ 䂪g z̐ ΂Ɠł
@Eւ̒͐d˂Aꕔ}sĉ̊҂ɔw̐wŗՂށB
@tłAɘJRÎ肪ٌmłB͓ŕٌmɂ݁A؁y͒nEs̎Ƃɖ߂AKfÂɎgށB
@VJisj̗{ؔ_Ƃɐ܂ꂽB卂֐i݁Aw𑲋ƁBi@ɂiB׋DɂȂR͂킩ȂA̗éA{͔^ĂꂽƂB
@ha2005N̏O@IŁAnEV5Ɏ}痧₵ĐEɏB̌O@I2xAQ@I1xނAc^IqEOⒷERÎuɂ͂ȂȂBI̓xɁuŁA̃ejXCɂȂȂȂvƂBɂ葱̂́uxIȗssu邱Ƃɓ{肪킫オĂ邩vƂB
@uʁvł邱Ƃ݂ƎAi畨̎dg݂l̂DBÁAANccBƎdg݂ςΖ͉łBǂӖ̂߂̈xĂB
@mI̍AŌ̐؂DƂĈꕔ̖}痧߂ꂽB₷΁A哊[߂Ăi}𗣂邱ƂɂȂA̓͒fB߂͂łȂBułڂ̑Oɋ߂Ă邱ƂvB\Ỏ̂ɂ́AȌfւ̎v߂B
@x͍ĂAs͌B_ɓ˂t邱ƂłB܂ł̔Mӂł̎dɒފo傾B

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/760.html
[n13] m2016VmInĉғ ݍތҁiVj
ĉғ ݍތ
Vm23 VŁn 2016N108

um[ƌovułȂv

@Os̐Xvi67jAE7As̎svUX[p[̑OŉɗB}̍דcO@ciV2jAsEHSIIo̎Oxꌧc炪񂾁B
@OxćAɈ{WO񑊂u撣ȂƑςȂƂɂȂ邼vƓdbƂ񍐂Aƌ钆Awc߂B

@t̕ĎRꎁi49jYAЖAE6ɊHƔsɓA1L̃X[p[OsSȂǂŃ}CNB
@{kЎɕotAː썎ɂBː쎁͊H̉Łu͋CꂢB ̒̓}XNȂƓȂBhЌvǂ񂾂AF̐ۏ񑩂l͂炸A傫Ȗ肾vƑiB
@ĎRuq͖hЎwjǂǂłAFSɔv͌_ŗĂȂvƂAĉғԂ΁ułȂƓȊOɂȂvƖB
@ːȈ̌oulȂ犠Hł}픘ւ̂ƂÂł@ւȂƂȂvƎ咣B ĉғłȂԂ̌ٗp΍ɂgނƂB

@mIɂ́Ac̐E̎O_ꎁi70jAsm̌㓡_i55j₵ĂB

iYSqAcj@

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/761.html
[RЊQ21] lԂNnkipI^Vj
_@lԂNnk
pI@w@C
Vm29 IsjIn 2016N108
@
@
nJɔXN
@
@nkw̋ȏɂ́Aučł݂͐̃JtHjABƖk̃AXJBɒnkNvƏĂB
@͕ςB2014Nɂ͕č암ɂINz}BŒnkȑO50{ɂāASĈɂȂ̂B
@Bł́A93Ƀ}Oj[hiMj5
E8̋nkNB߂ɓs΁A傫ȔQ𐶂݂˂ȂK͂B11N11ɋNnkł҂oAƉ|󂵂肷Ȃǂ̔QoĂB
@INz}Bł08N܂ł30NԂɋNnḱAM3܂ŐĂ2񂵂ȂB܂{Ƃ͈āA͐VIȖnknтB

@ŋߋNĂnḱAԈႢȂulԂUĂ܂nkvłBlԂnɑ΂ĉΒnkNƂm悤ɂȂĂB
@ŏ1962N̂ƂBč̃RhB̌RHŕːpt̎nɍāA4L̐[˂@Ď̂ĂBƂ낪A܂Œnk܂ȂɒnkNn߂B
@͏ȒnkAȂɂM5𒴂錋\ȑ傫̒nk܂ŋNB܂ĂxnkƂȂnł͑傫ȑɂȂB
@̂قAEenŃ_nkNĂB傫ȔQô67NɃChM6E3̒nkNĈɂ͖2lႪBRCi_Ƃȃ_𑢂ƂňNꂽnkłB
@ŋ߁AINz}B͂ߕčenŋNn߂Ă̂̓VF[KX̌@ɂ̂B
@̍̌@ɂ́ujӖ@itbLOjvƂ@gĂBw܂މt̂n[ɒŒĊ΂jӂ@BɂăVF[iŊjwɊڂBw̌KXo@@łB
@̎@ł͑ʂ̔p܂Bn1Lقǂ̐[Ɍ@pɈ͂Ē邱ƂŏĂB
@
@VF[KX̌@Ɍ炸AΖVRKX̌@A_Apt̒nBnɉeyۂƂnkŃÂƂ됢EIɑĂB
@̒łЂ݂܂ĂƂAt̂͊Ɗ̊Ԃ̖CĊ₷A܂nkN₷铭̂B΁AñGlM[uvĂ܂̂łB
@INz}Bł͔펖Ԃ錾āAB3200pp̐[˂̂37Jɑ΂A10Ԃ̎gp~wB1ɂ27Jɒ~wƂB
@ŎԂ܂邩ǂ͕ȂB܂ł̐E̗ႾƁAnւ̒ʂ̋}ȕώA͂ꍇłA܂ꍇłnk𑽔邱ƂB̕łn̈͂̕ϓ͒nkNƂ̂B
@nk𑽔Ă̂̓INz}BɌȂBčŒnkϑSĂčn (USGSj͍N3Ɍ\񍐏ŁAnk\n}̑Ώۂɏ߂ĐlדIȒnk܂߂B
@USGSɂƕčŐlדInk̃XN
B́A댯x̍ɃINz}AJUXAeLTXARhAj[LVRAA[J\[̊eBƂB
@̏BłM3ȏ̒nkA11NiKłł20I6{ɂĂBVF[KX̌@ŋߐɂȂBB
@ΔR̒ł͊eA܂Ȃ߂ɁuvvƂ܂łꂽVF[KXÅJɂ͂܂܂ȃXNƂYĂ͂Ȃ̂낤B֗ǋZṕA͒nɂؕԂ̂Ȃ̂B

@܂ނEЂł@1941N܂B69N傩痝wmB͒nkwBkC勳AɒnȂǂCB2005N4猻EBu^nk\ǂ邩viԓЁjAuΎR\{ajǕ΂܂ŁviNHKoŐVjȂǒB
@
@
eҒF upIEŋ߂̐VLvɂΎ̒ʂB
uʐM 2016N105ijjɊeɔzMvBw_xRBulԂNnk@VF[KX̃XNɖڂvM܂B
http://shima3.fc2web.com/saikinnnokijikara.htm

http://www.asyura2.com/15/jisin21/msg/654.html
[EIEmgj214] ԒQ@cii}jɂĎRVm̉i2016/10/10zsjmNn
ԒQ@cii}jɂĎRVm̉i2016/10/10zsjmNn
@
niigatamamãCu 2016/10/10 18:25:02 TwitCasting
http://twitcasting.tv/niigatamama/movie/313637983

@
m13:05/1:33:35n
@
݂Ȃ񂱂΂́B
Љ܂Qc@c̕ԒłB
݂͂Ȃ܁A{ɂQ肪Ƃ܂B

̐VAɂȂł傤B_̌ʂo܂BuXAĎRvāu4vB4ƂƖ80lłB80̐V̗L҂u킩ȂvB2l̈ႢɖĂlłB

cmĂ܂Bů()ĉғƂ͂[ł͂ȂBv܂IA_IȈ͂c͎󂯂Ă킯łBꂾ}{CŁmnH𓮂B

91A}̓KAĐXv񂪁A}{1ԉk܂B1012A܂薾()AKVɓƕ񓹂Ă܂Bĉicł͊ȉ\Ă܂BXmvn񂪒mɓIłɂ́AKh̓ʉƂēB

12A܂肳Aq͋Kψ͊H̋ZpIȍioƂĂ܂B̎VɎ}E̒maĂ΁Aĉғ͂ǂȂ̂ł傤B

}͖{CȂłBK͌oYb߂ꂽ啨łBĂ̔hɐXv񂪓ƂĂB

݂ȂB킽̏ZޏzmsnAH40kmłB̎̂̕40km͂ǂȂł傤B˔\ɉ܂BzɏZށAĂɏWA킽̋ʂ̎v\\АVmɂ́A⌠͂ɂ݂̂ȂfĂقBzɏZށAVɏZނ킽̖ƈSɍlĂقB

ĎR݂͂܂BːȂ̈ťo܂B킽͔ނȂłƎv܂B݂Ȃ񂢂ł傤B

킽ǂi}A񐄑Eł܂łB̂Ƃlѐ\グBA͐EłȂ̂Ɩ{ɎvقǑ̖i}cɂĂ܂B

1TԁA80lɂ킽̐͂܂傤B݂Ȃ܂̂m荇ɂЂ肢܂BĎR𓖑I܂傤BĐVƏz̖ƈS܂傤B肪Ƃ܂B

2016N1010
ĎRl
zّz[
@
iF@
킽Ȃ
@
oȋc̏ЉƈAF
nGKiVɐV[_[aj
@
oȋcF
 Fii} Oc@cj
lii} Oc@cj
ii} Qc@cj
R FiЖ} ccj
HR O}qii} ccj
~J ii}6摍xj
@izsccj
xi{Y} zsccj
ǖ Nizsccj
{ Kizsccj
qc izsccj
Ic pizsccj
aFizsccj
qKizsccj
R isccj
n qisccj
hVisccj
쓈 NYi\sccj
c Sqi\sccj
@
َmF
X 䂤iIΖ{j
s iЖ}j
r Wi{Y}j
O iii}j

http://www.asyura2.com/16/senkyo214/msg/260.html
[n13] m2016VmInuÁEiCEvɊҁbuEvd46iVj
uÁEiCEvɊ
Vm1ʁn 2016N1010
@
@
@ȉAuEqĎx΍vi12.8jAul΍vi7.2jƑB
@j́uiCEٗpvi22.8%jAuvi20.5%jAuÁEEvi19.2%j̏B́uÁEEv (30.0%jAuvi20.3jB
@҂鐭ɁuvN50i25.9jA60i28.6%jA70Έȏi22.7jB
@XvxL҂̒ł́uiCEٗpvƁuÁEEvAꂼ27.1A24.0Buv3Ԗڂ14.1B
@ő̑_ƂđiĎRꎁxL҂ł́uvi32.0%jōőBŁuÁEEvi23.0%jAuiCEٗpvi14.3%jB

FOtuVmɖ]ސvȗBieҁj

uEvd46
Vm2ʁn 2016N1010

_ыƁAurv

@uǂȓ_ɏd_uČ҂IԂvƂ̖₢ɑ΂ẮAuEvƂ̉񓚂łAŜ46.4ɏBŁuEsrv17.2Aulv16.2B
@v̐Xv͎AAĎRꎁ͋YAAЖ̐Eꂼ󂯁Ai̗^}Ό\}ɂȂĂBAfɁu҂x鐭}EćvI񂾐l4.6ɂƂǂ܂B
@x}ʂł́AxwŔfɐli44.0jłȂArllꂼ2OƔrIBixw59.1ɏd_uĂB
@dl̒ł́AĎRɓ[Ƃl36.5AXɓ[Ƃl34.1Brdlł́Aso̒X56.0ŁAĎR21.2傫B
@iOt͎̐ľܓ̂߁Av100ɂȂȂ j

OtumIԊv͏ȗBieҁj

y@zm2ʁn
793ԁA18Έȏ̗L҂ΏۂɁARs[^[Ŗׂɓdbԍ𔭐ēdbRDDi_EfWbgE_COj@Ŏ{BۂɗL҂鐢тɂ̂1424ŁÂ911l񓚂𓾂B

mI֘Am1ʁn
2ʁ@֐SxA7Q@I
3ʁ@^}Ό"2"̗l
28ʁ@ːDAVm̑Ή
29ʁ@ĉғu΁v6

t̐V mI֘ALie҂ɂЉj

XAĎR^mI1TԑO^ԓxȂ4^{Аm1ʁn
XAĎR@ԓxS^mI_iV񃂃Aj
uÁEiCEvɊm1ʁn
mIu֐Sv74^{А^7̎Q@Im2ʁn
uEvd46^_ыƎҁAurvҁm2ʁn
^}ˁu2v^Q@Isk̎ As֑Ś^Č_} i̓m3ʁn
[3.77 Om3ʁn
O[@OI荂^mIiV񃂃Aj
ːD i܂^A100xNȉSʕۊǁ^uߗ׏Z VmɑΉҁm28ʁn

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/762.html

[n13] m2016VmIn^}ˁu2viVj
m2016VmIn^}ˁu2viVj

^}ˁu2v
Vm3ʁn 2016N1010
@
@
Q@Isk̎ As֑S
Č_} i̓

@
@ƂɖVlőOs̐Xvi67jAEƁAt̕ĎRꎁi49jYAAЖE̗L2₪˂mI16̓J[܂1TԂ؂B}7̎Q@IVIɑ^}Όu2Ehv̗l݂A}␶̓}̌֌WcSʓIɉB哊[߂i}Aꕔ̍cĎRxɉ\Bs̑͐X𐄂B
@
@}͎Q@IVIŁA}̐̓}A\EXTqɐɔsBuAsv悤ƁA}̏OQc͐XvƊXɗBדcO@ci2j͑Ss𖱂߂X̌oɐGAu񑊂ƒژbłjBpCvĂvƃAs[B
@̊yσ[h]钆ŏO@́u1UvL܂A֌Wc͊@B
@O2014NO@IŁA6I̎}ŗBsꂽ֓mO@cikMzj͒n3삯BuMSɂ͓̂OB͂1񂵂IBOIɂvƈӋCށB
@Q@ǏʂO@IɓĂ͂߂ƁA13͎}A46͖}̏ƂȂvZBCO@ci6j͒nՂ̏zsŖ}ɖ8[ƂuQ@I͕s{ӂȌʂɂȂBmI͓ɈꐶɂvƌB

@}3}_͎̂Q@I̍ČA͖i}哊[ŁA}̎xĉ̘AV͐Xv́uxvɉB
@̒Awc҂̂i}̎xB܂łɍqhcAinhɑ铡cjcɓBq͊XŁuĎR͌؂Ȃ΁Aĉғ̋c_͂ȂƌĂvƎxiB
@ԒQ@ciVIjuĉғł݂Ȃfł͕̂ĎRvƂĎx邱Ƃ߂BO@cui}̑݊Ai}Iւ́je͑傫vƌBɑ΍RӖ߁AĎRxɈӗ~݂BIՐɌAi}̓͑傫ȏœ_ƂȂ肻B
@
@sA͐Xv𐄑EĂA̎sXɗBXiɓElOs7AsỎŁusASs̎тʂlAM֌WX̗͂̌򂾁vƗ͐AꏏɊƂ̂BcVsƓnӍLgĒ9AVs̃CxgXƗB
@8ɓ˔@AonfOcTFḿA܂ł̋L҉ŁAǂ̌邩ĂȂB
@Ag̃cCb^[iZeTCgjł͌q͖hЂɊւAeɁuJv𓊂|B񓚂ĎRɑ΂āǔ݂q͖hЂɌׂ邱Ƃ𗝉ĂB撣ĂvƃG[𑗂Bm̎ɂ͐Xv9A񓚂BeҒ
@

eҒ@cTFmƕĎREXṽcC[ĝƂ͎̒ʂB
@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
{AVm߂I܂BV̖ɂāAlAnnAq͖hЁAɂǂ̂Ș_҂Ǝv܂B
8:37 - 2016N929
@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂPz
̂ł́AWԔŃxgfłBbBh胈Ef܂͕ːv[ԑO̕pKvłBޔwo钆UPZZSSlɐԂł̔zz͍łBZɎOzz܂H
8:38 - 2016N929
@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂQz
nkƂ̌ЊQAꗥޔꍇAF{nk̂悤Ɍ|ɂ鎀҂̔O܂BɎwǰ߂܂H
18:24 - 2016N929
@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂRz
̎Aꗥޔ߂܂Aʂ㏸(500sV/h)̔ł́AQԂŔNԔ픘xʂ𒴂܂BłUPZZSSl邱Ƃ͍łBɎwǰ߂܂H
12:36 - 2016N101
@
ĎR@
@RyuichiYoneyama
VmƂĂԎĂ܂BꗥޔAʂ500Sv/hɒBĂ̔AwE̒ʂ񌻎IłSłȂƎv܂B󋵂ɉASŌIȔvɂȂwǰ߂܂Bs̓_Ȃǂ΁A΍KłB
1:06 - 2016N103

@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
ĎRA񓚂肪Ƃ܂B₩́A胈Ef܂̎Ozz{邩ǂ̉񓚂ȂǍ݂q͖hЂɂׂ͌邱ƂĎR͗ĂƎv܂B撣ĂB
22:33 - 2016N105

@
X ݂
@moritamio24
ycm̂Bz
UPZ20SvɂȂ_ŏiꎟړ]jƂȂĂ܂AȂׂɈSɔł悤ׂ̉ƍl܂BUPZޔւƏ󋵂iWꍇ̑ΉZŋ̉悤Ƌc܂B
17:34 - 2016N109

@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
X񓚂肪Ƃ܂B Kς̎wj̉߂Ɨ܂BwEĂB sɉ񓚂΁AƌݓIȋc_łƎv܂A̐ASmۂ肢܂B{𕷂̂ŁA̖̍₢Ɉ肢܂B
12:16 - 2016N1010

@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂSz
́ASPEEDI̊pn̂̔fŔF߂jłBvSPEEDI̊p𖾋L܂H
12:16 - 2016N1010
@
ĎR@
@RyuichiYoneyama
VmƂĉ񓚂Ă܂B͂AȊwIɊÂAłSvȔĂ߂ɁARSPEEDI̊pvɖLĂ܂B
13:51 - 2016N1010

@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂTz
̓҂̓dɏdȉe^ug_EBv͉BƔF߂܂BK̓KRɑgD̎͊܂܂܂BXEF[f̂悤ɔ芠H𓌓dHD番Č\ɖ{Ђݒu邱Ƃ߂܂H
12:18 - 2016N1010
@
ĎR@
@RyuichiYoneyama
VmƂĉ񓚂Ă܂Bug_EBvɏے铌d̑̎ɂ͔ɑ傫Ȗ肪ƍl𓾂AK^cSۂ̓Iiu鎖߂܂BwE̔芠HE\{Аݒu͂̂߂̍łLȎïłƍl܂B
14:12 - 2016N1010

@
@
cTF
@IzumidaHirohiko
yVmɖ₢ƂUz
̂ŔːDbۊǂƂȂĂ܂Bd͎̐ӔCʂĂȂƂƂłAĉғc_OɊjʂ蓯ЂɈ߂܂H
21:39 - 2016N1010
@
@

mI֘Am1ʁn
2ʁ@֐SxA7Q@I
3ʁ@^}Ό"2"̗l
28ʁ@ːDAVm̑Ή
29ʁ@ĉғu΁v6

t̐V mI֘ALie҂ɂЉj

XAĎR^mI1TԑO^ԓxȂ4^{Аm1ʁn
XAĎR@ԓxS^mI_iV񃂃Aj
uÁEiCEvɊm1ʁn
mIu֐Sv74^{А^7̎Q@Im2ʁn
uEvd46^_ыƎҁAurvҁm2ʁn
^}ˁu2v^Q@Isk̎ As֑Ś^Č_} i̓m3ʁn
[3.77 Om3ʁn
O[@OI荂^mIiV񃂃Aj
ːD i܂^A100xNȉSʕۊǁ^uߗ׏Z VmɑΉҁm28ʁn

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/763.html

[n13] m2016VmInuvĉғ6iVj
uvĉғ6
Vm29 Љn 2016N1010
@
{А_
@
@VЂ79Ɏ{_ł́AmIł̘_킪ڂĂ铌d͔芠H̍ĉғɂāu΁vuǂ炩ƂΔ΁v킹񓚂60.9ƂȂAu^vuǂ炩ƂΎ^v̌v24.2傫B^Ɣ΂̍36.7|CgŁAN12AN7̐_炳ɍLB΂wiɂ͍ĉғi߂鐭{A1̂Ndɑ΂sM̍܂肪B
@
񂶂upFvAFSnZB

@
@ĉғɂāAł񓚂́u΁v36.5ŁAuǂ炩ƂΔ΁v24.4B̓킹΂͍N12̓VƂ̍_ł47.4AN7̎Q@I̐_ł51.5B6ƁAQ@IɑđOtQ B
@Áu^vuǂ炩ƂΎ^v͂ꂼ8.4A15.8B 킹^߂銄͑OAOXƂقډ΂B
@uǂƂȂv13.7BOX28.2AO19.3ƌ葱钆A΂̍vĂB
@΂Ăwiɂ́A{Ⓦd̎pɑ΂^ԂsM肻B
@{9A܂ł1~ȏ̍𓊂Ȃ{i^]ɎĂȂBFu񂶂vi䌧j̔pF܂߂{I\Bq͐Sʂ̐ssɂȂĂB
@d͕̓AuFSnZig_EjvƂ[ȎԂBĂƂ6ɔF߂BƓd́ẢBɊւ؈ψŏڂo܂̉𖾍Ƃ8Ɏn߂΂肾B
@O@ĨGAʂɌƁAn锐s܂2GAŔ΂61.5B̌܂̃GA6O𔽑΂߂B
@Nʂł́A20ōĉғɔ΂52.3A^34.3Ƒ̔N荂B40ȏ̊eNł͔΂6𒴂B
@x}ʂł́A}xwŔ΂42.2Ǝ^38.7BA^}̌}xw͔΂7B
@mIŎ哊[ƂĂ閯i}̎xw͔΂8BmIŋ鋤YAAЖ3}̊exw79΂ƂĂBx}Ȃ}hw͔΂68.6B
@[ŌƁAv2̂AXvi67jɓ[ƂlŔ΂44.6AĎRꂳi49jɓ[Ƃlł78.5B

Otu芠H̍ĉғɂāv͏ȗBieҁj

y@zm2ʁn
793ԁA18Έȏ̗L҂ΏۂɁARs[^[Ŗׂɓdbԍ𔭐ēdbRDDi_EfWbgE_COj@Ŏ{BۂɗL҂鐢тɂ̂1424ŁÂ911l񓚂𓾂B

mI֘Am1ʁn
2ʁ@֐SxA7Q@I
3ʁ@^}Ό"2"̗l
28ʁ@ːDAVm̑Ή
29ʁ@ĉғu΁v6

t̐V mI֘ALie҂ɂЉj

XAĎR^mI1TԑO^ԓxȂ4^{Аm1ʁn
XAĎR@ԓxS^mI_iV񃂃Aj
uÁEiCEvɊm1ʁn
mIu֐Sv74^{А^7̎Q@Im2ʁn
uEvd46^_ыƎҁAurvҁm2ʁn
^}ˁu2v^Q@Isk̎ As֑Ś^Č_} i̓m3ʁn
[3.77 Om3ʁn
O[@OI荂^mIiV񃂃Aj
ːD i܂^A100xNȉSʕۊǁ^uߗ׏Z VmɑΉҁm28ʁn

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/764.html

[n13] m2016VmInc_u̓IɁviVj
c_u̓IɁv
Vm3ʁn 2016N1012
@
@
ZpρEΎ
@
@d͔芠ḦSc_錧Zpψψ̗Ή돺EV喼_11AŉA16ɓJ[mIł̌̋c_ɂāu̐Ȃs\vƎwEAϋɓIȋc_߂B
@mIŁAǂ̌̎咣d̉B̎ƂǂȂƂ莋Bud̑̎ςƖÂ߂ɒmƂĂǂ邩ĂقvƑiB
@قɁA1̂̌؂̋̓IȐiߕÂ̍ۂ̔v݂̍ɂĂc_[߂悤v]B

t̐V mI֘ALie҂ɂЉj

ƊEĉɉx^m݋ƁnƂ̃pCvdmJgnegDňقȂ铮mJAnQ@IقǔMCȂm3ʁn
ƊEć@ɉx^mI@vĉ̓iV񃂃Aj
ĉғł̒Pꑈ_O^Osm3ʁn
gbv36.5^}x^}hw͑^{А_m3ʁn
}x@gbv^mI@{А_iV񃂃Aj
[pdt^O^Vm31ʁn
v|F11VsIǔ\B10ɓŒmI̊O[80㏗1ɊO[ς݂AWL҂VXeŌۂɃG[bZ[W̊mFӂA[pČtB2ڂ̓[ς܂߁A2[͗L[ƂĈB

http://www.asyura2.com/09/ishihara13/msg/765.html

[eXg31] eXg
m2016VmIns撬ʓ[n}łȂ߂

### VmIi2016N1016j@ĎR vs X݂

VŜł̕ĎRƐX̓[Ɠ[͂ꂼꎟ̒ʂB

[
mnĎR (49) V@528,455[
@@@X@v (67) V@465,044[

[
mnĎR@52.2
@@@X@v@45.9

@ ق2l̗҂̂ŁA[̍v100ɂȂȂB

̎s撬ʂ̓[̍n}Otł킵Ă݂B

CARTO ƂEFuT[rX𗘗pBF͓̂ʕށiquantilejƌĂ΂@ɂƂÂBޕ@Iׂ΂Ƃ͎Iɕ\̂ŁAނ̏ڍׂ͂킩ȂBʕނł͎s撬̂킩₷PB΁A̒n}Ot͂߂đ傴ςȌ}ɂȂB

@ CARTOƂȂȂyn}Ot́uvɂẮAGVƂVL҂cC[gŒmB

ΐF̔Zs撬ł́AĎR̓[XĂBFȂɂė₪݊pɂȂAɐX₪ĎR悤ɂȂB

n}Ƀ}EXJ[\ĂƁAes撬̊bf[^\Bォ珇ɁAs撬iYOc@IjAĎR̓[AX̓[A[̍iĎR̓[X̓[ljB

ΐF̂킾ĔZs撬͂ǂ낤B

ΎsBcTFm̏ognBrFscx̗NɂĂB
VsHtBVÎsBX䂤c̏ognB
슗Sc㒬BΎsƏHt̊ԂɈʒuBM͐Xvɏonv񒷂1lB
VsB݂߂Z[Œm鋌S𒆐SƂJ[B
sBĎȐognikSVJjB

AƂ킯ΐF̔s撬B

DSYB
DS֐쑺B
HSHB
OSo_蒬B
4̒ł́AN7̎Qc@IVIŌIȁu2[̓Iv͂X䂤A̒ꎁɑ傫ȍĂB
S꒬BőɍꂽRɂĂ͌ȂBn悪lȂǂ̐؎ȉۑȂŁA邢͕ĎŘĉғVOCV[̑i₩ɂꂽ̂낤B
u10Nڂ}āvi_cqY 2014Nj
kSĒBn粜Ag͌̉łAN5AXvsijƂƂɎ񒷗Lu̐擪ɗĐcᔻ̉ΊWB
sƍnsBꂼꓹH̃Ct߂Ă鎖Vɕ񂶂ĂB
sBXv̂GƁBsƂčN11ɂ5I͂BƂ͂AĎRmIɗ₷܂ł͖i}̐V5摍xBߋɂV5悾3A}{ېV̉痧₵Ă͂̂тɗIBsł̒nΌɌ肵ĂΕĎR܂ƂʂBȂ݂ɐX䂤2014NAېV̓}ɂĎRɗ䂸点iDŖ}g݁AV5悩痧₵ƂB̂Ƃ͒ɔsꂽAN7̎Q@Ił͐J͂Aső̒𐧂B

̂悤Ɏs撬ƂɂȂ߂Ă݂ƁAĎRVSyœ悤ɎxW߂킯ł͂ȂƂƂ킩BVs̊e͂߂Ƃl̑J[ł̎x̍L肪AՂɗ򐨂ĎR63[̒nIȑ叟炵̂B

Vs̎csi4j́AXvxĉϋɓIɍsȂĂB̂悤ȖmȈӎv\ɂ炸A܂Ŏcs4IxĂVs̑mƂĕĎRI񂾁Bc㒬iME5jAsi͎ؗsE2jAsivZjsE4jAOsiElsE3jAVcsiK]sE2jȂǁAłȎxՂL񒷂Xvق̎̂łAۂĂB

ȏ̊ώ@ʂɂĂ͂ɂ킵ׂĕ͂Ƃ낾Ae҂ɂꂾ̗͗ʂȂBCƂwE邾ɂĂBe҂͍AĎRȂA͕ĎRɌϑȂiDɂȂn̐ɂ͂ƂɎ𐟂܂悤ɂB܂As撬␭}čLĎRւ̊҂LlAɂꂩV̐Vn͍ĂƂA̓ɂ܂xꂸɂčsȂĂ͂Ȃ܂B
@
@

### mQlnQc@IVIi2016N710j@X䂤 vs

Ql܂łɁA2016N7̎Q@IVIł̐XTqƒ̓[̍ɂĂAv̂Œn}OtɂĂ݂BF̔Zs撬ł͓[ŐXTq₪B

[
mnX@Tqi60j@560,429[
@@@i57j@558,150[

[
mnX@Tq@49.0
@@@@48.8

@ 1l҂̂ŁA[̍v100ɂȂȂB

[EIEmgj214] m2016VmIns撬ʓ[n}ł݂

### ĎR vs X݂i2016N1016@VmIj

VŜł̕ĎRƐX̓[Ɠ[͂ꂼꎟ̒ʂB

[
mInĎR (49) V@528,455[
@@@@X@v (67) V@465,044[

[
mInĎR@52.2
@@@@X@v@45.9

@ ق2l̗҂̂ŁA[̍v100ɂȂȂB

̎s撬ʂ̓[̍n}Otł킵Ă݂B

CARTO ƂEFuT[rX𗘗pBF͓̂ʕށiquantilejƌĂ΂@ɂƂÂBޕ@Iׂ΂Ƃ͎Iɕ\̂ŁAނ̏ڍׂ͂킩ȂBʕނł͎s撬̂킩₷PB΁A̒n}Ot͂߂đ傴ςȌ}ɂȂB

@ CARTOƂȂȂyn}Ot́uv̂Ƃ́AGVƂVL҂ɂsmIʕ͂cC[gŒmB

ΐF̔Zs撬ł́AĎR̓[XvĂBFȂɂė₪݊pɂȂAɐX₪ĎR悤ɂȂB

n}Ƀ}EXJ[\ĂƁAes撬̊bf[^\Bォ珇ɁAs撬iYOc@IjAĎR̓[AX̓[A[̍iĎR̓[X̓[ljBn}ɂvX^}CiX{^ŁA\g^kłB

ΐF̂킾ĔZs撬͂ǂ낤B

ΎsBcTFm̏ognBrFscx̗NɂĂB
VsHtBVÎsBX䂤c̏ognB
슗Sc㒬BΎsƏHt̊ԂɈʒuBM͐Xvɏonv񒷂1lB
VsB݌vւ̔Ή^ƏZ[Œm鋌S𒆐SƂJ[B
sBĎȐognikSVJjB

AƂ킯ΐF̔s撬B

DSYB
DS֐쑺B
HSHB
OSo_蒬B
4̒ł́AN7̎Qc@IVIŌIȁu2[̓Iv͂X䂤A̒ꎁɑ傫ȍĂB
S꒬BőɍꂽRɂĂ͌ȂBn悪lȂǂ̐؎ȉۑȂŁA邢͕ĎŘĉғVOCV[̑i₩ɂꂽ̂낤BQlFu10Nڂ}āvi_cqY 2014Nj
kSĒBn粜Ag͌̉łAN5AXvsijƂƂɎ񒷗Lu̐擪ɗĐcᔻ̉ΊWB
sƍnsBꂼꓹH̃Ct߂Ă鎖Vɕ񂶂ĂB
sBXv̂GƁBN11ɂ͎s5I͂BƂ͂AĎRmIɗ₷܂ł͖i}̐V5摍xBߋɂV5悾3A}{ېV̉痧₵Ă͂̂тɗIBsł̒nΌɏœ_ڂ΁AĎR܂ƂʂBȂ݂ɐX䂤2014NAV5悩痧₵ĂBېV̓}ɂĎRɗ䂸点iDŖ}g񂾂AɔsꂽBN7̎Q@IŐJ͂Aső̒𐧂B

̂悤Ɏs撬ƂɂȂ߂Ă݂ƁAĎR͐VSyœ悤ɎxW߂킯ł͂ȂƂƂ킩BVs̊e͂߂Ƃl̑J[ł̎x̍L肪AՂɗ򐨂ĎR63[̒nIȑ叟炵̂B

Vs̎csi4j́AXvxĉϋɓIɍsȂB̖mȈӎv\ɂ炸Acs4I܂ŎxĂVs̑mƂĂ͕ĎRI񂾁Bc㒬iME5jAsi͎ؗsE2jAsivZjsE4jAOsiElsE3jAVcsiK]sE2jȂǁAg̋łȎxՂĂȎ񒷂Xvق̎̂łA悤ȌۂB

ȏ̊ώ@ʂɂĂɂ킵ׂĕ͂Ƃ낾Ae҂ɂꂾ̗͗ʂȂBCƂwE邾ɂĂBe҂͍AĎRȂA͕ĎRɌϑȂiDɂȂn̐ɂ͂ƂɎ𐟂܂悤ɂB܂As撬␭}čLĎRւ̊҂LlAɂꂩV̐Vn͍ĂƂA̓ɂ܂xꂸɂčsȂĂ͂Ȃ܂B
@
@

### mQlnX䂤 vs i2016N710@Qc@IVIj

2016N7̎Q@IVIł̐XTqƒ̓[ɂĂAv̂Œn}OtɂĂ݂BF̔Zs撬ł͓[ŐXTq₪ĂB

[
mInX@Tqi60j@560,429[
@@@@i57j@558,150[

[
mInX@Tq@49.0
@@@@@48.8

@ 1l҂̂ŁA[̍v100ɂȂȂB

[n13] m2016VmIn鐭́bۑ ɖvbقiVj

### 鐭

Vm1ʁn 2016N1017@

meҒFIʂ񂶂1ʃgbvL̉n

@mIŕĎRꎁ𐧂B_𓌋d͔芠HɍiAL҂ɍĉғւ̎^ۂ𔗂錧[IȐ킢tƂB̌ւ̋s݉iDŁA̍ĉғ͈wɂȂƂ͊ԈႢȂBɂ͌ȊOɂۑ͎RςĂBlAU͑҂ȂBAƂ}́uPvԂɂA̖}nm̎rB

@ĎRwć͎uCV[iPꑈ_jvIWJB^}EXuĉғɃm[ƌ킯ȂvƔᔻAihƈʒutC[W헪B

@E̐cTF͍ĉғւ̎^ۂ͖mɂĂȂAĎR͑IōĉғuF߂ȂvƓݍ񂾁BVЂ̐_łU߂ĉғ΂̐̎󂯎MƂȂB

@X̑SsȂǂ̌otɎāuÂ^Cv̐ƁvƋB𐄐i鎩}ւ̌̕sM̔wiɂƂ݂B

@Ảۑ͌ł͂ȂBuĎRvɋ߂̂́AL̐͂B

@cł͋cȂ6߂鎩}Ƃ̑Η\zBĎR͉ߋɎ}𗣓}ĂAcƂ͊mBlɐ{^}Ƃ̊֌WOB唼XxsƂ̘Agۑ肾Bł́A}EŏImcƑΗ1NقǂŎEB

@ĎŔAΉ́ucHpvƂA̕ł̎p͖mł͂ȂB{CfqH̑DwȂǁAu@\sSvwEc̈̕YɂǂΏ邩BOꂵ̊JKvɂȂB

@ĎR͍soȂArSmBu͓ȂA̐ȂvƂ͂ȂȂ悤A؂Ȃ^c߂B

### ۑ ɖv

񓹕 O@Vm3ʁn 2016N1017

@I͂Ȃĉғ̐I錧[ƉB̈ȍ~͂Ƃ킯̊Ԃōĉғɔ΂鐺܂BꂪĎRm̍ɉグ̂͊ԈႢȂB

@mIŌ肪傫ȑ_ƂȂƂ͔ɈӋ`ƎvB̎Q@IAIł͐Ivf瑈_Ăo܂邩炾B

@Ƃ͂΂ɏœ_𓖂Ă悤ȑIɂ͈aB

@dvȖ肾Aɒڊւ錧ۑ͂قɂBl΍qĎxAÁȄ[A_ȂǎRςۑ̘_cvۂ͔ۂ߂ȂB

@{CfqHv̑Dw͂߂Ƃc̃}CiXʂBꂽ̂悤ɂȂƂ肾B

@ĎŔAւ̑ΉŐcHpƂĂBA^ۂȂ̂ɂ̘Hɂ͒g܂ƂĂB

@ĎR͘HpƌłȂȂΉ܂߂ĂƋ̓IɐׂB̌𐄐iׂƏqׂĂo܂BȂlς̂B͂ɏڂ낤BnnɂJɑΉĂقB

@Xv̏oň_͐cɑ΂ᔻBkV̕Sԑōߗ׌Ƃa瀂𐶂قAsƂ̑ΗƂāA̍ĐiĂB

@Ƃ낪AIł͐cᔻ̓g[_EBĎRƂ̑Η𖾊mɎȂ̂ő̔s낤Bwiɂ́A}̐chƔch̑ΗAcᔻ𕕂ꂽBŌ܂ňꖇɂȂȂB

@IIՂɂ́AKr}}{Őcmɑ΂AXւ̎x߂ʂB̂Ǝ́A}̊@Əł\ĂB}炪12NOɒacmɑꂽiDłB

@ĎR͌cł͏^}ƂȂBőh̎}ւ̑Ήł́A卬Ɋׂ\B

@ĉғɑ΂閯ӂmɎꂽŁA^cɌȂsƂ̘Ag͂ǂȂ̂BfqHƂc̈̕Yւ̑Ή҂\ĂB

### Pꑈ_̌^^L_Ɏ炸^cGEV@w

Vm2ʁn 2016N1017

@16ɓJ[ꂽmÍAY}Ȃǖ}3}t̖VlEĎRꎁi49) AA}EOs̓EXvi67jjAVmɏAƂɂȂB̌ʂ̈ӖV@w̓cGɕB

@ǂd͔芠Hĉғ́uCV[iPꑈ_jvA𔗂Z[̍\}ɂȂB10Ň^̑IBłȂȂIɂȂƂB͒߂ŌƁACMXEUEƋ߂B΂΂F̖ɂȂAƂC[WɎ񂾏Z[B^}⌠͂ւ̔ƂӖł́Ađ哝̑Ił̃gvۂƂʂĂB

@Q@IVIł̖}⏟̉e傫B̗̂܂܂œ[l낤BAl钆̈lł鍑cƃI[̒mł͈ႤB{͈ႤōlȂ΂ȂȂB

@m͌ł͂ȂAYƂ╟Ȃǂ܂܂ȕSĂB{łΓ_ȂǂőS̓IȐ_ׂA񂹂񎞊ԂȂBɉBAc̖___ɂȂ肫ȂB

@ĎR͎ېVƂ}nĂBȑO͌𐄐iĂ̂ɁȀonɓĂƍlςB͔ɕ|ƂAɂ̃|sYB{Ƃ́A邽߂̎ił͂Ȃ̂ɁAĎR͐ƂɂȂ邱ƂړIɂȂĂƌĂ܂B

@n͌󋵂ɂẢۑ͎RςĂBsȏSȂVmI񂾂Ƃ́Aɑ傫ȃXN͂ށB
@
@
@ނE@@kCogB呲ƌAȂɓȂOdےȂǂ𖱂߂B2007N猻EB͍swAnB
@

### e}kb

Vm3ʁn 2016N1017

ʎ󂯎~߁^͂ꂩ
E}A@ʂ͎󂯎~߂邪Aւ̖ӂ܂ߔs͂͂ꂩ炾B}ƂĂ͑I΍{ŕj߁AgD܂߂Đ΂ĂBcŎ}͑}ƂƂɂȂ邪Ac^ɌĂ낤B

cc_́^uXXŁv
ucMjE}{\@肾ɑSĂĂ܂BX̕L咣͐ZłȂBĎR͔_ƁAlȂǂɂĂقƂǍlĂȂBcł͌v̂߁A^ʂ琥XXŋc_ĂB

Q@Io^X[Y
nmvEY}ψ@Ě̌pHAɁuĉғɓӂłȂvƓݍ񂾂Ƃ傫ȏBQ@I󂯁A}X[YB͌_Ɉˋi߂邱ƂAۑ̃|CgɂȂƎvB

j̓]_^Sɂe
XTqER}A\@߂đ傫ȑ_ƂIŁAĉғɔ΂閯ӂƂłBɑ傫ȏBj̑傫ȓ]_ɂȂ邾낤BAŜ܂܂ȑIɉegyƎvAg傳ĂB

ĉғŁ^֐S܂
RFEЖ}A\@ĉғ̐񂪏߂đ_ƂȂAL҂̊֐S܂ƎvBĉғȂƂ̎vȂiɂȂĂBĂ̎Q@IɑAs̗͂𓮂BɊY҂B
@

### eEkb

Vm3ʁn 2016N1017

V̔ɉhց^ӔCʂ
cTFm@IꂽĎRɐS炨j\グBւ̐ӔCʂAVɉh悤撣ĂقB

ĎRVmƁ^ӌ
cEVs@I킪ĉғ̃CV[ƂȂĂ܂Ǎۑ肪vĂ܂͎̂cOBsX̐E߂iKŁAĎR͏on\ĂȂB킾܂͂ȂBVmƂƈӌĂB

Ƃւ́^xs
cVEVHc@oςx钆Ƃ̌oc͂܂܂AxsB̘HgAViJւ̎xƂYƐUόUAٗp΍Ȃǒn抈Ɍoϐ͂ȃ[_[Vbv̉AiĂقB

TPPȂǂ́^_ۑR